HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lngnmn

-10 karma · joined December 24, 2016

submissionscomments
lngnmn··on Predict the future with Machine Learning
Future cannot be defined for a any stochastic process with unknown number of hidden variables with unknown weights. Everything core complex than a roll of a dice is unpredictable by definition, just because the model is incomplete. Even next roll of a dice cannot be predicted.

Probability is not reality. Simulations are cartoons. Map is not the territory. Models and simulations based on them are different from reality in the same way a movie is not reality.

People who can't grasp these simple ideas cannot be legitimately called scientists.

lngnmn··on Typed nils in Go 2
Oh, that is truly hipster's concept - more than one nil. similar to -0 and +0.

Public cosplay of [presumed] intelligence as a new smoking.

lngnmn··on Dijkstra was right – recursion should not be difficult
Recursion only begins with the notion of mutual recursion. Transforming imperative loops into recursion (with the constant-space accumulation pattern and TCO) is a nothing-special mechanical operation. Recursion really shines in mutually recursive algorithms, like the famous Hanoi Tower solution.
lngnmn··on Google Fires Employee Behind Controversial Diversity Memo
So, Google's snowflakes are trying to place some naive pseudo-scientific and pseudo-philosophical but popular among other snowflakes compilation of current memes and fancy terminology upon objective reality by silencing a naive but not clueless attempt to remind others about some old truths..

Let's put it straight. There are obvious, hardwired evolutionary specialization among sexes of all species. Sexes are evolutionary innovation to achieve better survival rates (achieved by the process of evolurionary trial and error and natural selection) not some stupid religious nonsense. So, there is no equality in principle, by definition, by design. The notion of equal rights is completely different story, it is social realm - few levels up from underlying biology.

There is not a single doubt that biology dominates and partially determines psychology (the nature part of the Nature and Nurture whole). Biology also dominates sociology - most of human traditions and social norms are deeply grounded in biological differences and specialization - there is nothing to talk about. Animal behavioral patterns, which could be called "traditions of species" are, obviously, determined by biology and environmental factors.

At least few stereotypes produced by various human cultures (products of social formations, partially determined by biology) are reflections to various extend of these real, existing, "material" fundamental differences captured in traditions. Dismissal of all the stereotypes as a category is plain stupidity.

Hipsters and snowflakes who are trying to gain attention by "challenging" objective reality with their naive memes (the ridiculous attempts to redefine what sexes are and what it is for with "third sex" nonsense is an obvious example) at very least raise some brows.

Notice that I am not in the least "conservative", I am principal and scientific. There are evolutional and biological reasons why this or that aspect of sex differences emerged and what is for. Whatever is valid for all species applies to humans too, no matter what liberal arts graduates would say about man's superiority.

Nature forms and dominates, Nurture varies and adapts. There is not a single doubt that equal rights must be given to both sexes (there are only two of them) and equal rights must be protected.

This is where the notion of equality ends. Equality of sexes is a hipster's utter nonsense, not because conservatives think so, or some popular religious text says so, but for straightforward scientific reasons, anatomical and neurobiological. This is so-called objective reality, and opinions and memes of current snowflakes are simply non-applicable.

lngnmn··on Prostitution decriminalized: Rhode Island’s experiment
It should be taught in high school that extremes are not representative.

The popular areas of sex tourism in Thailand are safer than most tourist hotspots without any security forces, cameras, etc. Everything is self-regulated, like a healthy market or society should be.

lngnmn··on Prostitution decriminalized: Rhode Island’s experiment
Look no farther than some South Asian societies. Countries with no madness around prostitution are better off socially.

It is not an accident that Thailand is a Buddhist country - people are tolerant to whatever is not harming others living beings.

Too much pressure on sexual issues is a sign of primitive authoritarian societies (who are cooksure that they know better what is right and what is wrong than biology and evolution).

lngnmn··on Software Engineering ≠ Computer Science (2009)
Sure. Engineering is an applied science. So, these cannot be equal.
lngnmn··on There Have Always Existed People Who’ve Simply Wanted to Be Alone
Since the time Vedic seers, I suppose...

BTW, prolonged solitude has been considered by most major Eastern schools (both Hindu and Buddhist) as necessarily precursor for spiritual transformations.

lngnmn··on Clojure will affect the way you think about programming
I really appreciate narcissism and arrogance of Rich - he spent these two years (or whatever the legend says) writing Clojure 1.0 before made it public and this is what arrogance is for.

Nevertheless, even an ordinary CS student would notice, that there is literally nothing extraordinary in Clojure which was not being researched and implemented in other languages, like Erlang, Scheme (that subset of it which does not include set-car! and set-cdr!) SML and, obviously, Common Lisp. The systematizing effort and ability to deliver are exceptional.

So, I am sorry, but I am not buying these marketing slogans, because I know on which principles it has been made.

lngnmn··on Clojure-turtle – Logo programming language in a Clojure context
systemd

More seriously, everything which made MIT to switch from Scheme to Python in the fundamental CS courses.

lngnmn··on Clojure will affect the way you think about programming
Why not Common Lisp or Scheme?
lngnmn··on Clojure-turtle – Logo programming language in a Clojure context
Yet another example of how interfaces and ADTs (together with layered DSLs) are the central concerts in classic CS.
lngnmn··on Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (August 2017)

  Location: South Asia
  Remote: YES
  Willing to relocate: YES
  Technologies: CS
  Résumé/CV: https://karma-engineering.com/lab
  Email: lngnmn1@gmail.com
lngnmn··on Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon
One word: Microsoft.
lngnmn··on Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide
Bridging of Finite-Infinite Divide
lngnmn··on Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide
But some mathematical logic is indeed sectarian.
lngnmn··on Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide
> For mathematical object to 'exist' only thing required is logical consistency under the rules used.

This is precisely the rule which establish existence of gods, accelerating time, higher dimensions, and other mental UFOs.

Disconnected from reality (from what is) abstract, seemingly consistent logic is what supports all the chimeras.

Read some Indian or Tibetan tantras, look at some mandalas - everything is logically consisted according to a particular sectarian logic.

lngnmn··on Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide
> We can't see or think anything concrete. We have never touched anything 'physical' or 'real'. It's all abstract representations in our brains.

This is some sectarian preaching in my opinion. The whole thing including these very Western philosophical sects are possible exactly because something concrete definitely exist. The DNA and the laws which make it stable and the whole life on top of it is the consequence of the fact that something concrete is out there.

This, BTW, is an millennia old debate between some branches of esoteric Eastern schools and should, perhaps, be a part of seconady school lectures.

As for definitions of infinity, the theoretical possibility of infinite series, infinite small numbers or infinitely many real numbers between 0 and 1 is nothing but mental constructs. There is not a single "concrete" infinity.

lngnmn··on Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide
There is no such thing as Infinite outside your heads. This is actually a pattern - a false dichotomy with a pure abstraction produced as an abstract opposite or an abstract result of negation of some other concept or a named entity. Applied Hegelian nonsense if you wish.

Infinity is a pure abstraction, like zero, but ill-defined (zero is an symbol for a concept of an empty slot, absence or nothing, while infinite is mere a negation of finite). Like many other concepts it might be useful, but usability does not imply existence.

lngnmn··on Artificial Intelligence Is Stuck
Emotions are "learned heuristics".
lngnmn··on Artificial Intelligence Is Stuck
Pattern recognition and feedback loops aren't enough. Artificial Intelligence require Artificial Emotions.
lngnmn··on 153k Ether Stolen in Parity Multi-Sig Attack
Yet another homegrown PHP-sque language. The Fractal Of Bad Design is actually a pattern.

My bet they never took any PL course, and have very vague understanding of what consequences certain design decisions would produce. "20 years of PHP coding" or something like that.

Any decent PL course would emphasize the first-class-everything (procedures , obviously), lexical scooping for proper closures, strong but dynamic typing (no implicit coersions) etc. No matter which sect one belongs to - ML or Scheme - these are universal fundamentals, the well-researched foundation.

PHP/Javascript coders usually do not understand the principles and implications behind languages they use. Otherwise they would develop a healthy aversion, like to a tasteless, vulgar porn.

Sane people with PL background would use a dialect of Scheme as a DSL (the numerical tower and all the nice things) or at least Lua (because packers are afraid of parenthesis and see nothing behind of them).

Actually, Scheme (or a simplified dialect such as the one inside Julia - flisp) would be almost ideal choice for financial DSLs.

For those who are cosplaying a PL expert (with 20 years of PHP and Javascript coding under their belt) there is a good read: http://users.rcn.com/david-moon/PLOT3/

lngnmn··on Ask HN: When has switching the language/framework made an important difference?
J2EE
lngnmn··on Australian PM Calls for End-To-End Encryption Ban
Instead of better education, social security and jobs creation...
lngnmn··on VISA offers restaurants $10,000 to stop accepting cash
Anti-monopoly and human rights guys should perhaps take a look into this.
lngnmn··on Ravens can plan for future as well as 4-year-old children can
Ravens have a concert of future? Amazing!

What if ravens just act accordingly to environmental cues instead?

lngnmn··on What if AI is a failed dream?
The classic AI (as in the AIMA book), it seems, got it right - heuristic-based search, guided by feedback (to improve an heuristic) is what intelligence is in general. Every living organism posseses intelligence (by the process of trial-and-error, which is a search, to "learn" an "optimal" heuristics with selection by the process of evolution) of some kind relative to its environment. This is how a bacteria fought viruses, for example.

The problem is to find a good-enough heuristic, or to "extract" one from the actual (not imaginary) features of the environment and "train" it. This is, roughly, how ensimes has been made.

This second goal is murderously hard, because to select right set of features which adequately represent some aspects of reality (as it is, not as we imagine or know it is) is where humanity is still failing miserably.

lngnmn··on Toward Go 2
The classic Wizards lecture on generic '+ is good enough argument.

The numeric tower of lisps is the canonical use case of what generic functions are good for.

Smalltalk, the second greatest language after Lisp, is also good example.

lngnmn··on ECMAScript 2017 Language Specification
Holy fuck! The Fractal Of Bad Design all over again...
lngnmn··on Zip code better predictor of health than genetic code
Probabilistic models based on naive gross-over-simplification of wastly complex reality at its best.

There is indeed a huge distance between DNA and non-genetic diseases and attempt to bridge this gap with a naive probabilistic model will surely yield nonsense.

Social and environmental factors are much more fundamental than actual DNA (gene regulation is still poorly understood) for non-genetic diseases. So, yes, statistically it is true.

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →