132 karma · joined March 14, 2015
And all smart websites should include a ToS that says you are not allowed to access their data, so they can sue for trespassing anyone that they don't like selectively.
The far reaching of government into this, and also the pirating stuff (which I do not condone but think that arresting people for that is waay too much) is what makes me want for the system to collapse under it's own weight. Like some website suing members of congress for visiting it while violating the ToS in this case.
I also secretly wanted Oracle to win vs Google so that cloning an API was piracy and that would extend to being a crime to purchase pirated goods which would make all clean room reverse engineering a criminal activity. That would lead to anyone that uses a PC without an authentic IBM BIOS (look up Phoenix BIOS) to be arrested, in theory, so even the US president would have to fall into that. It would have been a glorious shitstorm if Oracle won and IBM took that precedent to it's logical implications, the computer world would have failed, and the law would either be made even more arbitrary or be fixed, but at least it would be shown how idiotic the state of affairs was.
Even normal trespassing laws are way too overreaching (see how it is handled in the UK for a saner example) but now you have the amazing possibility of remote trespassing.
The fun part is that it's just a matter of someone hiding something that says you cannot access the site in a place that you have to access the site in order to read -- the ToS. Suing people over this is idiotic.
The real problem is the involvement of Govt, and this kind of absurdity regarding ToS, EULAs and so on, is something that has been going on for decades. If you have the money you can make Govt your personal watch dogs.
You are exactly right. But although a site can deny you access for any arbitrary reason (it's their website, after all) obviously government think they are the ones to enforce this crap.
What if the ToS say you can only access a site while jumping hoops? Only read the ToS after a while and wasn't hooping? Well too bad, now you are being sued for reading the main page _and_ the ToS page without jumping around.
This comment Terms of Service: If you read any of this text you owe lerpa $1.000.000 to be paid up until 09/01/2016.
It's most likely Fidel.
Just take a look at Hubert Dreyfus' work to better understand the issue.
What you're saying is that might makes right(s), pun intended. And that's just as silly as it gets, that's the reason people get all sort of authoritatians systems...people decided to call them witches and kill them so they were on the right...
That's the point of invented rights in a nutshell, to weaken the real actual rights, while bribing people into the illusion that they are better off that way.
But let's not be naive, the fight happens because the some people want the government to step it and make some of those things illegal. Be it to turn illegal to modify the car you own, or illegal to not allow to modify your electronics.
People don't just have views on that, they want to force their views on others.
In the search for a cure for head ache, some guy took aspirin and did a magic rite, and he was cured; another guy just took aspirin and he was cured. Both account can be reproduced, and so far have worked. Therefore when doing analysis you can ignore the bit about magic, while it may be relevant in some mystical sense (the spirits are more happy if you do it, whatever), it is unnecessary to explain the cure from head ache.
Harmful lays laws should not be considered lawful just because somebody wrote them down.
1) the ones that believe government would work as long as we had good people there; and that's where we need to focus, getting good politicians that can do good things, oh well if there are bad apples, nothing is perfect
2) government is a necessary evil, that has to be constantly under check because even if there is good such thing as a good politician, the ones that should worry us are the bad ones even if that also hinders the good ones; oh well if government has it's hand tied, government doesn't need to be a father figure, and has to be limited
The first group, fueled by the symbiosis of some enlightenment naivete, different classes of people trying to legislate advantages for themselves and the lust for power, won over time.
And that would be nice to have, a vcs that allows you to fold and unfold commits to different levels of granularity.
Wanna have only a straight line history with all feature branches squashed? There you have it. Just need some of them like that? Sure enough. What if you want every time the file was saved? Not a problem, just configure it to commit automatically.
If the issue was being forced to continue with the canary then there is a solution for that just use as a canary, before you received any order: We have received a gag order!
And when you do receive a gag order what are they going to do? Make you remove that? Keeping it seems as a direct violation of that order.
He doesn't owe you anything. You and other should be thankful for him to have allowed you to use his code. Fuck that entitlement bs.