HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

loveparade

2,076 karma · joined December 30, 2022

Meet Me At The Love Parade
submissionscomments
loveparade··on Closer to production quality Python notebooks with `marimo check`
I wish this didn't have AI in it. I've been looking for a Jupyter alternative that is pure python and can be modified from a regular text editor. Jupytext works okay, but I miss the advanced Jupyter features. But I really don't want to deal with yet another AI assistant, especially not a custom one when I'm already using Claude/etc from the CLI and I want those agents to help me edit the notebooks.

Take out all the AI stuff and I'd give it a try. I use AI coding agents as my daily driver, but I really don't need this AI enshittification in every tool/library I'm using.

loveparade··on I am a programmer, not a rubber-stamp that approves Copilot generated code
That sounds more like an organizational problem. If you are an employee that doesn't care about maintainability of code, e.g. a freelancer working on a project you will never touch again after your contract is over, your incentive has always been to write crappy code as quickly as possible. Previously that took the form of copying cheap templates, copying and pasting code from StackOverflow as-is without adjustments, not caring about style, using tools to autogenerate bindings, and so on. I remember a long time ago I took over a web project that a freelancer had worked on, and when I opened it I saw one large file of mixed python and HTML. He literally just copied and pasted whole html pages into the render statements in the server code.

The same is true for many people submitting PRs to OSS. They don't care about making real contributions, they just want to put something on their resume.

AI is probably making it more common, but it really isn't a new issue, and is not directly related to LLMs.

loveparade··on Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a simple instruction?
I've experienced similar things, but my conclusion has usually been that the model is not receiving enough context in such cases. I don't know your specific example, but in general it may not be incorrect to put an Arc/Lock on many things at once (or using Arc isntead of Rc, etc) if your future plans are parallelize several parts of your codebase. The model just doesn't know what your future plans are, and in errs on the side of "overengineering" solutions for all kinds of future possibilities. I found that this is a bias that these models tend to have, many times their code is overengineered for features I will never need and I need to tell them to simplify - but that's expected. How would the model know what I do and don't need in the future without me giving all the right context?

The same thing is true for tests. I found their tests to be massively overengineered, but that's easily fixed by telling them to adopt the testing style from the rest of the codebase.

loveparade··on Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a simple instruction?
Yeah, it has been really good in my experience. I've done some niche WASM stuff with custom memory layouts and parallelism and it did great there too, probably better than I could've done without spending several hours reading up on stuff.
loveparade··on Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a simple instruction?
Rust, Python, and a bit of C++. Around 80% Rust probably
loveparade··on Why the push for Agentic when models can barely follow a simple instruction?
> Beyond this, if you’re working on novel code, LLMs are absolutely horrible at doing anything. A lot of assumptions are made, non-existent libraries are used, and agents are just great at using tokens to generate no tangible result whatsoever.

Not my experience. I've used LLMs to write highly specific scientific/niche code and they did great, but obviously I had to feed them the right context (compiled from various websites and books convered to markdown in my case) to understand the problem well enough. That adds additional work on my part, but the net productivity is still very much positive because it's one-time setup cost.

Telling LLMs which files they should look at was indeed necessary 1-2 years ago in early models, but I have not done that for the last half year or so, and I'm working on codebases with millions of lines of code. I've also never had modern LLMs use nonexistent libraries. Sometimes they try to use outdated libraries, but it fails very quickly once they try to compile and they quickly catch the error and follow up with a web search (I use a custom web search provider) to find the most appropriate library.

I'm convinced that anybody who says that LLMs don't work for them just doesn't have a good mental model of HOW LLMs work, and thus can't use them effectively. Or their experience is just outdated.

That being said, the original issue that they don't always follow instructions from CLAUDE/AGENT.md files is quite true and can be somewhat annoying.

loveparade··on Ask HN: What do you do while ChatGPT-5 is thinking?
Sad but true.
loveparade··on Ask HN: What do you do while ChatGPT-5 is thinking?
I often use that time to spec out a future task. Either by going through Github issues, doing some research and adding details, or by spinning up another codex/claude session to create a detailed design document for a future task and iterating on that. So one agent is coding while another is helping me to spec out future work. So when the coding agent is done I can immediately start on the next task with a proper spec, reducing margin for error.
loveparade··on Ask HN: Has AI stolen the satisfaction from programming?
Reading HN I seem to be in the minority but AI has made programming a lot more fun for me. I've been an engineer for nearly 25 years and 95% of the work is rather mindless boilerplate. I know exactly what I need to do next, it just takes time and iteration.

The "you think about the problem and draw diagrams" part of you describe probably makes up less than 5% of a typical engineering workflow, depending on what you work on. I work in a scientific field where it's probably more than for someone working in web dev, but even here it's very little, and usually only at the beginning of a project. Afterwards it's all about iteration. And using AI doesn't change that part at all, you still need to design the high level solution for an LLM to produce anything remotely useful.

I never encountered the problem of not understanding details of the AI's implementation that people here seem to describe. I still review all the code and need to ask the LLM to make small adjustments if I'm not happy with it, especially around not-so-elegant abstractions.

Tasks that I actively avoided previously because they seemed like a hassle, like large refactorings, I no longer avoid now because I can ask an AI to do most of it. I feel so much productive and work is more satisfying because I get to knock out all these chores that I had resistance to before.

Brainstorming with an AI about potential solutions to a hard problem is also more fun for me, and more productive, than doing research the old ways. So instead of drawing diagrams I now just have conversations.

I can't say for certain whether using LLMs has made me much more productive (overall it likely has but for certain tasks it hasn't), but it definitely has made work more fun for me.

Another side effect has been that I'm learning new things more frequently when using AI. When I brainstorm solutions with an AI or ask for an implementation, it sometimes uses libraries and abstractions I have not seen before, especially around very low level code that I'm not super familiar with. Previously I was much more likely to use or do things the one way I know.

loveparade··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (October 2025)
For the long videos I just relied in ffmpeg to remove silence. It has lots of options for it, but you may need to fiddle with the parameters to make it work. I ended up with something like:

``` stream = ffmpeg.filter( stream, 'silenceremove', detection='rms', start_periods=1, start_duration=0, start_threshold='-40dB', stop_periods=-1, stop_duration=0.15, stop_threshold='-35dB', stop_silence=0.15 ) ```

loveparade··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (October 2025)
I've built something similar before for my own use cases and one thing I'd push back on are official subtitles. Basically no video I care about has ever had "official" subtitles and the auto generated subtitles are significantly worse than what you get by piping content through an LLM. I used Gemini because it was the cheapest option and still did very well.

The biggest challenge with this approach is that you probably need to pass extra context to LLMs depending on the content. If you are researching a niche topic, there will be lots of mistakes if the audio isn't if high quality because that knowledge isn't in the LLM weights.

Another challenge is that I often wanted to extract content from live streams, but they are very long with lots of pauses, so I needed to do some cutting and processing on the audio clips.

In the app I built I would feed an RSS feed of video subscriptions in, and at the other end a fully built website with summaries, analysis, and transcriptions comes out that is automatically updated based on the youtube subscription rss feed.

loveparade··on GPT-5-Codex is a better AI researcher than me
You can also reach research parity by downloading a Github repository. Is that impressive too?
loveparade··on Ask HN: Tell me about the best programmer you worked with
Claude Code. He always tells me I'm right.
loveparade··on Scientists discover surprising language 'shortcuts' in birdsong – like humans
I hope the EditorBird added subtitles.
loveparade··on Many women have 'lost' their boyfriends because of OpenAI's GPT-5
Looks crazy but this isn't really anything new. Before AI these people became obsessed with fictional characters from romantic novels, movies, or videogames and treated them as their partners and fantasized about them. Now it's more interactive with AI but still the same thing.
loveparade··on Ask HN: Does anyone know of a general news site akin to Hacker News?
The funny thing is that I find HN especially useful for non tech news. It's highly biased for tech news, but only the most important normal news make it to the front page, so it's a great filter.
loveparade··on GitHub MCP exploited: Accessing private repositories via MCP
TLDR; If you give the agent an access token that has permissions to access private repos it can use it to... access private repos!?
loveparade··on Ask HN: Anyone struggling to get value out of coding LLMs?
That's because the reality is somewhere in the middle. It obviously isn't 100x or even 10x except for very specific toy tasks, but for me it's probably around ~1.5-2x in everyday work. And I work on mostly long-tail scientific stuff, I imagine it's more if you do something like frontend dev with a lot of boilerplate. I'm absolutely convinced that people who say LLMs are not making them more productive either don't understand how to use them correctly, or they are working on very specific niche problems/infrastructure where they aren't useful.

2x may not sound like much compared to what you read in the media, but if a few years ago you had told companies that you can provably make their engineers even 2x more productive on average you'd probably be swimming in billions of dollars now. That kind of productivity increase is absolutely huge.

loveparade··on Chomsky on what ChatGPT is good for (2023)
> AI this decade have not, at least so far, substantially deepened our understanding of our own intelligence and its constitution

I would push back on this a little bit. While it has not helped us to understand our own intelligence, it has made me question whether such a thing even exists. Perhaps there are no simple and beautiful natural laws, like those that exists in Physics, that can explain how humans think and make decisions. When CNNs learned to recognize faces through a series of hierarchical abstractions that make intuitive sense it's hard to deny the similarities to what we're doing as humans. Perhaps it's all just emergent properties of some messy evolved substrate.

The big lesson from the AI development in the last 10 years from me has been "I guess humans really aren't so special after all" which is similar to what we've been through with Physics. Theories often made the mistake of giving human observers some kind of special importance, which was later discovered to be the cause of theories not generalizing.

loveparade··on Claude 4 System Card
Just anecdotal experience, but this model seems more eager to write tests, create test scripts and call various tools than the previous one. Of course this results in more roundtrips and overall more tokens used and more money for the provider.

I had to stop the model going crazy with unnecessary tests several times, which isn't something I had to do previously. Can be fixed with a prompt but can't help but wonder if some providers explicitly train their models to be overly verbose.

loveparade··on Ask HN: Go deep into AI/LLMs or just use them as tools?
I come from a more traditional (PhD) ML/DL background. I wouldn't recommend getting into (1) because the field is incredibly saturated. We have hundreds of new, mostly low quality, papers each day. If you want to get into AI/ML on a more fundamental level now is probably the worst time in terms of competition. There are probably 100x more people in this field than there are jobs, and most of them have a stronger background than you if you are just starting out.
loveparade··on ChatGPT Is a Gimmick
I use LLMs to check solutions for graduate level math and physics problem I'm working on. Can I 100% trust their final output? Of course not, but I know enough about the domain to tell whether they discovered mistakes in my solutions or not. And they do a pretty good job and have found mistakes in my reasoning many times.

I also use them for various coding tasks and they, together with agent frameworks, regularly do refactoring or small feature implementations in 1-2 minutes that would've taken me 10-20 minutes. They've probably increased my developer productivity by 2-3x overall, and by a lot more when I'm working with technology stacks that I'm not so familiar with or haven't worked with for a while. And I've been an engineer for almost 30 years.

So yea, I think you're just using them wrong.

loveparade··on Side projects I've built since 2009
I think "sold" probably doesn't mean what you think it means here. Have you looked at the projects? Nearly all of them are just statics lists of things. Like "a list of all country flags" or "a list of modern inventions"

Maybe it was some SEO related sale with the domain and bit of ad revenue that someone bought for $100, which probably isn't the definition of selling a side project that most users on HN have. In fact, looking at the domains, the domains were probably worth more than the content on those sites.

That's why I originally flagged this post because I thought it was a bit misleading. I didn't think most people here would consider simple lists of things as side projects.

loveparade··on Is Winter Coming? (2024)
If you don't know how to ask a human doctor a good question you can't expect to get a good answer either.

The difference is that a human doctor probably has a lot of context about you and the situation you're in, so that they probably guess what your intention behind the question is, and adjust their answer appropriately. When you talk to an LLM, it has none of that context. So the comparison isn't really fair.

Has your mom ever asked you a computer question? Half of the time the question makes no sense and explaining to her why would take hours, and then she still wouldn't get it. So the best you can do is guess what she wants based on the context you have.

loveparade··on The Fall of Roam (2022)
> When I write my notes the thought, ‘Where am I going to put this?’ plagues me every time.

This is so true. Regardless of how useful note taking actually is, the kind of people using these apps are those who like the idea of having everything "perfectly organized" - and this friction and uncertainty of where to put notes gets in the way of that. I'm the same. Every time I know that I don't have a proper place for a note I stop taking notes alltogether. I guess that's for the better.

loveparade··on If nothing is curated, how do we find things
I think you are bringing up an interesting discussion of curation vs. word of mouth. Where exactly do you draw the line?

Players counts kept increasing because a people came across the game on social media - upvoted reddit posts, high number of retweets, streamer sponsorships, etc. And a lot of that got rolling only because of initial positive reviews and PR. But isn't upvoting/downvoting something on reddit or other social media a form of curation? Is there even such a thing as pure word of mouth on the internet?

loveparade··on The great displacement is already well underway?
> im not a victim and i don't have victim mindset. i am survivor.

Anyone who uses the kind "labels" to describe themselves probably wouldn't even be considered for a job where I work. It's a massive red flag to most HR departments, especially in tech. Not trying to be offensive, but this has been my experience. You will probably have more success not trying to describe yourself in terms of politically-loaded labels.

loveparade··on Show HN: Factorio Learning Environment – Agents Build Factories
"put the right signals into my train network"

Not even humans can pass this benchmark.

loveparade··on Google edits Super Bowl ad for AI that featured false information
To be fair, do you believe a human would do better? If you hired someone to create content for your cheese website they would probably do the same thing. They'd search google and copy statistics without triple-checking all of them.

I don't think it's fair to frame this is an AI issue. The internet is simply full of misinformation. Should AI outperform the average human and detect misinformation? Maybe. But I don't think that's part of the current value prop, at least not for "non-reasoning" models. If you use an LLM you should be aware that what you're getting is whatever is most commonly found on the web. If that's not what you want, don't use an LLM.

loveparade··on How does DeepSeek work: An inside look
Article quality has IMO gone down considerably in the last 2-3 years ever since LLMs became a thing. Probably not because LLM articles are upvoted by humans, but more likely because it's much easier to create and manage realistic bot fake accounts with LLMs.

We're at a point where it's impossible to tell which users are bots and which are human by looking at their comments.

← PreviousPage 5 of 13Next →