HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

leohutson

323 karma · joined November 11, 2012

submissionscomments
leohutson··on Hackers are the new lawyers
Absolutely, "paper" trails through and walking along rivers and beaches bordered by private property are other interesting examples of where the law and "norms" of the situation are often pretty blurry. That's just land, computers are a whole other level of complexity, plus the "norms" are not yet decided.
leohutson··on Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous car
Doesn't even need to be a traffic infringement, most jurisdictions have loose catch-all minor crimes like "disturbing the peace" or "disorderly conduct", with pretty low burdens of proof.
leohutson··on Job hopping helped Silicon Valley thrive. Why do other states restrict it?
People should perhaps be free to create whatever informal contracts they want between themselves, but there is no "freedom" that entitles them to have their arbitrary contract enforced by the state.

When enforcing those contracts through coercion, the state denies the infringing party some freedom.

leohutson··on Almost everyone is doing the API economy wrong
What's the context here though?

I had to skim like 5 paragraphs to even know wtf the title meant.

leohutson··on Stop Obama’s Internet Giveaway
Try opening the Google link in incognito. Or don't, it's not really worth the effort to read such a biased piece.
leohutson··on The American Economy Is in a Funk, But Not for the Reasons We Think
There's nothing wrong with "content" when it's purely entertainment, but freakonomics falls well into the TED, Malcolm Gladwell, "fake-insight" category, that makes you feel clever about knowing some counter-intuitive fact, when the majority of the time, it's only counter-intuitive because it has been presented unintuitively in the first place, or because the fact is actually bullshit.
leohutson··on Frameworks Don't Make Much Sense
Not quite sure I understand the calling distinction? I guess the article is more about web frameworks, which I have no knowledge of. I had desktop applications in mind, in particular GUI centric frameworks like Qt, which aside from moc is mostly just a very extensive set of libraries that build functionality on top of each other.
leohutson··on Frameworks Don't Make Much Sense
Frameworks are just a set of libraries that play nice.

If you use a bunch of separate libraries from different developers, then you have to write a lot glue code to get data between those libraries.

That code is usually slower, as it will involve copying and transforming data, i.e. you'll be copying data in and out of different classes, copying data to memory allocated by the library, copying data to differently aligned memory, transposing data, copying data between different sized scalar types etc.

Frameworks make cross platform development a lot faster, and learning a framework is no more of a waste of time than learning another language or native OS api.

I absolutely agree, that bundling together a bunch of dependencies, and having those dependencies maintained by the same vendor has a risk/cost.

Don't choose a shitty or faddish framework; put as much research into choosing your framework as you would into researching it's individual libraries, use the framework as it was designed, and only use what you need.

leohutson··on GitHub is undergoing a full-blown overhaul as execs and employees depart
So you'll just take a guess at your biases and then try to counteract them arbitrarily?

I'd like to know how you even begin to judge what ethnicity someone is just by looking at them. Sounds like an extremely fraught game to play.

Part of the answer is surely to try your utmost to take all the subjectivity out of the process. I've mentioned it here previously, and people said that they enjoy getting to make subjective value judgments of candidates. I think that is a poor attitude.

This is the kind of process I was thinking:

One person strips CV's of irrelevant info (names, ages, schools, etc). They hand that to another person who decides who to interview. When the candidate is interviewed, pre-determined questions get asked, and then notes are taken of their answers and any relevant info, and that gets handed over to the person who makes the ultimate hiring decision.

Even that process probably leaks a bit, but it's better than simply trying to guess.

leohutson··on GitHub is undergoing a full-blown overhaul as execs and employees depart
I would care if my coworkers were bigots, and I would especially care if they were prejudiced against me, how can you effectively work with someone who doesn't respect you? Pretending bigotry doesn't exist is the same thing as pretending that race/sex aren't visible. You will also have to apply the same affirmative action when promoting people, as a couple of years work experience doesn't erase the generations of privilege you're competing with.

I never said that minorities can only be hired by applying insufficient scrutiny. What I will say is as a group, minorities can only be hired in a proportion that is different to the proportion of minorities in group of qualified applicants if some weighting is taken off the job relevant qualifications, and applied to their membership in minority groups.

If you could come up with a huge list of entirely fungible, interchangeable resumes and interview notes, you could consciously pick minorities first without harming the quality of your recruiting. What kind of roles would have that weak of a job market though?

If candidates aren't fungible weighting any importance to race/sex means taking some weighting off something else, and it means that bigots will assume individuals from minority groups are less qualified, because of the fact that the group as a whole is less qualified, because of your own policies. It perpetuates both inequality and bigotry.

leohutson··on GitHub is undergoing a full-blown overhaul as execs and employees depart
How is race or sex aware hiring going to help with eliminating subconscious bias? It reinforces bigotry, because it gives a rationalization for bigots to not respect their minority coworkers, as they can claim that they were not subject to the same scrutiny when they were hired.

What is the historical justification for the effectiveness affirmative action? Certainly, countries like Malaysia and South Africa with extreme disparity seem to have mixed results at best.

I agree that pretending ethnicity/sex are not visible, is not the same thing as making ethnicity/sex invisible. But actually implementing enrollment and employment laws or policies that hide this information from decision makers could make it nearly invisible.

That's actually not the fundamental problem though. Even if you managed to a perfectly even proportion of middle class stem graduates from 1st and 2nd tier universities represented on your payroll, you'll still end up with a monoculture. Not because of some hard to pin down unconscious bigotry, but because little has been done to eliminate class from society, and social class is a big factor in a persons access to education and the quality of their childhood.

Poor, working class women have less work opportunities than men, as less educated ( religious ) working class people tend conform to traditional gender roles more than middle class people, well paid working class jobs require more physical strength, and unlike middle class mothers, working class mothers cannot afford childcare or help with housework while working or studying. Like ethnicity, class is almost hereditary so is easily confused with ethnicity in statistics.

Making the statistics look better by hiring proportionally more middle class minorities is a face saving exercise, not a solution.

leohutson··on AI That Annoys Telemarketers
This happens all the time, scammers calling from India via voip and scaring elderly people into installing malware onto their Windows computers. The police say they can do nothing about it, but this service would be a perfect way to make these scams unprofitable by tying up their operators.
leohutson··on 15 years of VLC and VideoLAN
This is a thing already. It's an option as a qt phonon backend in Linux at least, so all qt apps that use it will support any of vlcs codecs.
leohutson··on The myth of the ISIS encrypted messaging app
It's convenient that they can justify the risk to democracy with information we aren't allowed to see. I guess we'll just have to take it on faith
leohutson··on Israeli Drone Feeds Hacked by British and American Intelligence
> This type of leaking gives credence to the national security concerns

Gives credence to what/whose concerns? What do think Israel would have learnt from this leak?

If Israel were spying on US drone video transmissions, and a "traitor" in the Israeli security apparatus leaked that info to the press, would it still be harmful for the "public" to know?

It really weirds me out the degree to which people seem to moralize these brain-dead spy games. It's like we're already in state of paranoid pre-war. It's OK to spy on another country, and it's OK for our allies to spy on us, but its not OK for citizens to spy on their own government, it's OK for foreign governments to spy on our citizens, but we're only allowed to spy on our own citizens in foreign countries or foreign servers.

If it's of no interest to the public, then surely the secret was not a secret at all, and there was no harm in leaking it.

leohutson··on The Rails Doctrine
It's just subjective and unproductive noise.

The strict moderation and categorization is what makes stack exchange useful in general. Why not use a free-form forum like Reddit for that kind of question? Because you know the answers are going to bullshit opinions and holy wars, mostly by people that are trying to solve different problems than you, or are actually less knowledgeable than you.

Given the fact that Reddit and similar forums suck for finding solutions to specific problems, why should a Q/A site that is good for finding solutions for specific problems try to emulate it?

Quora and Yahoo answers also suck because the questions are almost entirely anecdote and opinion based, and it seems to be acceptable to cite "experience" as a source for bullshit opinions. "Being a pilot with 10 years of experience" is not an adequate reference for a response to a question about the safety of using a cellphone radio on a commercial flight, nor does "being a veteran" count as original research into Iraqi popular support for the 2003 invasion.

Of the good "answers" from Quora that I've seen shared, all are basically long form blog posts that have found a "close enough" question to answer, rather than been motivated by the question, and I would have actually preferred to read them on medium or some other blog site. However interesting they are, they aren't answers.

I think projects like Rosetta code are useful for comparisons of programming languages, because they keep it concrete. You can also look at big high-quality projects on github or whatever and directly judge the subjective qualities of a language for yourself, based on how readable the code looks to you.

leohutson··on 13k BTC, 300k LTC Stolen from Cryptsy Exchange
Price fluctuations make bitcoin a non-starter as a savings account anyway.

It would be better to store savings in an interest bearing account with a bank or other investments, some of which might include bitcoin and some of it's possible successors.

For me at least, the compelling thing about cryptocurrencies is the possibility of cheap transactions, but bitcoin itself doesn't really seem to fit the bill as it stands, so it seems like a high risk investment.

leohutson··on "Free Basics" - Myths and Facts
Facebook doesn't need to do this.

They have a huge market share on the real internet, they could simply give more people neutral internet access, and they would still grow.

The fact that are attempting this means that they obviously don't believe in the longevity of their product on its own merits, so they are going to try to lock in a few users while they can.

leohutson··on Kim Dotcom loses extradition case
Most countries have had films shot in them. Globally, the film industry does seem to have unusually strong sway with politicians though, considering the relatively small amount of money and people involved.

With regards to dotcom's extradition, I do think the initial raid on his house was an absolute disgrace, but it seems pretty unlikely that he would have had the grace of the court this long in any other OECD country, although that's partly because of the idiotically bungled warrants. The extradition process would have been much faster from the UK for example. [1]

As a rule, our judges are typically not very cooperative with our government [2], let alone foreign ones.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK%E2%80%93US_extradition_trea...

[2] http://www.stuff.co.nz/nelson-mail/69299045/judge-critical-o...

leohutson··on Bacteria that resist 'last antibiotic' found in UK
The abstract of paper you shared was interesting, but the reason you are being down voted is probably because of the tabloid level of political spin you have forced on it, and the crank-like way that you have tried to make yourself out as a victim because of intolerance for the "controversial" synthesis you have presented.

Migration in the context of epidemiology has nothing to do with your political status in that country, and has everything to do with your physical presence, and contact with other people in that location.

Sure, shut the UK's boarders to all international travel. Perhaps you'll manage to stop sex tourists from bringing back super-gonorrhoea from the third world.

leohutson··on Kindergarten Has Become the New First Grade
I was taught to read before school, not in kindergarten, but at home. I feel like it didn't do any harm, and my reading comprehension was top of my class until I entered high school, when I more or less stopped reading for pleasure altogether. I wasn't bored in class, because we picked our own books to read, so you could read at your own level.

I think that being taught some stuff at home might have stunted the development of my time management skills, because I could always complete the work in a very small part of the assigned time.

Mum had taught me some basic mathematical manipulations and "short-cuts", and I remember for a while I was ahead of the class in that too, again I wasn't bored though, because I just completed the problems quickly and then did my own thing. The problem was, when the level of difficulty caught up to my skill level again in high school, I was used to having time to muck around in class, and I never put in enough time and effort to finish the assigned work.

When I eventually have kids, I'll teach them anything they ask about, or need help with, but I'm going to trust their teachers with their core subjects by default.

The way I see it, the school material will be pretty straightforward, and easily remediated, but soft skills and self discipline are developed early on, and should not be interrupted for the sake of knowing how to simplify a fraction a year early.

edit:

Thinking about it more, it probably wasn't just my Mum that had made class too easy, the pace was probably a bit too slow for me anyway. When I entered high school, I was put into the advanced stream/track, but by that time my poor study habits were already formed. Perhaps there should have been multiple streams in primary school also.

leohutson··on Another Dell root certificate discovered
I'm happy with my zenbook hardware wise, but it still came with a bunch of crap installed. I only use my arch partition, but I think I'll wipe the windows partition it came with and do a fresh install if I get tempted to use windows for something. Microsoft is the one to blame for this situation really, they need to take responsibility for checking the security of all OEM installs prior to shipping.
leohutson··on Tor Wars: The Signal Awakens
People that claim open source has no security value seem to believe that just because you can't catch every vulnerability through public review, you may as well not bother at all. That logic is obviously faulty, I can't imagine they would apply the same rationale to cancer screening.
leohutson··on Corporations and OSS Do Not Mix
I was more thinking of stuff that is entirely mine that I just want to dump a copy of onto the web.

I don't think it's fair to make contributors assign copyright to me, especially if they are major.

I'd probably just keep a private fork from before their contributions, and, if for whatever reason my employer is GPL averse, that's their problem, and they can pay to reimplement anything they need from after that point.

Edit:

Perhaps a fair way to do it would be to say that contributors who agree to the CLA are also assigned rights to the whole code base, with the restriction of only being able to redistribute it wholesale as GPL. Similar to the way commercial sound and video clip libraries are licensed, you are allowed to redistribute it as part of another work in whatever license you like, but wholesale redistribution is only allowed under the GPL. That would give the same advantages as a more permissive license, but reduce the freerider problem to some extent.

leohutson··on Corporations and OSS Do Not Mix
Dual license your code. You can still supply it to your current employer, and any future employer under a proprietary license.
leohutson··on Corporations and OSS Do Not Mix
Yeah, that makes sense to me.

I get sick of seeing entitled programmers whining that some library is LGPL or GPL, and saying they aren't going to use it as a consequence. Don't expect the author to be somehow sympathetic that you aren't going to be able make money off their work without offering anything in return, whether it's code or money.

leohutson··on Money Flooding Out of Canada at Fastest Pace in Developed World
Excess isolationism also makes the economy more vulnerable. For example, primary industries are more exposed by gluts in production flooding the market and driving down the value of goods, and shortages of domestically produced goods will obviously have a more severe impact on consumers.

Obviously no protectionist scheme is going to tax goods that it's market cannot produce, but there is always a tendency to put industry above consumer, and assymetric/mercantile style protections in place.

People often have intellectual debates about ideology/philosophy here, but nationalism is the real political force. If a government can be seen to steer its economy in the right direction, and its people feel well off compared to their neighbours, it will be popular, regardless of ideology, and regardless of how fairly it has treated other nations in trade negotiations.

Likewise, a state will inevitably favor free trade when it will profit over other states, and protectionism when it won't.

In the rare case when both states will benefit from an arrangement, there's usually some third party getting screwed, i.e.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OPEC

I'm conflating capital controls with trade, but my point is more that they are often negotiated at the same time, and in the with the same ultimately selfish and unideological outlook.

leohutson··on Show HN: Vertexshaderart.com
I agree that to do it properly requires driver and hardware support.

However, it's already possible to have fairly granular control over compute resources with CUDA for example, and also to run streams of commands concurrently, so that would solve part of the problem.

The other part of the problem that could be solved by vulkan is the browser taking control of compilation, which allows for more static checking and refusal of possibly unterminated loops.

leohutson··on Show HN: Vertexshaderart.com
I'm actually more concerned by how easy it is to peg the GPU. The operating system does a pretty good job in controlling errant processes in general, but with GPU stuff it's easy to get your computer completely unresponsive. My android phone rebooted while trying to load one of these demos. The GPU APIs and drivers are two raw to expose to the web directly,especially compared to the way threading, networking and storage have been abstracted. Hopefully vulkan will allow for a more web suitable api to be built on top of it.
leohutson··on Volkswagen’s Diesel Fraud Makes Critic of Secret Code a Prophet
Why? Competitors are the best placed entities, in terms of both resources and motivation, to perform a review.

Also, do you want officials to have to review and test one hundred different implementations of a safety critical piece of code, or would you prefer an evolution to a single standard shared code base, shared between manufacturers, for which all testing efforts are directed at new patches?

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →