HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

loveparade

2,076 karma · joined December 30, 2022

Meet Me At The Love Parade
submissionscomments
loveparade··on How does DeepSeek work: An inside look
IMO the more interesting question is why low-quality stuff like this keeps getting upvoted here. Feels like any submission that has AI in it automatically gets to the front page no matter the quality. Sad state of HN. I just can't imagine that people actually read this stuff and then decide to upvote because they found it useful. It's probably upvoted by people/bots who only read the title.

The whole reason I come to HN in the first place is to filter out BS clickbait articles exactly like this one, not to have them fill the front page.

loveparade··on When AI Promises Speed but Delivers Debugging Hell
In my experience, AI is good at building stuff in two scenarios:

- You have zero engineering background and you use an LLM to build an MVP from scratch. As long as the MVP is sufficiently simple there is plenty of training data for LLM to do well. E.g. some kind of React website with a simple REST API backend. This works as long as the app is simple enough, but it'll start breaking down as the app becomes more complex and requires domain-specific business knowledge or more sophisticated engineering techniques. Because you don't understand what the LLM is doing, you can't debug or extend any of it.

- You are an experienced developer and know EXACTLY what you want. You then use an LLM to write all the boilerplate for you. I was surprised at how much of my daily engineering work is actually just boilerplate. Using an LLM has made me a significantly more productive. This only works if you know what you're doing, can spot mistakes immediately, and can describe in detail HOW an LLM should be doing the task.

For use cases in middle, LLMs kind of suck.

So I think the comparison to a (very) junior engineer is quit apt. If the task is simple you can just let them do it. If the task is hard or requires a lot of context, you need to give them step by step instructions on how to go about it, and that requires that you know how to do it yourself.

loveparade··on DeepSeek-R1: Incentivizing Reasoning Capability in LLMs via RL
There has never been much secret sauce in the model itself. The secret sauce or competitive advantage has always been in the engineering that goes into the data collection, model training infrastructure, and lifecycle/debugging management of model training. As well as in the access to GPUs.

Yeah, with Deepseek the barrier to entry has become significantly lower now. That's good, and hopefully more competition will come. But it's not like it's a fundamental change of where the secret sauce is.

loveparade··on Ask HN: Anyone else find LLM related posts causing them to lose interest in HN
Crypto market cap is trillions of dollars, and how many crypto posts do you see these days? Not really a strong argument.
loveparade··on ChatGPT Search
I couldn't agree more. Neither LLMs or search engines yield reliable answers due to the ML model and misaligned incentives respectively. Combining the two is a shortsighted solution that doesn't fix anything on a fundamental level. On top of that we have the feedback loop. LLMs are used to search the web and write the web, so they'll just end up reading their own (unreliable) output over time.

What we need is an easier way to verify sources and their trustworthiness. I don't want an answer according to SEO spam. I want to form my own opinion based on a range of trustworthy sources or opinions of people I trust.

loveparade··on Math is still catching up to the genius of Ramanujan
If you are optimizing for finding geniuses like R, you may be right. Many probably fall through the cracks of the educational system. But I don't think this is what we are or should be optimizing for. The vast majority of people would end up unemployable if they weren't "forced" to study things they don't enjoy because some skills are just more employable than others. You're lucky if you enjoy engineering/science, but not so lucky if you only care about art literature.
loveparade··on Show HN: HN Update – Hourly news broadcast of top HN stories
Agree and I would add,

4. Skimming HN is useful in text-format because you can go deeper on something that catches your eye by following the link. The podcast format removes this because you can't click on something you hear and dive deeper into it. Skimming without the ability to dive into something is not useful, see next point.

5. High-level summaries are not my use case for HN, or any social media. They don't provide real value, just the illusion of value. What I want to dive deep into stories I am curious about. That can be done with TTS, but I would need to curate my feed first, and then use the podcast format to dive deeper into my curated stories.

I almost feel like this product would be more useful if you remove the LLM aspect and instead let me paste a list of HN threads into it and just TTS all of them, including the full comments. Then I could listen to this long-form content while driving or doing something else.

loveparade··on Nearly all of the Google images results for "baby peacock" are AI generated
I don't think the heuristics are that different. SEO-spam and BS content existed before, and both Google and YT were full of them, all made by human "content creators" who optimized for clicks and focused on gaming the YT recommendation system. AI content isn't that different. But unfortunately it's now 100x easier to generate such content, so we see a lot more of it. The problem is fundamentally a problem of incentives and the ad-based business model, not a problem of AI. AI has made the enshittification problem a lot more visible, but it existed before.

I don't know what the solution here is. My guess is that the "public internet" will become less and less relevant over time as it becomes overrun by low-quality content, and a lot of communication will move to smaller communities that rely heavily verifying human identity and credentials.

loveparade··on Google’s AI thinks I left a Gatorade bottle on the moon
Except that none of the fundamental limitations have changed for many years now. That was a few thousand papers ago. I'm not saying that none of the LLM stuff it's useful, it is, and many useful applications are likely undiscovered. I am using it daily myself. But people expecting some kind of sudden leap in reasoning are going to be pretty disappointed.
loveparade··on Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read?
What people forget to mention is when they have read a book. I read the Selfish Gene when I was a teen and it left a lasting impression. It was published in 1989. How the Mind works was published in 2011.

Reading the Selfish Gene today as an adult, when you've probably read a dozen similar books already, is not going to have the same effect. It's going to be pretty boring. That's why asking for book recommendations is flawed to begin with.

loveparade··on Google’s AI thinks I left a Gatorade bottle on the moon
Interesting, I feel pretty much the opposite. To me these podcasts are the equivalent of the average LLM-generated text. Shallow and non-engaging, not unlike a lot of the "fake marketing speech" human-generated content you find in highly SEO-optimized pages or low-quality Youtube videos. It does indeed sound real, but not mind-blowing or trustworthy at all. If this was a legit podcast found in the store I would've turned it off after the first 30 seconds because it doesn't even come close to passing my BS filter, not because of the content but because of the BS style.
loveparade··on An Intuitive Explanation of Black–Scholes
And it's a cycle. Supply and demand are partially driven by pricing models used by hedge funds, and variants of Black Scholes is one of those.
loveparade··on Tell HN: Is this AI doom loop? I thought o1-preview was amazing, until it wasn't
Yeah, but "reason" is not a well-defined term. It means different things to different people in different contexts. It's just marketing speech. You can easily argue that all ML models, even those from 50 years ago, can reason to some extent.
loveparade··on I am starting an AI+Education company
Not so sure about that. Because when you hunt around for things you know the source. If I watch a lecture by a math professor I can make a guess about the trustworthiness of the information. With an LLM, I can't.
loveparade··on Eight Years of GraphQL
Eight Years of GraphQL, and I have yet to find a single use case for it in my projects. I've had to interact with external GraphQL APIs a few times and each time it has been a terribly painful experience. Funnily enough, for the few queries where GraphQL would've actually been useful to get some deeply nested data structure, it was usually impossible to use it because the "query is too big/deep" or it had cycles
loveparade··on I am starting an AI+Education company
Yeah, because when it teaches you something you don't know you don't realize how many oversights it makes.
loveparade··on Deconstructing the Role-Playing Video Game
Now add things like Diablo 2 or Elden Ring to the mix, both of which are officially categorized as action rpgs. But they are a completely different experience and genre.

Some people don't like the term, but at least with JRPGs you know pretty much exactly what they are. Any other RPG term is completely meaningless because it's way too broad.

loveparade··on Ask HN: Most accurate scientific book on human sleep?
What the... I was expecting some kind of math slip up, which can happen to all of us, especially in front of a camera. But this is just scary. No matter how tired or nervous you are, this isn't a mistake an educated person should make.
loveparade··on Ask HN: Is anyone building automated long-term investing software?
There is no reason to make a long-term trading bot because that's what ETFs and various derivatives already are. They are algorithmic assets that you can customize according to your risk preferences, and you can just buy them.
loveparade··on Hokusai's 'Great Wave' features on new Japanese banknotes (2019)
Waifu banknotes would become worth significantly more than their nominal value... they may want to avoid that.
loveparade··on Brew-Nix: a flake automatically packaging all homebrew casks
Here are a couple:

- Learn Nix

- Homebrew can be a pain. I've had several occasions where it broke something on my system with its magic. The main reason for this is its imperative (as opposed to declarative) nature. You can easily install things that clash with other software installed on your system.

- You can easily install different versions of the same software without having to worry about clashes

- Fully declarative configuration. You know exactly what is installed on your system at any time.

- Portable reproducible configuration. Imagine you get a new laptop. Because you have have your system configuration declared with nix and home-manager you can copy the configuration file, run install, and your system is set up, exactly the way the old one was.

- To add to the above, you can also do the same with non-MacOS systems if you make your config conditional on MacOS. I sometimes want to work on a remote Linux machine. I can set up a full dev environment with all the tools I use locally with a single command now.

loveparade··on Brew-Nix: a flake automatically packaging all homebrew casks
Instead of Spotlight I use Raycast. It has been working great for me.
loveparade··on Brew-Nix: a flake automatically packaging all homebrew casks
This looks interesting. Personally I have been moving away from homebrew and use nix-darwin (https://github.com/LnL7/nix-darwin) with home-manager for my local software. It has been working great, but there are still a few packages that require Homebrew due to their complex build process. Maybe this helps.
loveparade··on What does it feel like to read RSS feeds?
I agree with the OP here. The biggest issue unsolved by RSS is customizability. You can pick what feeds you subscribe to, but that's your only level of control. HN, Reddit, Twitter, etc give you a feed of several hundreds posts per day. Most of them are irrelevant to my interests or filtering criteria. For example, I may only be interested in posts containing certain keywords, a certain amount of comment activity, or a certain number of upvotes/downvotes. Whatever it may be. The RSS protocol doesn't let you control this.

Of course, I can ignore anything I am not interested in. But the reality of the situation is that out of 30 minutes reading RSS feeds I spend 20 minutes filtering out stuff I am not interested in. Also, crucial information such as post popularity is missing because it's not available at publishing time and changes over time. "Social" is not part of the protocol.

You can argue that social media sites don't belong into RSS, but then you are removing the single biggest use case of RSS. If I can't put social media feeds into RSS it's useless to me because social media is exactly what overwhelms you with information and FOMO, which is what RSS should be solving.

loveparade··on Next-generation web framework Teo, supports Node.js, Python and Rust
I like the idea and it's not specific to web development. So many times in my career I've wanted to share a schema and data types of an application across languages that need to communicate with each other. For example, a C script that generates JSON data to be read in a Python notebook into the same data types.

I'm aware that serialization frameworks like protocol buffers do this, but they usually come with a whole lot of other baggage, dependencies, hit-or-miss language support, and clunky APIs. I want something more lightweight that allows me to start developing an application by developing its schema, without it being tied to a specific serialization framework or language implementation.

loveparade··on Ask HN: Who Went Mac –> Linux?
I have been a Mac user for about 10 years now and I'm now thinking about making the switch to Linux. I don't use Apple products on my Mac and all the Apple ecosystem apps get in my way more than they help. The biggest reason for my switch is gaming. Linux is pretty much on par with Windows these days, but Mac gaming is still nonexistent and an afterthought for nearly all developers.
loveparade··on Ask HN: What nonfiction books do you keep rereading?
I read that book and didn't take away anything from it. It left no impression. Maybe it should give it another try. Can you explain why you think it is so good?
loveparade··on Crypto Had Its Chance
This post here is as shallow as it gets. But surprisingly it hasn't been flagged and removed yet. It may eventually, but the opposite political side is usually removed/flagged within minutes or at most an hour.
loveparade··on Crypto Had Its Chance
Because all the pro-crypto posts are being flagged and removed, so these are the only ones left. Often see them in my RSS feed before they're removed. In general I recommend subscribing to HN via RSS feed only. Unrelated to crypto, it's absolutely crazy what kind of other stuff gets flagged and removed and how politically biased it is in certain topics. Echo chamber is an understatement.
loveparade··on Ask HN: How did you get yourself out of a rut?
Out of curiosity, how old were you when you got it checked?
← PreviousPage 6 of 13Next →