Based off his background (old moneyed, Cambridge educated) and how he governed Singapore (with an iron fist), obtaining more wealth was probably low on his list of priorities, what he wants is power.
738 karma · joined May 9, 2018
Based off his background (old moneyed, Cambridge educated) and how he governed Singapore (with an iron fist), obtaining more wealth was probably low on his list of priorities, what he wants is power.
It is impossible to convince someone with reason if the person is simply unreasonable - erroneous standards, bad reasoning, fallacious arguments - but it has been illuminating on how such minds "work".
Carry on hnfong and gmerc, I'd love to add more to the above.
Here is a selection:
[0] https://www.cambridge.org/us/universitypress/subjects/politi...
[1] https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/authoritarian-rule-of-l...
[2] https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691211411/sp...
[3] https://www.ethosbooks.com.sg/products/air-conditioned-natio...
What is happening in other countries has no bearing on whether Singapore is a police state or not, it is what Singapore does that qualifies it. While the term “police state” might be too strong for Singapore, here is why it might apply:
1) Internal Security Act - The ability to detain anyone deemed as a “national security threat” indefinitely without trial. Lee Kuan Yew famously argued against it before independence. After independence, he retained it and went on use it against political opponents. (Who do you think are the new colonial overlords telling others how to behave, what to say or what to think?) 2) Lack of civil and political rights to act as check and balances against overreach by the state. Eg. Widespread and intrusive surveillance of much of the country, especially in the poorer areas; extensive power of the police to investigate with little oversight - TraceTogether data debacle; politically motivated persecution of dissidents and journalists etc. 3) Control and manipulation of the local media landscape in order to achieve/support their goals.
[0] https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691211411/sp...
Let me remind you again that you need to address my arguments to refute it.
Don’t take my word for it, decide for yourself. Check out the readings I quoted earlier, all of them are written by Singaporeans, are in academia, come from a variety of backgrounds and not all are males. If you’re short on time, academic reviews provide a good summary (on whether it is worth reading). Here’s one for you: https://pacificaffairs.ubc.ca/book-reviews/singapore-identit...
Second, a president elected through an electoral system purposefully designed by an authoritarian prime minister, whose party the same president-elect was part of, who was elevated to the unelected permanent position of Senior Minister in that party - hardly qualifies as a reputable source. Here are a few reputable alternatives written by Singaporean scholars:
[0] https://www.cambridge.org/us/universitypress/subjects/politi...
[1] https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/authoritarian-rule-of-l...
[2] https://www.ethosbooks.com.sg/products/air-conditioned-natio...
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Covenant_on_Civi...
My other recommendations would be Jothie Rajah’s Authoritarian Rule of Law [1] and Sergei Guriev & Daniel Treisman‘s Spin Dictators [2].
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherian_George#Academic_career
[1] https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/authoritarian-rule-of-l...
[2] https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691211411/sp...
1) The surveillance is excessive and unnecessary in a country with extremely low crime rate. 2) Such intrusive and widespread surveillance is very problematic in an authoritarian state with a history of persecuting dissidents 3) Public funds spent on unnecessary projects means less for tackling issues such as high inequality
It might not be apparent to one, depending on the area they live in, the wealthier areas receive much less surveillance than the public housing areas. Privately developed property do not have police surveillance in their lifts or estates and have less surveillance in the general area (eg. bus stops). Vice versa, the number of surveillance cameras is much higher in the low income public rental/housing areas. There is a lot of discussion on inequality in the US but Singapore has even higher inequality/Gini coefficient. There is much more than what meets the eye, especially in a state characterized by scholars as “sophisticated authoritarianism”. [0]
[0] https://www.cambridge.org/us/universitypress/subjects/politi...
[0] https://www.cambridge.org/us/universitypress/subjects/politi...
> a rather novel opinion
It's remarkable how one can evade the inherent contradictions in their position while appearing quite righteous about it.
"I never said the Bible is wholly true (and I will not address its inherent contradictions) so the joke's on you!"
I am not denying that there were political factors in play. I am saying that the main factor in play was his dissent against the Church.
> valid scientific criticisms of his work. Ironically, what you are arguing is much like the chief scientific error Galileo made
There is a distinction between 'evidence that refutes the geocentric model' and 'evidence that supports the Copernican heliocentric model'.
While the technology available did not allow him conclusively proof the Copernican heliocentric model (there were also issues with the model), the evidence he had strongly refuted the central thesis of the geocentric model - that Earth is the center of the universe and everything in the sky resolves around Earth. That lead him to advocate for the Copernican heliocentric model, inference to the best explanation.
Galileo observed that Venus had phases despite remaining near the Sun in Earth's sky, which proves that Venus revolves the Sun, not the Earth, hence refutes the geocentric model. His discovery of the moons revolving Jupiter further refutes the geocentric model, that not everything in the sky revolves around Earth. [0]
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geocentric_model#Copernican_sy...
Perfect. To summarise: the genesis creation narrative can never be wrong. It is an allegorical narrative with no factual value. Despite having no factual value, one can be mistaken about it. The burden of proof lies not with the claimant but the dissenter, if they can overcome their "false perspective", ignorance or naivety that is.
That is incorrect. Galileo observed that Venus had phases despite remaining near the Sun as observed from Earth, which proves that Venus revolves the Sun, not the Earth, hence refutes the geocentric model. His discovery of the moons revolving Jupiter further refutes the geocentric model, that not everything in the sky revolves around Earth.
How is that even remotely related to "all experts are wrong"?
> The Galileo thing was about politics, not religion.
As I said in another comment, the Copernican heliocentric model is at odds with the Church's geocentric doctrine and the Scriptures, hence challenging the Church's and the religion's credibility and authority. To claim that the Galileo affair is simply a "personal feud" is wholly disingenuous.
> It also wasn't scientific.
Galileo used the empirical data (observation of the planets) he obtained through his telescope to test and justify the Copernican heliocentrism model - it is the definition of science.
The bottom of page four of the report states the WIV institute's genetic engineering capabilities and that it has likely conducted some engineering of coronaviruses. Does that constitute proof of WIV engineering the COVID19 virus and the virus leaked from the lab?
Not an expert but from page three of the report:
"Almost all IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not genetically engineered. Most agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not laboratory-adapted; some are unable to make a determination. All IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not developed as a biological weapon."
The creation narrative in Genesis: either "the Bible is sacred and wholly true/correct" OR "the theory of evolution is true/correct". If the Bible can be wrong about the nature of the universe (as the Church was wrong about heliocentricism during Galileo's time), then surely it can be wrong about any number of issues.
It is often used as an example because it is the prime example of the beginning of The Enlightenment, also known as The Age of Reason, the triumph of reason and evidence over dogma, which gave rise to modernity.
> It’s that religion isn’t fundamentally opposed to science.
Take the creation narrative in Genesis: the world was created ~10,000 years ago in 6 (or 7, depending on how you count it) days. Is that narrative in fundamental conflict with modern science? Can both the genesis creation narrative and the theory of evolution be right? What and who decides which is correct? Should reason and evidence guide our beliefs or ancient texts proclaimed to be sacred?
References?
The charge of heresy is for heretic views, such as the Copernican heliocentric model in his case. It threatens to upend the authority of the Church; if the Church can be wrong about the nature of the universe then surely they can be wrong about other matters as well. His Dialogues remain banned by the Church till 1835, ~200 years later. To say that Galileo was convicted of heresy for "bad behaviour" is simply disingenuous.
When one cherry picks evidence like that...
Also, Cameron is the first person to do a solo descent to the Mariana Trench. Based on the interview, he was involved in the engineering and design of that Deepsea Challenger submersible and they concluded that the titanium+carbon-fiber hull design (which Oceangate used) is unsuitable. So, he’s not just “another celebrity”; his testimony carries some weight.
Prosperous for _whom_? Inequality is rising and according to CIA World Factbook, Singapore is ranked the 24th on the Gini index, right behind Saudi Arabia (23rd). (Singapore is curiously missing from World Bank's Gini index due to insufficient data)
Prosperous of _what_? Material goods? Considering the severity of the inequality, prosperous is hardly the right characterization.
Let's establish some facts. One of the areas the article fails to mention is how the dominant party (PAP) manages to stay in power for such a long time. It achieves that through a sophisticated system of gerrymandering, draconian national security laws, persecution of oppositional figures, control of the local media landscape, lack of civil and political rights (which allows for all of the above) and the list goes on. [0]
With all that in place, the PAP received ~60% of all the popular votes in the 2020 general election (gerrymandering allows them to obtain ~85% of parliament seats). Would you like to speculate on the number of votes the PAP might receive if Singaporeans were allowed to make an _informed_ choice? If the system is as desirable as you seem to think, why would the government need such absolute control over the nation and its citizens? Surely the citizens would overwhelming vote for such a government/system.
In any case, disagreements ought to be directed at the facts of the article, not the speculated agenda of the paper/author.
[0] https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691211411/sp...
Besides, what he intended for the rest of the world is irrelevant to whether the system is worthy of admiration.
In any case, he has advised China's CCP and Kazakhstan's Nursultan Nazarbayev, both authoritarian governments.