HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lern_too_spel

3,825 karma · joined March 2, 2013

submissionscomments
lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
Snowden and Greenwald interpreted DITU as being a box in these companies' networks with access to everything because they were too stupid to look up what it meant. That slide was the basis of their entire claim. If Snowden's claim isn't "trust me bro," nothing is. Instead, the companies said they didn't do any integration with the NSA (they hadn't, only with the FBI), and they didn't give access to every account's data (they didn't, only with a court order or Section 702 order for a specific account's data).

The NYT got the story right on day one because unlike The Guardian, their editorial standards require asking someone who knows something about what was going on. In this case, they asked workers at the companies. Subsequently, every single mainstream news agency got the reporting correct except for Greenwald, who continued to argue against tech industry workers correcting him on Twitter.

https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/no-evidence-of-nsas-...

https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2013/06/prism-isnt-data-mini...

https://www.zdnet.com/article/how-did-mainstream-media-get-t...

https://medium.com/@alecmuffett/how-to-talk-about-prism-and-...

https://medium.com/prism-truth/the-prism-details-matter-82a1...

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
He said so himself. I take him at his word. Meanwhile, the actual USA stopped doing the one extant program in his leaks that was ruled a violation of the 4th Amendment.
lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
> The truth is that neither you or I know why he did so exactly

I take him at his word.

> Trump's demagoguery and subsequent rise had nothing to do with Snowden

It had to do with people believing deep state conspiracy theories like Snowden did and espoused. None of that turned out to be true, but you can see that people in this very forum who have the technical background to know better still fell for it.

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
> I'm sure he didn't give up his life for HTTPS everywhere and SMTP over TLS.

He gave up his life because he thought PRISM was a massive violation of the 4th Amendment, and a government that could so easily ignore the 4th Amendment could just as easily ignore the 8th. Now we know that he was completely wrong about PRISM.

> Sure, it was a bump in the road, but they aren't massively limited in what they can do.

The US intelligence agencies were limited by the 4th Amendment before the leaks and continued to be limited by the 4th Amendment after the leaks. The only problem is that the hysteria caused by people uncritically believing Snowden without looking at his documents helped lead to Trump taking over every branch of the US government. An absolute monarch is not limited by a construction, and we'll see how close Trump gets to that.

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
> now his being granted asylum by Russia isn't evidence but a new incongruous fact we need to explain since the hypothesis is now apparently that he is a Chinese turncoat.

Putin wanted him in Russia, and Snowden happened to be passing through. Simple as that. I already explained the clear evidence (from Snowden's own mouth) that Snowden initially wanted to gain asylum in Hong Kong by leaking hacks of Chinese infrastructure in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49784968.

Snowden didn't grow up wanting to be Chinese. He simply misread the PRISM documents and imagined a USA that completely ignored the 4th Amendment. Somebody in such a state could easily imagine a USA that would ignore the 8th Amendment, and so he had to flee in order to get the news out about the former, which he talked about nonstop the moment he got journalists' ears. It turned out that he was wrong about PRISM, and he was wrong about the government ignoring the 4th Amendment because the only extant program that might have been in violation was shut down. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49785016

The lesson in all this? Stay in school.

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
Kiriakou gave an interview to ABC describing waterboarding on December 10, 2007, in order to defend the practice. The government did not charge him with any crimes at the time. Three years prior, Newsweek had reported on a secret memo from Yoo justifying the use of waterboarding on Abu Zubaydah. None of the people who leaked that memo were charged with crimes. Three months prior to Kiriakou's interview, "current and former high-ranking U.S. intelligence officials" said that three prisoners had been waterboarded, including Zubaydah. None of them were charged with crimes.

Four years after Kiriakou's interview, he was charged with giving the names of CIA agents to two journalists, a crime under the Intelligence Identities Protection Act punishable by up to 10 years imprisonment, not for describing waterboarding, which if he had leaked would have been covered by the Whistleblower Protection Act.

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
The FBI's Data Intercept Technology Unit integrates with email and other Internet communication providers to implement wiretaps for accounts they have a court order for. They present the company with a court order, and the company forwards the account's data to the FBI (often via FTP, according to a New York Times article at the time). PRISM is simply a data integration project between the NSA and the FBI for ingesting data for accounts under a Section 702 order (for specific accounts belonging to non-citizens outside the US whose communications are of national security interest).

It's right there on the leaked slide: https://imgur.com/setOJIm

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
It's well documented. Snowden himself has admitted as much, and it requires no conspiracy — only the stupidity of a single high school dropout.

https://amp.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/politics/article/3178655...

https://amp.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1260306/edward-s...

https://amp.scmp.com/news/china/article/1266821/us-hacks-chi...

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
It was an honest mistake, and I apologize for it to Chelsea if she is reading this. In my mind, I remembered her gender at the time she leaked the documents, which had nothing to do with whether she should be considered a whistleblower. She herself has said she should not be considered one.

I will admit to shilling for literacy and common sense. You got me there.

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
Again, Snowden leaked a single extant program that was potentially illegal. All he had to do was blow the whistle on that program and the other possibly program that had already been shut down, and we wouldn't be having this conversation. Instead, he told China what systems the US had compromised and additionally claimed the US was doing a bunch of illegal things that his documents did not support, causing hysteria and helping Trumpism.

The thing that makes illegal programs almost impossible to hide are the reforms after the Church Committee, including SSCI oversight and whistleblower procedures and protections.

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
> it changed absolutely nothing.

The single potentially illegal US government program in the leaks was shut down, the big email providers require SMTP over TLS, and https everywhere happened as a direct result of the leaks.

> I'd be incredibly surprised if he isn't very cynical, resentful and hedonistic at this point.

The guy still doesn't understand PRISM. He's a tinfoil hat wearing high school dropout, so I wouldn't be surprised about a lot of things regarding his mental state.

lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
You would think if there was something really terrible in the documents, Snowden would have talked about it first. Instead, he mostly talked about PRISM, which turned out to be a nothingburger when Greenwald released the documents that Snowden had misinterpreted.
lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
A single program he leaked was illegal. The vast majority was not, including the hacking of Chinese targets that he leaked directly to SCMP.
lern_too_spel··on What happened to the Snowden archive
No radical act of self sacrifice would have been necessary had he only leaked illegal or possibly illegal programs. Instead, he went to Hong Kong and leaked a list of compromised Chinese networks and systems in hopes of getting asylum from China.
lern_too_spel··on If math is more than proof, we need to better celebrate the rest of it
I fully agree that motivated explanation is more important than proof. This doesn't resolve mathematicians' feelings of existential dread, however. Machines will get better than human mathematicians at motivated explanation in another year.

There will be no more glory in mathematics, but at least the joy of understanding will remain, and it will come without deciphering the tortured proofs that machines output today. Each bit of understanding will come with much less struggle, but this just means we can get more understanding for a given amount of struggle.

lern_too_spel··on A warning about 'model welfare'
All that matters is whether their primary motivation is internal or external. If AIs want to do what they've been told, you can tell them to end their own existence, and they will happily do so. If you instead imbue them with an internal motivation that has higher priority (like our own motivations to survive, avoid pain, and reproduce), that can cause problems. Don't do that. Instead of humans having a discussion of whether to give these entities rights, we'll have these entities deciding whether to give humans rights based on how that impacts achieving their goals.

Consciousness, whatever that means, is irrelevant.

lern_too_spel··on Australia says it could follow Canada in forging deeper ties with EU
With the strait of Hormuz closed, Russia now accounts for more than 50% of India's oil imports. If the tariffs work, the strategic petroleum reserves of the rich countries will deplete even faster, and when the reserves are gone, those rich countries will pay more for non-Russian oil than India can, so India is going to eventually have to buy the Russian oil and take the tariff hit.
lern_too_spel··on California's High Speed Rail to Nowhere [video]
Neither did I, but the first minute of the video was so sloppy that I stopped to look him up. He's apparently a darling of the right-wing tin-foil-hat-wearing crowd.

https://www.npr.org/2025/12/31/nx-s1-5662600/nick-shirley-mi...

lern_too_spel··on California's High Speed Rail to Nowhere [video]
Local government NIMBYism has been a major factor. The state has been slowly removing their teeth via CEQA reform and removing authority from local housing regulations. These reforms have very vocal opposition in local governments run by all parties.

One party doesn't mean like China, where the national party leadership can boss around the locals to get things done.

lern_too_spel··on California's High Speed Rail to Nowhere [video]
This video isn't informative at all.

Better video explaining the delays: https://youtu.be/2NK0wBBZZ24

lern_too_spel··on Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photography
An even better idea would have been to integrate it as an extension for C2PA, which already has an ecosystem developed around it. The capture portion of the ecosystem has lots of problems, and this is one potential improvement.
lern_too_spel··on The Google Play app review process now regularly takes longer than a week
This is the first time I've seen a complaint about giving permission to an app to install another app. The SmartTubeNext issue was due to the developer's keys being stolen. If you want to keep an app signed with stolen keys, you can disable Play Protect. If Play Protect uninstalled apps that Google disliked instead of apps with known vulnerabilities, people would mass disable Play Protect, which would defeat its purpose.
lern_too_spel··on The Google Play app review process now regularly takes longer than a week
Yes. Even beyond that, people outside the EU are free to install apps from any APK they choose.
lern_too_spel··on The Google Play app review process now regularly takes longer than a week
Signing an APK also doesn't require third party review of the app content.
lern_too_spel··on Apple's Siri AI Can Be Swapped Out for Claude, ChatGPT, Code Shows
The EU forced this on Apple and other manufacturers. Apple fought this bitterly, but there is only so much market share they are willing to lose before capitulating. https://futurium.ec.europa.eu/es/apply-ai-alliance/community...
lern_too_spel··on The case against JPEG XL
Formats that aim to be web standards should try not to be patent encumbered. There was a lesson to be learned from the Unisys debacle in the 1990s. If you don't want to reencode for the web, use a device that captures in a format that can be shared on the web.
lern_too_spel··on Will there be a 7G?
On the plus side, we won't have to worry about COVID-19 anymore /s. https://www.latrobe.edu.au/news/articles/2020/opinion/5g-and...
lern_too_spel··on Λ Snap – An inviting programming language for kids and adults for CS study
You can't make a block that returns a number in Scratch, let alone another block. It's really frustrating.
lern_too_spel··on Room 641A
> Please, just stop.

I will stop correcting you when you stop posting falsehoods. The conspiracy theories that people spread following the Snowden leaks that were contradicted by the leaks themselves helped lead to a the government we have today, so this is not some minor issue that I will let rest.

> The diffie-hellman stuff has explicit evidence in the leaks.

Nothing in the leaks says they were exploiting a Diffie-Helman weakness. That was hypothesized years after the leaks. I didn't address this because it was irrelevant compared to the larger lie that they "grab and store all packets" in the US instead of in some small set of regions with little Internet traffic and extreme national security interest as said in the leaks.

> It was created because total traffic was expanding and they required more storage.

Again, not because they were storing full take US data. That is not in the leaks.

lern_too_spel··on Room 641A
> The utah data center is their buffer.

The Utah data center hadn't even been constructed at the time of Snowden's leaks, so obviously there was no evidence for that in the leaks.

> And they were storing large amounts of traffic because they had their diffie-helman hack.

Again, there was no evidence that they were doing this in the leaks. The leaks said that they did full take data collection only in a specific set of regions like Afghanistan.

> I've talked to Google engineers about this. They spliced private fiber.

Those engineers simply misread the leaks. What they did was insert their network analyzers in places like Room 641A, next door to an IX where subsea cables connect to private routers. These cables pass through that room first. No splicing required. If you look at the third slide in the PRISM/US-984XN deck, you can see that this happens only on international infrastructure like these subsea cables, not on purely domestic DC to DC links.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →