HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lotu

989 karma · joined November 15, 2007

submissionscomments
lotu··on Utah voting system fending off 1B hacking attempts per day
I federal id card is a political non-starter in the US because of a a bunch of reasons. First the federal government currently lacks infrastructure to issue IDs effectively. The states handle drivers licenses at DMV which handle a lot of stuff besides just issuing IDs, building separate federal systems would be a large undertaking.

The REAL ID act which was an attempt to create a federal ID managed by the states was passed in 2005 by is still not implemented because many states simply refuse to comply with the law some have even passed laws that prevent the state from complying with the law. The federal government lacks a way to force a majority of the sates to comply with it's will (see marijuana laws). And states don't want a federal id.

lotu··on ‘Everyone is breaking the law right now’: GDPR compliance is falling short
I’ve had discussions with people working in ads at Google that are basically, “so GDPR is the EU’s attempt to kill off all our competition and presently entrench us in the marketplace.”
lotu··on Ask HN: Your favorite syntactic sugar from any language?
So much so, I wish more languages would adopt it.
lotu··on The Ornithologist the Internet Called a Murderer
While I sometimes feel a lot of these things, I don't think you are diagnosing the cause correctly. I don't see how the fact that we have a single dominate social networks, and search engine are the cause. I can't imagine how having a distributed social network or more competition in the search market would make people be more civil.

First off, people have always been uncivil both on-line and off-line. If you look at the adoption of the internet it started among "tech" people then it was societal elites, like professors, doctors, scientists, and lawyers, then moved down the chain to office workers, collage students and so on. It should not be a surprise that as the "common" people came on the internet that the sophistication and civility of discourse decreased. The same thing would be observed if you had in-person events with these groups of people.

I argue that this is the cause of decline in civility: https://www.statista.com/statistics/865523/us-offline-popula... not consolidation.

Yes their are problems but, if you look at where hate groups and online mobs appear to be most prevalent it is in the small distributed uncontrolled forums that don't have the manpower or compulsion from corporate overlords to police this type of thing.

Secondly it is incorrect to think the internet hasn't done more enormous good, if you look at marginalized communities and the ability for people to find, connect and mobilize it has been because of the internet. I don't think it is a coincidence that the acceptance of LGBT people corresponded with a massive increase in the ability to communicate with other people.

Just as the printing press did not make all of humanity scholars; the internet has not made humanity civil to each other.

lotu··on The Ornithologist the Internet Called a Murderer
The article isn't actually specific on this. They mention death threats but don't quote any. (I'm betting Mr Filardi didn't keep a scrapbook of death threats, and with his facebook account gone the record is gone too.) Given the number of people involved in the tendency of people social media presume they are immune from consequences, I feel really confident that dozens of people made comments that went over the line and would be clear prosecution cases.

But if we as a society wanted to we could have a lawyer comb through all the comments sent to people that are victims of online mobs and pick out the ones that constitute real prosecutable things.

lotu··on Neighbourly by Google
Why should we expect an online forum to be free of racism if oral forum of speech isn't.

As another poster pointed out in a way the fact that racism is obvious in these platforms is an improvement over it hiding in plain sight.

lotu··on GDPR: Programmatic ad buying plummets in Europe
I'm confused by your comment are you saying diffrent rules should apply to Google vs other companies or are you saying Google lack the engineering talent to comply and everyone else has it.

The former is a deeply troubling form of government that leads (in my view anvetiablly) to corruption and abuse of power. The latter is plain backwards Google has the resources to be profitable under any regulatory regime it is small companies that don't.

lotu··on GDPR: Programmatic ad buying plummets in Europe
That is an awesome idea! I really like it, one thing I do know if you dig in the the ad settings for most provides you can find a page where they display this info and you can edit it.

Unfortunately short of some type of mandate I don't see how this could work, because it would be next to impossible to get 90% of the population to fallout the cookie.

My company actually did a bunch of research on collecting consent from users to show personalized ads, (aka what everyone is doing right now)

Only 25% of the the users read the 3 sentences before clicking on a selection. 25% did not read anything many thought our privacy dialog was in fact an ad. :(

Many people said they didn't want personalized ads because they thought it would mean filling out a survey like the one you just described even though it obviously (to us) did not.

One person actually said, "I'm okay with them using my browser history to show ads but, I don't want them to use my personal data like my banking records or my medical history." This is very ironic because we presented the option to do exactly what they wanted by they didn't understand what it was because they did not consider the browser data to be "personal".

I really wish that when you first opened a browser their was a dialog about hey these or the things you need to know about how we pay for the internet. Though I have no idea how get to that spot.

lotu··on GDPR: Programmatic ad buying plummets in Europe
This was/is unclear, I actually remembering having an hour long discussions about this exact topic several months ago. This is the biggest problem with the GDPR it was hard to understand what could and could not be done.
lotu··on GDPR: Programmatic ad buying plummets in Europe
>it might support just a hundred publishers rather than ten million sites - but so be it.

You want millions of people to loose their lively hood over this issue? That sounds cruel and spiteful to me.

You also have to think of many small companies that make niche products that would no longer be able to find their customers and thus be forced to close.

> 2) in a vast global experiment where advertisers knew everything about everyone they still completely failed to show people relevant ads.

The premise of your statement is false, advertisers have never know every thing about anyone. That was just marking bullshit by ad-tech companies targeted at adversities and publishers, "We know everything about your users! So if you hire Acme Ad Tech your profits will go through the roof!" The fact that users hear the statements and understandably freaked out was collateral damage. The fact this statement was demonstrably false was irrelevant.

The fact is that the amount of data used to do targeted advertising is quite sparse in-fact, no-one wants to spend the effort to individually go through mountains of data and figure out the best advertisment. Really the only data used is

1. demographics (age, gender) 2. location (this is so a NYC based restaurant chain doesn't waste money advertising in California), 3. language (people actually hate seeing ads in a foreign language) 4. interest categories (like do you like Football, or Cars, or video games, this is how facebook advertises a lot they figure out your interests based on posts, then allow advertisers to advertise to you based on that category, (interestingly they don't actually sell the list of interests mostly because that would mean advertisers would not have to buy ads through Facebook and more)) 5. product targeting (this is you visited acme.com and put an acme roadrunner trap in your cart but never checked out so now it follows you around the internet.)

> Most notoriously even the giants who know what you ate yesterday fail to realize you probably don’t want ads for toilets for a year after you bought a toilet.

Yeah, that's my point, using more data (like the fact you bought the toilet) is more work and using the current amount of data works well enough for them so that is all they do.

lotu··on GDPR: Programmatic ad buying plummets in Europe
Native ads don't do this unless you mean something other than the standard definition.

Native ad is just an ad that is formatted so it fits with the aesthetic style of the page, (for example it uses the same fonts and colors). This makes the ad less jarring to the user and makes the overall page look better. Many people don't like them for this exact reason, because they say ads should be very obvious and native ads might look like content.

Native ads can do tracking the same way non-native ads can.

The rest of the comment is more or less spot on though.

lotu··on How 2 M.T.A. Decisions Pushed the Subway into Crisis
Ehh, if you changed it I bet people would learn really quickly not to lean on doors. Most people leaning on doors are going to be young people with decent reaction times and balance so I wouldn’t even expect injury more like surprise. It would probally be reasonable to run a publicity campaign to reduce surprise as people don’t like being supprised.
lotu··on Facebook now denying access unless EU users opt-in to tracking
My understanding is that Facebook doesn’t actually sell data to advertisers. By this I mean you can’t go to Facebook and say, “I would like to buy data for 10,000 18-24 year old males in New York City, how much?” Instead you say, “I have an ad I want to show to 10,000 18-24 year old males in NYC, how much?” Facebook then handles serving the ad for you and sends you data about how succufull your campaigne was, when people click on the ad and visit your website you obviously can collect data from them there. This is subtle difference and one I think few people have been articulating, probally in part because it makes you sound like a shill for Facebook.

This actually makes more sense finically for Facebook, if they did the first thing people would only have to buy data once, and worse they could resell the data to third parties decreasing Facebook’s control of the market. Instead by retaining control of the data Facebook can charge an advertiser for every ad they show, making more money. Ironically this also better protects peoples privacy because Facebook isn’t actually giving the data away.

lotu··on Are you really Facebook’s product? The history of a dangerous idea
It also means advertisers can’t miss appropriate your data (this could be part of the security thing). So I can’t say I want to know what themaguffinman’s been searching and google will send me a list of his searches for $50. When people say selling your data that’s the image I get even though it is compleatlly in accurate.
lotu··on Are you really Facebook’s product? The history of a dangerous idea
Or how about “If you are’t paying with money, you’re paying with time or attention”
lotu··on Google loses ‘right to be forgotten’ case
Most interviewers aren’t engineers, in tech sure, but their are lots of other industries
lotu··on When the business model is the privacy violation
Several of them also were asking what chickens where and why one would desire to own chickens in the first place. The whole thing is very sad the point of this is for each congress person to get to feel special by getting to look down and act tough against Zuckerberg. They didn’t even spend the effort to do basic research so they didn’t waste time answering questions that could be answered by using facebook.
lotu··on When the business model is the privacy violation
100% to this. I’m an enginer also working on GDPR and you sound exactly like my product manager. GDPR is likelly to result in the number of advertising technology companies going from thousands to dozens. One of the requirements is that you inform users who you are sharing the data with. If you have a list of ~10 companies is allowed under GDPR, but a constantly change it list of 500 companies is not. The result massive consolidation.

This is very ironic because one the the complaints of the EU against companies like Facebook or Google is that they are monopolies in the advertising space, and then they passed a law that will have the effect of force it their competion out of the market place.

It’s a real shame that no one is really covering this aspect of GDPR.

lotu··on When the business model is the privacy violation
An interesting if rather long read. However I’m not sure if your solutions of voluntary donations and cryptocurincies have viability. Voluntary donations have high friction to get a user to start donating (You don’t want to donate to a site you only visit twice and who knows if you will visit the site in the future). Cryptocurincies are unproven at this point.

You also don’t mention how targeted advertising is critical to many small business. If you have niche or specalized product it can be very difficult to find people that want to buy it, you are limited to only places where those people are in high concentrations, it is quite reasonable to expect that the elimination of targeted advertising would quietly erase these business as they are no longer able to find their consumers. Diffrent payment models don’t address this.

lotu··on When the business model is the privacy violation
That sounds like an explicit HIPA violation and is very much against the law for both the hospital to share the data and Facebook to do that linking. It sounds tin foil hat conspiracy to me.
lotu··on When the business model is the privacy violation
To do what? Facebook uses user data to, run Facebook, do research (train machine learning which uses de personalized data), and show ads. If they aren’t showing ads what other things are you expecting them to do that you find problematic.
lotu··on Google seeks to limit ‘right to be forgotten’ by claiming it’s journalistic
Obviously not, the point is if you are poor and want to know if someone has a history of scamming people do you want to not eat this week and be a formal background check, or run a quick google search and not worry about where to find food. They are diffrent products but they are used for the same purpose many times.
lotu··on Google seeks to limit ‘right to be forgotten’ by claiming it’s journalistic
What if grocery stores where required by law to evaluete people’s claims that articles about them should not be published and then remove those articles from the newpapers it sells (though newspapers sold directly to consumers were still unedited). You might presume that the grocery store (if it had the resources to handle this burden) would have to make journalistic decisions about if it sould allow or densely every single request. This is almost exactly like what Google is claiming.
lotu··on Google seeks to limit ‘right to be forgotten’ by claiming it’s journalistic
Okay this quote at the top of the article irked me.

> Google has argued that it should be protected under an exception for journalism because it provides access to journalistic content. Even as a legal sleight of hand, the argument is quite a departure from Google’s customary efforts to present itself as a disinterested arbiter of information, a position that has become more untenable with time

Google was forced to become an arbiter of information by the very law in question. The EU could have set up a court system where you would sue the government and lawyer would argue against you why the information was in fact in the public interest and a judge would then decide the case. They didn’t do this probally because it would be a expensive and leave the government getting blamed when decisions are inevitably wrong/unpopular. Instead they forced Google to do this in a shout of confidence that Google would act in the public interest and not simply in the interest of resolving cases as quickly as cheaply as possible. It is easy to imagine a alternative world with a diffrent dominiat search engine that would allow information like corruption, histories of abuse and neglect to be hidden from the public.

lotu··on Google seeks to limit ‘right to be forgotten’ by claiming it’s journalistic
This is a interesting point. You could imagine a partial simplistic solution that de ranked historical information for people unless it is specifically being asked for. It’s not clear that a search for a person’s “Bob Smith” nessacarily is interested in Bob’s 20 year old crimes, they might reasonably looking for things that person is currently doing like making music or writing or something else. This is the case when we search for celebrities. Now most people don’t have much interesting stuff on the internet so those old articles pop up. In fact those old arrivals typically have such low rankings that a common solution to this problem is to start a blog and be really aggressive about putting your name all over the place, if the point of Googling someone was to reliably find out if they have a criminal history from a long time ago you wouldn’t expect it to be so easily defeated.
lotu··on UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar
People who own the roads and collect tolls?
lotu··on Walmart Launches Small Army of Autonomous Scanning Robots
It is in the video
lotu··on How Your Returns Are Used Against You at Best Buy, Other Retailers
A return policy doesn't mean the store is a 15 day rental service with no cost. Those exist but they cost money. So the idea that returns aren't unlimited is reasonable. I'm going to suspect the the lawyers that draft the language know what they are doing the Mr. Rittman who is a VP not a lawyer is not speaking using accurate legal terminology but rather colloquial terminology. There is still a huge problem in contract law with how contracts between large companies and individuals are neither read nor understood by the individual but we pretend that they did.
lotu··on How Your Returns Are Used Against You at Best Buy, Other Retailers
Dead link
lotu··on Google helps Pentagon analyze military drone footage–employees “outraged”
Japanese internment camps? I’m sure at that scale people died that would not have.

Next given the scale of wwii I’m sure there were us citizens fighting for the axis powers. The main difference is we lacked the ability to track, research, and target individuals like we do today.

← PreviousPage 7 of 17Next →