5,379 karma · joined October 1, 2010
The concept of "waste" completely shifts. Like in 1990, I had to decide if dow loading an image was worth it, because it would take 5 minutes or more. Now, it isn't even a remote concern, even though images are clearly "wasting" bandwidth sending a 12mb image to my tiny phone screen.
It is much more interesting to think about the cultural impact of that shift. You can be concerned about the impact of AI on various fronts, but worrying about "waste" is tilting at windmills.
AI is simply going to bury it as a useful system. What will grow from the ashes will be something much more dynamic, where verifiable data is the gold and the conclusions and associated details will persist only as the human-level translation.
If you are on top of the AI, it is a powerful tool for exploration of ideas, organization of thoughts, bridging connections, outlining, filling in gaps.
But if you vibe write, it will look good on the surface but be full of illogical, contradictory statements, disconnected characterizations, etc.
The best comparison is photography. Instantly, a whole career path of portraiture was tossed out the window. Go to a museum and you see portrait after portrait - the best ones. There were millions of shitty ones made at all levels of society, and that job was replaced by cameras. But painting didn't go away, it got weird, it became anti-camera and more human, in a way.
This splitting of purpose and amplification of humanness is going to ramp up. Expect everyone to grow a taste for weirder, unprocessed music, experimental novels, wild and unexpected designs. Art is human communication and AI brings that into sharp relief.
Novels seem the most protected from AI - pulp/romance/beach novels will be crushed by volume and the sad remains of the publishing industry along with it, but interesting human novels will be just fine. And, much like with photography, I think AI will eventually normalize to its own artistic medium with writing, where careful usage will allow more ambitious work to appear that wasn't possible before, like a novel written using only sestinas, for example.
So I expect more of a sobering process for AI companies rather than a blowup, simply because they all still will have cash in the bank and some have actual products with clients that make use of them.
When everyone first uses AI they are swayed by its intelligent sounding sentence construction. It took time to be able to look past that and understand basic assuptions still needed to be questioned.
Some mathematicians (like SWEs) view AI as a boost to their ability to explore and understand possibilities - it is a great tool. Others see it as taking the soul out of what they do (loss of flow or craft). Most worry about losing their jobs.
I think for both mathematicians and SWEs, there is real loss for how we worked in the past, but I don't think job loss will be quite as severe as feared (and may actually increase). Because we still need, more than ever, people who understand the output and, more importantly, can ask the right questions.
When I was there it was wild to see a completely different array of plants and flowers. There is one small white flower that had petals that felt like some sort of sythentic material. There is a whole world that very few people experience or even know exists.
At work, even if Fable is technically better I much prefer Sol because it is so much faster and concise.
If you are offended by his math gifs and feel that the widely regarded best mathematician of our time should use embedded LaTex or something better, why not offer to upgrade his blog?
If we are going to include musicians, Tracy Chapman indeed seems like a troll when have the significantly more impactful Bob Dylan, who dramatically altered the musical and political discourse at a key time in American history. Tracy Chapman... had a few good hits?
The MRI example is very interesting - add a bit of noise and the crisp results fall apart. But we know we can carve out some determinism by orchestrating around LLM (validation loops) but they are only as good as the coverage of validation and the fidelity of expectations.
Which raises a fundamental question: where is the line between an effective harness and a broken one?
To put it in halting problem terms, if we have an outside program that checks the internal program for halting, we know we will capture some number of previously incatchable halting problems. How can we quantify this? We know there is a class of halts we can catch and prevent, but there will always be more complex ones that escape us.
In the real world, knowing the task is impossible doesn't impact the value of reducing the problem. More importantly, knowing which types of halting problems can be fully captured and which ones are intractable. Agent orchestration could directly benefit from layering a framework over this fuzzy space of knowableness.
Right now we mostly YOLO prompts with some docs/skills in the mix but I think it will start to look more like internal MCPs, with tools the LLM can string together. I think the reality will be most tasks end up serviceable by Haiku-level LLM, not Fable.
By the same measure, NVDA is Cisco, providing the backbone and capturing a ton of the early benefits, but soon becomes furniture while the excitement moves further up the chain.
After working with LLMs day-in, day-out an SWE for months, I feel like this could be greatly improved with something like a state machine of progress and proper orchestration. Instead of spinning up a ton of subagents to follow different paths, whip up some Markdown (or LaTex or whatever math-equivalent) to store summaries of attempted paths, and have the agent augment those docs. Leave a paper trail of what has been tried. Iterate on that paper trail and repeatedly examine it for untried alternatives.
LLMs can construct, navigate and summarize exceptionally well. Why is anyone trying to make them "hold the whole thing in your head"? I may be completely off the mark here since I have no math background, but my intuition for how LLMs are able to build on understanding through an external context store makes me feel like this isn't much different than someone trying to one shot a 3D game with Fable Max for $10,000 when they could get the same, or better, result with more human intention.
In general, I would not be surprised if 5.6 was a much better tool for high mathematics than Fable based on the abstract thinking. For my dev workflow, I have flipped my approach from planning with Opus 4.8 high and implementation with GPT 5.5 to planning with 5.6 high and implementation with Fable medium (and I might even drop to Fable low). This is only on the company dime, of course.