HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

limit499karma

119 karma · joined July 26, 2024

submissionscomments
limit499karma··on The art of programming and why I won't use LLM
> black box

Actually the opacity of the abstraction layer is the core of the issue. First we note that opacity is a measure in both the inner-workings of the 'box' and orthogonally (in context of LLMs) a measure of deterministic outcome.

Programming, it is asserted by some of us, is exactly the act of instructing a deterministic 'black' box.

Peer-coding with an LLM is the act of cajoling a mechanism to hopefully consistently produce the input to a sensible "blackbox". It is not programming, it is getting help. Now if the help was 100% reliable, we could discuss programming the helper.

The other day I had a vision of the future AI whisperer in the corporate setting. They wear capes of varied colors and possibly sport a wand. "It's an art you see".

limit499karma··on Arrest of Pavel Durov, Telegram CEO, charges of terrorism, fraud, child porn
a very impressive guy. too bad he didn't name the oss libraries.
limit499karma··on Telegram founder Pavel Durov arrested at French airport
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Ut6RouSs0w

after watching Carlson's interview with Durov have come to think he may be the genuine article. Very interesting bit his relating us agents trying to recruit a dev and pushing some specified but alas unnamed oss libraries to use in Telegram.

limit499karma··on Telegram founder Pavel Durov arrested at French airport
"The deputy speaker of the state Duma, Vladislav Davankov, said he had called on Russian foreign minister Sergei Lavrov to secure Durov’s release. “The arrest of [Durov] could have political motives and be a means of obtaining the personal data of Telegram users. We must not allow this,” he said on his Telegram channel."

https://www.ft.com/content/c5d40e3c-9f9c-43dc-a467-1c713b40c...

That makes me wonder if Telegram was always a Russian spook op and its [ineffective] banning just a ruse.

I don't think any of the major platforms are independent of some spook oversight.

limit499karma··on Confessions of a Theoretical Physicist
According to a few (related) mystical schools of thought (that share a boundary with Jungian psychology) there is a distinction to be made between mind and intellect. The former, the mind, is held to be effectively a super-sense and its content and preoccupations naturally (as with the elemental senses) are bound firmly to the body. The intellect however is seen as the realm of knowledge whose domain extends to the transcendent.

While our intuition is indeed informed by experience it should be understood that speculative meditations (should one care not to believe in inspiration "from above") can enrich mental content and provide structural elements for conceptualization that transcends ordinary perception.

So the intellect is indeed superior to mentation. And for many of us this distinction is informative of our belief in the incompleteness of our self-perception.[..]

limit499karma··on Spider Uses a Light Show to Trick Eager Male Fireflies into Its Web
Well, this is not even 1 mm thick. It's just 2 glossy papers that are held by the adhesive so the gap while I slip it under the glass is pretty minimal.
limit499karma··on Spider Uses a Light Show to Trick Eager Male Fireflies into Its Web
Any semi-stiff plane would do, the thinner the better so as not accidentally injure the little critter's legs and what-not. These days keep an unpeeled decal that has just the right thinness/stiffness properties.
limit499karma··on Basic Mechanisms In Fire Control Computers (1953) [video]
I just downloaded (thanks to other commenter below) and would question the "use" part. What is the "peen" end used for? Having read the section on hammers I still don't know. (Just re-skimmed the section and I still don't know.)
limit499karma··on Artificial intelligence is losing hype
Why are you throwing in 'consciousness' in a comment regarding mechanical intelligence?
limit499karma··on NASA acknowledges it cannot quantify risk of Starliner propulsion issues
The issue is design and development methodology.

> "Spend some time with the other team"

How about design documents? Is that truly a lost art among the latter-day geeks?

limit499karma··on China's manufacturers are going broke
It is not officially a recognized politburo. The Eastern approach to these top down systems is to have a overt power structure whereas such a structure is denied in the West even though as you say it is all in the open.
limit499karma··on China's manufacturers are going broke
It wasn't just US. The hidden politburo of capitalists decided and the nations followed orders.
limit499karma··on Ex-Google CEO: AI startups can steal IP and hire lawyers to 'clean up the mess'
A typical specimen - no wonder he is a darling of MIC. This guy is the creepiest thing out of old Sun Microsystems. Must be one of those "bozos" Andy,Bill et al worried about in re to hiring ..
limit499karma··on An approach to the fundamental theory of physics
Is this an actual dialogue [link please?] or do you mean the duel between G.E.B. & Emperor's New Mind?
limit499karma··on In the Beginning Was the Command Line (1999)
This seems to deny the possibility of equivalence of any sequence of actions taken in a bounded spaces of entities (named widgets thus type:id) and actions to another 'representation' (e.g. text):

   { select[i]@dropdown:states > click@button:submit }
The fact that we don't have this (yet) does not mean it is not possible. In fact, given that the current darling of tech LLMs can 'compute visually' based on tokens (text) should make it clear that any 'representation' can ultimately be encoded in text.

So a 'record' feature on GUI 'a' can create action encoding that can be emailed to your peer looking at GUI 'b' and 'pasted'.

limit499karma··on Al-Khwarizmi
> Al-Jabr (The Compendious Book on Calculation by Completion and Balancing, Arabic: الكتاب المختصر في حساب الجبر والمقابلة al-Kitāb al-mukhtaṣar fī ḥisāb al-jabr wal-muqābala) is a mathematical book written approximately 820 CE. [...] The term "algebra" is derived from the name of one of the basic operations with equations (al-jabr, meaning "restoration", referring to adding a number to both sides of the equation to consolidate or cancel terms) described in this book.

This is not correct.

المقابلة indicates two entities facing one another. Root is Q.B.L. from which we also get Qibla (that is direction of prayer). So it indicates the balancing of terms on each side of the equation.

الجبر is actually one of the names of God and it means forceful/irresistible compeller. In context of حساب (computation, reckoning) حساب الجبر then means a computation that is compelled (by mathematical logic).

limit499karma··on Where should visual programming go?
> (mechanical sympathy)

I get what you are trying to convey but that usage of the term is not helpful in the general case as it confuses what mechanical sympathy actually means.

Mechanical sympathy is simply this: abstractions that acknowledge the underlying embodying stratum of a dynamic construct. In code, that translates to software that attempts at harmonizing the software abstraction with the operational characteristics of the underlying computing device.

limit499karma··on Jacek Karpińśki, the computer genius the communists couldn't stand (2017)
Any nation that becomes captive to ideological selection for its key sectors will naturally tend to selecting subpar individuals in position of power.

This is a cautionary tale. The same thing has happened to our nation, America, with the attendant decline across the board over the past 20-30 years.

limit499karma··on France high-speed rail traffic disrupted by 'malicious acts' on Olympic ceremony
Would be incredibly stupid of Russians to do something like this.

Over at France24.com this is what is posted ATM:

"Two security sources said the modus operandi meant initial suspicions fell on leftist militants or environmental activists, but they said there was not yet any evidence."

← PreviousPage 3 of 3