HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

leifg

1,002 karma · joined May 15, 2008

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/leifg; my proof: https://keybase.io/leifg/sigs/2oSnL-U5YbaZPjyig4HsLw_eQgbSeuqc2y7auIghWJY ]

[ Kismet Code: 0b8f2d ]

meet.hn/city/us-San Diego

Socials: - github.com/leifg

Interests: Remote Work

---

submissionscomments
leifg··on The Bitcoin Energy Argument That Nobody Makes
Author here. I agree, me not liking it is not a great point. I think a stronger point would have been:

If you take the energy usage of anything you need to ask: "Does the positives of the thing justify this energy usage?". Let's say the current energy consumption of the Bitcoin network is X. You will find people saying "X is totally justified for the upsides the network brings" and you will find people that say no to that. But if you ask the yes people then: "What about 2X, 4X, 100X?" More and more yeses will switch to no. Of course you will find some people that will say "A power consumption of infinity is justified for the Bitcoin network and I rather have that than a car a house $other_thing_energy_consumption_thing" but I doubt this will the majority.

And this is the fundamental point tried to make. With rising Bitcoin prices the power consumption will cross every threshold without changing the positives that the network brings. I don't see a way to convert the people who say "it's NOT worth it" to "yes it is worth it" without affecting the Bitcoin price.

If you compare that to Christmas light there is a big difference. If you have people that say: "I don't like that Christmas lights use so much power" we can think of multiple solution to decrease the power usage without affecting the upsides proportionally: Can you compromise on using Christmas lights a week later in the year? Can you commit to slowly changing your existing lights to more power efficient ones? Can you use them for an hour less per day? And you can build incentives and legislation around that. I know that even in this space there are hard liners on both sides but I believe it is completely feasible to reduce the power consumption without affecting the upsides in the same way.

leifg··on Rails is not written in Ruby
If I understand the Ruby pipeline operator it's essentially an alias of the dot. The example in the feature tracker is:

``` 1.. |> take 10 |> map {|e| e2} |> (x) ```

which is equivalent to

``` (1...).take(10).map{|e| e2} ```

So in order to use it you still need extensions on every single object. The only reason that looks nice is because in this example you continuously call methods on lists that return a list. You can't add `my_custom_list_operation(list_input)` in between.

leifg··on German gov plans software company's liability for damages caused by vulns
To everyone saying my weekend project is going to be on the hook for millions:

The keyword here is "fahrlässig" (translates to negligent). Whoever is damaged must be able to prove that a bug caused through your program was negligent. I myself have tons of weekend project that have no stakes at all (most are libraries that are used by essentially no one and I make $0 from all of them combined) and even there I spend a little bit of time keeping dependencies up to that. With the few bug reports I get I at least look into them. It will be very hard to extort any money out of me under this law.

If you are running a startup and making money you will need to allocate resources to maintenance, stability and bug fixing.

leifg··on The New York Times buys Wordle
You mean the name? I guess that makes sense.

If the NYT would release "The daily NYW word game" it would probably not catch on as much.

leifg··on The New York Times buys Wordle
Is there any IP attached to wordle?

What was preventing them from paying someone to build a clone?

leifg··on Binance kept weak money-laundering checks even as it promised tougher compliance
General question: are crypto exchanges not regulated the same way banks are regulated (in the US)?
leifg··on The time might come when we add some JSON specific command line options
To everyone saying "just use tool x for this": the advantage of curl is that is so widely available.

For your development laptop you can install anything you want but more often than not you need to log into a EC2 instance, a Docker container you name it.

Curl is often pre installed or very easy to install. I know it's usually not an up to date version but as time goes by you will be able to rely on this feature on pretty much any machine.

leifg··on You, Me, and Utility NFTs
The NFT ticketing example always makes me furious especially the "solving shady secondary market" argument.

This is a ridicolously easy problem to solve: Make tickets personalized, give buyers the opportunity to sell ticket back to the ticket seller. Problem solved. If checking your ID card on entry is too much of a burden, non-NFT tech can help by loads (app with rotating QR code that invalidates tickets).

That is 1000 easier than any NFT gimmicks. If you want to tell me that you want to use NFTs to solve the scalping problem, please explain first why the above example won't work.

leifg··on A Better Git Flow
This to me seems more like a logical separation than anything technical.

I use GitHub and always squash commits before merging a PR. This keeps the commit log clean and also has the side effect that you have the PR number in the merge commit.

Having said that I also suggest keeping PRs small. If you are going to reformat a code base, make that a separate commit. Updating a library, separate commit. Adding a library you need for a new feature: create a PR for the library update, base your implementation off that branch and rebase against main when the first PR is merged.

leifg··on Direct conversion of CO2 to solid carbon by Gallium-based liquid metals
> Gallium is cheap (~$300/kg)

Please correct me if I get the numbers wrong but if that is the price, that means the price of 1 ton Gallium is $300,000 per ton

From [another comment](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29990056) I got that the ratio of CO2 to Ga would be 1 to 2. So in order to reduce 1 ton of CO2 you'll need to spend $600,000. That seems insane. Especially when the damage done per ton of CO2 is usually valued at ~$200.

leifg··on Show HN: Justyourip.com
Not sure what the difference is but either probably works for my use case.
leifg··on Show HN: Justyourip.com
That is already 100 times better than existing solutions.

That being said, I find it useful to see the location I'm connecting from (mostly to make sure that my VPN works).

leifg··on Basic income would not reduce people’s willingness to work
The problem I have with the UBI is that you absolutely have to nail it on the first try in order for it to succeed. A great example is the housing market (in the US but also applies to a lot of European countries).

Regardless of UBI there will always be locations that will be more popular than others. I'm not saying everyone wants to live in San Francisco or Manhattan but I don't think supply will always exceed demand.

Assuming this there will be regions where demand for housing exceeds supply. So naturally the price of rent will go up. In some places that means you will have to find a job in order to be able to pay rent. At this point people are again subject to the current patterns of exploitation.

Sure if you can't make rent in one of the coastal cities you can always move inland and have a nicer life but even leaving money issues aside there are so many factors why people are not willing or even unable to move (proximity to family and friends is a big deal).

All that is to say, before you can even think of a UBI you will have to first solve the housing crisis because at best UBI will mitigate it. And this is just one example (cough health care).

leifg··on Web3 Is Not a Scam, but It Can Feel Like One
Alternative Title: "Web3 feels like a scam, it probably is one"
leifg··on Updating a 50 terabyte PostgreSQL database (2018)
One of the things I always wonder with giant relational database is. How much of the "typical relational stuff" are they actually using?

Do they have constraints on rows? Are they using views or do they just denormalize and duplicate? Do they use joins at all? Are they even doing more than 1 thing in a transaction?

leifg··on The Tipping Point: The Economics of Taxi Fares
Here (in California) I mostly see 18,20,25 for restaurants and even higher ones in coffee shops (sometimes over 30 as the highest tier)
leifg··on My First Impressions of Web3
> What surprised me about the standards was that there’s no hash commitment for the data located at the URL.

I hear a lot that some of the smartest people work on web3/blockchain/crypto.

It blows my mind that the NFT standard doesn’t enforce a content hash. I genuinely thought that was part of the standard.

How did no one foresee that content at a URL can change?

leifg··on Mozilla Foundation pausing cryptocurrency donations
Aren't Paraguay, Brazil and Argentina in the same trade union? I don't know the details of Mercosur but in the EU you can buy whatever you want in any other EU country and take it back home without the need for customs. Where is the black market part of that trade?

As for your trade example I would like to see the details of that. There are not a lot of vendors that accept crypto and those who do, use 3rd parties which then usually require some amount of KYC (even if it's is minimal). Combine that with how many vendors are actually able/willing to ship to the country in question and you are left with a very small set of online stores. Add shipping costs and custom fees that will eat in your margin. So yes in theory you can setup an import/export company empire in order to exchange your crypto into local currency but that is pretty much the definition of "not scaling".

My point is: if a country wants to make cryptocurrency useless they can totally do it.

leifg··on Mozilla Foundation pausing cryptocurrency donations
While "banning crypto" is a challenging task, making cryptocurrency useless in your jurisdiction is extremely easy.

prohibit any business to accept crypto as payment, ban crypto exchanges from operating in your country, ban banks of your country to accept transaction that they suspect coming from cryptocurrency exchanges

You can still have your crypto wallet, but what use is it if you can't exchange it in your local currency? You can always meet someone in an ally or travel outside the country and bring cash back in but these are solutions that don't scale.

leifg··on Inviting another GitHub user to be your successor
Wasn’t there a case where someone went to prison and no one had access to repo?

Is that handled with this feature?

leifg··on Show HN: OnlyRecipe.app – Remove clutter from recipe sites
I use a similar recipe manager on my phone (paprika 3 but also playing around with Mela). They come with an integrated browser to download the recipes.

Not only do they did rid of the novel about the ingredients and their origins, they also get around most paywalls.

The thing that would make me instantly switch to any other manager is an app that would parse recipes from the various YouTube and TikTok videos. If you follow the right accounts these videos are a gold mine.

leifg··on How Y Combinator Changed the World
The internet, the electric grid and satellite communications are all great examples for state sponsored endeavors…
leifg··on How Y Combinator Changed the World
Call me a socialist but we had scientific and engineering breakthroughs without hyper capitalism.

If NASA had the budget of the 1960s today we would be way ahead of what Space X is doing now.

And yeah, even without that I’d trade Space X for more global equality in a second.

leifg··on Web3/Crypto: Why Bother?
> Ok, so how is this remotely the same as PCs being cheaper? Well because to some people this matters a great deal. Why? Because much of the power held by large companies (and by governments) comes from the fact that they operate and control databases.

The key point here is "Some People". But to make meaningful change a majority of people have to switch to a new system. The sad truth is: 90% of people do not care.

The best example for this is podcasts. They started out as a decentralized utopia. Self hosted files, self hosted feeds, multiple apps to listen to them, improvements of existing formats (mp3 chapters were not really a thing before podcasts), there were even talks about enabling BitTorrent distribution.

Fast forward a few years, now Spotify seems to accumulate most of the podcast universe and a lot of the existing podcast use them as a distribution platform. And their exclusive content is drawing in more and more users.

So my question here is: if we have a decentralized system that works but people willingly use a centralized alternative of that, how can you claim that decentralization is remotely popular?

You need to address this social issue before coming up with any kind of technology to solve it.

leifg··on Web3/Crypto: Why Bother?
Leaving aside the discussions around PKI and necessary centralization in public/private key authentication I've seen this web3 debate a couple of times now.

It starts with "web3 is the second (third?) coming of the internet and will revolutionize everything".

If you ask for proof or use cases the very first comment is: "You can log into Twitter using a public/private key pair"

These are two very different statements. So even if you assume there is advantage in public/private key auth it is still nowhere close to an internet revolution.

Imagine the PostgreSQL team had praised the JSON data type as the revolution of the internet and disruption of all industries as we know it. It's a useful feature and it is used by a lot of companies but it has zero impact on everyday people. And Bloomberg and the Wall Street Journal are certainly not writing about it.

leifg··on Why Web3?
I think the argument made implicitly is that with web3 you could actually monetize your contribution. If you run an IRC server you (usually) only have cost. One part of web3 is tokens so you can actually earn some fake money by running an IRC server.

I think if you look at the economics of that though I don't think it will turn out in your favor. You are either making 10ct a month from it or you'll have to heavily invest in hardware to (potentially) turn a profit.

The reason some of that works now is because we have an inflated price of tokens and people are speculating on it going up. But that makes it not an appealing service for you to pay for.

And all of that forgets that the vast majority of people is not willing to pay anything to use a service. No matter how often web3 people will yell "If you don't pay for it, you're the product".

leifg··on Blockchains Are Too Old to Be the Beginning of Anything
Maybe but I feel the term is currently so much in the public that it's unlikely to change its definition.

What I think is more likely, that the buzzword web3 will evolve into something that has nothing to do with blockchains or even tokens.

leifg··on Blockchains Are Too Old to Be the Beginning of Anything
Mmmh interesting, I always assumed the term smartphone was basically a term coined with the iPhone. I should have probably called it something like "the modern smartphone". I didn't want to write iPhone because that's not a category.
leifg··on Web3 Is Bullshit
Seems like we have very different interpretations and standards for “disruption”.

I don’t consider “everyone is talking about it” disruption. I want to see real world implementation that goes beyond “virtual asset value goes to the moon” to be convinced.

As I said in an earlier comment: It’s been almost 13 years since the first block has been mined on the Bitcoin blockchain and the positive impact on society/economy is pretty disappointing.

leifg··on Web3 Is Bullshit
Even if that’s true the argument “web3 is better for some users and developers” is very far from “web3 will disrupt the internet as we know it”
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →