HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lstyls

378 karma · joined July 9, 2014

submissionscomments
lstyls··on Bad Character: If Chinese Were Phonetic
Point conceded, but it still doesn't take away from the broader point which is that the parent makes a false assertion:

> David Moser also arguing that the Chinese writing system is objectively inferior

lstyls··on Bad Character: If Chinese Were Phonetic
Pinyin Chinese is an international standard and keyboards would be basically unusable for writing Chinese characters without it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinyin.
lstyls··on Bad Character: If Chinese Were Phonetic
Not sure if you're trolling or not, but I'll bite.

Did you even read the article you linked to? The author makes so such argument. The point of the article is that it's extremely difficult for non-native speakers to learn written Chinese.

lstyls··on Bad Character: If Chinese Were Phonetic
Yep! His native language is English I believe.

I read this article as promoting phonetic languages. The entire premise of the article series is things that should never have been invented, so I don't think that's a leap here, even if he does hedge at the end with the "he has no idea if he would be better off in a world" thing.

lstyls··on Bad Character: If Chinese Were Phonetic
Care to add anything to the conversation, or are you just here to stereotype?
lstyls··on Bad Character: If Chinese Were Phonetic
Color me shocked that somehow the author found the alphabet of his native language to be superior.

This article takes as a given some assumptions that I don't understand at all. China being resistant to change? There are few cohesive societies that I can think of that have experienced more change than China since the end of WWII. And it would be an understatement to say that the rise of literacy rates are more strongly correlated with industrialization than adoption of phonetic alphabets.

I think it's telling that the author grew up in a Chinese-American community. Expat communities tend to lag their mother cultures in terms of social progress. An experience growing up in a community could explain this "steeped in tradition" characteristic that is attributed to Chinese culture here.

Disclaimer: I'm a white American. My wife is Chinese and emigrated herself from China as a young adult; I get a lot of my perspective from her. Would be interested to hear what Chinese members of HN think of the article.

lstyls··on Alphabet adds patent claim to Uber intellectual property theft lawsuit
As an existence proof: the infamous apple "rounded corners" patent[0] that was granted in 2012 is based entirely on design merits. There is nothing in the patent about details of manufacture from what I can tell. IANAL.

[0]: http://assets.sbnation.com/assets/1701443/USD670286S1.pdf

lstyls··on Ask HN: What does your production machine learning pipeline look like?
You're right about scale, but I think forgetting that the model training is on very different hardware than what production web and storage servers use.

Unless the have the need for dedicated GPU hardware at scale paying by compute unit still makes the best business sense.

lstyls··on Thinking About Recursion
This is a great analogy, but doesn't cover the set of recursive algorithms. It describes depth first search exactly.
lstyls··on Instacart in Talks to Raise $400M at $3B Valuation
I think you nailed it. I live in NYC and work too much, meaning I live and die by trading money for time. And every time I use instacart I regret it for the exact same reasons you describe.

The idea of hooking into some kind of warehouse management network makes a lot of sense. Does an API exist? Probably not. But there's an opportunity right there. Partner with a major warehouse management system, preferably one that works with Safeway or Stop n' Shop, and figure out a way to cut out the store visits altogether.

Of course this would mean automating away the shoppers :/.

lstyls··on The Essence of Event-Driven Programming [pdf]
Just realized that this is not even close to "like I'm five". Least bad thing I can come up with:

It's math for lazy computers talking to each other.

lstyls··on The Essence of Event-Driven Programming [pdf]
What I got from this paper is that the authors are using a flavor of symbolic logic called "temporal logic" to formalize concepts fundamental to the event-driven programming paradigm. The notation seems to make intuitive sense as an extension to the formal logic I learned in my undergraduate discrete math course.

I'm not all the way through the paper but I actually find it quite helpful in explaining the essential meaning of these concepts. I haven't worked with these concepts much, and the tutorials I've read in my free time have focused more on practical use of various implementations of eg futures rather than explaining their actual abstract meaning.

Caveat: I am not familiar with this academic domain so this is my own interpretation. If someone who is better versed can elaborate or correct me, please, please do so.

lstyls··on Scuba: Diving into Data at Facebook [pdf]
I don't know those platforms, but Scuba doesn't support relational operations. It's not as much of a limitation as it sounds like because you can log your data in a denormalized way.
lstyls··on Scuba: Diving into Data at Facebook [pdf]
Scuba made decisive tradeoffs in the functionality that it provides. Notable ones include that it doesn't support joins within a table, and doesn't provide any cross-table operations. Mostly it is used for basic filtering on constant values, and gathering summary statistics on those values. This is less of a limitation than it sounds like because when you know this ahead of time you just log your writes in a denormalized way and you don't need to join anything later.

As @ot said, Presto is just a query engine and it doesn't provide a backend. It provides an API that allows it to be plug in to different data warehousing systems. I would assume functionality depends to some extent on what your data is stored in, but in general Presto supports the full suite of standard relational db style queries.

Source: I work at FB as well. In fact I was using Scuba just now to do a quick analysis of our storage requirements for Scuba itself :)

lstyls··on On 2016 Apple: What do “Pro” users want?
> simplifying the connections to all external add-ons

The problem is that Apple did not simplify the connections. They unified them. The focus on a single hardware port is all well and good, but in this case it's just glossing over the fact that there are a wide array of different protocols that talk over this hardware and not all of the hardware supports them.

lstyls··on Penn Station Reborn
Did anyone else notice the test string at the bottom of the article?
lstyls··on Fast.com: Netflix internet connection speed test
I have TWC in Brooklyn and for a while was on the phone with Level 3 support often. Every time they had me use speedtest.net. So even their network engineers trust that site more than their in-house one.
lstyls··on In Memoriam: Ian Murdock
A suicide or homicide will almost certainly trigger a post-mortem. In the US the quality of the process varies widely by state. Some states have medical examiners, who are appointed and generally expert clinicians. Other states have a coroner system where the coroner is an elected position. Unsurprisingly states where the latter is true tend to have worse results.
lstyls··on Show HN: Potbox – A premium cannabis subscription club
No, one would not be better off making these arguments in court.

> Cannabis has demonstrated medicinal value, directly contradicting statute. Statue provides no evidence of, nor ability to verify, its claim that there is a lack of evidence of medical value.

Please cite a case of a law overturned in the US judicial system because of medical value.

> Individual prohibition requires a constitutional amendment a la amendment 18.

Again, please cite case law. I'm pretty sure you don't need a constitutional amendment to outlaw possession of a type of good.

> Founding leaders of US grew hectares of cannabis. System is in gross hypocrisy.

Seriously? It wasn't outlawed until the modern era. By your logic, should slavery still be legal since founding fathers owned slaves?

lstyls··on Evan Spiegel Reveals Plan to Turn Snapchat into a Real Business
Facebook pays its bills via selling ads, which is not the same as selling data. Snapchat can do same - I'm sure they have plenty of resources to help them do this, and Twitter is an example of a company with a similar user base that makes money. My point is that monetization does not necessarily lead to failure as you had asserted.
lstyls··on Evan Spiegel Reveals Plan to Turn Snapchat into a Real Business
> The issue, like every other person with a company like this, is that if there is even a hint of commercialization, the users will jump to the next "cool" thing.

Like what happened when Facebook monetized?

lstyls··on Chinese Men Indicted in Theft of Code from U.S. Tech Companies
I'm surprised nobody has pointed out yet that the headline is mistaken - no code was stolen in this incident. It was hardware designs that were stolen, as the first line of the article states:

>> "The Obama administration on Tuesday announced the arrest of a Chinese professor and the indictment of five other Chinese citizens in what it contended was a decade-long scheme to steal microelectronics designs from Silicon Valley companies."

lstyls··on Osquery Security Audit
Agreed, without details for others to learn from this post seems little more than self-promotion.
lstyls··on Facebook PathPicker
Even if this was the case (this was poor wording in the original PATENTS which has since been fixed) you are only subject to these constraints in any code you provide that includes the source code. Since this is a shell tool, that is largely irrelevant. For the same reason, you can compile and release binaries from closed source binaries using gcc even though it is licensed under GPL.
lstyls··on The Best and Worst Places to Grow Up in the U.S.
I grew up in central MN, and I agree that strong support of public education is likely the driving factor.
lstyls··on Why we are leaving Dropbox
I don't think there's a great opportunity there. Cloud storage is at this point a commodity product, so a new business would be differentiating entirely based on user experience and would be at a competitive disadvantage in storage costs compared to the big hitters.
lstyls··on NSA's Backdoor Key from Lotus Notes
I don't know much about crypto. This is bad I assume?
lstyls··on Silicon Valley doesn't create jobs; it's wiping out middle-class jobs
I 100% agree that there has always been sensationalism in journalism - that's nothing new. But back then the volume of print media was limited by physical factors - it was expensive to get an article in print. The new economics of media has fundamentally changed the business models. There was no print equivalent of Buzzfeed for example.

My point is that the barrier to entry for shoddy journalism is so low that articles like this are flooding the medium more than ever.

lstyls··on Silicon Valley doesn't create jobs; it's wiping out middle-class jobs
I agree to a point, but would qualify this to the problem being unfettered capitalism in a vacuum of social investment. The growth in the knowledge economy has such a huge potential to level the playing field - but it can only do so if there is fair access to good education.

Here in the US, only those with means have a decent chance of getting the kind of education that enables them to join in the new class of workers, which results in a feedback loop and a widening income gap.

lstyls··on Silicon Valley doesn't create jobs; it's wiping out middle-class jobs
Its so ironic that the author is a journalism professor. This article would make for a perfect Journalism 101 case study on cheap rhetorical tricks: appeal to anecdote, straw man, etc.
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →