HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lilactown

849 karma · joined September 2, 2015

submissionscomments
lilactown··on ‘Extremely aggressive’ internet censorship spreads in the world’s democracies
That's not the literal definition of fascism but it's also Not Good(tm).
lilactown··on Lambda Fellows
There is already a history of unpaid internships being abused in the USA, as they became the only way for people to enter an industry - entry-level labor became completely saturated by unpaid internships.

This causes a whole host of problems. One is that it acts as a filter for people who can afford to spend 1-2 years being an unpaid intern. For a high status industry, this prevents swathes of people who don't have the support networks to afford being unpaid.

The other is that, once this becomes an industry standard, entry level labor being so cheap incentivizes bad labor practices. Why hire a senior level talent when we can hire someone to manage 6 unpaid interns? Why promote this person when we can pay them literally nothing?

lilactown··on The Joys of Being a Stoic
Heaven forbid!
lilactown··on If pay had kept pace with productivity gains, minimum wage would be $24 an hour
Someone else elsewhere made this point: the widget makers are not generally capable of increasing their own productivity because they don't have access to the capital required.

This method of organizing labor and value which disallows workers' to gain anything from increases in their own output keeps them from ever being able to participate in it, leading to alienation from their jobs and living in a perpetual cycle of poverty.

lilactown··on If pay had kept pace with productivity gains, minimum wage would be $24 an hour
What value does technology provide other than increasing labor efficiency? If tech helps me build 10x the number of widgets, should all of that surplus value only be captured by the technology owners?

What about the people who build and service the technology which allows these improvements to be implemented?

lilactown··on Social Cooling (2017)
I am not necessarily saying that leftists are a panacea of altruist thinking, having washed away their colonial upbringing in their dialogues with a theoretical minority. ;)

Rather, I understand leftist thought to be rooted in questioning hierarchy and power structures, which I believe leads to more readily seeking solidarity with those that are not as well off as they are.

> By coincidence, today I saw a debate where a strongly left-wing person dismissed some complaints of a marginalized person

This does sound like a funny happenstance. My original reply was about this same sort of funny coincidence in reverse; how I often see the left critiqued as being "intolerant" when I frequently see them lifting and amplifying the voices of those who are disenfranchised by the system that they materially benefit from.

> How much would a white left-wing person be willing to debate with e.g. a conservative immigrant?

First, debates are not typical discourse. In my experience, debates are meant to be a show of virtue. Whose virtues you're being weighed against will greatly determine your behavior or whether you even decide to participate at all. I think that Hacker News values sound, well written arguments, which is why I am here posting. :)

Therefore, I think that given the propensity toward identity politics (from both sides) and the difficulty in interrogating the root of the beliefs that immigrant without appearing to be questioning the validity of them, I (as a white leftist) would prefer not to debate them. So, yes, I would rather propose someone whose lived experience might be more similar to theirs - perhaps a left-leaning immigrant - specifically because I would be afraid of either appearing weak in the eyes of right-wing spectators by deferring to their lived experience, or seem like an asshole because I am questioning the validity of their experience. It would be a PR nightmare. :)

In a private, personal setting (i.e. not a debate) I think that talking to your hypothetical conservative immigrant would probably be a great opportunity for me to learn about their experience and explore the root of their beliefs. I hope I would get to share mine as well.

lilactown··on Social Cooling (2017)
I meant no disrespect. If I read into your reply here, I think you feel that I am saying that anyone who is "not a perfect leftist" is "shitty"? On reflection I can see how that would be interpreted.

What I meant to wrote was 3 separate points:

- Bernie is not a perfect leftist

To be clear: I don't hold Bernie to the standard of being a "perfect leftist," rather stating the obvious that he is not one. And while I would love a candidate that agreed more with my viewpoints than him, I don't think he's a bad person because he doesn't.

- Bernie has had some shitty takes and policies

I do believe that Bernie Sanders, the politician, has not always wielded his power in my best interest; for instance, voting for the "Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Terrorists" joint resolution that has been used as justification for our military presence in the middle east. I would, in a glib way, rate that vote and the opinions he gave during that time as a "shitty take." I don't think that disrespects him as a person.

- Sometimes people get better (and sometimes they don't)

Sometimes people evolve their politics and beliefs as they learn more and the material conditions which they exist in change, which is good. Sometimes they do not, and that's bad. I do not think that adopting strictly leftist beliefs - of which there are a cacophony of differing, conflicting ones - is inherently good. Rather the lack of evolution is bad.

lilactown··on Social Cooling (2017)
I do actually agree with you. It is very easy to be radical in your beliefs (in either direction) when you don't need to interact with the people that they effect. There are plenty of "ivory tower" leftists. The difference is that I do believe that those leftists are seeking to find solidarity with the oppressed, though not always successfully. Sometimes they miss the mark, and there are plenty examples of shitty behavior, but I think that they're heading in the right direction.

I also think that it's unfortunate it's so easy to mistake a critique like that as an attack of the left as a whole. Leftist policy should always have the goal of materially making peoples lives better. We should ruthlessly measure and criticize whether we are in fact succeeding in that, both by the numbers and by the lived experience of the people they effect.

The current form of discourse in America is so hyper-partisan as to make that sort of critique almost impossible to do in public, as it comes off as a show of weakness rather than an opportunity for evolution. It's painful.

lilactown··on Social Cooling (2017)
Disproportionate power _compared to whom_? To take your example: on any given day, if I'm a female HS student interacting with a male teacher, the power differential is hugely in his favor.

The teacher can fundamentally change the course of my life by limiting my ability to take more advanced courses and/or what colleges I can get into. They can humiliate me in front of my peers. They could simply make it impossible for me to learn and engage with material that could be important to my future success.

The fact that a female student has the ability to speak out about being abused _does_ upset that power imbalance, but it would be a mistake to claim that it gives her _more_ power than the teacher.

Either way, power should be wielded with good judgement, and there are certainly consequences on both for using it (and abusing it).

lilactown··on Social Cooling (2017)
I would add into this mix that the engagement algorithms social media uses to pick which posts show up in peoples timelines, go viral, etc. is very much a cyclic process that reinforces all of the social problems that you speak of.
lilactown··on Social Cooling (2017)
I tried to couch my reply as not assuming intent on your part specifically, but rather my attempt at pointing out a pattern I have seen other people engage in and be subject to.

When looking at this and your other reply to me elsewhere in this thread, it does not feel like you're engaging me in good faith.

lilactown··on Social Cooling (2017)
First of all, note that I did not talk at all about parties. I talked about left and right. Historically, the parties that represent right and left (or how much to the right and left they skew) has changed; which ideas fall in the category of left and right thinking have not as much.

It seems that your stance is based on the idea that a large group of people simply adopts one viewpoint or another arbitrarily, that those solutions have not changed over time, and that because of this we should treat them with equal merit. I believe this is wrong, for a number of different reasons.

First, it ignores the outcomes of the actual policies as well as the framework of thinking that it supports. Someone who has a "different take" whose outcome changes whether I or my friends can afford health care or not is not an "equal but opposite" philosophy.

To build on that, because it ignores the actual outcomes and treats all ideas as equal, it supports a framework of hyper-partisan thinking, the idea that ideology is about who you are loyal to. In this framework, your belief makes sense: just because we're loyal to different parties doesn't mean we can't be friends! But again, it ignores the very real implications of those beliefs.

Finally, it also concludes that solutions to these problems, and the people who are in charge of supporting them, cannot evolve and improve, only be renewed as a way to for members of a party to pledge loyalty. Bernie is not a perfect leftist, and has certainly had some shitty takes and policies; sometimes people get better (and sometimes they don't). As our understanding of the plight of the common people grows and adjusts to the new realities we are faced with, different solutions will evolve on the left, and that is good.

lilactown··on Social Cooling (2017)
I agree with the spirit of your words. I think that the subtext of your post (or at least people that espouse similar things on the internet) is that this is the fault of a certain brand of American politics (left leaning, "SJW" types) that don't engage with many right-leaning people.

The frustrating (and silly) thing is that this argument is used a lot to attack left-leaning folks who _do_ engage with many people whose experience and world view are very different from them... like people who are homeless, immigrants from other countries, people who are racially minoritized, people who are disabled.

For many people who don't experience those kinds of life experiences, building relationships with those folks can be really tough and bring into question a lot of the foundations of their world view.

The argument that left-leaning people won't engage with right-leaning people often feels like it's used as an excuse for right-leaning folks to use rhetoric and hold positions that routinely disenfranchise and threaten the safety of the kind of people that left-leaning people have worked to empathize with and build relationships without consequence. That the people who continue to have right-leaning views don't seem interested in putting in the same _effort_ to empathize and build relationships with people other than themselves is both hypocritical and not surprising to me.

Finally, engaging with "challenging" opinions is all well and good as a mental exercise, but building and maintaining a relationship with someone is a project that requires continuous work (even as just a friendship) and I think it's worthwhile to be selective in the people who you put in that kind of work for.

lilactown··on Some thoughts on JSON vs. S-expressions (2012)
I still believe that EDN[0] is one of the best general purpose data serialization formats - definitely a huge upgrade from JSON.

It addresses most of the authors problems while _also having s-expressions_, e.g.:

    (foo bar baz) ;; this is valid EDN

    {:foo [bar baz]} ;; this is also valid EDN
There are parsers for many popular languages, and a language already entirely based on it: Clojure.

[0] https://github.com/edn-format/edn

lilactown··on Animal Populations Fell by 68% in 50 Years and It’s Getting Worse
We are not beyond carrying capacity. We have enough food and other resources to clothe, house and feed everyone in the world and forever if we could organize ourselves. Capitalism has failed us in doing so. We need a new way of organizing.

The Malthusian idea of "there are too many people" leads us to only one logical conclusion: eugenics, genocide. Don't fall into that trap. The basis is provably not true.

lilactown··on React is becoming a black box
the bummer about reagent is that it allocates so many immutable data structures on render. I've not figured out a way to ergonomically write hiccup without paying this constant performance tax, which is felt on a lot of large reagent apps.
lilactown··on Using Clojure in the command line with Babashka
Whenever "Clojure startup time" comes up, people are quick to point to one thing: either it's the JVM "bloat," or that it's nothing to do with the JVM and is actually all Clojure.

Here's a pretty good (if a bit outdated) analysis on Clojure startup time: http://clojure-goes-fast.com/blog/clojures-slow-start/

The question is, could Clojure be rewritten in a way that loads significantly faster with the same behavior on the JVM? I'm not sure.

And especially on big projects, the lack of DCE on the JVM can lead to loading a ton of useless code that significantly impacts startup time outside of the Clojure language.

lilactown··on The database I wish I had
yes absolutely. In my scifi utopia, the government provides a digital identity to each citizen as a social service :)

One of the downsides of this is that it actually degrades privacy by improving private institutions (and the governments) ability to track you.

One way I've thought of to get around this is to allow people to spawn new identities from their own root identity. This could allow a certain amount of anonymity, while allowing institutions to filter identities by requiring a certain amount of social proof (e.g. length of time since identity has been created).

Some services might ban non-root identities (e.g. banks), while others (like a bar) just needs to be able to trust that you have a valid ID and can be used to prove you're over a certain bio age.

In the event that you need to prove you own a specific ID, there could be a way that given a root ID and a non-root ID, you re-generate the non-root ID from the root - thus proving you own it.

lilactown··on The database I wish I had
A lot of facebook's value prop for users is in what you're saying - not as a social media company, but as a centralized identity provider for the social graph.

Perhaps a decentralized solution could still use a centralized identity provider to help with things like spam & impersonation/fake profiles and prove who they are, while still allowing users to own the information _about_ themselves.

The problem here is incentives; there's not much money in being a dumb identity resolver unless you're harvesting everyones data AFAICT, so I sort of doubt a private consumer solution will emerge in the near future.

lilactown··on Viewpoint: 'I feel like I was accidentally hired'
> What does it matter whether I'm one of the 49% who are making that argument in good faith?

Because my time and energy is scarce, and so are other peoples. Why should I oblige someone who is arguing in bad faith the time and energy to deconstruct their argument and build it back up to the level of discourse required to talk about these issues, when they will just continually drain me of whatever reserves I have. That's the point of a bad faith argument; to mask as a legit one in order to drain the opposition.

> Do you want more racial division or do you want more human unity?

I don't think that's even the topic of question. Racial division or unity is not at stake; it's justice and equality. Framing it to be about "unity" is an approach that experience has shown people who have paid attention to racial equality & justice over the last 30 years as _not_ working.

> how could my keeping your race constantly in mind do anything but delay your getting what you want?

Keeping in mind a person's experience as you interact with them is paramount for empathy. For a large portion of people in America, their race is inexorably tied to their experience. You're not being asked to think, "Oh this person is Black, I need to act like X & Y & not Z because the SJW police told me to." You're being asked to think, "Oh this person is Black, I need to understand their experience so I know how to act around them so that they feel safe."

Some people find it helpful to boil these down to rules of thumb, but these are simply tools to help people who are new to empathizing with the experiences of POC to not fuck up as much. Take them at your leisure based on your perceived level of understanding.

Lastly, I'll leave you with a few questions to ponder & research if you feel like it's valuable:

How does a society repair the subtle mechanisms within it that perpetuate racial injustice and inequality?

How does a society acknowledge and celebrate cultures that are different from the majority (as in, without erasing them or forcing them to adopt white culture)?

How does a society enact justice for the communities who have been terrorized and brutalized due to racism perpetrated through people, policy, and the power structure in all areas of the country?

To me, "ignoring race" does not come close to getting to the root of these questions. It is extremely palatable because it requires no work on my part, but experience shows it does not actually bear fruit.

lilactown··on Viewpoint: 'I feel like I was accidentally hired'
In the socratic fashion, I would ask you: why are Chinese or Japanese people treated differently when they have very light skin, similar to white people?

The answer is that it's not just your skin color but many other features that lead people to assume many other things about you: culture, heritage, upbringing, physical and mental acumen, etc.

Historically, black people from Africa in America have been routinely oppressed and forced into the lower class, whereas Indian people have a much different history (that I cannot speak to, I don't know much about it). Therefore, they are treated much differently by our society.

lilactown··on Viewpoint: 'I feel like I was accidentally hired'
I also despise the current state of public discourse for the very reason that stating that at the beginning of their post is necessary.

It's impossible for us to know if the poster of the original point is posting in good faith or not (such is the nature of the internet). By noting that it is a common alt-right strawman, and engaging with it anyway, it can help readers understand the meta of discourse that leads many other people to decide _NOT_ to engage with the argument.

The core problem with the discourse that is frustrating us is that people leverage these viewpoints not to generate discussion and mutual learning, but to try and terminate discussion in order to win people over to their side.

The way that the original point terminates discussion is tricky. Feeling "guilty by association" is a perfectly valid feeling. But the implication is, "things that make me feel guilty are not correct", and that can easily terminate a discussion because we have to untangle that first.

Continuing to post in support of the thing that makes someone feel bad is seen as callous, which is why I believe the replier speaking up for BLM is being downvoted. They are ignoring the OPs feelings, which _may_ be valid and real, but it can just as easily be an attempt to redirect the discussion.

Ultimately, feelings of guilt is not something that can really be processed over posts on social media, which is why I wish that the greater HN community would engage less in upvoting "peoples tactics made me feel bad" and more in productive discussion of how to do better than the status quo when it came to racial justice and other social topics.

lilactown··on Viewpoint: 'I feel like I was accidentally hired'
You're just dealing with a social problem that you haven't as much experience with. As you grow to better understand the interpersonal dynamics between you and other people w.r.t. race it'll be the same as learning how best to communicate with old, or disabled, or femme, or masculine people without offending them.

It's not hard, just new. You're not crazy, just inexperienced. All we should do is keep trying to get better at it.

lilactown··on Mini PCs in 2020
If I was more of a hacker, I would spend time to get a Linux system just to my liking. I find myself chained to the Apple ecosystem mainly because it’s what I use day-in-day-out across all my other devices (esp. for work) and I just have no desire to experiment. It’s just enough *NIX and just enough polish to keep me happy.
lilactown··on Mini PCs in 2020
Hm that’s interesting. In which case(s) does Thunderbolt 3 become a bottleneck? I do have a thunderbolt 3 monitor.
lilactown··on Mini PCs in 2020
For me, sitting for periods longer than 20 mins makes my back hurt; so I alternate between standing, kneeling and laying on my back on the couch :P
lilactown··on Mini PCs in 2020
I’ve recently purchased a MacBook Air to replace my Pro as my day-to-day laptop while coding on the couch, and been thinking of getting a Mac mini to handle the times when I want the extra power: for playing games like WoW or doing mobile development. Android Studio brought my 2013 Air to its knees previously.

Has anyone done this and been satisfied / dissatisfied? The Mac mini just seems so economical both in terms of size and dollars. I guess the only thing I would maybe want to shell out for is an eGPU, but I’m not even sure that’s necessary for my usage.

lilactown··on React Native for Windows and Mac
They do a translation between CSS/flexbox and the native UI layer, just like on iOS and Android
lilactown··on A Critique of React Hooks
Here's a rundown on mixins vs. hooks: https://reactjs.org/blog/2016/07/13/mixins-considered-harmfu...

I haven't used Rum in anger, but I do use reagent at work, and there are compatibility tradeoffs not just with other libs but also React itself that storing lots of state outside of the component tree in a mutable ref causes.

There's potentially a lot of work to be done to support React concurrent mode, which has a measurable impact to the user experience of apps that we build. Following best practices set by the React team - including using hooks for sharing and composing behaviors - sets us up better to take advantage of that in the future.

Ultimately though you don't need to rewrite your Rum/reagent apps, but instead there's an onus on the maintainers of those libs to build scaffolding around their lib code and encourage their users to migrate in a direction that will benefit them.

lilactown··on A Critique of React Hooks
I use ClojureScript professionally, and I believe Hooks are great. Reagent, Re-frame all have tradeoffs that they've made to try and shoe-horn in a solution that Hooks cleanly provides first-class support for.

I see a lot of other Clojure users wade into discussions like these and reveal an unexamined view of the technology they use and the way that other communities are trying to solve these same problems. It's really discouraging to see people put Clojure(Script) and associated libs on a pedestal, because it removes any nuance from the discussion and makes people think that the Clojure community are a bunch of holier-than-thou zealots.

FWIW, I was (am still) super excited about Hooks and have posted a lot of things critiquing ClojureScript React wrappers in the past, but I recognize now that they are making tradeoffs that ultimately are what the authors think are in the best interest of their user base. It would really be great if you (and everyone else) would enter these discussions with the same assumption.

← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →