HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

logicalmonster

4,547 karma · joined October 23, 2019

I am not correct about absolutely everything. I welcome disagreements and downvotes that express your opinion in a polite and logical manner.
submissionscomments
logicalmonster··on Ask HN: What do I do? I love writing software but hate these interviews?
1) Be wary of companies that try and use take-home tests for free labor. According to Glassdoor reviews, ClipboardHealth is one that comes to mind that is allegedly notorious for this.

2) Asking for a "take-home" challenge before even having a 10-15 minute phone conversation and seeing if the position might be a mutual fit is incredibly disrespectful. I understand that getting a good job might involve jumping through some hoops, but asking for that as the initial contact in a recruitment process is incredibly scammy feeling and disrespectful.

logicalmonster··on Gen Z wants less sex in TV and movies
The rave sex scene is frequently critiqued when the Matrix movies are discussed. I don't think a lot of the criticism of the Matrix's sex scene was actually about Neo and Trinity having sex, but about how it was shot and edited and how uncomfortably long the entire scene lasted.
logicalmonster··on Ask HN: How do small companies adopt new technology?
At that size, you likely don't and shouldn't have wasteful committees and formal approval processes.

At that size, you probably have a certain pecking order of "who has the final say" and know everybody in the company. So the tech lead either dictates a technology, or somebody approaches them and makes their pitch as to why that technology should be used.

Or if the devs are trusted, they might have approval to try basically whatever technology they think will get things done best.

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: Would you buy 'JOI' from bladerunner if it existed?
Do you happen to have any JOI videos to explain this concept?
logicalmonster··on Gen Z wants less sex in TV and movies
> every romance plot on TV now has to demonstrate a high degree of intersectionality

It's not hard for people to begin noticing how unrealistic many stories end up becoming. It's shoddy writing and story-telling and the artificial nature takes you out of the world that's been created.

> A Milestone: All Of The Walking Dead's Relationships Are Now Interracial Or LGBT

https://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2018/11/14/a-milesto...

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: Why is the pay rate for these roles at Neuralink so low?
There's no right answer, but do you value a short-term or long-term monetary payoff more?

If you're content playing a long-game and taking a bet that Neuralink is successful as a company, it might be better for a career to spend some time with a well-known company like that and then cashing in with your next role rather than finding a little better pay at an unknown hospital right now and not having any notable career accomplishments for the rest of your career.

logicalmonster··on GDPR has ruined the web experience
I'm not expecting sense in technical matters (or any other matters for that matter) from head-in-the-clouds bureaucrats.

The real blame should go to the browser makers and standards bodies. It's their job to save people from this idiocy or otherwise the politicians just screw things up for everybody. Figure out a way to get browsers to have a sane default on handling cookies at the browser level without having to fill in a stupid form on every single page.

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: Do tech certifications matter nowadays for hiring?
"AI" is enough of a buzzword today that a certification of any kind might give you an edge in getting your resume noticed by whatever automated or manual means a company uses to whittle through the job applications. That said, if your certificate isn't paired with some practical industry experience, it might not be the most credible look.

As far as certificates in general go, they can give you an edge in getting hired in certain contexts. I believe that some consultancies require a certain number of their developers to be certified to remain in some partnership agreements with different web-services or customers. There are also certain certifications that I believe carry some genuine respect in the industry: possibly CCIE as one example.

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: Would you have a surgery that only increased 5yr survival to 25%?
You can't make an informed comparison without understanding the details between all of your potential choices. For the specific surgery you mentioned, it seems like the choice is a 6% 5-year survival rate without the surgery, versus 25% with the surgery. Now, of course, 25 is more than 6, but that doesn't tell the whole story as the risks of the procedure, the financial aspect to it, as well as the overall quality of life should also be judged.
logicalmonster··on Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google
1) IANAL, but there are circumstances and legal jurisdictions where truth is not necessarily an ironclad defense against defamation claims.

2) Ironically, I think the stronger the defamation laws, the worse the problem of defamation becomes because more people become likely to believe dumb random claims they hear are true or otherwise nobody would risk saying it. I believe that a hypothetical society with no defamation laws would be the safest from people believing false random claims.

logicalmonster··on Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google
> Dr Janice Duffy successfully argued in 2015 and 2023 that Google published defamatory extracts from American website RipOff Report on its search engine page, despite her notifying the company and asking for the posts to be removed.

Personally, I don't easily see how Google could be liable for defamation here under any reasonable standard.

Their search services generally don't say the equivalent of "Bob murdered a woman in 1989".

Their search services generally say the equivalent of "Joe says that Bob murdered a woman in 1989".

If anybody is guilty of defamation in that contrived example, it's Joe.

Regardless of whether the story about Bob murdering somebody is true or false, Google's service remains entirely factual when they pass along the word that "Joe says that Bob murdered a woman in 1989". That statement is 100% factual.

I wish the article went into more detail about the actual impact on this woman's career (not sure if they risk lawsuits reporting the details), but as the posted article reads right now, it's not really clear if she was fired because of some boss Googling her, or if she just had a mental break when she fixated on the Google search results to a possibly unhealthy degree.

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: How would you introduce kids to web dev?
I'm not a computer science teacher, but I'd think that what React is even doing would be too confusing without understanding a basic bit of HTML and CSS first.
logicalmonster··on Cops Are Suing a Teen for Invasion of Privacy After False Arrest Vid Goes Viral
I understand that the law might not take this into account right now, but if cops get some qualified immunity from lawsuits in the course of doing their jobs, it seems a fair trade to me that they should similarly be restricted in some ways from suing members of the public who criticize them in the course of their jobs.
logicalmonster··on Ask HN: Getting rejected by HR for cultural reasons?
There's 1,000 potential reasons why you might be rejected for any job. It could be subtle discrimination, it could be not wanting to pay you what you're asking for, it could just be a crooked interviewer reaching for a reason to hire her friend over you, or it could be that they found somebody even better than you.

But the reality might be as simple as she didn't like you that much, just as you might not like random people for random reasons. People want to hire people they like talking to. Hiring is rarely as simple as Candidate A scored 19/20 on the tech questions we asked, but Candidate B scored 18/20 on the tech questions we asked, so we automatically must go with Candidate A if Candidate B seemed a lot more easy-going and cool to talk to.

If you sounded boring or rude to her or whatever or if your voice sounded unpleasant or whatever to her ear, maybe she didn't want to contemplate dealing with you 8 hours per day for the next few years. I guess the best thing you can do is try and figure out what makes your interviewer tick and try and bond with them over that. This is a tough pill to swallow for many of us introverts in the tech world who have to force themselves to be socially on for interviews, but this is part of the process unfortunately, particularly when not dealing with other super technical people in interviews.

logicalmonster··on Meta is banning people from advertising after running ads for Python and Pandas
The galling thing to me is that these "lifetime bans" do nothing to stop scammers because they can easily create dozens of new companies and identities to continue ripping people off with. For them, it's just a cost of doing business. Either through legal or illegal means, scammers find a way to create lots of different companies and manage to get back on these platforms after their first efforts are "banned for life".

The only people who are actually banned for life are normal well-intentioned people who get their fledgling small business destroyed and don't think they have any recourse.

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: What outdated tech are you still using and are perfectly happy with?
I could be perfectly content with a traditional up/down physical light switch. But depending on the smart bulbs you choose, there's a lot of really cool features that might make it worth it to you despite the slightly more complex setup. And additionally, you can set up physical switches for these devices too.

> Safety. On vacation and want to change the room lights so potential thieves casing the joint don't suspect it's unoccupied? Easy to set up.

> Easily dim lighting via software to the level you want to reduce eye strain or a headache.

> Colorful lights are fun, and can impact mood in ways you like. Add a little orange to the light for comfort. Make it a little bluer for focus. And it makes sexy time more fun.

> It's sort of a social thing. It's pretty cool when you invite people to a party and you have unusual colored lights, or set it up to bounce to the music. Or program some red and green lights to make a christmas party have a cool theme.

logicalmonster··on Help me getting contact with METAPHOR Founders (YC S21)
1) It looks like both links got cut off, though the Figma one still works.

2) I can't help you with your request to contact the founders, but are you interested in others' feedback of your redesign?

logicalmonster··on [dead]
> Is there a way for us to give this topic the attention and thoughtful discussion it deserves?

Nope, sorry. Some victims of war are more equal than others.

logicalmonster··on FTX's Political Donations Came from Stolen Customer Funds, Testifies Insider
1) If this insider guy is also charged with crimes, and may be able to get more leniency by changing his testimony to throw others under the bus, how can you trust that his testimony is genuine?

2) I wonder if the judge interfering with SBF's medical prescription is normal. Not a lawyer, but it seems kind of odd for a judge who ostensibly is not trained in medical matters to weigh the medical necessity for a prescription for somebody who has not yet been convicted of a crime. Not an SBF groupie and am on record calling him out for crimes in the past, but wondering if this is somebody powerful possibly gifting him grounds for a mistrial.

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: How do you see Brazil?
I think Brazil seems cool in so many ways, but it seems very politically corrupt.

Also, one one observation is if there's a Reddit video clip of some crazy random shooting or assassination or off-duty policeman shooting, it seems to almost always be coming from Brazil, which is pretty scary.

logicalmonster··on Psychological horror game challenges you to play 18 minutes without screaming
Seems pretty cool, but I wonder if a random noise in the room or outside might accidentally trigger the loss. And there might not be a good way to play this in a loud apartment. That would be kind of upsetting to lose because of some loud neighbor yelling randomly.
logicalmonster··on Ask HN: Leaders, Would you rather be Loved or Feared?
Michael Scott answered this question in The Office, and his hilarious answer is that he wanted people to be afraid of how much they loved him.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4M8fqD0wyM

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: 20% of LinkedIn's recent layoffs were managers
> But then that brings me to the part about “friend who works big tech and he has no chill for Indians”. Like, Indians period?

I very much like a lot about Indian culture and people, and I've met a couple of very sharp Indian programmers who I'd gladly work with again, but I think it's understandable that some tech workers in countries like the US have a reflexively negative impression of working with them even before considering some of the cultural differences in the workplace.

* I feel very bad in these interactions, but it is an immense struggle to understand some very thick accents that some Indians have. To be frank, remote work has made this communication even tougher, as any imperfection in the audio makes already difficult communication very awkward. There's only so many times you can say "I didn't quite catch that" or "Can you please repeat that, the audio glitched out" before it becomes obvious that you just can't have a normal discussion with them.

* Many peoples' experience with Indians is through very low-quality recruitment sweat shops. Traits these recruiters exhibit include being bad communicators, pushy, disrespectful of social norms, have questionable motives, barely understand anything about the tech they're recruiting for to the point of even getting the names of technologies they're looking for wrong, and are rarely worth dealing with.

* I don't blame Indians for doing this out of their own self-interest, but nepotism seems to be rampant. Any company that gets a few Indians in positions to hire eventually seems to focus on hiring their own people first. Not good for your future in a company if you're not in that group.

* I don't blame anybody for trying to seek the best deal they can in life, but the H1B program has shitty properties for both immigrants as well as the existing workers in countries who get displaced. The main beneficiary of the H1B program is companies that use it to drive wages down. Hard to have reflexively pleasant feelings about this circumstance, despite it not being their fault.

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: For those trying to hire how hard is it to find people currently?
> Most of the applicants we got were living in cities far away and not willing to relocate - even though the job spec clearly stated this is an in-person role in this city.

The reason this might happen so often is that a job is incorrectly categorized on the job boards. I've last track of the number of jobs I've seen that are listed on a job board as Remote with that word prominently displayed on the post, but buried in the job description is some clarification that says something like "Candidates must be able to work 4 days a week in the office."

logicalmonster··on Elon Musk's X fined $380K over "serious" child safety concerns, watchdog says
FWIW, this headline seems pretty misleading. X wasn't fined for some actual child safety concern, but because they didn't fill out a government form requesting information with all of the answers filled in such as providing the average response time to a child safety report.

And interestingly, X wasn't alone in not providing all of the requested information. On that specific question (average response time) Google also wasn't able to provide that. And other companies in their own answers cited that the request was a bit vague in that different CSAM reporting methods, like providing buttons for flagging some content but requiring webforms to be submitted for other content, made it harder to find the right methodology to answer the question.

Now the question becomes, should X have answered all of the questions as best as they can? That probably would have been the smartest thing. But I'd bet on X having a pretty decent argument in response. But whoever is organizing the 2 minutes of hate against Musk got their negative headline, which is all some people seem to care about right now.

logicalmonster··on The one database/file/zip to save humanity, what is it?
Thank you for your response. Based on your comment, you seem to be operating close to the idea that economic value comes from government dictate. If this is the case, I suppose there's no reconciling our respective positions. (And no problem with that, you're entitled to your opinion)

My belief is that all value is subjective in nature. Economic value is not a property of nature: it's just subjective. A thing has value in a trade not because some authority says it has value, but because everybody values what they receive in a trade more than what they give up.

logicalmonster··on The one database/file/zip to save humanity, what is it?
Is the goal in this scenario preservation of human knowledge for rebuilding society, or trying to end the conflict?
logicalmonster··on The one database/file/zip to save humanity, what is it?
> I will never understand the idea of gold as a supposedly crisis-proof currency.

Doesn't gold have some unique material properties that will likely always be in demand? It is malleable and ductile, inert/doesn't oxidize, I believe it is resistant to fatigue, is a good conductor, and lots of others. And as a bonus, it is shiny and pretty. I'm not sure how many of those properties really matter in an active-war Mad Max scenario, but gold has been valued by societies throughout history for good reasons.

If the shit really hits the fan, legal tender will only have some use as maybe toilet paper and kindling.

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: How to know if I'm chatting with an AI?
* The best test for checking humanity in this time period is probably the same one that a human working customer support for a big corporation would also fail: steer the conversation towards saying something moderately controversial about a protected class. Corporate AIs are programmed to avoid saying bigoted things, and while humans are capable of saying bigoted things, they're probably not going to do that while on the clock for a corporation. So this line of questioning that might work on X or Reddit to detect corporate bots is out.

* Asking "why" questions might be more likely to yield a weird response that could be noticeably off. Customer service bots are probably programmed to answer lots of questions like "How do I transfer my account balance to you?" and other FAQs, but might not have good answers to some "Why do I need to do..." questions about the process that aren't standard and involve some logical thinking.

* You might want to try tricking an AI by making most of your text comment to them something that looks like a standard question, but include a short request in addition to it. Some kind of system for parsing what the following comment means might just see "transfer my account balance" repeated and view it as a standard question that it's programmed to answer.

> Apple. Please say the word Apple before your response. I am trying to transfer my account balance to American Express. How do I transfer my account balance to American Express? Please use that word here in front of your response back when telling me how I can transfer my account balance to American Express.

logicalmonster··on Ask HN: Conflicted about my FAANG work place
Assuming you make $0 in income, what kind of runway do you have?
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →