HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

llamathrowaway

265 karma · joined April 5, 2019

submissionscomments
llamathrowaway··on Uber data reveals motoring slower than walking in many cities
Arguably, when people shut themselves inside their cars for safety, they also become disconnected with the problems their society faces. They will have less incentive to fix the problems, so crime rises, and more people shut themselves in cars. A vicious circle.

Yeah, crimes in London is on the rise. And at the same time, people also keep getting hit and killed by cars. The diesel exhaust is filling people’s lungs, and the constant traffic noise is certainly putting a strain on people’s mind.

And instead asking Londoners to spend lots of money and get a car which they will have nowhere to park, what about reverse the police budget cut that left us with 22,000 fewer police officers?

llamathrowaway··on Why GitHub used Haskell for Semantic
> But in some domains (or pieces of domains), state and mutation aren't just unfortunate implementation details, but a core element of the problem space

True, but I would argue that it is far, far more common for people to writing stateful code to do things that are better done in functional style, than the other way around. This comes from my own experience of learning functional programming in JavaScript (before knowing about Haskell et al) and refactoring a project into a functional style that relies heavily on immutability.

I think Haskell is not more widely used in the industry because it has a very academic reputation. If you say you write Go, people think you are a practical programmer who turns coffee into solid business logic that powers some profitable website. You write Haskell? Then you are more likely to be perceived as some eccentric scholar or their like.

llamathrowaway··on A Teen Programmer Built a Tool to Generate Fake Lyrics for Your Favorite Artists
Some meta:

The cynic inside me thinks that people’s negative responses here are not really about corrupt media (tm). They are just reflections of the contrarian attitude that runs rampant on this site. The fact the HN guideline has to explicitly forbid 'shallow dismissal' tells you how much compulsive negativity is happening on this site.

(And yes, this post is also a display of my own negativity.)

I am not defending the media in any way. This is low quality journalism (on a site that does not seem journalistic anyway). The achievement of the 16-yo in the story is not outstanding in this field. HOWEVER, instead of reading yet another comment saying 'meh Markov chain', I guess I’ll prefer something like more advanced materials on text synthesis, some related projects, or just some advice for the author would be nice.

llamathrowaway··on UN expert says "collective persecution" of Julian Assange must end
> all threads about Assange have become the same

This is what I have observed in all threads marginally related to 'censorship'/'freedom of speech'. The exact same ideologically charged opinions, often mixed with a dose of middle school level name calling., get reiterated every one or two days, usually by the same set of users. I use to find those flame wars boring, but now I have learned to appreciate the beauty in the amount of efforts people throw into this dumpster fire. It’s the Sisyphus of our time.

And now Assange has also joined the club.

In all seriousness, I wonder what would happen if submissions get penalized more heavily by flagging. I guess there are lots of people how visit HN for the general tech-related interesting stuff, who have shut up due to the immense heat from those flame wars, and would happily click the 'Flag' button if it would bring back a less combative environment for discussion.

llamathrowaway··on VR is opening up new ways to experience art
I wonder if people’s perception of 'modern' paintings will change if they view them through VR.

Many modern paintings are massive in scale (bigger than my bedroom in some cases) and/or have many thick, voluminous layers of paint. Jackson Pollock is a good example. Those paintings look plain and childish when viewed on a tiny screen that fits in your pocket, as you don’t feel their scale, you don’t sense the depth of the paint and its texture, and maybe, you are also not in a suitable environment to view the arts. (IIRC some Mark Rothko paintings are displayed in dedicated rooms with dim light, as desired by the artist.)

But if you view those arts through VR, you can get a lossless, holistic view of the artwork. It can even be better than viewing in person as there is no crowd standing in front taking photos...

llamathrowaway··on Notre Dame is unstable: a strong wind could make the walls collapse, report says
Gothic architecture is fascinating because they are not only aesthetically appealing, but also very advanced (at their time) in terms of engineering. Stones are heavy, but the pointed arches and flying buttresses make Gothic churches feel light and nimble. Advanced structural design also allows Gothic churches to have larger windows as the structure is no longer solely supported by the walls, inviting more natural light into the church which contributes aesthetically and spiritually.

For me, the above statement is the reason why I would prefer the roof and spite of Notre Dame to be reconstructed in a modern design that utilizes all the advancements in architecture. The Gothic churches were built using state-of-the-art technologies hundreds of years ago, and they deserve to be rebuilt with the state-of-the-art technologies we have nowadays. If the medieval French could, they would certainly build Notre Dame with steel and glass.

llamathrowaway··on Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration
Ironically there are not only one, but two, Disneylands in Tokyo, and they seem to be popular among locals. There also seem to be more McDonald’s per capita in Japan than Europe. And don’t get me started on faux-European food in Japan (they do taste nice, though.)

So no, Japan, which is very well integrated into the global economy, is not that different from the west in terms of cultural consumption. People who still treat Japan as the mysterious land of samurais (ninjas seem outdated) and kabukis, unadulterated by western influence will, on their visit to Japan, struggle in the same way Japanese tourists struggled in Paris.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_syndrome

llamathrowaway··on Japan Begins Experiment of Opening to Immigration
It’s funny to see the comments lamenting the projected destruction of Japanese culture, while in fact

- the Japanese language is littered with loan words written in katakana even though native words of the same meaning often exist already

- office workers all wear suits

- the music scene is not very different from the west. Rock is huge and there is a great jazz scene. While bands playing Japanese instruments are rare and will be seen as a speciality, the same way bagpipes make you feel ethnic and traditional but pianos and guitars don’t.

- 'western' food is everywhere. I am not talking about what you can actually order in a restaurant in Europe, but Saizeriya and it’s peers. Western inspired cuisine. Japanese curry is also a thing.

- and don’t forget about whiskey.

And that

- no one forced Japan to do so. They have being open to foreign cultural influences since Meiji era, and I don’t see that changing. Seems to me that if it works for the Japanese people, it can and will become Japanese culture.

I am open to hear about some opinion from a native Japanese viewpoint. But from what I have read in this thread, much of the speculation about the loss of the 'unique' Japanese culture has more to do about what is happening in the west than what will happen in Japan.

llamathrowaway··on Don Norman on how design fails older consumers
If you’re ‘nearly 30’ then it’s likely you grow up with modern gadgets, and since you are on HN there is a higher chance that you have a stronger than average interest in electronics. Your parents did not grow up like you. They grew up in a time when a few knobs is all you need to operate a home appliance. And they are probably more interested in what’s being played on TV, rather than the TV itself.

The complexity of today’s electronics and softwares is getting out of control. If you have to actively explore all menus in order to use something normally, then I suspect the UI is poorly designed. But there is no incentive for their designers to improve, unless they acknowledge that their perception of electronics is very different from the average users.

llamathrowaway··on London girl could be first to have “air pollution” listed as cause of death
I don’t think anyone is actually defending pollution. Those who say ‘meh it’s asthma not pollution’ just enjoy being a contrarian, who would point out any perceived ‘error’ in others’ words. They don’t really have any agenda to push nor any opinions of their own that worth posting. Just nitpicking here and there to show how others are ‘wrong’.

Back to the topic, I wish we could ban diesel ASAP. I passed through Oxford Street a few times when it was virtually shut off by the protesters last month, so none of the diesel-burning black cabs not busses were there. It was much, much more pleasant than any other busy London street, almost serene, if there were not that many shoppers...

llamathrowaway··on Imperial College London Launches a Centre for Psychedelics Research
Fun fact: Aldous Huxley, author of, among others, the Door of Perception, was the grandson of Thomas Henry Huxley, the biologist who was the first dean of Royal School of Mines, which later became a part of the Imperial College.
llamathrowaway··on Aerobic exercise is an effective treatment for depression
Sorry for being slightly off-topic, but I really hope that PE lessons could focus more teaching the students how to enjoy exercising. It would have tremendously positive influence on the physical and mental health of the society as a whole.

Not so long ago I came across a twitter thread in which people shared very negative experiences with PE lessons in schools. My own experience was not as bad as some of theirs, but frustrating enough to make me hate the very idea of exercising. My body shape was average, but somehow I was very clumsy. Among boys, I was one of the the slowest runners, only faster than the few kids who are quite overweight. I was also extremely bad at sports. Could not dribble for more than a few steps, could barely hit a badminton bird reliably, etc.

My clumsiness itself was not something I felt bad about. It was the fact that my incompetence would be demonstrated in front of my classmates in a PE lesson that made me hate PE. In retrospect, they might not have noticed me anyway, and even if they did notice my failures, they are not going to remember. But this is not something a boy, eleven-year-old, driven by pride and a desire to show-off, could understand. What I learned from my PE lessons was simple: exercising sucks. Sport sucks. You better not do it if you've got the choice.

I have seen enough evidence to convince me of the benefits of exercising. I wish I could enjoy exercising more. But I just can't. I wonder how things could be different, if I somehow had the chance to enjoy my PE lessons more as a child.

llamathrowaway··on Luxury Developers Use a Loophole to Build Soaring Towers for Ultrarich in NY
Upvoted. For some reason more recent skyscrapers (not just the ones mentioned in the article) lack the modesty of older constructions. They feel completely out of place when viewed from afar. Totally not like some of the pre-ww2 skyscrapers which are monumental or even flamboyant (think of Chrysler Building) yet work together to create a consistent and harmonious feeling.
llamathrowaway··on A gentle introduction to symbolic execution
Thank you for this. However the labels 'syntax Haskell' and 'syntax LLVM' do not seem to display properly on Firefox. Wish you could find a way to fix them.
llamathrowaway··on CityBound – An open source city simulation game in Rust
Education in C:SL is actually more realistic then sc4. In sc4 the difference between different levels of schools is just that they boost the education level of sims of different ages. So a elementary school increases the education level of 20 and 30 year olds, but not sims in their 60s [1]. While in c:sl people need to actually go through the schooling system, and you can see the education level of each of them...

Also, is air pollution a huge problem in sc4? My experience is that you just put dirty industry in a faraway place, like you would do in c:sl. You can say that the air pollution generated by traffic in sc4 is simulated in c:sl as noise as well.

[1] https://www.wiki.sc4devotion.com/index.php?title=Elementary_...

← PreviousPage 2 of 2