HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lotu

989 karma · joined November 15, 2007

submissionscomments
lotu··on Spotify to Apple: Time to Play Fair
> In my book, the problem is that you are not allowed to provide a link to your payment website inside your app.

The counter point is, if Apple allowed this, then every single App would use that method. Most people would not realize or care that they bought the XYZ in a web view vs through the AppStore payment system. Even apps that are currently paid only would switch to a "free" app with a "pay here" in-app purchase.

At this point the AppStore no longer can bring in any money for Apple except indirectly via encouraging iPhone sales.

Maybe Apple could charge the publisher for each app download or something instead to keep making money but I doubt that would be very popular.

lotu··on Elizabeth Warren Proposes Breaking Up Tech Giants Like Amazon
The problem is this type of vertical splitting doesn't solve the problem of large tech companies. It's like treating a burst appendix with a kidney transplant.

The problem of Amazon is that it is effectively the only online shopping place, and thus can act as a Monopsony in hiring it's workers for warehouses, splitting AWS out of that doesn't fix that problem. Maybe you could require that distribution centers be owned by separate companies. This might work but locally each Center would still be a Monopsony and thus cause the same problem. Maybe if you capped the size of distribution center you could force lots of smaller ones to be built, but at this point I worry that you are going to end up making shipping slower and more expensive.

The problem of Google is they are very dominate in the Ads space splitting out the Ads portion into another company would not solve that. Facebook's problems is everyone has put their data in Facebook has friends in Facebook and feel compelled to keep using it. I don't see how splitting up the company into, Instagram, What's App, and Facebook solves the network effects of those apps.

Splitting up tech companies is not a punishment to make the CEO feel bad or change their ways. It is a technique to change how we need the market works to benefit the large population. As such we need to think about how to split them, the effects, and most importantly if the effect achieves the intended result.

lotu··on Chelsea Manning jailed for contempt of court
Unfortunately, that journalist is being investigated for crimes so that is somewhat inevitable. This also, is the opposite of a journalist going to jail to protect a source, Manning is the source and everyone already knows that.
lotu··on The Stigma of Choosing Trade School over College
Your brain isn't developed (it keeps developing till at least 30) to the point that you are capable of acquiring that expansive world view during those first 12 years. There is a reason we don't trust teenage drivers, and part of college is that transition from being a teenager to being an adult. In high school you are still only seeing people from your neighborhood but people go far away for college where they meet people who are totally not like them.

(Yes, people mature at different rates and some can acquire some of that world view in High School.)

lotu··on Facebook Still Tracks People on Yelp, Duolingo, Indeed
Malware and spyware wasn't generally sophisticated enough to do this type of data collection and targeting. This is a ton of work, as evidenced by the 10s (maybe 100s?) of thousands of engineers employed doing it today.

The data Malware and spyware went after was your credit card number, and bank account & passwords. Which they then used to steal money from you.

No one ever was worried that malware would build a profile of them and sell it to internet advertisers who would send them more relevant ads.

lotu··on Facebook Still Tracks People on Yelp, Duolingo, Indeed
As of Android 6.0 they use the Apple permission model where the app doesn't ask at install time, but at run time and has be able to deal with the permission being denied.
lotu··on Facebook Still Tracks People on Yelp, Duolingo, Indeed
> Simply make "I want to see targeted ads" an opt-in choice, then. I suspect the take-up would be a fairly small percentage of the population, but if it would satisfy your needs (and others like you), then I'm all for it.

This is disingenuous, I suspect that you know why. The reason few people would opt-in is not because few people support or agree with the premise. The reasons is the very act of "opting-in" to a thing is a huge barrier.

If receiving CPR was "opt-in", I would expect 1/3 of the population would just never get around to it or somehow be confused with the process. I bet you even could drive the opt-in rate down to 10% just by requiring a separate paper form that had to be requested and mailed to specific address.

Targeted ads are a method by which lots of people are able to make a bit more money. These aren't exciting changes but it is the difference between lots of people having hobby and making it their job. As most people don't care enough about the privacy of their internet history to take trivial steps like using private browsing windows. Why should the obligation to be on the large number of people who don't care when the small number of people who do care can take trivial steps, like private browsing?

lotu··on First contact made with melted nuclear fuel at Fukushima plant
Nuclear kills less people than Coal mostly from asthma, but coal even causes more cancer because on a normal day it emits far more radiation in the form of small particles of radioactive dust present in coal.

The real danger of Nuclear is it can make land unusable by people for centuries (this actually appears to be good from a biodiversity and ecological heath stand point because people do more damage to that than some radiation). But by contributing to climate change coal has the potential to put far more land under water.

If we had gone for widespread adoption of nuclear power on the scale of Japan climate change would not be a problem like it is today.

lotu··on Amazon destroys millions of unsold products
> A new petition calls for Amazon to donate reusable items to families in need.

So Families in need are going to get 1000 copies of each of 2017 worst books? Or random electrical equipment that only has a specialized use?

lotu··on CCPA Will Hit Dev Teams Harder Than GDPR
People who have been hurt by the fact that synthesized data often doesn't exactly match real data.
lotu··on Google’s also peddling a data collector through Apple’s back door
This is my problem with many "privacy advocates" on the internet. It often feels like the end goal is not, to help consumers, or make it clearer what technology is doing, but to get rid of large tech companies on principle or maybe return the internet to the glory days of the the late 90's and early 00's, or just end consumerism in general. It just so happens that privacy is the most effective path to that goal.
lotu··on Google’s also peddling a data collector through Apple’s back door
It has been pointed out else where in the thread that they do have mics in them. It is possible that Nielsen is only looking for audio from TVs and Phones, but Google also wants general audio for speech recognition. But I'm not sure.
lotu··on After GDPR, The New York Times cut off ad exchanges and kept growing ad revenue
From professional and personal experince, remarketing ads, what you are describing, are much more effective ($ spent / products sold) for the advertiser than traditional ads.

So why do ads follow you even after you bought the product? Well the ads are still less than 1% effective (products sold / by ads shown), so for the average company (not Amazon) it is just not worth the engineering effort for a < 1% savings on your remarketing budget. Secondly, this is more speculation, but for many products the chance of buying a product given you have already bought one (e.x. a spare or a gift) is still higher than chance for a random person. As such the ads are still effective.

So what is the deal with the NYTimes? They a huge popular publisher (especially amount rich people) already command high ad prices through traditional adverstising. The value of a remarking ad (to the advertiser) is largely independent of the site that it is shown on. So The New York Times would naturally have fewer of these ads because the adverstiser gets more ads/$ on other sites. A diffrent site like a local paper might have a diffrent story. However remarketing ads have never been a large percentage of ads shown so from a revenue stand point publishers care a lot less about them.

lotu··on Project Alias hacks Amazon Echo and Google Home to protect privacy
That is correct! Google, Amazon, and Apple despite having vast resources don't have the ability/desire to pay for the bandwidth, storage, and processing needed to have 24/7 recording and analysis from every smart device, especially when you realize that includes cell phones.

Also it is ironic because all modern cellphones have the whole smart speaker thing built into them but people aren't freaking out about that in the same way. (Probably because they haven't realized it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯)

lotu··on Rise and Demise of RSS
Why do you assume RSS is immune to bots? The attacks on the election focused on Twitter and Facebook because they where dominate not because they were uniquely vulnerable.
lotu··on Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers and even hedge funds
I think 'pause' is a better word than 'off'. The reason is that a person is more likely to think that turning 'off' location history deletes the old location history, which it does not. 'Pause' makes this differences clearer to the user who might not be as familiar with technology.
lotu··on Why Doesn't Google Comply with Do Not Track?
Maybe depends on how they though it would play out in the media. Unfortunately the whole opt-in vs. opt-out is too complicated to be explained in most reporting. Google might have worried that not respecting Do Not Track for IE could be interpreted as an Anti-Mircrosft move that would run afoul of monopoly law.
lotu··on Firefox desktop market share now below 9%
Why not setup email forwarding and just wait a few years for people to get the message?
lotu··on An AI Lie Detector Is Going to Start Questioning Travelers in the EU
I don't think GDPR would prevent this I read though it for work before it was implemented I don't recall anything saying algorithms can't make decisions about people. Our company uses algorithms to decide what ad is displayed to people, and I'm not recalling anything that would make these diffrent under the law.

Furthermore, I believe the government has been given broad exceptions from GDPR for anything related to doing government stuff. This is form of legitimate interest "processing is necessary for the performance of a task carried out in the public interest or in the exercise of official authority vested in the controller;" It is in the public interest the border control laws be enforced and a manner that is both effective and minimized cost to the public, also this involves the exercise of official border control authority, therefore this is acceptable.

(Standard reminder that if you are relying on the advice of a stranger for legal issues that matter you should get an attorney.)

lotu··on Ex-Google Employee Urges Lawmakers to Take on Company
When Instagram was bought by Facebook I think it had 13 employees. Would they not of had to comply with GDPR then?
lotu··on Chrome 69 will keep Google Cookies when you tell it to delete all cookies
So this means if you want to clear all your cookies you have to sign out of Google? I really don't see what the big deal is it looks like the button is pretty darn clear about what it does and does not do, perhaps they could include a link to sign out of google as well?
lotu··on Funding Choices – Google’s new tool for GDPR compliance and content monetization
Bandwidth isn’t the main cost of running a website you also have to pay people to make content. Compared to that bandwidth is free.
lotu··on Driverless Hype Collides with Merciless Reality
> How do humans handle edge cases anyways?

30,000 deaths per year suggest that humans fail at these edge cases all the time. Maybe ate their best a human outperforms a machine but as any person who drives if other drivers are at their best.

lotu··on Trump Accuses Google of Burying Conservative News in Search Results
It is called understanding context. This isn’t a thread about weird tech glitches it is a thread about Donald Trump accusing Google of liberal bias; something that apprentlly involves showing more black people than neccassary in search results.

If you lay out the game theory brining this up in this context you are implying that this is part of some vast liberal conspiracy. That is the problem.

lotu··on Trump Accuses Google of Burying Conservative News in Search Results
Are you literally suggesting that for some of the most important queries that people make Google should just return no results because it is too hard to decide who is on top?
lotu··on China’s Mass Internment Camps Have No Clear End in Sight
The term concentration camps referse to any camps where you rounded up a bunch of all people belonging to some group with no due process, and typically including whole families (this is what distinguishes them from prison). By this definition they are concentration camps, as are the camps used by the US when they rounded up the Japanese americans and several other instances going back to the 1800's.

However in the eyes of most people concentration camp refers to the extermination camps where the Nazis systematically kill everyone who was brought into them. I think most people feel that it is important to distinguish between camps that lock people up without recourse, and camps and kill people. That is why we aren't referring to them as concentration camps. If you call them concentration camps people expect that means systematic mass murder, when they realize that is not what is happening you loose credibility and those people end up ignoring the real human rights crisis.

To be more precise under today's usage concentration camps include both the extermination camps, and internment camps. Internment camps is a more precise definition of what this is.

Also I think unfortunately while that while their is wide expression of the belief that extermination camps are immoral and should not happen. I don't think there nearly the same expression around internment camps.

lotu··on Whiteboards used after Gatwick flight information screens fail
If your displays are openable and have the right connector you could just use them. However, as someone else pointed out whiteboards work in a lot more situations.
lotu··on Reddit Security Incident
I have trouble calling this scary when the data we are talking about is upvotes and private messages associated with an alias (not necessarily associated with an human) that are over a decade old.

From the standpoint of the person who took the data it is likely boring enough that it's not even worth the effort to restore the database.

Given the existence of more pressing problems I really can't do more than shrug.

lotu··on A way to track people with cellphones with GPS capabilities turned off
This was actually how the very first iPhone did it’s location tracking when it didn’t have a GPS chip in it.
lotu··on Researchers Unmask Anonymous Twitter Accounts With 97% Accuracy Using ML
It appeared to do even less than that, because they don’t have a ground truth of throwaway and main account associations. It sounds like they where just able to re-associate an account with it’s origional name after removing the name by looking at metadata. This is throughly unimpressive.
← PreviousPage 6 of 17Next →