HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lerpa

132 karma · joined March 14, 2015

submissionscomments
lerpa··on I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality
It's not like NN would make them have more competition, either. Which, if they are greedy bastards that make anything for a profit, would make instead of charging to access some websites, get that same money from raising prices to everyone, easy as pie.
lerpa··on I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality
So maybe you found the actual problem. And forcing anyone providing network services to be common carrier just makes it less likely for competition to happen.
lerpa··on Chrome breaks the Web
This is like Internet Explorer way of doing things all over again. Instead of following the standard, just try to guess what people wanted to do, so you create a new standard.
lerpa··on The End of the DreamHost vs. DOJ privacy case
> The idiocy is accepting that researching extreme content is evil. It is not.

The Govt people don't believe that, otherwise they would need to arrest themselves.

They just want to do some terror on the populace to the extent that merely knowing something exists makes you a suspect. That is police state 101, it makes people turn their neighbors in even without much evidence, so they are seen as not involved.

lerpa··on Top medical experts say we should decriminalize all drugs (2016)
> as much as I agree with the policy position

So do I. But that is irrelevant.

> I detest the "scientific consensus" speak

Same here, specially when implying that health researchers talking not about their actual results but about the _opinions_ they have of what should be the law and what shouldn't, are in some way scientific.

Research and policies are not the same things.

.

Otherwise next you'll see things like "Researchers find most animals kill each other mercilessly, so we should decriminalize murder."

lerpa··on I’m an Ex-Google Woman Tech Leader and I’m Sick of Our Approach to Diversity
> If you can reasonably assess that your process is fair, I don't think anyone should care how the numbers bear out.

Because it goes against the results they wanted to arrive at.

lerpa··on I’m an Ex-Google Woman Tech Leader and I’m Sick of Our Approach to Diversity
> she hired at least a few women over men which she thought were better candidates simply because "we have to". That's a problem.

I don't have any problem with people having arbitrary standards which guide their hiring process. They could be hiring the worst candidates, and I don't care, it's their business, may be they want to do charity or whatever.

The problem I have is with the "have to" hire such and such, and when they start painting all of that bs as being some sort of scientific thing where if you don't follow suit not only doing what they say, but also agreeing with them, you are the scum of the earth.

The statistics probably are sound, but the conclusions drawn from them are another matter. Anyone that have been exposed to statistics to some degree know that statistics fallacies abound, people that inject their own prejudices to explain out the numbers also exist, and that analysing things with lots of variables is not easy.

For example, they claim "it's just fair" if they hired as much women as women graduate in IT related areas, and otherwise it means people hiring are biased against women. Well, that's just non-sense. What if women perform actually worse? If not so, what if most women don't want to work at Google, I've heard lot of "interesting" stories that don't make me that amused if that was the case. What if women want to work in other areas that aren't as prominent in Google and go to other places instead?

As I said, saying it's just bias is just a premisse disguissed as conclusion. Just shows the bias of the people coming to those conclusions.

lerpa··on YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist material'
Exactly, but in a world where people desire facebook and others to have "truth checking authorities", I don't expect things to get much better.
lerpa··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
> Google failed at doing this.

Implying they cared about false stereotypes. They only failed if they actually wanted to do that.

My bet is this gives them negative PR to their target market, end of story.

lerpa··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
Well it's better to have a job that to don't have one, right?

But being treated as less capable thus requiring lower barrier of entry to women is just plain old sexism.

lerpa··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
> In an exam where an upper caste person might have to score 100 to get in, the reserved caste person would have to score 70.

And we all know that the way to treat people with respect is to deal with them as if they were handicapped.

lerpa··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
> What I don't understand is why this is so bad?

It's the idea that it would be unfair that on average women cannot do as well in things men do, ignoring basic biology that genders are different and that there are things that absolutely no man can do, that women can. Even sometimes those areas which privilege females are seen as they were basically cornered into doing, and have no bearing into the fact that while there is some chauvinism, that possibly on average the desires, needs and skills may be not better or worse but different. And the women that embrace those things are positive are seen as being dominated against their will, or brainwashed into hating themselves.

In short, if a women does something that historically men used to do, then it's good. Else, and even more if it is something that historically women used to do, they are being subject to sexism.

The PhD guy should know better, perhaps too much specialization in his field made his brain go fritz.

lerpa··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
> what happen if less than 40% want to be in the profession? Are you going to force them to join non-desire careers?

"Nah, we all know CS is the best, and the only logical possibility is that women are being discouraged to do it, because if I chose an IT career, it's obviously the correct choice of profession." -- Lots of people here.

lerpa··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
> I'm a proponent for an "early bias" theory

Or maybe women just enjoy doing different kind of things than men.

lerpa··on 18yo arrested for reporting a bug in the new Budapest e-Ticket system
One thing that solves this is stating the obvious, something getting hacked means someone was incompetent.
lerpa··on Net Neutrality Day of Action: Help Preserve the Open Internet
ISPs have a lot to win with keeping their monopolies as it is.

Given the amount of alarmism it actually seems to me there is heavy propaganda advocating for the status quo, for some reason, perhaps they want further regulations that can be done more easily through net neutrality. Not sure.

lerpa··on Net Neutrality Day of Action: Help Preserve the Open Internet
If there are bad players, why instead don't you get rid of the legislation that gives them monopolies, so other people can offer better services?

Instead you're just giving the bad apples your money. Oh how awful for them... and they will put data caps and raise prices, because as long as the laws gives them monopolies you can't do nothing about it.

lerpa··on Net Neutrality Day of Action: Help Preserve the Open Internet
Net neutrality just helps the status quo, and forces the "evil greedy ISPs" to take your money. Yeah let's show them by giving them money and no competition to their business... wait.

Vote for less regulation, not just getting rid of NN but getting rid of the monopolies that exist at the local level.

lerpa··on Is it unethical for me to not tell my employer I've automated my job?
It would if you were explicitly told to do it without automation. Otherwise you're paid to do a job, and you did it, so all good.
lerpa··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
Sure, and I think they should also fine for a couple of thousands the evil people that are supporting that monopoly and making it possible, by using such sickening services Google provides.
lerpa··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
Applying well documented authoritarianism doesn't make it less so.
lerpa··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
What market, do people have contracts with Google that I am not aware of?

Oh right, no, and what they have in their website promises no expectation of doing what you need.

lerpa··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
Twice wrong, doesn't make it right.
lerpa··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
> It doesn't work like that.

Then don't use any. You are not entitled to it, nobody has any obligation to have a service that does what you want.

lerpa··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
Google doesn't have to fulfill any interests of yours, though.
lerpa··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
It's actually called authoritarianism - when pushing what government wants violates other people's rights to do business as they please even if it isn't criminal activity.
lerpa··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
People like the guy you replied to would only start to question things, once the EU decides they cannot keep working the way they want to.

They live under some sort of bubble of selfishness, where they believe others have to change in order to do to what is best for them. Guess what, as long as Google is committing no crime, why should them?

lerpa··on Euro MPs back end-to-end encryption for all citizens
Either you have the right to privacy or you don't. It's just double speak to say the government can violate any right, then either the government is acting criminally and people involved should be personally punished as such, or you don't actually have privacy.

That's like saying people have the right to life but government can murder anyone they want because they are the government. It's silly and meaningless. Rights are to be protected even when the government is against them, perhaps even more so in such cases.

lerpa··on Just Say No
That's like saying light worked different on the time of the Greeks because they thought our eyes shoot beams. Face palm

Their understanding of the thing was different, and wrong, the thing in of it self wasn't.

lerpa··on Just Say No
Explanations.

That there exists more than one explanation for a phenomenon, like ethics and moral values, doesn't mean that choosing any of those at random yields a good explanation. It also doesn't mean that there is no valid explanation at all.

That's just lazy not-100%-sure-therefore-I-substituite-my-own-reality-ism.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →