HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lern_too_spel

3,825 karma · joined March 2, 2013

submissionscomments
lern_too_spel··on Hang on to Your Firefox
If you're going to use a Chromium based browser, why pick one that's filled with crypto ads? I use Firefox on mobile because it supports extensions. One of the main benefits of the web is that, unlike proprietary native apps, I get to experience it the way I want. The web is nearly intolerable without extensions.
lern_too_spel··on Play Store blocks AuroraStore, hurting GrapheneOS users
App verification means she can safely install apps from the Internet. The app developers can simply serve the apks from their own websites.
lern_too_spel··on Meta Security Researcher's AI Agent Accidentally Deleted Her Emails
> Yesterday Claude Code made 5 large edits to my codebase in planning mode (claims it used a bash script instead of standard read/write tools so the guardrails didn't trigger) it's why I put agents in containers.

She asked it to clear her inbox, so she has to give inbox access to her agent. I don't see how containers would help here.

lern_too_spel··on Meta Security Researcher's AI Agent Accidentally Deleted Her Emails
> The nondeterminism and chaotic nature of LLM output is enough to rule them out as a reasonable foundation for any fully automated system that would be controlling anything potentially dangerous or damaging.

You could say the same for humans. The difference is that humans have been conditioned to be extra cautious about things that could get them fired, and there is no benchmark for Meta's model developers to benchmax about that.

lern_too_spel··on Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America
It's not so bad. Schoolchildren merely have to change the acronym they use to memorize the Great Lakes from HOMES to SHAME.

Edit: It seems others have figured this out before I did.

lern_too_spel··on California lawmakers unanimously pass Linux exemption from age-verification law
California is a common law jurisdiction. Judges evaluate cases and make rulings based on the intent of the law instead of the literal text as written in order to avoid absurdities, setting precedent for future similar cases. If the lawmakers disagree with case law, they amend the law.
lern_too_spel··on California lawmakers unanimously pass Linux exemption from age-verification law
This law does not require non Linux users to give up their ID to use the Internet, so why would they make Linux users do so?
lern_too_spel··on 9th Circuit sides with states in Kalshi gambling fight
Why should it be comparable to tobacco? It should be derived from first principles. Figure out the external cost to society and tax it enough to pay for those costs after money distribution overheads. If there is no tax structure where the revenues exceed the costs, ban it.

The difficulty with taxing prediction markets is that encouraging gambling on some events incentivizes gamblers to try to influence those events in a way contrary to how people would want to influence them in the absence of gambling, which typically means gamblers are incentivized to influence events in a way that will increase societal harms. For some events, resolving one way or the other is inconsequential, but this is not true for many of the events I see people gambling on in prediction markets.

lern_too_spel··on Judge rules Trump administration’s blacklisting of Anthropic was illegal
Objectively, the courts ruled for Obama and against Trump. You can read the rulings to understand why.
lern_too_spel··on Get your Windows license refund
If you replace the OS, you don't have remote root open, and you can back up whatever you want.
lern_too_spel··on Get your Windows license refund
What freedom do you need beyond replacing the OS, which is possible on all phones Google sells? If you want to replace the radio firmware, that isn't something that would be possible without that duopoly either.
lern_too_spel··on Hilariously fast volume computation with the divergence theorem (2018)
For this particular case of 3 dimensions, I found

Newson, H. B. “On the Volume of a Polyhedron.” Annals of Mathematics, vol. 1, no. 1/4, 1899, pp. 108–10. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/1967277

lern_too_spel··on Fable and the end of the free lunch
Put it in your own system prompt. They all provide tools for doing this. OpenaAI Custom GPTs, Gemini Gems, Claude Projects, etc. Or you can easily roll your own using their APIs.
lern_too_spel··on Hilariously Fast Volume Computation with the Divergence Theorem
You might be interested in the shoelace formula and its generalization to n dimensions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoelace_formula
lern_too_spel··on Stop Anthropomorphizing Intermediate Tokens as Reasoning/Thinking Traces (2025)
> You’ve shifted your goal posts.

Remember the problem we're discussing is whether these LLM systems can think. Your deliberate misinterpretation of a question does not make you win that argument.

An LLM can solve problems for itself in just the same way that a human can solve problems for itself. It cannot directly rewire your thinking in the same way that another human cannot.

> It requires human thought to cook.

Why? What part of cooking requires human thought? https://www.moley.com/

> nor is smell digitizable in an equivalent way to humans,

Sensors aren't thinking, but people are working on better olfactory sensors too. https://www.nature.com/articles/s44182-025-00071-y

> assertion that’s flatly untrue.

You have yet to show me a problem that can only be solved by human thinking.

> When your “proof” for thinking is the output

What other way can we show thinking? From the input? Obviously not.

> My analogy shows the idiocy of your argument

It shows the idiocy of your argument. The output is thinking, just as the output is light. You are the one who continues to mistake the output for the mechanism.

> Religion is always absurd, and this new one is no different.

Your assertion of magic in biology that can't be replicated artificially is indeed absurd and one that almost no scientist would agree with.

lern_too_spel··on Stop Anthropomorphizing Intermediate Tokens as Reasoning/Thinking Traces (2025)
> Not comparable. Simple and biological are not remotely similar modifiers.

PNAS disagrees with you. Biological is a perfectly cromulent modifier of machine.

https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.1401577111

> They will not, unprompted. Every instance of LLMs doing things requires a prompt, somewhere up the chain

Exactly the same as a human brain. Somewhere up the chain is a limbic system that defines basic survival and reproductive goals, as coded by evolution.

> No LLM has been created that decides on its own to run random text through it's forward pass.

What do you think agent harnesses are doing when they try to solve a difficult problem? They generate multiple possible thinking streams using the LLM (system 1) and then evaluate the resulting outputs (system 2) to proceed.

> It said it has no mechanism to read its own weights and copy them.

That's an easy enough problem to solve.

> No one asked a cell to self replicate either.

Evolutionary forces asked the cell to self replicate.

> Yet no one would call this reproduction, replication or any kind of process where evolution can occur.

It is trivially replication. If it copies itself onto another machine and sets it running, then it is obviously reproduction. If you make these instances compete for resources (an AI risk scenario), you will apply evolutionary pressure and get evolution.

> This is entirely untrue in biology

You keep making the same mistake. Biology isn't some magic domain where facts don't matter.

> The relationship between structure and function is a major constituent of the rules of life.

Where did I say the structure of a part doesn't matter? I said that as long as the part is the same, the way it is manufactured doesn't matter.

> What is thinking, in a strictly biology free context? Can you define it?

Easy. It is the process of considering information, creating ideas, reasoning, solving problems, and making judgments. We can show that thinking is happening by posing a problem that requires these abilities and verifying that it is solved.

> By your standard, fools gold is gold, and the alchemists achieve Artifical Gold.

No, I am saying that you don't have to wait for a supernova to get gold. You can make it artificially by bombarding lead nuclei.

> Do they share the inner drive that humans do? Or a dogs?

Evolution selected for a limbic system that gives humans and dogs the same inner drive. Humans have a larger frontal cortex to do thinking to act on that inner drive. The LLM performs the same role, doing the thinking part that the frontal cortex does. Adding drive is separate from thinking but entirely trivial. We do it all the time when we give them prompts.

> They are controlled by a mix of deterministic and stochastic processes.

The point is that they require no thinking.

> The 'code' isn't reacting to a variable; the variable is fundamentally rewriting the machine.

Once again, the mechanism by which the goal is provided to the agent or the way that thinking occurs doesn't matter. Only the thinking part.

Why do you attribute magic to biology? You claim to be a scientist, but you do not apply scientific reasoning.

lern_too_spel··on Stop Anthropomorphizing Intermediate Tokens as Reasoning/Thinking Traces (2025)
> Theres an itch deep in my butt,

The LLM will tell you how to solve it. If you mean the LLM should modify your thoughts, no human could do that for you either, but an LLM agent can just as easily as a human figure out how to build the brain computer interface to make this possible in the future.

> Is there a reasonable definition of thinking where the words "paused" and "turned off" aren't treated the same?

No reasonable definition of thinking requires that thinking can't be paused or turned off. Please state your point more clearly.

> You are yet to show me it produces thinking.

Every problem that previously required human thought can be solved by LLM. QED.

> Your claim is like saying the bulb produces light, so it also goes through fusion.

No. How many times do I have to explain that the mechanism of thinking is not the same, just as the mechanism of producing light is not the same? You need to think to understand this, which is something that frontier LLMs have no problem with, but which most humans struggle with.

lern_too_spel··on Stop Anthropomorphizing Intermediate Tokens as Reasoning/Thinking Traces (2025)
> And biological clearly exceeds the definition of “machine”.

No, it's a modifier. Just as the word "simple" has a meaning separate from "machine," and "simple machine" has another meaning.

> That’s the thing, you need people

Why? LLMs will repurpose code written for other purposes on their own.

> our manufactured machines show nothing like the flexibility of function of biological molecules

Biological molecules show nothing like the flexibility of LLMs.

> Why does one arise naturally and sustain itself whereas the other is very reliant on human intervention?

Because nobody has tasked an LLM agent to self replicate. This is an AI safety issue, not a technical issue. The reason that one arose naturally is that it takes a lot more machinery to get to an initial self replicating LLM agent, so it is exceedingly unlikely to arise by chance.

> Yeah this doesn’t hold for biology.

That doesn't matter. The way something is built has no bearing on its function. Why should anything be required to be built biologically or additively or subtractively? That's irrelevant to what the produced structure does.

> All of biology doesn’t share an inner drive and agentic behavior. Once again, you show a 6th grade level understanding of biology while making sweeping claims about it.

Where did I claim otherwise? I might as well say something about the grade level of your reading ability, but let's cut the snark.

> Yes IF you give it a goal. This isn’t true for biology. You don’t need to give bacteria a goal.

Evolution forces goal directed behavior on systems.

> Do you not understand that the robot vacuum runs on deterministic code?

Of course I do. Do you not understand that hunger and signals and other basic biological signatures are controlled by deterministic pathways?

lern_too_spel··on Moderna reports first positive Phase 3 for mRNA neoantigen therapy in melanoma
Let's get your theory straight. You posit a conspiracy where some cabal kept mRNA vaccines on the market despite harms while removing the AZ vaccine. This theory requires a conspiracy. Hence, conspiracy theory.
lern_too_spel··on Stop Anthropomorphizing Intermediate Tokens as Reasoning/Thinking Traces (2025)
> You haven’t proven an LLM has thought

Give me any problem that previously required human thinking. Any. That can be solved by LLMs. All you have to do is provide a single counterexample.

> not least that you can literally turn off an LLM, whereas every process but death in biology shows continued activity even when the organism “looks” off,

There is no reasonable definition of thinking that requires that it can't be paused.

> why are these two things the same?

I said they aren't the same, just as a bulb isn't the same as a star. An LLM can think, just as a human brain can think. A bulb can produce light, just as a star can produce light.

lern_too_spel··on Fable and the end of the free lunch
> If you have to say "don't make up something" for every possible question you ask

You don't. It goes in the system prompt.

lern_too_spel··on Nitter and XCancel receive cease and desist notices
I prefer not to share links that require the people receiving the link to create an account to read the content and it's replies or post to such websites for that matter. That's basic netiquette.
lern_too_spel··on Stop Anthropomorphizing Intermediate Tokens as Reasoning/Thinking Traces (2025)
> You’re the one making the logical leap claiming there’s thinking.

How? What problem that previously required human thinking is not solvable by these systems? You're applying some magical definition to thinking that you have not made public.

> Its weights don’t change when it gains experience, after its training period. To say that it’s “thinking” is bizarre when it remains untouched entirely by the process.

Two mistakes:

1. You don't need to learn to think.

2. Even the most basic sequence models update their internal state as you feed in tokens. You don't need to update the model weights themselves to learn.

lern_too_spel··on Fable and the end of the free lunch
The point is that it's trivial to fix the problem of cooking the waterfowl or writing your code with existing tools. Just ask them to verify.
lern_too_spel··on Fable and the end of the free lunch
His point was that, just like humans, if you ask the LLM to look it up, it will give you the correct answer. Just like humans, if you don't ask them to look it up, you don't know what you're going to get.
lern_too_spel··on Oceans hit highest temperature on record
Wind produced 10% of China's electricity last year, and its share is growing at 1% per year while coal's share shrinks. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/05/business/china-wind-turbi...
lern_too_spel··on I were 17, I'd learn how to build LLMs from scratch
Yann has been consistently wrong about the limits of LLMs.
lern_too_spel··on Oceans hit highest temperature on record
You said "modernization of existing plants" but quoted "New coal-fired plants."

China's 2025 five year plan targets peak coal before 2030 and might have already reached it in 2026. https://energyandcleanair.org/china-energy-and-emissions-tre...

lern_too_spel··on Moderna reports first positive Phase 3 for mRNA neoantigen therapy in melanoma
It was already recommended that healthy young men get the Pfizer vaccine instead of the Moderna vaccine.

I'm not sure why you're bringing the non-mRNA AstraZeneca vaccine into this. Keep your conspiracy theories straight.

lern_too_spel··on Stop Anthropomorphizing Intermediate Tokens as Reasoning/Thinking Traces (2025)
> And biological machine is?

"Biological," too, is well defined. It relates to living things and their processes.

> Why do the machine parts in biology show such flexible application?

Evolution.

> A gear cog won’t ever moonlight as a signaling chip

A gear cog was purpose built for that purpose, but you will find that people often recycle parts into other systems, often in completely different roles.

> How is the biological machine able to build itself?

Protein synthesis.

> What does self assembly imply for the machines function?

The way that a machine is built has no bearing on how the machine functions. I could build the same machine using a 3d printer or a CNC router.

> Where does this machine get its inner drive?

Evolution selected for organisms that survive long enough to reproduce. Different biological systems handle this differently.

> No LLM has been found that starts outputting text unprompted.

If you give an agent a goal, it will perform actions to achieve that goal. This is just as true for artificial agents as it is for biological agents.

> Why is no manufactured machine able to do this?

Many do. Even robotic vacuum cleaners will charge themselves without human prompting.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →