HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

loewenskind

1,848 karma · joined May 19, 2010

submissionscomments
loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
>For groups of more than a few hundred people (some say 50) this turns out to work better than any of the alternatives such as communism.

Citation please? Where has communism seriously been tried? Russia was trying a lot of things at the same time while simultaneously engaging in wars and dealing with their own in fighting. Communism didn't flourish in this environment, but what would? Capitalism itself depends on rule of law which was spotty at best.

>But it does cause income inequality as a necessary side effect.

Again, if you're talking about US levels of inequality I'm going to need another citation. I can't think of any developed country that isn't capitalist but I can think of a lot that don't have US levels of inequality.

>China may label itself communist but it is quite far removed from using communism as an organizing principle to create wealth.

Exactly. Granted, China does interfere in their markets a great deal (e.g. pinning their currency to the dollar artificially) but market interference isn't communism. It's a capitalist market their interfering with not a communist one.

loewenskind··on And suddenly, you're hip
I'll concede that that is very good. And I'll also concede that I can't think of any other systems that do this as well as CPAN (if at all). But my point remains that for 99% of developers we want a library that provides functionality (e.g. an ORM for a common database) and in that respect CPAN will only have an advantage for very obscure requirements. And even then it still loses to Java.

The testing stuff is good and it's the direction everyone should be going but not having it obviously isn't too much of a problem because so few systems currently have it (CPAN was successful long before it had it as well).

loewenskind··on Obama administration moves forward with unique Internet ID for all Americans
>Hmm. You don't think that people's preferences tell us anything?

It's irrelevant because it's an incredibly over-simplistic metric and it's subject to manipulation (i.e. everyone hearing 2nd and 3rd hand the US is the greatest country in the world, which in some ways it was some decades back and deciding to go there).

>American poor people are stereotypically obese and have multiple cars and big screen TVs.

Done with credit. You could have the same thing in Romania if they let everyone had 5 credit cards, different credit for their house, difference credit for their car and different credit for the place where they buy their TV.

Being fat doesn't mean they're getting more food, it means they're getting more bad food. A better thing to look for would be a place where the poor are not hungry and not malnourished.

>Oh, and they have free healthcare too.

What are you talking about here, ER care? Can they get a hip replacement for "free" like they could in e.g. Sweden? Why are cancer patients divorcing their spouses to ensure said spouse wont end up losing his/her retirement money paying medical costs of a dead person?

>Why is comparing the pressure between {your favorite western European country} and the US irrelevant?

Because it's impossible to quantify why this pressure is happening. Is it because of coincidence? Misinformation? Informed choice? Opportunity (e.g. "we can walk to the US but can't afford to get to where we really want, and anywhere seems like it would be better than here")? Given that we can't say with even the slightest amount of confidence, this number is almost completely meaningless.

A number that would have more meaning would be if some place had no or negative immigration but that's not the case in any first world country as far as I'm aware.

>Huh? Opportunity is surely one factor in "place to be".

But it speaks to the location of the actor, not how good the country he's going to since he is choosing the new country over less than the whole set (i.e. if someone leaves mexico to go to the US that is more likely to mean that he/she chose to go the US over staying in mexico or going somewhere else in middle america than to mean that he chose it over France).

loewenskind··on Obama administration moves forward with unique Internet ID for all Americans
I think he's assuming that it will be some day. Giving the insane stuff going on the US lately I think that's probably a valid assumption.
loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
>It looks like the OP doesn't like CEOs.

Not at all, it's a needed and valuable position to be sure. And I have no problem with them being the highest paid person in the company, even by several times. I just think the vast majority are ridiculously over paid.

>But, the OP also seems to be making the mistake of implying CEOs == the rich.

No, I was singling this group out as a big source of inequality. Larry and Sergei are founders. Their wealth (initially) didn't negatively impact anyone else. Michael Jordan made his money directly from advertising which means he was paid what companies thought was fair [1]. Politicians get rich from corruption and gaming the system. The difference between them and overpaid CEO's is that what they do is obviously illegal or at least immoral. Lots of people herald overpaid CEO's as something to aspire to.

[1] This is different from a typical mid to large size company CEO who's pay is decided by a board (i.e. often totally shielded from any market forces). The board will mostly be composed of people who are themselves CEO's of companies for which this CEO is a board member...

loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
We were talking in the context of the US where this is absolutely not the case. In the UK the wealth inequality would be less of a big deal than in the US precisely because the UK takes better care of it's poor (with the unfortunate abuse that comes with that).

pg's comments about wealth are correct: me going out and creating something that makes me a billion dollars doesn't take anything away from anyone. But this is provided I'm a one man show and have no team. As soon as it's not "me" but a company, then me having enormous compensation very much does take away from others. The more money I take out of the pot, the less there is for workers, new positions, etc. It wasn't so long ago that top CEO's were making 70k/yr. :)

loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
Except we've had capitalism for thousands of years now and the majority of people who seem to have those large aspirations are psychopaths who want to rule the world (or at least the ones who manage to achieve really large scale success of their goals).

I also think "due to capitalism solving most of our problem" is a bit of a stretch. It's solving most of the problems of the rich people of the west but I bet the world's hungry don't find it so grand. Especially since there is plenty of food to feed them. There's just no money in doing so.

loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
I'm just saying loafers isn't a deal breaker. Past societies dealt with it by not allowing it. If we ever realize a future utopia we could probably live with a small percentage of the population spending their whole life doing nothing but gaming. But it is my strong (completely unprovable without actually trying it) suspicion that many people who game their lives away actually would rather be doing something else (e.g. working in a space station), they just don't feel they have the option.
loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
Lots of reasons. You could watch the movie "Reds" with Warren Beatty. It's just a movie, but it should be a good jumping off place to see what parts to investigate.

For example, I'm sure sanctions from the rest of the world [1] from the beginning didn't do them any favors. Having a wolf in with the hens (named Stalin) was also unfortunate.

[1] All terrified that revolution would kick off in their countries. Justified fear as well, it did just that in Spain.

loewenskind··on And suddenly, you're hip
>CPAN increases dramatically with every addition

Demonstrably nonsense. Let me add a new module called ACME::DoNothing. What have I increased besides disk space and a meaningless module count?

loewenskind··on Obama administration moves forward with unique Internet ID for all Americans
Irrelevant. Look at any standard of living study. They'll all have most of western Europe above the US for the average person. Most western European countries have more incoming migration than they are comfortable with.

I also think you'll find that migration pressure to the US has started to slow. You may still have a large amount from Mexico but that is about opportunity, not a testament of the US being the place to be.

loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
>Consumption isn't useful to society.

That seems absurd on it's face. If there is no one to consumer what exactly are the producers selling?

>A developer (potentially earning $200k/year) who builds an application can be hundreds or thousands of times more productive than a secretary (potentially earning $20k/year).

Exactly. Surely you're not under the impression that programmers are in the top 1%? Maybe one or two of them but the post I commented on contended that the most productive people are the most wealthy. Nothing could be further from the truth.

>The same applies to a manager who streamlines a production process

If you find a CEO who actually does this (has to be CEO to break the top 1% who are apparently so much more productive than anyone else). I've seen many CEOs ruin things in my career and I've seen many be nearly irrelevant but I can only think of a couple of CEOs who actually made a huge and obvious difference to their company (e.g. Steve Jobs).

loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
Neither of these are examples of capitalism.
loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
Maybe that high school dropout is wasting his life away because he sees no means of being successful.

I think you'll find that most people who prefer to stay at home and mooch off the system do so because to make their life just slightly better would require them to seriously bust their asses. That means their effective compensation would be very low (maybe zero or even negative in some cases).

We have and have had societies in the past where everyone got equal compensation. Do you think those societies allowed loafers to goof off all day and contribute nothing?

loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
That's pretty short term and pessimistic thinking. If you no longer had the burden of providing for yourself and your family would you seriously not do anything productive? Do you seriously not have any projects or things you would love to work on but never will because you can't easily get paid to do so?

Further, capitalism can't possibly be the solution to every problem. For example, capitalism will probably never take us "to the stars". There isn't enough money in it to cover such a massive expense. But yet, going to the stars is the only possible way to defend against the thread of a "planet killer" meteor/asteroid. The only time there would be money in it is when we knew such an event was imminent but by then it would be too late.

loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
Ugh. The reasons Russia's communism failed is an incredibly complicated and still debated subject. Throwing it all to "people's inherent desire to be better than others or to excel" is completely wrong.
loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
>Capitalism, and the income inequality it causes, has proven itself time and again as the most efficient organizing principle to create wealth.

Bizarre statement. Compared to what? Primitive cultures that didn't have money? At what do you mean by "wealth"? Fiat currency (in which case Mugabe has been the most successful)? Accumulated toys and gadgets?

Because if you're talking about anything else you're talking about capitalist countries. Sweden is capitalist, as in Denmark (despite both having over 50% tax rates). Hell, so is "communist" China.

The question is just how much regulation they use and where, but make no mistake: they are all capitalist systems.

loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
But what is the point of such a line of discussion? If there are no consequences then of course no one would care. The whole reason such a thing is discussed is because there are indeed very real consequences.
loewenskind··on Inequality in Equalland
Good lord, how did a post like that get an upvote? It's ignorant well beyond the point of normally being considered a troll post.

>The fact is the majority of people aren't successful or really very useful to society.

That's an insanely arrogant thing to say, not to mention complete garbage. The only reason we even have a society at all is because of that majority you dismiss. They are the ones who spend the money, do the mundane jobs that the top 1% can't be bothered to and so on.

>The top 1% of society do most of the work, so they get most of the reward. That's pretty fair IMHO.

Wtf? Citations? Actually I'm not sure what kind of citation could possibly be provided to demonstrate such a statement was anything but full retard. How do you define "work"? Obviously not manual labor. I will venture a guess that you must be talking about CEO's, but there is no metric you could name that you can't find people lower on the food chain who outwork any CEO on.

>Human motivation requires that success be rewarded.

More Rush Limbaugh-esque nonsense. Rewards take many different forms. A college professor might take reward in the results of his research, even though he'll never be compensated like e.g. Larry Ellison who some would qualify as a blot on the IT industry.

loewenskind··on Obama administration moves forward with unique Internet ID for all Americans
I think what he is suggesting is making a new Internet. Long term this will have to be done at some point. We will have to create a peer-to-peer based net that is not connected (or at least doesn't rely on) the current one.
loewenskind··on Obama administration moves forward with unique Internet ID for all Americans
>And, as bad as the US is on an absolute scale, I'm having trouble finding some place better.

Then you're either putting impossible requirements on the new place (e.g. "and my friends have to all live there") or you're simply not looking. Throw a dart at western Europe. Any of those places will provide a better quality of living for most people.

loewenskind··on Obama administration moves forward with unique Internet ID for all Americans
I'm pretty sure our children will be talking about how pg was thoroughly proven wrong in this. What percentage of americans go to college? pg's quote seems to assume most will but I suspect it's the exact opposite. This means you are getting a small percentage of "late bloomers" and a lot of people who's only education was appallingly bad. Your late bloomers aren't going to do you much good when the majority of all people who vote are ignorant.
loewenskind··on And suddenly, you're hip
>Though it's really no fair comparison as CPAN contains what.. 89033 modules?

Why do people keep trotting out this stupid pointless number. How much of that is duplication? How much of it is crap? How much of it is literally toys (e.g. ACME stuff)? In any case, Java has vastly, vastly more so any language that runs on the JVM automatically beats perl here.

99% of programmers will never notice any functionality missing in Ruby or Python that CPAN has.

loewenskind··on Mark Zuckerberg Named TIME’s 2010 Person of the Year
Can we stop throwing around terms like "conspiracy theory" in an attempt to kill discussion?
loewenskind··on Version control for solo Mac developers
>You forgot the piece that SVN integrates with IDEs. This is it, case closed.

IDE integration makes more sense with file focused systems like ClearCase. With "whole picture" focused systems like SVN, Git, etc., the value of IDE integration is less because you check in whole change sets at once. The only IDE I've ever seen that dealt with this reasonably well was Smalltalk.

>They want IDE integration, they won't use branches or any other features (some won't even know what the hell "branches" are), they will only use version control as a means to have a centralize repository for the code.

DVCS can do exactly this. Set up a hook so that e.g. Git pushes to a central repo on commit. You don't need to teach them about branches or any of that, just give them something simple.

By doing just this much you get automatic local "backups" of the repo and you get vastly better protection against corruption and tampering.

>And they use Windows.

No problem. Mercurial, for example, supports windows very well. Including a Tortoise interface that is (IMO) better than what SVN provides.

>SVN solves the problem. It's either SVN or something worse (CVS and SourceSafe are still widely used).

That may have been true 5 years ago but it just isn't today.

>Version control is a tool. You have a set of requirements and you choose the tool based on those requirements. There is no such thing as "obsolete".

This is a pretty ridiculous statement. Of course there is a such thing as "obsolete". When an alternative comes along that does everything its predecessor did, better and even with extra features on top of that then it has fully obsoleted said predecessor. This happens all the time in software. SVN fully obsoleted CVS. C fully obsoleted B. On and on.

loewenskind··on Version control for solo Mac developers
Which GitX fork or which Git fork? I didn't realize either of them had forked.
loewenskind··on Version control for solo Mac developers
>- windows support is still far from brilliant for git

It's not that bad, certainly not much worse than SVN itself on windows.

>- even a non-technical user can understand and use tortoisesvn in 2 hours

2 hours? A non-technical person can understand everything about e.g. Git that they're likely to need in less than that.

>- SVN revisions are really easy to understand

Not sure what you mean here. 1783. Is that somehow easier to understand than an equally meaningless hash key? At least in Git you could describe the version by the checkin text.

>but most of my non-technical clients are on svn

I think you're really doing them a disservice with this. As soon as they have any kind of accidental corruption I think you're going to be sorely missing Git's recovery capabilities and ability to mathmatically prove you're working with the version you think you're working with.

loewenskind··on Version control for solo Mac developers
>Hey, at least they're using something.

Bad attitude in my opinion. At some point they will have to do a costly and complicated migration to a modern system, and that could have been completely avoided by simply using a modern system to begin with.

>There's no need to waste time on a religious war within the church of version control, when there are non-believers who must be shown the light.

The only religious behavior I see here is claiming that a two systems are equivalent when they clearly are not.

loewenskind··on Version control for solo Mac developers
>Just because there are better alternatives now for distributed version control, doesn't mean that the centralized approach has suddenly stopped working.

Except that a distributed RCS can do everything a centralized on can. The funny thing is, this is the last argument used by people religious about SVN but even this doesn't stand up. SVN isn't even particularly good at doing centralized revision control. Do you work somewhere that you'll have to be able to prove what was in a given release? SVN can't do that since you can rewrite history with no way of detecting the rewrite. If this is not acceptable you'll have to buy Fisheye.

SVN on it's own isn't useful for much of anything. It's only after applying several other commercial products that you finally get something only substandard.

loewenskind··on I Miss Lisp
I wish they would fix this in SBCL. The stepper is such a pain to set up and use. Smalltalk has really spoilt me in this regard.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →