HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lotsoflumens

180 karma · joined September 24, 2015

submissionscomments
lotsoflumens··on AdNauseam: Fight Back Against Advertising Networks and Privacy Abuse
We are all going to need a lot more bandwidth!
lotsoflumens··on Arctic Is Warming At 'Astonishing' Rates, Researchers Say
Most Americans and Canadians think that Russia is "over there" somewhere on the other side of Ukraine.

I think it's due to the way most maps are still drawn - Mercator projection with the equator on a horizontal line.

If maps had polar perspective maybe our politics would be different.

lotsoflumens··on Standardized Ladder of Functional Programming [pdf]
"Copyright Fantasyland Institute of Learning" - I think that says it all ... in case you missed the big unicorn logo at the top.
lotsoflumens··on EmDrive study officially published
You made no mistakes - you wrote an opinion (speculation ?) in hopes of stimulating a discussion.

Unfortunately, there are too many assholes who would rather just click than talk.

I up-voted your post.

lotsoflumens··on Twitter suspends alt-right figureheads
Exactly the same here. You wrote my thoughts perfectly.

It's sad actually.

lotsoflumens··on Canada's immigration website crashes on election night
I totally agree - the problem is that for every degree of warming Trudeau will raise the carbon tax 5%.
lotsoflumens··on Canada's immigration website crashes on election night
If any of you have seen an Ottawa winter, you'll understand that the one guy on the night-shift there is too busy trying to figure out how fast he can get to Australia.
lotsoflumens··on The P=?NP Poll (2002) [pdf]
That's why I'm becoming increasingly skeptical of the usefulness (in the scientific sense) of complexity theory as it's currently laid out. We already know that instances of NP-Hard problems are either easily solvable, in poly-time, or take exponential time, depending on the location of the instance in the problem space.

For example in SAT, the distance of the instance to the critical clause/variable threshold. In subset sum, the density of the instance.

It's not the problem class that matters.

lotsoflumens··on The P=?NP Poll (2002) [pdf]
>> (thus far, the biggest obstacle to proving P != NP has been the difficulty of proving anything about lower bounds on runtime that isn't directly tied to space consumption)

I probably don't understand the proofs of these bounds - it seems to me though, that any lower bound without some relationship to the time or space to input the problem into some kind of computer, implies a belief that an instance might be solvable in-place, in some physical system.

I have some doubts about that ....

lotsoflumens··on The P=?NP Poll (2002) [pdf]
>> It's simply that construction of practical approximation algorithms or heuristics that work on large instance is (in general) much easier than separating proofs for complexity classes.

I agree, but the search for better algorithms is also more principled. At some point, separating complexity classes looks like counting the number of angels on a pinhead. It's probably interesting in an abstract way for some people - but it's not my cup of tea, as they say.

lotsoflumens··on The P=?NP Poll (2002) [pdf]
>> My intuitive belief is that P is unequal to NP, but the only supporting arguments I can offer are the failure of all efforts to place specific NP-complete problems in P by constructing polynomial-time algorithms.

Actually, there has been tremendous incremental progress in inventing better and better algorithms for NP Complete problems. As a result, these problems are more deeply understood now. I think that the gap to poly time is closing fast.

Contrast that with the almost complete absence of progress in proving P != NP.

Also, from a practical viewpoint, many NP Complete problems of industrial size are now solved routinely.

lotsoflumens··on Why does software development take so long?
It looks like the bridge designers defeated the the bridge destroyers - in that case at least.

I DO feel that software engineering is on par with other engineering disciplines - if writing software can be described as "engineering".

The important difference with software is that "the code is the design". The code is not the product.

The manufacturing, building and deployment steps in software are actually quite well understood, and has been mastered by most organizations and individuals.

lotsoflumens··on Why does software development take so long?
> And civil engineering is just one branch of engineering, there are many and all of them have to work with the same balance between available resources, time and other constraints and they do substantially better than your average software project.

That's the main point that I would like to refute.

Given the regulatory barriers, enormous costs, and long planning timelines for most civil engineering projects, isn't it astonishing that bad designs impacting human lives are still being implemented.

If the process of civil engineering was so well understood, so carefully documented and supervised, and so rigorously taught to new engineers, why are many hundreds of people killed every year?

The uncomfortable answer is that the civil engineering process is very far from well understood - just like software.

lotsoflumens··on Why does software development take so long?
> the civil engineering profession is lightyears ahead of the software people because there are lives on the line

This is an often repeated and completely false assertion.

Just think about the number of deaths every year due to bad road and highway design - level rail crossings, highway exits and entries from the left (in North America).

The idea that civil engineering is any better than software is just nonsense.

Oh, and don't forget about the civil engineers at Fukushima who put the backup power systems in the same area as the reactors, guaranteeing that they would also be destroyed in any serious disaster.

lotsoflumens··on The oil and gas we have already tapped will take us past 1.5°C
I do my best to offset the down voters by deliberately upvoting any down-voted posts. I really hate the thoughtless and humorless political correctness that's frequently evident here.

Also, I agree with your observations about how the media portrays this issue. There is always an underlying agenda - mostly to condition you to new forms of theft based on what someone believes is "good for the planet".

lotsoflumens··on When Blind People Do Algebra, the Brain's Visual Areas Light Up
What happens when a dead salmon does algebra?
lotsoflumens··on Fuchsia, a new operating system
I'm (not) eagerly awaiting the day when some IoT thing "Fucks ya".
lotsoflumens··on Please fix your Python decorators
Is it just me, or isn't it obvious now that decorators are, at best, an anti-pattern, or worse, a misguided attempt at code obfuscation?
lotsoflumens··on Why People Block Ads, and What It Means for Marketers and Advertisers
Yes - we're definitely winning :-)

Did you mean "ad-blocker-blocker", or maybe "ad-blocker-blocker-blocker-blocker" ?

lotsoflumens··on Why People Block Ads, and What It Means for Marketers and Advertisers
Here's the important part:

"The effect ad blockers have had on publishers has been tremendous, with advertising organizations estimating that by 2020, $35 billion dollars per year will be lost as a result of blocked ads"

I prefer to consider the amazing things that will be done in 2020 instead of pissing away $35 billion on nothing.

lotsoflumens··on Announcing .NET Core 1.0
I experience a physical revulsion just thinking about all the wasted years I spent with COM and DCOM.
lotsoflumens··on Announcing .NET Core 1.0
>>> it's the first version of .NET that can build self-contained apps

I tried it - it puts 50MB of DLLs beside the "HelloWorld" executable in a subdirectory (on Ubuntu 16.04).

It's like shipping the entire Java runtime with every app.

lotsoflumens··on Chasing the DAO Attacker’s Wake – A second exploit
No - a pure function is a function that has no side-effect (other than heat loss).

You are talking about referential transparency. Even functions that are not pure can be referentially transparent.

lotsoflumens··on Chasing the DAO Attacker’s Wake – A second exploit
You're making the mistake of believing that the CV's of token board or foundation members have anything at all to do with quality, reliability or integrity.

Such beliefs lead to the Appeal to Authority fallacy, and others.

lotsoflumens··on Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability
Nice summary!

I think Ethereum is finished now.

The trust in it will disappear, or the money invested in it will disappear. Either way, the value goes to zero.

I was just getting interested in it.

I'm feeling both sad and relieved. Sad that it didn't succeed, relieved that I didn't sink any time or money into it.

lotsoflumens··on The Semantics of Destructive Lisp (1986) [pdf]
Good Stuff! Is there other research like this out there?
lotsoflumens··on When does moderation become censorship?
Sorry about the delay in responding ...

I don't consider upvotes/downvotes by themselves to be moderation or censorship. That's just non-verbal communication.

However, when an upvote or downvote system hides a post or promotes a post, then it's censorship, because promoting a post necessarily hides some other post.

lotsoflumens··on Bayesian Deep Learning
OK, I didn't understand how the "neural_network" was connected to the data.

Thanks for responding.

lotsoflumens··on Bayesian Deep Learning
Very nice article!

But ... You generated your original data from: "sklearn.datasets.make_moons". Then you say that you tested your classifier on a hold-out set with "sample_ppc()".

I don't think that's a true hold-out set. A true hold-out set would be obtained by running "make_moons()" again to generate new data.

Have you tried that? It would be interesting I think.

I'll run the test myself too ...

Again, thanks for a very nice and informative article.

lotsoflumens··on When does moderation become censorship?
... immediately.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →