HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lotu

989 karma · joined November 15, 2007

submissionscomments
lotu··on Facebook’s tracking of non-users ruled illegal again in Europe
I think you dramatically overestimating the value that you might get from form submissions, provided you are intending to commit identity fraud. Which literally no-one is suggesting ad tracking is doing.
lotu··on Facebook’s tracking of non-users ruled illegal again in Europe
I don't get why you are being downvoted so many huge things are literally funded by ads. Google Maps is funded by ads, so is all of Google X. The money that started the development of self driving cars and made people believe it was something we could be done soon was funded by ads. Where did Facebook get 2 billion dollars to by Oclous to provide funding for VR? Ads. Perhaps in a future we will have a good model for micropayments and you can pay .1 cents for every webpage you visit be in the meantime ads provide the revenue streams that make this work.
lotu··on Facebook’s tracking of non-users ruled illegal again in Europe
The problem is the example being made is that if you are a big American corporation than European regulators will go after you otherwise ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
lotu··on The Car of the Future Will Sell Your Data
That is the question people should be asking if you don't like the question "how much extra would you pay not to see ads in you car?" we can do the equivalent "how much of a discount would trade to see ads in your car?"
lotu··on U.S. To Probe Apple Over Updates That Slow Older iPhones
You are correct but, you should still respond the the underlying point. Should we (to make things more consumer friendly) regulate what ports are provided on computers and laptops?

I argue no. Apple has always been a head of the curve on removing hardware from their devices. This is upsetting if you use that device but it also frees up resources that can be used for other things. This includes space/weight/power wise in the device and economically factories making floppy/cd-rom drives now make something more useful. The problem with regulations is they are often slow and arbitrary. That is not what we want in tech.

I could imagine in 2010 that regulators (perhaps encouraged by a congress person that has a stake in CD-Rom factories), decide the iPad is a type of laptop and so much include a CD-ROM drive in it. Yes having every company make individual decisions is messy and inefficient but that doesn't mean regulations will end up producing better results.

lotu··on U.S. To Probe Apple Over Updates That Slow Older iPhones
Presumably hosting malware isn't one of the things the poster "needs it to do".
lotu··on U.S. To Probe Apple Over Updates That Slow Older iPhones
It bothers me a little the way people are assuming active malice where passive indifference and normal progressions of technology and features is sufficient to cause what we are seeing.

Apple could be inserting code to slow down phones in a very controlled and deliberate effort:

  if (version <= iPhone7) {
    wait_ms(100);
  }

This is what I think of when someone says Apple is deliberately slowing down phones but I don't find this credible.

For this specific case Apple's explanation, they started throttling down CPUs based on battery age to prevent unexpected phone shutdowns make sense. I do have issue with how this was initially messaged (a.k.a. it wasn't) but I understand why, consumer tech news tends to be very low information. It doesn't make sense for Apple to try to explain to users the details of every tweak to power management settings, and if they did it would either be lost on most consumers or be transformed in to negative headlines about how updating your phone makes it slower, in large part because the headline "Will the New iOS Update Slow Down your iPhone?" gets more clicks than "Apple makes Incremental Improvements to Power Management of iPhones as Part of Long-Term Strategy". So I understand the strategy of saying nothing.

Furthermore I expect most of the actual (not perceived) slow down is from dozens of conversations like happening:

Eng: New feature FooBar is awesome we should include it in the next iOS release. QA: FooBar isn't passing latency tests on our latest iPhone so you can't include it. Eng: Darn :(

<2 years later>

Eng: I still think Foobar is awesome, and look it very snappy on my current phone. QA: It works on our latests phones too, and users like it. Okay it is in! Eng: Yay.

This is fundamental to how software has been developed forever. We make faster hardware to be able to run more complex taxing software and than means older hardware will be slower in comparison.

lotu··on Coalition Announces New ‘Do Not Track’ Standard for Web Browsing (2015)
This is trying to create a way for publisher to say, "I don't want to track users" and have it be understood by software. Right now no such system exists. You could see organizations doing testing to see if tracking happens but they need to know what the publisher say they will or won't do. It still might not get adoption but it isn't nothing.
lotu··on Internal FCC Report Shows Republican Net Neutrality Narrative Is False
To this point I talked with my Republican parents about this they were not very informed about what Net Neutrality was but they liked the idea of less regulations. I explained how it would allow the "Washington Post" to strike a deal with Comcast to be the exclusive low tier news site for so you would only be able to access "fox news" and "drugg report" if you paid for a higher tier plan. They did not like the idea anymore.
lotu··on A basic income could boost the US economy by $2.5 trillion
> If the argument is "we could use tax money (via a stipend to citizens, and then extracted as rent) to implement a law that required a trailer park to provide a functioning sewage system", then the easiest and most efficient way to do that would be use tax money to provide a functioning sewage system.

That's assuming the only objective was to fix trailor park sewage, when realistically there are thousands or maybe tens of thousands of similar problems that different populations. The federal government simply doesn't have the resources and logistical capabilities, to identify and address each need in turn. If they tried lots of needs would end up overlooked. So instead you provide the UBI and let the money get directed to the most pressing need.

lotu··on Germany bans children's smartwatches
I always figured it was kinda the opposite, a GPS tracker allows a parent to feel more secure about letting the child out of their sight thus decreasing the "helicoptering". I'd be much more comfortable letting a child walk a couple 2 miles to see their friend if I know I'd be able to quickly recognize if something went wrong (i.e. the child stops moving, or starts going in the wrong direction very quickly.).

Now there is a point as the kid ages where it could get creepy but I think that really depends on you a person, if you are a generally creepy person on not. For example my family of all adults share an iTunes family account to share movies and stuff, this also lets us look at each others location via find my iphone. However this isn't a problem because not of us are creepy assholes.

lotu··on Google's CEO is increasingly boxed in by regulators, critics, and employees
> Ads are laser targeted?

You clearly don't work in ads, we don't manage to have ads that render 100% of the time. Everyone thinks we have super awesome targeting that tracks your every move but most of that is marketing bullshit from people are trying to work for advertisers. Here's a huge amount are targeted do are you in this area, are you in the 18-24 male demo, and did you visit website XYZ in the past 30 days.

lotu··on The Nuclear Potato Cannon, Part 2 (2006)
Well it sounds like the the only reasonable, responsible course of action is to replicate the original test but use modern high speed recording equipment to determine what would happen to that steel plate.
lotu··on Larry Page Deposition in Uber vs. Waymo
I believe Larry Page is saying that you get compensation like being a C-level exec, but instead of having your own company you work at Google.
lotu··on H&R Block and Intuit Are Lobbying Against Making Tax Filling Free and Easy
This is instead of you collecting and sending all of your personal and financial history to a third party.
lotu··on In Manufacturing and Retail, Robot Labor is Cheaper Than Slave Labor Would Be
Comparing the inconvince of having to switch schools, not being able to volunteer and depending on healtcare/insurance to slavery is a massive insult to people that where and are actual slaves.

Actual slaves did not legally own themselves or their children. Their owners can did take children, parents, and spouse and sell them to different slaveholders so they would never see each other again. A slave could not say fuck this my master is rapping and beating me daily so I'm just going to leave.

If you want to a simple question to determine if someone is slave or not ask what happens if punch your boss in the face. An employe will be fired and never work their ever again, a slave will have to continue to work their for the rest of their life.

lotu··on Math Professor Fighting Gerrymandering with Geometry
The thing is in the US we lack a mandatory national or even state id. We use a driver's license which is effectively mandatory in rural parts of the country because otherwise you can't get anywhere. However if you are poor and live in a city the odds that you don't have a driver's license go way up. It turns out that their is no ID the government forces you to have. Clever politicians realize that they don't need to prevent everyone who disagrees with them from voting just preventing 2-3% is likely enough in many races.

The idea of voter ID is effective because of what you just said it sounds so reasonable, until you look at the motivation that it disproportionately results in poor people not being able to vote.

lotu··on [dead]
This is silly it suggests the President is constrained by political forces (in part created by Facebook) but dosen't believe the Zuckerberg is constrained by these forces as well.
lotu··on How Children Lost the Right to Roam in Just 4 Generations
I would say it isn't just that you can "afford" to let them off the leash more it's that you don't have the time/energy to keep track of them. If you are dealing with an infant a toddler and a 5 year old, you are simply won't be able to follow the 8 year old around. Let's say they run off with some frinds with out permission you can either leave the 3 other kids alone to find you 8 year old (who is going to be home when they get hungry anyways) or you can say, "fuck it" I got more important things to handle.
lotu··on Welcome, ACLU
Personally, I've always wondered if the people who don't want to make cakes for a gay wedding/provide flowers would be willing to subcontract that out to someone else. When you buy a cake you don't generally expect that specific person will be making that cake. This would allow them to not participate while at the same time protecting people from discrimination.
lotu··on Testing Ads in Facebook Messenger
Apple's iMessage does this, each device has a public/private key that is shared. When you send a message it is encrypted with all of the recipient's devices public private keys. If the device is not on at the time Apple holds on to the encrypted message but cannot read it because the private key is stored on the device. The only downside to this is that you cannot sync old messages to a new device.
lotu··on A story of a designer learning math
beachbum8029 is being silly because the Godel incompleteness theorem stats that is you cannot prove all true statements.
lotu··on Librarians in Florida went rogue to save 2,300 books from an algorithm
I doubt he knew this was illegal. Charging someone with faking a library card is about the same level as shutting down a lemonade stand for failure to have a business license.
lotu··on To Build a Better Ballot
I think explaining score voting is pretty easy you just have only 3 categories labeled ️(1) (2) (3) for each candidate and they put a mark on what they think for each one. As an aside I susspect that having more than 3 or 4 catagoreis isn't a good idea and creates false precision that complicates things.
lotu··on A list of modern C++ features
To replace C++ it you would either have to make a near human quality automated converter (which is likely impossible right now) or make it compatiable with C++, in the way Groovy is compatiable with java.
lotu··on An App Saw Trump Winning Swing States When Polls Didn't
It's really easy to have an effective track record when n=1.
lotu··on A list of modern C++ features
The one feature that really annoys me is the std::optional. This is awesome and very needed feature however it is too clunky for something that should be used very frequently. Swift does such a nice job with its '?' operator, I wish C++ had something similar.
lotu··on What Percent of the Top-Voted Comments in Reddit Threads Were Also First Comment?
This search for a better way to rank comments still, in my opinion, makes a large incorrect assumption; namely that it is desirable (and possible) to display comments in order from "best" to "worst". If you think of comments only from the prespective a viewer then yes ordering comments from best to worst makes sense, the viewer wants to get as much information as quickly as possible. But if you are looking at establishing a robust meaningful dicussion, part of that is that all comments should have a chance of getting responded to that is proportional to their value, not their rank. Realistically the top three comments in a large thread are about equally good, but the top comment is going the vast majority of views and replies. One system the facilities dicussion might effectivelly shard it's users into separate threads of managble size so they can have a real dicussion, though I'm fuzzy on the details.

Given all the worry we have about about how our online discussions work I think their is real societal (if not extrable monetary) value in discovering a better solution.

lotu··on Self-Driving Cars Must Meet 15 Benchmarks in U.S. Guidance
The VA Healthcare debacle. The government was unable to timely provide healthcare and instead of trying to fix the problem they hid and covered it up by falsefying records. The new system they made is complexly incompetent where doctors and patains are force to spend days on the phone with people who have no clue what they are doing.
lotu··on Self-Driving Cars Must Meet 15 Benchmarks in U.S. Guidance
I asked my doctor to email me my records and was told it is illegal due to HIPAA it makes no fucking sense but that's what it is.
← PreviousPage 8 of 17Next →