HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lnwlebjel

710 karma · joined December 15, 2020

submissionscomments
lnwlebjel··on There’s a heatwave in the sea and scientists are worried
It's not ignored. From NASA:

"The amount of solar energy Earth receives has followed the Sun’s natural 11-year cycle of small ups and downs, with no net increase since the 1950s. Over the same period, global temperature has risen markedly. It is therefore extremely unlikely that the Sun has caused the observed global temperature warming trend over the past half-century."

Relevant figure: https://royalsociety.org/-/media/Royal_Society_Content/polic...

It's not a lot. See also:

https://royalsociety.org/topics-policy/projects/climate-chan...

If you have better data, I'd like to see it.

lnwlebjel··on Death Valley Just Had the Hottest Midnight on Record
One of my favorite things to do when the news is all about heat waves is monitor the weather at Furnace Creek, Death Valley:

https://forecast.weather.gov/MapClick.php?lat=36.44802000000...

The forecasted high on Saturday is 126°F.

lnwlebjel··on Stanford president resigns over manipulated research, will retract 3 papers
Richard Feynman on the subject:

"researchers must avoid fooling themselves, be willing to question and doubt their own theories and their own results, and investigate possible flaws in a theory or an experiment. He recommended that researchers adopt an unusually high level of honesty which is rarely encountered in everyday life, and gave examples from advertising, politics, and psychology to illustrate the everyday dishonesty which should be unacceptable in science. Feynman cautioned,[3]

'We've learned from experience that the truth will come out. Other experimenters will repeat your experiment and find out whether you were wrong or right. Nature's phenomena will agree or they'll disagree with your theory. And, although you may gain some temporary fame and excitement, you will not gain a good reputation as a scientist if you haven't tried to be very careful in this kind of work. And it's this type of integrity, this kind of care not to fool yourself, that is missing to a large extent in much of the research in cargo cult science.'"

from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult_science

The frauds and bad scientists will be found out, eventually.

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: What YouTube channels do you watch with your kids?
Mark Rober has many great and some good science and engineering videos that my kids love:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCY1kMZp36IQSyNx_9h4mpCg

He get's my vote for the current best communicator of science, on par at times with Carl Sagan. This video explains neural nets/machine learning and had my kids riveted:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmlRbfSavbI

We've gone down some deep lego rabbit holes, such as the great ball contraption:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCmwskpxyCg

These are pretty light but entertaining:

https://www.youtube.com/@howridiculous

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGzXtNdhjPxvCNWFme1bG0g

The latter is a guy that builds fresh water aquariums. The fact that he can do this full time for a living (via YouTube) is one of the most amazing and unlikely results of the internet (IMO).

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: How Do You Utilize Your Personal Knowledge Base?
Use of this type of thing has been absolutely essential to my work as a research scientist, as the modern equivalent of a 'commonplace book' (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonplace_book). Search is the primary advantage over paper notebooks and so search is arguably the most important feature of any of these 'knowledge bases'. Tagging or other forms of organizing being subsets of search, and in my opinion essential features.

So, how do I employ it? One is to search on a subject I'm interested in or working on, ie to find notes, previous readings and writings, then add to these or go from there. Another is to keep various kinds of lists, (eg lists of ideas, things to read, etc). Otherwise the way your able to link things together with tags and other forms of linking is also pretty great - these are all features I will insist on when I move to something new, since I use tiddlywiki, which is a mostly dead project.

Anything with these features works like an external brain, allowing for recall, with just enough inefficient that you have to engage with the material, and possible mix some notes and facts together to hopefully inspire some new ideas.

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: What's a not so famous software company that makes a lot of money
I used to know the founder of JDA Software (which now operates under a new name). They do logistics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Yonder

The link suggests 1.1 Billion in revenue in 2021

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: Which book has had the most meaningful contribution in your life?
Yes, way more detail backed by a thorough assessment of the scientific evidence, and the application of this knowledge toward improving healthspan (minimizing mental and physical decline with age).

Some examples: healthy joints by examining and addressing movement patterns and muscle imbalance; maintaining muscle mass through weight training and prioritization of protein consumption (including red meat); the importance of V02 max as demonstrated by 3-6x decreases in mortality; the implications of all this on reduction of cancer, Alzheimers risks, etc.

The difference between this book and all others I've seen is that, as a trained scientist with a mathematical background, Attia has a rare combination of MD training, a mathematical/scientific way of thinking, and a history of working as a consultant in risk assessment. All this provides a much needed framework to assess what is known in the space and use it to make practical recommendations for how to live - and how to asses new evidence as it comes in.

Much of it my not be new to you (in particular), but the book may provide important reasons why you would want to do these things. Motivation is a huge part of it.

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: Which book has had the most meaningful contribution in your life?
For me it's a book I am reading now: Outlive, the science and art of longevity, by Peter Attia MD. The book is a summary of the many podcasts which I have been listening to for a couple of years now, a result of which I am happier, healthier (by arguably the right metrics), fitter, and better able to navigate life and the prospect of getting older. If you are over 40 I highly recommend it, and if you're over 50 it's a must read.

If I could sum up, I would say that so much of health and fitness is just trying to figure out the right thing to do - this book applies an appropriate level of skepticism to say what we know and what we don't on this subject, and teaches you how to assess for yourself what you need to do to improve your odds of a long healthy life. Finding it is like finally finding the a great text book on subject that you haven't been able to wrap your head around.

lnwlebjel··on Microsoft’s Satya Nadella Is Betting Everything on AI
> A lot of knowledge work is drudgery, like email triage. Now, I don't know how I would ever live without an AI copilot in my Outlook. Responding to an email is not just an English language composition, it can also be a customer support ticket. It interrogates my customer support system and brings back the relevant information. This moment is like when PCs first showed up at work. This feels like that to me, across the length and breadth of our products.

Anyone have this? I have about 50 gmail filters that could use some intelligence

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: Where are all the parties?
I blame COVID, but our neighbors started doing low-key happy hours about once a month and these have been wonderful. We've also started meeting people for pizza at restaurants again and that has been similarly great. So I'd like to think that we're all out of practice and it's taking a while to get to ball rolling again.
lnwlebjel··on How to slow down scientific progress, according to Leo Szilard
> it doesn't mean that reality will agree with you, it means you have become a better politician

This is true, and we're reliant on the reviewers being in touch with reality, which I gather is not always the case, though in my (limited) experience it has been. Writing proposals does feel different than writing papers and I do worry about getting too divorced from reality. I endeavor to stick to nonfiction!

The slowing of the feedback loop is only necessary if you wish to fund your work from sources that require it. Self funding through other means would have advantages.

lnwlebjel··on How to slow down scientific progress, according to Leo Szilard
As one who actively participates in this parlor game, I disagree with the premise. Prior to writing proposals, I would have thought writing proposals was a huge waste of time and effort. However, we have a saying that no good idea goes to waste. When writing, you have to be clear and concise and your idea has to be good to get funding. If you don't get funded, you usually get good, useful feedback. You get better, your ideas get better, and the person reviewing them has learned what many scientist in the field are proposing as the best new directions for research. These are all valuable uses of time that might otherwise be spent learning how to make your ideas better, how to communicate them better, and how better understand what is going on in the field. In other words, things that you would be doing anyway.

I think the biggest problem facing science right now is the scale at which it is occurring. My field does not have this problem, but I can't imagine what it's like trying to stay on top of the literature in e.g. medical sciences. Paper writing and peer review work at much smaller scales - there are order hundreds scientist in my field and I think it's functioning just fine. For fields with thousands and 10s of thousands of active researchers, I think there needs to be a different way to vet and organize information. I don't know what that is exactly but it might look something like twitter (can't believe I'm writing this!). On second thought, maybe it looks more like HN!

The misalignment of incentives can be problematic as well, but arguably, not the biggest problem.

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: What are your thoughts on students replacing their notebooks with iPads?
I have a kid in 8th grade. The school issued iPads and all work is done and submitted on them. Internet hotspots are issued to kids who have no internet at home. My opinion is that the are a slightly net-negative for learning, given the time she takes fiddling with the various apps to get them to do what she needs them to do. I suspect that they greatly simplify grading (and thus the teacher's job), and are thus here to stay.

Otherwise, I think it's an abomination. Using the same device for learning, entertainment, social media and other distractions just seems like a really bad idea. Maybe I don't give the kids credit - but this is my working hypothesis. I'd be glad to be wrong.

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: What technology seems like magic to you?
Brains. We have essentially the same neurons, same transmitters, same proteins, etc. as a fruit fly. But for every one they have, we have 100 million. Emergent characteristics are like magic.
lnwlebjel··on Retired U.S. generals, admirals take top jobs with Saudi crown prince
This would be my first assumption - if not the pentagon then the CIA.
lnwlebjel··on LaTeX Makes Me Angry
See overleaf.com which approximates this feature.
lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: Working full time while also caring for an infant?
Having done basically this I can say I highly recommend not doing it. Reading your post brings up really awful feelings. Those two years were horribly stressful - I'm not sure I've fully recovered to be honest.

Furthermore, the kid has needs too, and one of those is to occasionally get your full attention, and for you to not be stressed out. I'm not sure my kids have fully recovered either.

I would use all the vacation, family leave, and sick time first, and then consider going into debt to get your wife through school.

lnwlebjel··on Lowest “Who is hiring?” Post Count in 30 Months
For a data centric view on the larger economy and an assessment of leading indicators I highly recommend this blog:

https://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2022/09/predicting-next-r...

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: How to find what I am really good at?
Your response carries much too much confidence. There is no debate any longer - the story is pretty well worked out [1][2]. Nature only gets you so far. See for example how much top pro golfers practice (or musicians, or whatever ..). (Not that it matters but I learned this late in life and was able to apply the knowledge to make it near the top of my admittedly very narrow field). Sure, at the top 0.1%, maybe even 1%, your nature really matters, but you still need to practice.

You, meaning anyone, could probably practice hard and join the upper x% of just about anything (setting aside things like the NBA that overvalue nature). What x is, well that is subject to debate. So is the source of motivation, and that is almost the most important thing.

[1] Peak, by K. Anders Ericsson and Robert Pool [2] talent code, by Daniel Coyle

lnwlebjel··on Most US professors are trained at same few elite universities
Good points for sure. The thought experiment I had in mind was a little different. You're on hiring committee at University X, and you can hire candidate A from prestigious university, or B from less prestigious University. Presumably, they get the same resources going forward.

Perhaps you are right that the social connections alone would differentiate candidates A and B. Which would suggest that hiring committees are somewhat correctly acting in their own best interest when they hire A.

lnwlebjel··on Most US professors are trained at same few elite universities
What would be more interesting is this: are the researchers in the 80% category as productive as the researchers from the 20% of elite institutions category (on average)? This could be studied and measured, and would go a long way toward dispelling the notion of prestige.

I see what they are getting at - yes there needs to be more diversity in academia and education needs to be more available, and widely distributed, across society. I don't see however, how this is going to motivate hiring committees to take an otherwise promising, and competitive person from a lower prestige institution, who is almost certainly competing with an equally qualified person from an elite institution. Making the case that this person would also be a very good bet might help.

lnwlebjel··on What I’ve learned from users
Interesting. I rank buy a car from a new car salesman as the worst consumer experience of my life. So much so that I've since bought used cars and in the future hope to buy a Tesla in large part to avoid that experience. I understand that it could greatly benefit the salesperson in understanding the social psychology of the consumer ... but never again will I subject myself to that process.
lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: Did anyone here with normal-to-low levels of energy has had success?
Productivity = focus * time

Yes, time is important - but depth of focus is almost as important.

lnwlebjel··on A Surprising Side of Carl Sagan
I'm a huge fan of his work, and was greatly influenced by Cosmos, watching it as a child. I don't really care if he had a big ego or wasn't the best at math. What he did better than anyone else was to convey the sense of wonder. He maintained curiosity and skepticism in equal measure. That is hard to do, but understanding and communicating the sense of wonder to the masses is even harder - and I'm very grateful that he did.

"If their culture has not given them all the tools they need to pursue this great quest, let us temper our criticism with kindness. None of us comes fully equipped." - Carl Sagan. The Demon-Haunted World.

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: First-time dad-to-be. What do you wish you'd known back then?
> Start a college savings fund and tell everyone you’d prefer they contribute to that vs plastic junk. You might get a few takers on something with enduring value.

Such a great idea. Alternatively, get a snow shovel to use when cleaning up the house because there will be a lot of plastic junk.

lnwlebjel··on Ask HN: First-time dad-to-be. What do you wish you'd known back then?
I will just add that I was a much better parent when I only had 2.
lnwlebjel··on A new carbon capture plant will pull 36k tons of CO2 from the air each year
Bill Gates's books has a great account of what it will take to get us out of this mess - and I agree, it is a huge mess - and Carbon capture is likely to be a small part of the solution.
lnwlebjel··on Show HN: Movably – Protect your health, move more while you work
As a person with persistent hip mobility issues - from sitting all the time - this is a great idea and I hope it catches on.
lnwlebjel··on A new carbon capture plant will pull 36k tons of CO2 from the air each year
Malthus was wrong because of innovation, and if Gretha is wrong, it will also be because of innovation.
lnwlebjel··on Not future-proofing
I agree, he seems to argue for conduit, making the house more configurable and thus better able to 'learn'.
← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →