This really just betrays that you were not paying attention beyond the tagline.
Multiple cities have already implemented trial programs to replace police services with mental health and EMT professionals to wild success.
Denver has the STAR program [0] and I'm aware of a similar program in New Orleans and I'm sure other cities.
I simply don't think anyone who gets upset at the "defund the police" over the pithy tagline is arguing in good faith.
> Alleged failures of capitalism often strike me as failures of the competition metric rather than failures of capitalism per se.
Proponents of capitalism seem to have never encountered Goodhart's law. [1]
[0] https://www.denvergov.org/Government/Agencies-Departments-Of...