HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lmm

47,766 karma · joined October 14, 2011

I'm known as m50d some places, including github; my blog (such as it is) is at https://m50d.github.io/
submissionscomments
lmm··on Let's Encrypt bans certificate usage in any US sanctioned territory [pdf]
Organisations that are serious about promoting privacy should have been avoiding the US since the '90s and/or '50s, but the second best time to reincorporate in a safe jurisdiction is today.
lmm··on Let's Encrypt bans certificate usage in any US sanctioned territory [pdf]
> Incorporating a subsidiary in a foreign country doesn't make the parent company immune to the legal obligations it has in it's home country.

We're not talking about legal obligations in its home country though. I can buy Jack Daniels at age 19 in my country from their local subsidiary, and no-one thinks that this should be a crime for their US parent company because the US drinking age is higher. (Of course it would be a crime for either the parent or the subsidiary to sell to 19 year olds in the US)

(No-one is blaming Dell or Let's Encrypt here, to be clear, it's the US' excessive extraterritorial laws that are the problem)

lmm··on xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontier lab
> Which has approximately zero to do with the anthropomorphization of the car itself.

You don't think people talking about the car doing things has anything to do with anthropomorphising the car?

lmm··on xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontier lab
People are weird about their cars and make major errors in judgement as a result (e.g. we tolerate incredibly high rates of people getting killed because they were "hit by a car", as though the driver had nothing to do with it). Pushing back on that is absolutely worthwhile.
lmm··on Confidential submission of draft S-1 to the SEC
Some companies trade at a discount to book value (very normal for banks, for example, especially those from e.g. Pakistan).
lmm··on Federal judge blocks H1B visa $100K fee
> Being fired means you lose healthcare and much needed benefits and of course a paycheck and all of that stuff, right?

I think there's some law that lets you stay on health insurance for a few months at least, and you can save up as a countermeasure to the loss of the paycheck. Bad as it is it's not comparable to getting deported after a couple of months.

lmm··on Why are cells small?
Yes. I remember reading that Ostrich eggs are the largest single cells (in terms of mass/volume; Blue Whale nerve cells are longer).
lmm··on What happens if Japan takes in zero immigrants?
> Are you suggesting that a newborn human has more positive economic impact than an immigrant? What factors are you considering?

I'm suggesting they have a more positive lifetime impact yes. Obviously publicly-funded education, healthcare and the like for the newborn until they're ready to contribute financially has a cost, but an immigrant is just massively disruptive - language support in public services alone is a significant cost, but much larger is losing the benefits of a cohesive, high-trust society. If the neighbourhood's kids can no longer run errands alone but now need (or are felt to need) an adult escorting them, you're going to get mothers quitting their jobs to do that; if an unattended shop is no longer viable then those businesses will close; if every business switches to payment in advance because they can no longer trust people to pay their bills then that's a whole lot of friction that slows down all economic activity...

lmm··on GitHub Is Down
Monday is probably the best day for an outage? Everyone's in the office, so you're not disturbing them, and hung over, so you're not hurting their productivity much.
lmm··on Do we fear the serializable isolation level more than we fear subtle bugs (2024)
> you’re very limited in the kind of logic you can express within a transaction safely

On the contrary, you have Lua which is much more expressive than SQL (yes Turing completeness, but there's a huge difference in how easy it is to read and understand).

> Pretending like redis is suitable for an RDMS workload because it executes things serially means you’re completely ignoring what transactions are actually used for and how they work.

Well the vast majority of RDMS workloads don't use serial isolation, that's part of my point. As for the rest, all I can say is I've worked on many systems in many industries and seen very few (honestly none) that actually made effective use of what transactions do and don't give you.

lmm··on Do we fear the serializable isolation level more than we fear subtle bugs (2024)
No. If you're going to use serialisable you might as well just use something like Redis (which achieves serialisable behaviour by the much simpler approach of... actually executing your operations serially, and generally outperforms a traditional RDBMS set to serialisable transaction isolation). If you're going to use the horrendously complex machinery of a traditional RDBMS, it should be because you need a level of performance not achievable under serialisable isolation level.
lmm··on Do we fear the serializable isolation level more than we fear subtle bugs (2024)
> Over and over again Acid RDBMS have proven that trying to "relax" the rules in pursuit of performance or worse, mystical holy grails that have never been right or correct for a primary datastore, is a mistake. And then people goes back to them, because is the best tool for ALL the primary data store jobs. ALL OF THEM.

On the contrary. The most successful RDBMS by far was MySQL in an era where it didn't have any kind of ACID (you could write the transaction keywords but they didn't do anything). As the story we're talking about now shows, RDBMSes are routinely deployed with transaction settings that their users don't understand, much less use; there are settings that would reduce bugs if anyone cared to use them, but no-one does. People cargo-cult the idea that they should be using an Acid RDBMS but they almost never actually want or need one.

lmm··on An Ohio Valley 100k-watt FM signal is severed in broad daylight
> I don't think the average American sympathizes with random shitheads, bro. romanticizing thieves into some kind of noble morally grey antiheroes wronged by the society and struggling to feed their kids is a uniquely bohemian delusion.

The concept of a "luxury belief" makes a lot more sense of it. Believing that thieves aren't just scumbags is like driving a Porsche, it's a way to signal to other people who've never had to struggle in their life that you're one of them.

lmm··on An Ohio Valley 100k-watt FM signal is severed in broad daylight
> Why hasn’t the economist of the world figured out a solution to this problem.

Because the only solutions that work are social.

> There has to be a better way when both sides would be better off by just paying the theif double. Some kind of proof of work system to show that you really are crazy enough to do the crime maybe.

Kipling has a poem about that one, it doesn't work out.

lmm··on Do we fear the serializable isolation level more than we fear subtle bugs (2024)
I mean you're not really making use of MVCC etc. at that point. Foreign keys are far less relevant because your transactions are all fully atomic, so it doesn't really matter if your data is in an inconsistent state in the middle of a transaction, and conversely you've got no risk of e.g. adding a reference to a row that another transaction deleted concurrently. Why not just use e.g. Redis at that point?
lmm··on Do we fear the serializable isolation level more than we fear subtle bugs (2024)
If you're going to use serialisable isolation level, why bother using a traditional RDBMS at all? At that point you're better off using a simpler datastore.
lmm··on How's Linear so fast? A technical breakdown
> it’s very possible to run a web app backend within ~10ms RTT of most users

Only if your users are all located quite close to each other, or (sadly very common) you only care about making it fast for US users and screw everyone else.

(Of course you can have "intermediary backends" around the world on a CDN's edge network or similar, but at that point you're paying the same complexity cost as this style of putting the "intermediary backend" on the client)

lmm··on What happens if Japan takes in zero immigrants?
> Immigrants are WAY more economically efficient than children.

In Japan? Doubt. The social cost may be harder to measure, but it's huge.

And even if they are more "economically efficient", why is that the goal?

lmm··on What happens if Japan takes in zero immigrants?
> Should the government increase its already high tax rate from up-to-50% to up-to-90% and take money from the childless to give to parents?

Yes

> Should the government replace your salary if you quit your job to raise a kid (since after-all that is a cost of the endeavor)?

Yes

> If you're just talking about "giving birth", I assure you the cost to give birth is already close to free, the government already covers that, and various cities have local parent stipends which make it "profitable" in a sense.

Yes and no. There are a zillion different support programs where you have to fill out a 4 page form in triplicate and submit to city hall to get $80 3 months later. Childbirth is induced regardless of medical necessity because there's one programme that covers medical costs up to the scheduled due date and another programme that covers medical costs after birth, but if you need medical care after your due date with the baby still unborn then you fall through the cracks. The country badly needs to replace its patchwork subsidy program with simply including childbirth under normal medical insurance.

lmm··on What happens if Japan takes in zero immigrants?
For one generation, maybe. Once they've assimilated even a little (which is usually what you want, right?) they revert to the same birthrate as everyone else.
lmm··on What happens if Japan takes in zero immigrants?
> They need _someone_ (or something, if they can manage) to sustain the way of life they hold so dear.

They don't though? Pensions will be cut. Retirements will be pushed back. Grandparents with dementia will be kept mostly-alive in their children's homes rather than getting proper care. There will be pain and suffering. But I don't see any of that pushing the country to breaking point.

> And it's not something a country can just decide on a whim like "oop looks like we really need more people tomorrow folks". What are they going to do? Import millions of people 18 years from now? Or plan ahead to make sure millions of babies are born now to grow into the people they like 18 years from now?

As hard as fixing a low population is, it's easier than fixing a society where trust has broken down, which is what the western countries that went hard on immigration are already starting to face.

lmm··on SpaceX, Other Mega IPOs Denied Fast Index Entry by S&P
> I can say with a lot of confidence that optics weren’t considered in any of this, possibly to a fault.

How can you possibly know that? Do the people on that committee have a cast-iron tenure guarantee?

lmm··on Mornings and nights no longer exist at 47C: A day in the hottest place in India
Depends on the season. "Everyday" was a poor choice of word, but 35+ wet bulb temperatures happen and are to some extent routine and expected.
lmm··on Mornings and nights no longer exist at 47C: A day in the hottest place in India
> The really scary thing will be when the wet bulb temperature goes above 35 degrees, and humans can only survive with AC.

That's already an everyday reality in Singapore.

lmm··on WSL 2 is getting faster Windows file system access
> better and more stable NVIDIA drivers available to Windows

Huh? It's the same driver. It works the same on every platform. There's no consistent difference in performance (at least not between FreeBSD and Windows, it's been a while since I ran Linux).

lmm··on The Ü Programming Language
Sounds pretty normal if someone's working full-time on it? That's what, 50/ working day, or about a commit every 10 minutes? Nothing to worry about.
lmm··on My Students Can't Read
> Is the problem participation? Or is it that entire years are devoted to reading ancient books with bad English and unrelatable themes simply because of tradition? Shakespeare wrote some neat plays but they’re not helping the reading epidemic.

Were Shakespeare's plays "relatable" 370 years after being published and then suddenly became unrelatable in the last 30? I think not. If students' participation in classes about them has changed, it's not because of the plays aging.

lmm··on Nvidia RTX Spark
> Sid

Are you refusing to use the Nvidia binary drivers and/or a setup like DKMS that ensures kernel modules are rebuilt as necessary? While I respect the principle, it's a problem you're creating for yourself.

> upgrade my Kernel whenever I want to without getting a black screen with a blinking cursor on the next boot.

Really? I had very much the opposite experience.

lmm··on Anthropic confidentially submits draft S-1 to the SEC
> Who invests in an index fund for "moonshots"?

> Everyone I know who invests in an index fund is doing so to mitigate the risks of things like "moonshots" which are typically much riskier investments.

The whole point of an index fund is to capture the growth of the whole market. If you wanted low risk you'd be buying bonds.

lmm··on Anthropic confidentially submits draft S-1 to the SEC
> The investors who wanted to take more risk could do that.

What? How? By moving out of Massachusetts? I could understand banning such a speculative stock for e.g. pension funds or whatever, but blocking private individuals from buying with their own money seems insane.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →