HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

loup-vaillant

10,104 karma · joined July 1, 2009

http://www.loup-vaillant.fr

https://monocypher.org

https://elligator.org

submissionscomments
loup-vaillant··on Just Enough Software Architecture (2010)
Even if it works and saves time, it may make us pay that time back when it doesn’t work. Then we to actually think for ourselves, but we’ve been dulled. Best case, we lose time on those cases. More realistically we let bugs through. Worst case, our minds, dulled by the lack of daily training, are no longer capable of solving the problem at all, and we have to train all over again until we can… possibly until we’re fired or the project is cancelled.

Most likely though, code quality will suffer. I have a friend who observes what people commit every day, and some of them (apparently plural) copy & paste answers from an LLM and commit it before checking that it even compiles. And even when it works, it’s often so convoluted there’s no way it could pass any code review. Sure if you’re not an idiot you wouldn’t do that, but some idiots use LLMs to get through interviews (it sometimes works for remote assignments or quizzes), and spotting them on the job sometimes takes some time.

LLMs for coding are definitely useful. And harmful. How much I don’t know, though I doubt right now that the pros outweigh the cons. Good news is though, as we figure out the good uses and avoid the bad ones, it should gradually shift towards "more useful than not" over time. Or at least, "less harmful than it was".

loup-vaillant··on Just Enough Software Architecture (2010)
If you think AI helps speed up development…
loup-vaillant··on How David Bohm and Hugh Everett changed quantum theory
> What hubris it would take to believe that we’ve discovered how the universe actually works

Isn't that what happened with the interpretations that came before many worlds? Weren't most people believing in an actual wave function collapse back then, with basically no one telling them of their hubris?

Genuine question: how soon did the "shut up and calculate" approach, as a refusal to interpret the maths, started getting traction?

loup-vaillant··on How David Bohm and Hugh Everett changed quantum theory
> Many worlds does postulate its many worlds rather than predict them as it provides no way their existence can ever be tested for.

Your conclusion does not follow from your premise. MWI does postulate different stuff from Copenhagen, but the existence of many worlds is not one of them. Just because I postulate Peano arithmetic doesn’t mean I also postulate 2+2=4. The latter is but a consequence of the former.

My understanding of MWI, is that it just "believes" the equations. Specifically, if the equations say the complex amplitude is not null, then this stuff is real. And that’s about it. It’s not our fault the equations describe non-null amplitudes, that if real are many worlds.

This interpretation business could apply to macro-scale physics as well: when you send a probe so far out there that it crosses the limit of the observable universe, does it cease to exist? What if there’s people inside, will they die? One would be hard pressed to argue from their discontinued existence: why would we disbelieve the equations of relativity, that work so well for everything we can observe?

Conversely, what makes you think that the equations that work so well on everything we can observe, would somehow stop working (or stop applying) on the stuff we cannot observe? I know you didn’t explicitly disbelieve the equations, but since we can’t at the same time believe in their general applicability and disbelieve MWI, it’s hard to interpret your refusal to acknowledge MIW as the most probably hypothesis as anything but scepticism about the applicability of those equations.

---

To throw you a bone I personally do have a reason to be wary: physics is currently inconsistent, and when we get a credible theory of everything, it may very well use different equations that do not describe many worlds, make long range probes vanish, or both.

loup-vaillant··on How David Bohm and Hugh Everett changed quantum theory
> Neither Bohmian mechanics nor many worlds are falsifiable, they are just interpretations.

If we accept that (I’m not sure I do[1]), then that must be true of all interpretations, including the once most popular, Copenhagen/collapse. And as valuable is the "shut up and calculate" refusal to interpret anything, I suspect it is at least in part a way to avoid the possible demise of the collapse interpretation. A compromise of sorts.

[1]: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/DFxoaWGEh9ndwtZhk/decoherenc...

loup-vaillant··on Don't name packages common nouns
> or better yet why they didn't just make math.Min and math.Max generic?

I don't know Go, but my first thought would go to lol no generics. Now that they do have generics I guess they could do it, but backwards compatibility may require them to use other names than `math.Min` and `math.Max`.

(Note: Go did have some generic built-in constructs from the start, and could have included `min` and `max`, similar to how OCaml did it. At the same time, you don't want too many primitives in your language if you can help it.)

loup-vaillant··on Stupid Slow: The Perceived Speed of Computers
Just because it became reality doesn't make it any less insane, though.
loup-vaillant··on Debian KDE: Right Linux distribution for professional digital painting in 2024
> Because Linux userspace libraries aren't designed to handle long term binary compatibility.

The kernel however, is. So how about static linking (almost) all the things?

loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
> Remember, this was about your point that wealthy people build their wealth by suppressing education in the general populace.

No.

> Wealth inequality and the state of democracy are digressions from that point.

Yes.

loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
> Just as a counterpoint to your late-stage capitalism-esque viewpoint, wealthy are also shown to over index in conscientiousness in some studies.

I fail to see how this is a counter point. Sure, conscientiousness, and I would add work ethics certainly explain some inequality. But even if they explained most of it (exploiting people does require work, and I'd expect the more conscientious capitalists are better at it), they would still come far, far short of morally justifying the level of inequality we observe today.

No billionaire ever deserved to be that wealthy.

Now we can discuss incentives, and I can accept that a good system may need to allow some people to accumulate undeserved wealth. Still, I will note that the mere existence of billionaires is a threat to democracy. (Or a blocker: our representative governments aren't very democratic to begin with, and we have studies showing that when billionaires and the people disagree over a piece of legislation the billionaires win most of the time.)

My current opinion on this is that putting a hard cap on individual wealth is a good thing. Furthermore, I think this hard cap should be well under $1B, almost certainly below $100M.

loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
> You seem to imply they are a higher rate of rich assholes, no?

It seems likely. But that's a detail, because I believe the more important effect is the contempt higher-class people can have towards lower-class people. Some of it may even come from cognitive dissonance. See, barring a few exceptions, one does not get rich just by working. One also has to exploit other people, to spoil them of a fraction of their added value. The richer you are the truer this gets, and then you have to find some way to look at yourself in the mirror despite that.

> actively suppressing education

I don't recall saying that. My exact words were: "I don't know about libraries specifically, but the idea that rich assholes would like to keep the education level of the general population below a threatening threshold is not conspiracy thinking to me, it's just obvious."

> especially when, as you say, they are the most likely to donate money to those causes.

I didn't say that either. My exact words were: "the largest contributor to pretty much anything has to be ludicrously rich. Because the only way to give that much, is to own even more."

loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
Wrong reading. I never intended to make a generalisation out of 6% or even triple that amount. I just wanted to establish that rich assholes are a thing.
loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
> You did say they want to remain high status, likely due to their over indexing in narcissism.

Quote me, or I didn’t.

loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
> If the wealthy don't fund something, it's because they're narcissists. If they do, it's because of statistics.

I said no such strawman, and it's not my main point anyway.

My main point is: the idea that rich & powerful people will generally do what it takes to stay rich & powerful is not conspiracy thinking, it's common sense. The idea that a sizeable proportion of them will resort to unethical (even lethal) means to do so is not conspiracy thinking, it's common sense.

That's it, and I don't think Mr Carnegie here provides any significant evidence to the contrary. I mean, the same guy reportedly had strikers shot and killed, didn't he? It's hard to believe such a guy donated large amounts of money out of the goodness of his heart.

loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
Can you precise what "that" is referring to?
loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
> But then you go on to say,

I said "tend to". A tendency does not make an absolute and complete genocide. I also said "I'm afraid", which is supposed to convey some level of uncertainty. Carnegie's donation doesn't invalidate my point, even if he wasn't an outlier.

> The irony is that one of the most ludicrously wealthy people in history was also probably the single largest contributor to public libraries.

Where you see irony, I see expected statistics: the largest contributor to pretty much anything has to be ludicrously rich. Because the only way to give that much, is to own even more.

And I will add that one incentive for rich people to donate is their public image. And in many cases their "donations" are largely neutered by tax cuts or by increasing the return on some of their other investments (basically their donations causing other of their investments to increase their returns). Donations by rich people aren't always genuinely generous.

loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
You do realise you're not contradicting anything I've just said, right?

Quoting myself, "I am of course not denying the existence of nice rich people".

loup-vaillant··on No one buys books
> > [Rich & powerful assholes often maintain their status by unethical means.]

> This is conspiracy level thinking.

The prevalence of assholes is a documented thing (latest numbers I've heard was over 6% of clinical narcissists, reportedly a very conservative lower bound), and who would ever be surprised that high-status people like being high-status?

I don't know about libraries specifically, but the idea that rich assholes would like to keep the education level of the general population below a threatening threshold is not conspiracy thinking to me, it's just obvious.

I am of course not denying the existence of nice rich people. Though I'm afraid they tend to be selected out of ludicrous wealth. In fact, I fully expect to find many more assholes among super-rich people than I would among the general population. (But I'm not sure either: the strife we find among some of the poorest people also tend to generate assholes…)

loup-vaillant··on Stop Acting Like You're Famous
Or that's bad, because all those kids who spent time looking good, didn't get as many compliments for their effort than they expected, or perhaps even deserved.

There are many caveats with judging people by their appearances, but complimenting someone on the part of their look they put unusual effort in for some unusual occasion, seems pretty healthy to me.

(Well, there's also the caveat that the rich ones will have better access to exquisite clothes to begin with…)

loup-vaillant··on U.S. sues Apple, accusing it of maintaining an iPhone monopoly
> Which leads one to wonder if the tolling and gate keeping is such a hinderance

I don't know, perhaps you should ask that to someone who actually made that argument? If I recall, people are still buying cigarettes, are they not? Stuff doesn't have to be good for you to sell good.

---

I don't dispute the facts you lay out here. I'll even cite game console as other general purpose computers that were (and still are) quite heavily locked down too. Apple however made one step further, and managed to sell a locked down general purpose computer for purposes other than gaming.

At the root of it all, I think, is how hardware vendors got away with selling their stuff without the full manual. Some instead provide a proprietary Windows driver. Others hide keys in them, don't tell users what they are, and then lobby to send heroic reverse engineers to jail. If I was the regulator I would probably start there.

loup-vaillant··on U.S. sues Apple, accusing it of maintaining an iPhone monopoly
It was a better product. But it would be quite a take to say their tolling & gate keeping was a significant contributor.

It was a better product because of its capacitive multi-touch screen and its overall speed (which I must insist depends more on what apps are installed by default than on the restrictions on third party apps).

loup-vaillant··on U.S. sues Apple, accusing it of maintaining an iPhone monopoly
> From my point of view, the problem is more that Apple set a precedent of these restrictions due to them being the first mover, and few mainstream phone companies have tried to break out of this idea

It's even worse than that: though I stand by what I said, you're correct, people are gradually realising that the difference between their smartphone and laptop/desktop (if any), is one of degree, not kind. But we don't see the push back we would have seen if they had realised right away. Instead, as you rightly point out, companies are building on Apple's precedent to try and expand their model to our good old laptops and desktops.

And it looks like they're succeeding. It would seem one has to pay Apple to even get the right to distribute a regular MacOS program regular users can actually execute (no Apple developer plan, no code signing). And newer versions of Windows are displaying increasingly scary warnings for programs telling you they "protected" your computer, which are bad enough that we get tutorials about how to get past them.

loup-vaillant··on U.S. sues Apple, accusing it of maintaining an iPhone monopoly
Exclusively, yes. Except for that second factor authentication they forced me to install on my phone (without which doing online payments would be a pain). I like and trust my Ubuntu laptop.

I do avoid Windows for those things, though.

loup-vaillant··on U.S. sues Apple, accusing it of maintaining an iPhone monopoly
> Phones are unique in the consumer space because of how—

—they were marketed as phones that can compute, instead of as computers that can phone.

That's the crux: people would never have accepted the restrictions on computers like the iPhone, if that thing were instead sold as a general computer called the iPalm or similar. But since it's sold as a phone, any thing else it can do is more easily perceived as a bonus, and we hardly feel the restrictions at the beginning.

Only people who see smartphones for what they really are, general purpose palmtops that can make phone calls, can really perceive the egregiousness of those restrictions. The first step then, is generalising this understanding to everyone.

A good first step, I think, would be to start naming those things more accurately. I'd personally suggest "palmtop".

loup-vaillant··on Florida Just Banned Lab-Grown Meat. I Tried to Find Out Why
As far as I understand the main problem is eating too much meat. Instead of having some at every meal (save maybe breakfast), we could eat once or twice a week.

(Not disputing the idea that how the meat was grown matters, though.)

loup-vaillant··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
Do you have a source for this? I recall he asked for intel on both parties, but ended up getting it only for one. The conundrum then became releasing only the one, or release nothing.
loup-vaillant··on 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death
> Killing him was an option on the table as far as I recall, but it wasn't what they ended up doing.

Because this time wasn't about silencing him (too late for that), but making an example. And for this, a blatant enough assassination would likely tarnish the image the US government wants to project too much. Going through the courts, making a show of "due process", now that's looking pretty good: "hey journalists, we can't kill you if you babble too much, but we can make you wish we did, and since it's all legal good luck about rousing public opinion about it".

loup-vaillant··on Nvidia bans using translation layers for CUDA software to run on other chips
Copyright grounds? Copying stuff can violate copyright, but documenting stuff? No no no, you'd need a specific law to prevent disclosing of information. Maybe misappropriation of trade secrets?
loup-vaillant··on Nvidia bans using translation layers for CUDA software to run on other chips
Is it? I mean, is the clause enforceable to begin with?
loup-vaillant··on Nvidia bans using translation layers for CUDA software to run on other chips
Can they? The article quotes:

> You may not reverse engineer, decompile or disassemble any portion of the output generated using SDK elements for the purpose of translating such output artifacts to target a non-NVIDIA platform.

Okay, so what if m purpose is just to explain to the world how it works? Maybe I'm just interested in the precise semantics of CUDA and all its possibly undocumented edge cases? Maybe what people do with this knowledge is none of my business? Maybe if I write a Vulkan translation layer I only do this so I can run it on NVDIA hardware?

And maybe, just maybe, their clause is an overreach and unenforceable? Though at this point I'd rater seek legal advice from a registered attorney.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →