HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

legutierr

3,060 karma · joined July 21, 2011

submissionscomments
legutierr··on Show HN: I “wrote” a kid's book with ChatGPT and Midjourney
No, your perspective on this is all wrong. The outrage about AI art is not about how it empowers its users.

Rather, the problem is that these systems only exists today because of the involuntary contributions of the very same people who are likely to be put out of business.

It really is about the how the contributors to these systems are being treated. The coders that contributed to Photoshop are analogous to the artists whose work was used to train these models. The difference between them is that the former gave their consent to the contribution, and the latter did not.

legutierr··on Show HN: I “wrote” a kid's book with ChatGPT and Midjourney
The people who wrote the Photoshop source code were paid for their contributions with full consent that their work would be included in the product and sold for a profit by Adobe. The artists whose work was fed into these systems did not consent, nor were they paid for their contribution. In fact, I have seen a few reports of people using these systems to generate lookalike artworks intended to resemble the work of specific working artists—artists whose livelihoods depend on client commissions. The only way that these systems could produce knock-off artwork after receiving a prompt containing that artist's specific name is if the artist's own copyrighted work was used in the training data.

Do you have any doubt that many working artists' copyrighted work was included in the the training data that produced these systems, without those artists licensing their work for that purpose?

It's not gatekeeping to insist that a project obtain a voluntary license from the people who contribute their work to a project.

And it's not gatekeeping to point out the fact that these platforms have only been successful by using working artists' copyrighted work in violation of their rights, without asking permission or providing compensation.

legutierr··on Snowden on the Lightning Network on Nostr
I think what OP is saying is that onboarding all of humanity onto the lightning network would exceed the capacity of the Bitcoin network.

Yes, once everyone is onboarded onto lightning the 1,000,000 tps bandwidth would apply. But to benefit from that, at least one payment channel per person would have to be written to the Bitcoin blockchain—a process that would take at minimum 30 years if all of humanity is to be on-boarded—and would more likely take several centuries, considering that those payment channels would also be competing with other bitcoin traffic.

Also consider that the security model of the lightning network requires that fraud penalties need to be written to the blockchain within a certain time window if a fraud is to be reversed. A clogged Bitcoin network where transactions are waiting too long to be added to the blockchain—or where blockchain fees are too high to justify adding a fraud-penalty transaction to the blockchain—would result in the entire security model breaking down.

legutierr··on Snowden on the Lightning Network on Nostr
> A relay doesn't talk to another relay, only directly to users.

Is this universally the case? I'm sure a relay could be built that pulls messages from other relays and shares them with its own clients.

legutierr··on Snowden on the Lightning Network on Nostr
How does someone use lightning on Nostr? I see a lightning link marked "Tip" on his profile page, but that seems to point to a plugin that you have to install in your browser: https://getalby.com/.

Is there some lower-level integration with lightning within Nostr, or is this it?

legutierr··on WTF with high school questions?
I feel like the teacher could be either the hero or the villain in this story—pushing you to excel, or tearing down a gifted student. What was the outcome of that meeting?
legutierr··on Detect breaches with Canary credit cards
> If someone steals my credit card, I’ll likely lose nothing other than some mild inconvenience updating numbers

You might not lose money when someone steals your credit card, but someone does: either your bank or the merchant will suffer a fraud loss.

Consumer fraud protections with regards to credit cards are necessary because credit cards are fundamentally insecure technology and would be unusable if issuers didn't take on so much of the fraud risk themselves.

> and I don’t even need to do that with the modern systems like Apple Pay which use unique per-merchant identifiers.

Apple Pay is a big improvement over standard credit card technology. It's also closed and proprietary, and requires special equipment to use, on both the merchant side and the consumer side.

> spend your time unbreaking the system instead of marketing it.

Are you criticizing me for writing this comment on HN because I am not at this very moment writing code? In your mind, people can't even talk about a project they may be interested in or working on until the project is finished?

> If you want people to buy your random hashes

Are you sure you are not confusing stablecoins and cryptocurrencies? These are very different things. Stablecoins are transferrable sovereign currency obligations the balances of which are recorded on a blockchain. Stablecoin tech can be used to allow consumers and merchants to interact with any type of monetary account as might otherwise be embodied by a debit or credit card, with similar business terms.

> That makes quite the contrast with the large sums routinely and irrecoverably stolen from blockchain users.

No doubt blockchain security needs to be substantially improved. It will happen, though!

legutierr··on Detect breaches with Canary credit cards
This is part of the reason that a lot of people are excited about stablecoins and blockchain payments.
legutierr··on Drug-resistant cases of gonorrhea detected in the US
So you are saying this functional vaccine exists, and has been approved by the FDA for another use, so that it can be used off-label, but that people do not use it because people don't know about it...

...and you don't name the vaccine or provide any specific information about it.

I'm sure you see the irony!

What is this vaccine called, and for what other purpose has it been approved? Do you have a link to a study indicating that it is somewhat affective against Neisseria gonorrhoeae?

legutierr··on NanoGPT
> The code itself is plain and readable: train.py is a ~300-line boilerplate training loop and model.py a ~300-line GPT model definition, which can optionally load the GPT-2 weights from OpenAI. That's it.

What's the best source for these weights?

legutierr··on Canada buys 88 F-35 fighter jets for $14.2B
Are you suggesting that Canada should renege on its defense spending obligations as a member of NATO, and simply benefit from NATO’s security umbrella as a freeloader? Or are you suggesting that Canada should drop out of NATO? I can’t really tell from your comment.
legutierr··on The number of banks willing to do business with the crypto industry is shrinking
While the block reward remains high in USD terms, I think you’re right with regards to the power balance. But if the reward falls low enough—which very well might happen, if the price of Bitcoin stagnates and if transaction fees stay low—then there won’t be enough miners to secure the network without some kind of change to the algorithm.

The Bitcoin Cash fork happened when prices were rising and the inflation rate was still high. What would the balance of power have been if the block reward were 1/16 what it was at that time? What if the only miners willing to stay in the network were trying to exploit it in some other way, because the block reward was insufficient an incentive?

In that kind of environment, both users and miners might start looking to make changes.

legutierr··on The number of banks willing to do business with the crypto industry is shrinking
> But bitcoin, for the first time in history, sets monetary policy in stone

There’s nothing preventing Bitcoin miners from modifying the Bitcoin supply algorithm and inflation rate, except for their collective unwillingness to do so.

Bitcoin block rewards go down over time in Bitcoin terms—but so far the long term trend has been that the rewards have gone up in USD terms. We have never seen a sustained, long-term decline in the block reward in USD terms.

When we have seen short-term declines in the USD-denominated block reward, the hash rate has also declined—meaning a good number of miners have stopped mining.

What happens if the price of Bitcoin stagnates in the long term? Will miners still mine when the block reward is slashed again? Or will they decide to modify the algorithm to ensure that they remain profitable?

legutierr··on Canada buys 88 F-35 fighter jets for $14.2B
How do you think it compares to the Typhoon?
legutierr··on Canada buys 88 F-35 fighter jets for $14.2B
Canada is part of NATO. The US is obligated to take Canada’s interests into account with regards to the country’s defense.

Canada is buying these planes because they are the most effective fighters available within the general price range.

legutierr··on The Fermi paradox revisited: Technosignatures and the contact era
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment
legutierr··on OneCoin co-founder pleads guilty to $4B fraud
This may be happening, but the reason it is happening is that Sarbanes Oxley made it such a burden to run a public company that companies that otherwise would have gone public began to seek capital in the private markets instead.

Regulation protects retail from making money as much as it protects retail from loosing money.

legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
Good points! Yes, public blockchains are often not suitable for private or confidential transactions. That being said, anonymization tools do exist, which can solve this problem for many use cases.

Also, I agree that blockchains only work in the context of a functioning legal system, in that the link between on-chain assets and physical assets must be enforced via some legal or governmental mechanism. This should be possible using contracts under current law, however, and such contracts could be limited to establishing this linkage, avoiding more complex issues that might otherwise come into play if it were not for the use of a blockchain for record-keeping, transfers and settlement.

legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
Could you explain what you mean?

As I noted, "by definition" a block that has reached finality will not be removed. Any attempt to add, modify or delete transactions or blocks prior to this point would be self-defeating because it would be automatically rejected.

Yes, newer blocks can be forked out of existence before they reach finality, which is why only blocks that have reached finality are deemed immutable.

legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
Reconciling digital records against physical assets is something that all electronic systems of this sort must contend with. But traditional multi-party systems also need to worry about reconciling each entity's records against all the other entities' records.

The blockchain simplifies the arrangement. Where is the additional complexity you are referring to?

legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
My point is not that the problem cannot be solved by traditional approaches, but rather to identify that it is a problem that somehow needs to be solved. It's something that people need to expend resources and take on risk to solve.

The reason so much time is spent negotiating legal agreements is to reduce the surface area of dispute. On one hand, we want to reduce the possibility of misunderstandings that could lead to a "shooting war" as you put it, and also to reduce as much as possible the scope of the matter that may need to be evaluated by a court in the event of a litigation.

Using a blockchain in a situation like this can make achieving both of those objectives much easier and less costly from both legal and operating points of view. There would still need to be some contractual relationship among the participants, but the scope of the contract can be simplified and reduced.

And if the number of participants involved exceeds two entities, a blockchain can vastly simplify the relationships of all the participants with each other, without needing to empower a centralized entity to coordinate among all the participants.

> Human history has lots of "people don't trust each other" scenarios, and they've been resolved in the past, with reasonable efficiency, without blockchain.

Sure, but what's wrong with reducing costs and complexity even further?

legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
This should be possible to do only through standardizable contracts, with enforcement through arbitration and/or the courts.
legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
To implement a traditional escrow you need an escrow agent and an escrow agreement, as you rightly note. In the event of a dispute, the escrow just holds onto the money until the question is resolved in arbitration or litigation.

Expenses involved is such a process include legal fees to draft and negotiate the agreement; paying the escrow agent for their bother; paying for litigation in the event of a dispute. Plus, you have the risk of the escrow agent misappropriating the funds.

Escrows can be implemented on a blockchain as well. If the use case is suitable, you can save a lot of money and hassle! And if settlement is on-chain and is indisputable, you might not even need any escrow at all.

legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
One reasonable way to keep detailed records of transactions is a blockchain!

The best thing about a blockchain in a situation like this is that the different participants don't need to reconcile their transaction records to make sure they agree. Reconciliation between the participants—which is costly and can lead to disputes—is unnecessary.

Of course there are other technologies you can use as well, but using a blockchain would be easier and cheaper—especially if additional parties begin to participate in the arrangement as well.

legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
Yeah, but what if that decentralized network of trustless computers already exists, and transaction costs relative to costs you would otherwise incur are very low?

The premise of your argument is that building a clearinghouse is cheaper and easier than using a blockchain. That seems laughable, honestly.

legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
What if there is no clearinghouse operating in that particular market?
legutierr··on Binance's books are a black box, filings show, as it tries to rally confidence
If two rival businesses are transacting with each other, and they don’t really trust each other fully, which one hosts the database?

Whoever hosts the database is in a position to manipulate data to the disadvantage of the other. Which entity gives in and gives up that power to the other? Why should either party agree to take on that sort of counterparty risk when they don’t have to?

Also, what instances of non-immutable blockchains are you referring to? Blockchains by definition are immutable post-finality.

legutierr··on Promotion of alternative social platforms policy
Per my understanding: most important functionality is implemented in the client; clients can connect to any relay server, and any number of relay servers; messages can be relayed by any number of relay servers; and anyone can spool up a new relay server at any time.
legutierr··on Promotion of alternative social platforms policy
Per my understanding, relays are stateless in the sense that they do not store any user state or message state, except what is self-contained within the relayed messages themselves. Also, messages can be relayed by any relay server and by multiple servers, and messages don't necessarily persist.

I've only started learning about it today, though, so my understanding is limited!

legutierr··on Promotion of alternative social platforms policy
Nostr is perhaps the most interesting of the list. Fully decentralized; messages are cryptographically signed; users are identified by their private keys; following is done on the client side, with no stateful server-side component; messages broadcast via stateless relays.

https://github.com/nostr-protocol/nostr

https://github.com/aljazceru/awesome-nostr

Overall design seems very simple. It feels a bit like email, in the sense that you could probably put together a barebones implementation like sendmail and still be fully functional.

← PreviousPage 4 of 26Next →