HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ludston

1,233 karma · joined July 3, 2012

submissionscomments
ludston··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (April 2025)
That's a cool project, but learning music via music theory is a bit like trying to learn English via grammar theory. It's backwards, and out of the hundreds of musicians I've met, I've never met one that walked that path.

Strong recommendation: Hire a teacher. Even with experience playing four instruments, and when I decided to learn another, I still hired a teacher.

ludston··on Basic Income Pilot Project: Study results
To be fair, there is a massive percentage of non-productive jobs that are mostly security guards for goods and locations, and many inefficient roles related to ticket clipping, inefficient distribution and marketing that all stimulate the economy without being productive.
ludston··on UK bans fake reviews and sneaky fees
It's like how when you buy something now you need to take a photo and email it to your local police station to prove you weren't buying drugs or something.
ludston··on The psychology behind why children are hooked on Minecraft
I know it is cynical, but this is such a puff piece that to me it feels like an advertisement.
ludston··on Doge staffer's YouTube nickname accidentally revealed his teen hacking activity
You can take the position of "achievement isn't a feeling of power" if you'd really like to, in which case I simply say find and replace all prior uses of "feelings of power" with "feelings of achievement" and the argument still stands. I'm happy to use whatever definitions you want. Taking joy from your success in doing things (whether you refer to it as achievement or power) is simply not an valid ethical justification when it is at the expense of violating other peoples right to control of their possessions.
ludston··on Doge staffer's YouTube nickname accidentally revealed his teen hacking activity
I don't know how to explain that the feeling of solving a puzzle is a "rush of power". If it weren't, you'd be equally happy fiddling with a pile of puzzle pieces and making no attempt to solve it as you were to searching for a solution.

There isn't anything inherently unethical about enjoying power, but neither is it in any way virtuous.

ludston··on Doge staffer's YouTube nickname accidentally revealed his teen hacking activity
I'm talking about the virtues that you've just tried to paint on people that practice breaking into other peoples computers for fun.

It seems like what you are looking for is a discussion about whether or not it it is ethical for bureaucrats and elected officials ought to circumvent or ignore their countries democratic processes and laws.

I'm sure there are some ethical justifications for doing this in some hypothetical situations, but really I'm not sure it's as useful to be discussing hypotheticals rather than specifics in this space.

ludston··on Why do we need modules at all? (2011)
Indeed! The traditional name for the proximity principle is called "cohesion"[1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cohesion_(computer_science)

ludston··on Doge staffer's YouTube nickname accidentally revealed his teen hacking activity
A lot of people like to tell themselves that breaking into other people's computers is about curiosity or activism or some other such virtue.

I don't see it. What I see is post-hoc rationalisation to justify lust for a feeling of power and control over others.

Practically any virtue you ascribe to "hackers" you can give to those kids that break into people's cars and take them on joyrides.

ludston··on Why do we need modules at all? (2011)
It is irrelevant until you have 4gb of binaries loaded from 50 repositories and then you are trying to find the definition of some cursed function that isn't defined in the same spot as everything it is related to, and now you have to download/search through all 50 repositories because any one of them could have it. (True story)
ludston··on Why do we need modules at all? (2011)
We need modules so that my search results aren't cluttered with contamination from code that is optimised to be found rather than designed to solve my specific problem.

We need then so that we can find all functions that are core to a given purpose, and have been written with consideration of their performance and a unified purpose rather than also finding a grab bag of everybody's crappy utilities that weren't designed to scale for my use case.

We need them so that people don't have to have 80 character long function names prefixed with Hungarian notation for every distinct domain that shares the same words with different meanings.

ludston··on Autology: A Lisp with access to its own interpreter
You can actually get completely stupid with this in Common Lisp using something called a "Reader Macro" which lets you temporarily take complete control over the interpreter.

For example, I have this joke project that defines a DSL for fizzbuzz:

https://github.com/DanielKeogh/fizzbuzz

ludston··on How the U.K. broke its own economy
> In February, the Bank of England reported an ongoing productivity slump so mysterious that its own economists “cannot account fully” for it.

And then goes on to immediately point out what I would expect to be the most obvious cause.

> Real wages have barely grown for 16 years.

Why would the general populous care to be more productive when they aren't going to see the profits?

ludston··on Every line is a potential bug (2009)
I'm looking at this feeling anxiety about whether or not the implementation of `map.get` is threadsafe with memories of deadlocks in unsafe hashset implementations whilst accessing values during resizing.

When what they really wanted here for bug free multithreading is some kind of promise or async await abstraction.

ludston··on I Went to SQL Injection Court
Arguably, all requests for files could be returned with all of the letters in the document but scrambled in a random order soas to obfuscate the file layout.
ludston··on I Went to SQL Injection Court
But on the other hand, in all database systems the schema is used to determine how the files are laid out. Although I suppose the same thing could be argued for any data that is stored in a file, excepting that a schema is metadata that determines the organisation of data so it's a bit of a special case.
ludston··on Why Clojure?
Even better than in small ones, because you don't need to spend 60 seconds building and restarting the application after changing one line: You simply redefine a single function at runtime and them can test the effect immediately.
ludston··on These years in Common Lisp: 2023-2024 in review
Common Lisp has Lisp in the name, but it is not the same thing. We're talking about languages developed 30 years apart here.

In the 80s, things like immutability just weren't pragmatic due to memory constraints, and CL was designed with pragmatism in mind. Scheme could be argued as FP. Clojure certainly is. CL is not.

ludston··on These years in Common Lisp: 2023-2024 in review
It also isn't one when "looking at it with the eyes of CS knowledge", given that Common Lisp has very powerful support for OO and procedural programming out of the box, and in order to most effectively use an FP style it's necessary to rely on community developed libraries...
ludston··on These years in Common Lisp: 2023-2024 in review
Common Lisp isn't a functional programming language to be clear.
ludston··on A style of leadership that is direct and forceful, yet also respectful (2023)
Eh, even when you don't like it, managing egos is an important part of being an effective leader. We're social creatures, and nobody wants to work with somebody that is comfortable humiliating them.
ludston··on Ask for no, don't ask for yes (2022)
It really depends on the culture of your organisation and how effective management is. If there is nobody that can act like this at your org it shows that your leadership team suffers from failure to delegate.
ludston··on Writing a Gimp 3.0 Plugin
As is tradition, all threads about an open source project must be kicked off with non-contributers putting shit on it unconstructively.
ludston··on Undergraduate shows that searches within hash tables can be much faster
Usually somewhere around seven.
ludston··on The Physicians Are Healing Themselves, with Ozempic
On the other hand, not having to carry around an extra 10-20kg everywhere you go is probably pretty nice.
ludston··on We are destroying software
The ones considered adults aren't so emotionally disregulated that they get angry about sometimes useful idioms.
ludston··on U.K. orders Apple to let it spy on users’ encrypted accounts
"Need" is obviously being used to refer to capability to execute interests here, and not requirement for survival. The US didn't need to have the cia help oust the Australian government in the 80s, nor did it need to install sympathetic governments across south America for the sake of its mineral companies, but it did it anyway. Russia does not have international mineral businesses with the capability to operate in these places in the same way the US does. Ethics of death only comes into it insofar as if the US did claim territory, it suddenly becomes responsible for the well being of the people living there, which it avoids by privatising the exploitation.
ludston··on Five coding hats
The difference is that code designed to be easy to read is not the same as code written to aesthetic principles. The easiest example of this I can think of is the difference between code that follows formal whitespace rules and code that gives variables long names so that it is easier to understand them. Or the difference between ensuring that none of the declarations at the top of a file are redundant vs ordering all of the function definitions such that they tell some kind of narrative.

Code can be aesthetic and yet hard to understand or ugly but obvious.

ludston··on U.K. orders Apple to let it spy on users’ encrypted accounts
One of the big differences between the USA and Russia, is that the US doesn't actually need to annex a country to get what it wants. The US historically acts on behalf of US owned businesses so they can extract mineral and fossil fuel wealth which is funnelled colonial era style back into the US economy. There is no need to plant a flag when it is cheaper and more efficient to achieve the same effect with Chevron.
ludston··on All Lisp indentation schemes are ugly
I can certainly think of examples where reading code is harder than writing it, but given that much of my professional role has been dissecting the horrible code written by other people in order to figure out not only what it does, but also what it was supposed to do, I simply disagree. Reading code is just more boring than writing it.
← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →