HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

llbeansandrice

1,616 karma · joined February 7, 2020

submissionscomments
llbeansandrice··on Everyone in Seattle hates AI
Or if they stand to make a lot of money.

See both sides can be pithy.

llbeansandrice··on Writing a good Claude.md
I think it's relevant when people keep using terms like "prompt engineering" to try and beef up this charade of md files that don't even seem to work consistently.

This is a far far cry from even writing yaml for Github/Gitlab CICD pipelines. Folks keep trying to say "engineering" when every AI thread like this seems to push me more towards "snake oil" as an appropriate term.

llbeansandrice··on Writing a good Claude.md
My issue is not with learning. This "tool" has an incredibly shallow learning curve. My issue is that I'm having to make way for these "tools" that everyone says vastly increases productivity but seems to just churn out tech-debt as quickly as it can write it.

It a large leap to "requires engineering and planning" when no one even in this thread can seem to agree on the behavior of any of these "tools". Some comments tell anecdotes of not getting the agents to listen until the context of the whole world is laid out in these md files. Others say the only way is to keep the context tight and focused, going so far as to have written _yet more tools_ to remove and re-add code comments so they don't "poison" the context.

I am slightly straw-manning, but the tone in this thread has already shifted from a few months ago where these "tools" were going to immediately give huge productivity gains but now you're telling me they need 1) their own special files everywhere (again, this isn't even agreed on) and 2) "engineering and planning...not done in days or weeks even

The entire economy is propped up on this tech right now and no one can even agree on whether it's effective or how to use it properly? Not to mention the untold damage it is doing to learning outcomes.

llbeansandrice··on Writing a good Claude.md
If AI is supposed to deliver on this magical no-lift ease of use task flexibility that everyone likes to talk about I think it should be able to work with a README instead of clogging up ALL of my directories with yet another fucking config file.

Also this isn’t portable to other potential AI tools. Do I need 3+ md files in every directory?

llbeansandrice··on Trillions spent and big software projects are still failing
I've seen plenty of incredible engineers let go because of "performance issues" that were just poor project management and goal posts that moved so fast waymo should study them to improve their self-driving capabilities.

Shit rolls downhill and there's a lot more fuss when an engineer calls out risks, piss-poor planning, etc. than any actual introspection on why the risks weren't caught sooner or why the planning was piss-poor.

llbeansandrice··on Homeschooling hits record numbers
Is this not possible while exposing children to a variety of view points from different sources or does it require that children are not exposed to certain perspectives at all?

The original comment makes a very bold claim of "indoctrination" of an entirely undefined set of values.

There has been no evidence that exposing children to this (undefined and buzzwordy) set of values means that they can't be raised according to other values.

I find this idea pretty wild to encounter on HN which is generally focused on open source and widely available information so that people can educate themselves is suddenly gone in a puff of smoke and some buzzwords when talking about educating the most curious minds in the world.

Define the values. Cite sources that this is "indoctrination" and not simply exposing viewpoints. Then maybe we can have a productive discussion.

llbeansandrice··on NASA chief suggests SpaceX may be booted from moon mission
What? The US got to the moon ONLY bc we decided the nazis were more useful and the Soviet Union collapsed bc they didn’t make the same choice?

That’s absurd.

Either way, I’d personally rather today’s Nazis of all flavors to be dead. At the very least they seem a lot dumber than the old ones.

llbeansandrice··on Rivian's TM-B electric bike
That’s still a pretty huge gap from 50lbs of dead weight. This is a horrible and expensive ebike idk why HN is trying to defend it.
llbeansandrice··on NASA chief suggests SpaceX may be booted from moon mission
“Unpopular” is a weird way to frame “is a Nazi”.
llbeansandrice··on MLB approves robot umpires for 2026 as part of challenge system
There’s plenty of judgement calls that will always need to be made close to home plate so I don’t think the home plate ump is ever going away
llbeansandrice··on MLB approves robot umpires for 2026 as part of challenge system
Umps aren’t consistent tho and because of the way seniority works, the worst umps (the older ones) get the jobs in the playoffs and World Series.

If you want a human element this is just using it as a challenge system. So the players have to have a good eye to decide whether an ump was right or wrong and they can’t get help from anyone else to decide to challenge a call.

llbeansandrice··on Time saved by AI offset by new work created, study suggests
What an absurd straw man. Moving the needle away from “large portions of the population are a few paychecks away from being homeless” does not constitute “the devil’s playground”.

Where’s all of the articles that HN loves about kids these days not being bored anymore? What about google’s famous 20% time?

Idle time isn’t just important, it’s the point.

llbeansandrice··on U.S. autism data project sparks uproar over ethics, privacy and intent
The state has made their intentions crystal clear…
llbeansandrice··on You wouldn't steal a font
It’s not uncommon to require clients to develop a relationship with the retailer before they’re allowed to buy the more exclusive goods. It’s not the same as the licensing analogy but it’s close.

Imagine needing to spend 300% of an item’s cost at the retailer before you’re allowed the chance to buy the thing you actually want.

llbeansandrice··on What if we made advertising illegal?
Are they happy? They resist any legislation to label things as ads and want them as unobtrusive as possible. They take over the platforms while there’s still astroturfing and sponsored content charading as regular content.

If we ban billboards at least the the countryside will look nice

llbeansandrice··on The Alpha Myth: How captive wolves led us astray
“Why not?” Isn’t evidence and there’s a burden of proof that goes with the above claim.
llbeansandrice··on FDA Authorizes First Over-the-Counter Hearing Aid Software
Playing video games when you’re supposed to be piloting a half ton death trap isn’t the same as teenagers lying to authority.
llbeansandrice··on Tattoo ink sold on Amazon has high levels of weird and rare bacteria
You should work on that
llbeansandrice··on The U.S. government may finally mandate safer table saws
Dying from a crash doesn't mean you don't put pressure on social services. You could die at the scene (first responders and paramedics still), on the way to the hospital, upon arrival, or hours or even days after.

This does nothing to alleviate those pressures and the number of organs that are useful for transplant after a violent crash (that kills the occupant!) is basically zero.

llbeansandrice··on Major data center power failure (again): Cloudflare Code Orange tested
A single k8s cluster spanning multiple datacenters feels mind boggling to me. I know it's not exactly uncommon for HA even if you just have a little one in your cloud provider of choice but I'm sure it's a totally different beast than the toy ones I've created.
llbeansandrice··on Why are there so many methane satellites?
> it looks like Starlink alone is up to 5,942 satellites in orbit [0] these days

Starlink operates by far the largest constellation of satellites. Definitely the largest commercial constellation. That's like saying Google "just" serves ~8.5bn search queries/day. I might be mistaking your implication tho.

llbeansandrice··on There are too many damn honeypots
ROTH is always my favorite one as in ROTH IRA. It's named after a person [0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roth_IRA

llbeansandrice··on The EPA is proposing that 'forever chemicals' be considered hazardous substances
That's a very bad faith paraphrase of their single comment in this thread:

> For what it's worth, depending on the harms, a sudden total ban is not out of the question as being beneficial to humanity as a whole. It would just be disruptive to enterprise, boo hoo. We don't need to always treat bad actors with kid gloves.

Hardly the extremism you're implying.

llbeansandrice··on Passwordless: a different kind of hell?
Apple also lets you do this.
llbeansandrice··on Passwordless: a different kind of hell?
It's just a credit card though? Seems like a weird distinction when those details are intended to be given out. I presume if you're using one-time cards you're not using Apple pay at all. Plus you need the CVC code and such to re-auth them on new devices.

Apple has issues with privacy, but I don't really see how this is one of them.

llbeansandrice··on I'm sorry but I cannot fulfill this request it goes against OpenAI use policy
I also hate how the seller's pages are basically useless as well. I want to buy something from a specific brand and going to that page I can't find more than half of their product list on their own seller page.
llbeansandrice··on Fewer people are buying electric cars in the US
With the monetary and opportunity cost of renting (hassle, unpredictability, risk) it makes sense very very quickly to just own an ICE car for the predictable edge cases.

Have you rented a car recently? It’s a nightmare half the time.

In engineering I’d call that a high risk single point of failure.

llbeansandrice··on Fewer people are buying electric cars in the US
EVs do not solve any of those problems and have their own negative externalities.
llbeansandrice··on SpaceX Illegally Fired Workers Critical of Musk, Federal Agency Says
It’s not confusion it’s a comparison. The other commenter is trying to highlight Musk’s cognitive dissonance.

On the one hand, he wants to support “free speech” on his platform (being able to say what you want _publicly_ and not get fired).

On the other, his employees are getting fired for things they are saying internally. Obviously less of a moral crime, but one speech he is okay with squashing because it’s criticism of him.

So given these two situations, what is Musk’s definition of “free speech”? A value he claims to hold very dearly and earnestly, but also tramples if it’s speech he doesn’t like.

llbeansandrice··on Every major pharmacy chain giving government warrantless medical record access
It’s not a problem unless they do something I don’t like like Apple /s
← PreviousPage 3 of 15Next →