HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

leto_ii

2,242 karma · joined October 16, 2019

submissionscomments
leto_ii··on Gödel, Escher, Bach is the most influential book in my life (2022)
GEB is one of the books that as an adult I have learned to not care about anymore. I've unsuccessfully tried reading it a few times (once made it a couple of hundred pages in) and came to the (personal) conclusion that if I want an intellectual challenge I'll just directly do maths instead of reading a semi-literary essay about maths.

Just like (some of) Joyce's work, GEB seems to me a puzzle who's main prize is the satisfaction of having understood it - obfuscation and abstruseness for their own sake.

For actually understanding Godel's work I would recommend Gödel's Proof (Nagel, Newman, somewhat ironically, prefaced by Hofstadter) or Philosophies of Mathematics (George, Velleman).

leto_ii··on Pixel owners report problems after installing January 2024 Google Play update
> With three phones and a one-in-eight chance of being affected (assuming 50% for each phone)

1/8 would be the chance to have all 3 affected. The chance of having at least one affected would be 1-1/8.

leto_ii··on Rue de l'Avenir
Didn't say they were perfect, but when it comes to the speed of scientific and technological progress, nothing beats the late 19th- mid 20th century era.
leto_ii··on Rue de l'Avenir
Amazing feat. Yet it's not the first time that I've also felt bitterness pondering such past achievements.

I can't escape the feeling that we used to be so much bolder and unconstrained in setting goals for ourselves and actually pursuing them. I feel like 1900 people would have fixed global warming, unaffordable housing, universal healthcare etc.

leto_ii··on Tell HN: Merry Christmas
Merry Christmas from Romania to the best community on the internet!
leto_ii··on Running Speeds
I was thinking about this and how you might get a lognormal from normals. Peer comments I think have good suggestions.

The thing is a while back I took a look at the times achieved by competitive athletes at the 100m dash (from worldathletics.org), and they looked normally distributed. Intuitively that made sense to me - many other human attributes are normally distributed, so why not this?

leto_ii··on Running Speeds
I'm not sure this analysis is as surprising or meaningful as it might seem at first sight.

In the end I think what this tells us is that in the general population there are many distinct subpopulations with different distributions of running speed. I would expect that if you start conditioning on things (e.g. gender, age, level of fitness) things start looking a lot more normal, rather than log-normal.

You might not be able to beat the Freeze simply because you're not a young fit male who trains to run fast. Really nothing surprising here.

leto_ii··on So far, AI is a money pit that isn't paying off
For the original wsj article: https://archive.ph/jMM1k
leto_ii··on A look into the finances of SpaceX
Did wsj wisen up to our archive.today trick?
leto_ii··on Is there a wider internet outage today?
In Bucharest I've had problems throughout the day. Most noticeably just now while streaming on HBO Max.
leto_ii··on Five Books: The best books on everything
Thanks for the thorough reply.

I think part of my point was covered by nathansherburn's sibling comment

> It sounds like you took the primary criticism in the parent comment to be about reading in general.

> I took it to mean that the best way to learn say economics is not to read one of "the top 5 recommended books on economics" but rather start by googling a specific aspect or question about economics that interests you and then following the thread.

I think my reaction was a bit vehement because it's not the first time I've encountered (albeit well intentioned) lists of "great books" on HN. In general I've grown to dislike ticking lists of things, be they books, "things to do before you die" etc. I just feel like this is too simplistic of an approach to anything in life. In my experience, the things that I learned best or the most meaningful experiences I've had were self-guided, often extemporaneous, almost always not matching neat prior expectations.

> Who’s talking about humble bragging? Wether you brag or not it’s up to you, I don’t see anything on the website encouraging you to do so.

True. This was mostly conjecture on my part as I've seen many people having neat lists of read books on their private sites/blogs (or links to goodreads etc.).

Addressing specifically the content on the website, I can say that the lists often seemed arbitrary, too granular or simply besides the point. I won't go into details, but I find all/most of the following to be confused, confusing, cutesy pop-intellectualism:

https://fivebooks.com/category/mathematics-and-science/maths...

https://fivebooks.com/best-books/artificial-intelligence-gpt... (pretty nonsensical, I assume it was made for laughs mostly)

https://fivebooks.com/best-books/learning-python-and-data-sc... (as practicing data scientist I've used none of these)

https://fivebooks.com/best-books/data-science-roger-peng/ (a random mix of things - Introduction to Statistical Learning is useful, but basic.)

https://fivebooks.com/best-books/nicholas-higham-applied-mat... (recurring theme, well exemplified here, is of books about smth, not something books. You're not gonna learn maths from these books. You're not even gonna start learning maths from these books.)

https://fivebooks.com/best-books/luciano-floridi-philosophy-... (just rando stuff. Plato, Descartes, Kant... thrown all in, because there must be smth about information somewhere there, right?)

leto_ii··on Five Books: The best books on everything
I find this to be simplistic pop intelectual nonsense. This is not how to learn anything.

It's way more meaningful to understand and pursue your own actual interests than to humble brag by ticking the "correct" readings.

Not to mention that talking about the best anything is basically meaningless, except for very tightly constrained achievements (e.g. we can talk about the best sprinter, but who's the best philosopher? or the best mathematician?)

leto_ii··on Office of the President of Mongolia: Top to bottom text on the web
Interesting to note numerals are still Arabic, but written vertically. Does that mean that in school Mongolian kids learn to write digits sideways? Would be pretty cool :D

edit: e.g. here: https://president.mn/mng/?p=7112

leto_ii··on Bard is much worse at puzzle solving than ChatGPT
Funny, cause Microsoft didn't die. They're doing great. More than that, they're the ones behind OpenAI.
leto_ii··on Bard is much worse at puzzle solving than ChatGPT
are the numbers correct?
leto_ii··on These Shapes Are Topologically Equivalent
I had the same initial impulse, but I think the transformation 1 -> 2 can't work irl. especially if those are compact solids.

Edit:

2->3 also seems impossible. you basically move the hole around.

leto_ii··on The Toll of Layoff Anxiety
> their point is that some people have an internal sense of resilience, or a constructed foundation of security

This may be true, but I think that this is also something that can be learned, at least to a good degree. Personally I feel I have managed to become less anxiety-prone through conscious effort and introspective work. Being an "orange" is not an immutable fact.

leto_ii··on The Toll of Layoff Anxiety
> anxiety is something you have

First, everybody is capable of anxiety and that's normal and to be expected in the current climate.

> a scale up that leaned woke [...] When layoffs happened, it was basically an all out mental health crisis, with everyone feeding into everyone else's anxiety.

Second, having an anxiety disorder is not a moral or behavioral failure and I don't see necessarily how it could be correlated to "wokeness".

> When you squeeze an orange, orange juice comes out because that's what an orange is made off. If extreme anxiety comes out when you are squeezed, it was there all along.

Again, this analogy doesn't make sense. It's totally normal for oranges to be full of orange juice. It would be weird if something else (or no thing at all) came out... Same with anxiety - it's normal for people to be stressed out in a stressful situation. It's not necessarily healthy, but should be expected.

Otoh, having an anxiety disorder is not a normal psychological state, but that's something that shows up all the time, not just when you're "squeezed".

leto_ii··on Asia’s advanced economies now have lower birth rates than Japan
> I’ve been with my wife for 20 years and we still stay up too late at least once a week because we don’t want to stop our conversation. It is the richest, most fulfilling relationship I can imagine.

> Beyond companionship, she is the ultimate ally. If I tell her I need her help, she is there for me 100%.

Congratulations and may it never change for you. I do however have to say that that is not the case for most marriages/ long term monogamous relationships.

If you could somehow set aside social pressure, shared financial burdens, guilt over messing up the kids etc. I think most existing marriages would break down. Few people actually share deep love, friendship and real, freely accepted commitment.

leto_ii··on The persistent and pervasive impact of bullying in childhood and adolescence
That's just not true. There are many kinds of social relations, dominance being just one particularity nasty one. Other apes also exhibit a whole range of social relations. It doesn't have to be a dog eat dog world out there, and most of the time it actually isn't.
leto_ii··on The persistent and pervasive impact of bullying in childhood and adolescence
Based on your virulent tone I suspect you still harbor strong resentment against your childhood bullies. I somewhat get that, I was bullied too and I still hate those kids.

As an adult however I realize that my bullies were actually abused children who had a rough time at home and took it out on me at school.

> When they break a bullies nose/arm/etc and get suspended you should not only encourage them to continue you should celebrate the victory.

Sorry, but this is completely sociopathic insanity. Celebrating one child maiming another? What is this, the hunger games?

> Bullies aren't beat enough at home, so it's your job to bring the beatings to them.

Do you think it's ever ok for an adult to beat a child? You have it all wrong, it's the kids who are beat who become bullies.

> If you are not capable of violence you are not peaceful, you are harmless.

Capable of violence is one thing, systemically encouraging it as part of normal upbringing is however strictly antisocial.

leto_ii··on The persistent and pervasive impact of bullying in childhood and adolescence
> It's the same rationale as in prison - you don't want to end up at the bottom of the dominance hierarchy.

The simple fact that you think it's not a problem to somewhat approvingly compare schools to prisons is already a bad sign. Schools shouldn't be like prisons. Prisons shouldn't be like prisons either, but that's another story...

leto_ii··on Meta lays off 11,000 people
These distinctions are pretty arbitrary, maybe just wait for GP to clarify.
leto_ii··on The currency of the new economy won't be money, but attention (1997)
While I agree that we could probably support the entire human species comfortably given our current level of tech development, I don't think that can happen without a revolutionary change of the economic/social system, away from capitalism.

The problem is that that won't happen in a nice way, if at all. Systemic changes come about after cataclysms, not incrementally.

Alas, cataclysms may be due soon...

leto_ii··on Someday aliens will land and all will be fine until we explain our calendar
Couldn't this whole thread just be condensed to: we have a thing called culture which is not completely rational or efficient? I'm sure the aliens would get that - they would probably have something similar, albeit with different irrationalities and inefficiencies.
leto_ii··on Are You Ready for the Internet? (1994) [video]
I realize I'm going way against the grain of other commenters, but this video has made me aware of how little progress has actually been made since then. I mean, the core ideas of the modern internet services we're relying on were already there back in 1994.

Aside from much slicker devices, much higher bandwidth, much broader reach and a few new things around the edges, how much change have we actually seen? I'm of course being a bit facetious - speed, convenience, reach are all very important. But when it comes right down to core "mind blowing" new tech, how much have we actually improved on 1994?

leto_ii··on Show HN: I may have created a new type of puzzle
My two cents:

1. Like other people I found the UX a bit confusing (figuring out that two animals can occupy the same spot, picking which one of them to move etc.)

2. This one seems hard for a first level, if it's addressed to a general audience. Even figuring out that some edges are directed is not obvious if you don't know about graphs in advance. You should build a tutorial for non-HN people.

3. Are there other levels?

4. Lights are flashing way too fast at the end. A text message would also be nice.

Otherwise a great job! Playable and fun once you get into it. Would totally play again :D

leto_ii··on Ask HN: How to reset your online bubble of 'interests'?
A few comments:

* uBlock Origin I found to be better than Adblock

* The TV ads can be avoided too, by not owning a TV :D (or at least not a cable subscription)

leto_ii··on How Mathematics Changed Me
I get that, but I have to say I also see merit in the position that maths is discovered, not invented. I'm currently doing some self-study into more rigorous mathematics and I do often get the feeling that some of the structures are just there, not human inventions made for human purposes.

I have recently been quite interested in the Cantor set, for example - hardly a useful tool...

leto_ii··on How Mathematics Changed Me
> that even math is chaotic.

Math chaos is actually a kind of order, just not the kind that is intuitively easy to grasp by humans.

← PreviousPage 2 of 20Next →