HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lotsoflumens

180 karma · joined September 24, 2015

submissionscomments
lotsoflumens··on Rock Garden programming: Programming in the physical world (2014) [pdf]
It's not April 1 - at least on planet earth. So, WTF?
lotsoflumens··on Ad Blockers Will Change How Ads Are Sold
Thanks, I didn't know about uBlock Origin.
lotsoflumens··on Ad Blockers Will Change How Ads Are Sold
I think it's a lot worse. Once you take yourself out of the cesspool (I cut the TV cable 4 years ago), and start really being careful about your exposure to worst of it, the impact of the few that manage to get past your defenses is magnified.
lotsoflumens··on Ad Blockers Will Change How Ads Are Sold
I use AdBlock, Ghostery, Disconnect and Privacy Badger. If you're not using any, I would recommend starting with AdBlock or Disconnect.
lotsoflumens··on Ad Blockers Will Change How Ads Are Sold
Yes, I think that's true. I certainly won't remove a single ad blocker - I currently browse with 4 blockers installed (LoL). Whatever one of them doesn't block, another one usually will.

I've previously advocated for a different kind of reform. I want advertisers to start paying web users directly. Then web users can reward publishers with their traffic. It's not a perfect solution because it probably means that web users will still see advertising, but at least they would be somewhat compensated for it.

lotsoflumens··on Ad Blockers Will Change How Ads Are Sold
That's interesting. I haven't seen the film, but that is prescient.
lotsoflumens··on Ad Blockers Will Change How Ads Are Sold
They are still in the denial and fight-back stages. He says: "The study should also confirm that people who are ideologically opposed to advertising are a minority compared to the ones who have installed an ad blocker simply because digital promotions and tracking have become unbearable".

This shows that they still don't see the big picture - that it's not just in digital media that ads have completely crossed the line, it's everywhere, from TV, radio and print, to billboards, jumbo-trons and corporate names on structures and landmarks. They are still clinging to the idea that they can go back to good times if they just reform some of their practices.

This is the end result of one group (publishers) relying on a revenue stream (advertisers) that destroys their own service and credibility. They still don't understand this.

lotsoflumens··on Show HN: Proxyblock – an interactive content-blocking proxy written in golang
Fantastic work! What's the license?
lotsoflumens··on Adblockers: The Only Way Out
>>At this point, if you want me to attend to ads, you will have to pay me, directly. I will open one end of a channel that leads to me. If the cash stops coming through, I'll close it. If the cash that comes through is insufficient to compensate for the peace of mind I would otherwise have by closing it, I'll close it.

+1000 This is the same conclusion that I've reached. Advertisers must pay us. There is no way that the free-ride that advertisers have been getting is going to continue. We control what enters our minds, not advertising companies. If they want to pitch products or services to us then they can pay for "qualified leads" : those people who explicitly allow them to advertise by first being paid.

We have the means to enable this (even somewhat anonymously) with bitcoin. Once the advertisers get over the initial disconnect with their current system, they (at least the enlightened ones) will understand that this helps them too. Instead of desperately hoping that someone out of millions will carefully consider their message, they can get a much higher response by advertising to the people who are more likely to be receptive.

lotsoflumens··on Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads
I understand your frustration! Everyone wants to believe that what they create has value and that people should pay something to enjoy it.

But we can't escape the reality that the world is being changed dramatically by technology and that the concept of "cost gravity" is unstoppable. Pieter Hintjens has a very good essay on this at http://cultureandempire.com

This is what we're seeing with adblocking - the technology to control which information is allowed to enter our brains is now available to everyone. Your brain is your most valuable organ, and it is highly susceptible to persuasion and influence through positive and negative images, greed, fear and jealousy. All of these can be, and are, manipulated by advertisers for their benefit.

It has always been an arms race. In the "good old days", when everyone watched TV in the evening with their family, advertising was probably necessary to support the content. Then after a few years the ads got louder (the volume was actually increased) so that people would pay attention during the commercial breaks. People discovered that their remote controls had a mute button, and then they had some welcome silence between movie episodes. Commercial breaks started to get longer and people discovered that they could record everything and fast-forward through the commercial breaks, saving much valuable time. A president of the MPAA (Jack Valenti I think) actually said that it should be illegal to skip through the advertising when viewing time-shifted video because that deprived the broadcaster of the revenue to which they were entitled.

Even movie theaters, where the assumption was that you could watch the movie since you paid for admission, started to show advertising at the beginning. At first it was just a couple of quick minutes before the feature, but that soon became many more minutes and now is at about 30 minutes (advertising thinly disguised as games and quizzes).

My simple proposal is that this downward spiral can be stopped, if advertisers accept that people want to control what they see and hear in an increasingly noisy world, and that this is both legitimate and necessary.

Regarding your question about why an advertiser should also pay me to watch an ad in addition to a Game of Thrones episode: Because, if they paid me, I would listen to their pitch. That's much more valuable than blindly displaying ads with the hope that 0.1% or less of the ad recipients would pay any attention.

lotsoflumens··on Give Google Contributor a try: Pay to remove ads
There's another way ... it may sound a bit crazy at first, but I think it's the only approach that will work.

* Advertisers must start paying visitors to view their ads *

Not just for clicking on ads, but simply for loading them into your browser and looking at them or listening to them.

I read somewhere yesterday that the ad business is $40 billion/year. None of that money goes to the people who are being abused daily by the onslaught of mental pollution that this "industry" produces.

What should be troubling to all advertisers, is that almost all of this stuff is displayed to people who will never buy their products.

Luckily, we have the mechanisms now to efficiently do this: Bitcoin etc. I foresee a payment system, probably mostly run by Google since they are the most connected to the current system, to mediate between ad-viewers and ad-producers.

There's the problem of detecting bots vs. people, but that already exists.

This system would also be good for website owners (content creators). A website owner would benefit by providing a reason for people to visit, thereby also gaining a percentage of the ad revenue. People visiting a website would be, in a sense, qualified-buyers of the products that could be advertised there, resulting in more targeted ads, perhaps by using the bitcoin addresses and the associated browsing history (something that's also already tracked but without consent).

I think it's the only way out of this mess. I don't have all the details worked out, I'm sure someone out there knows how to make it work.

← PreviousPage 5 of 5