HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ludston

1,233 karma · joined July 3, 2012

submissionscomments
ludston··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
If you use "exist" to mean "is a symbol defined within some system" rather than the typical "has isomorphism with reality" then you can say literally anything exists. Unicorns exist because English has a word for them.

So be it, but it is a useless definition of exists then isn't it?

ludston··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
You can define a procedure that reaches 2 very trivially. e.g. you generate all possible 1 digit numbers, then 2 digit numbers, then 3 digit numbers, etc.

This is how natural numbers work in the first place. You're just adding a decimal point to all of the possible places it could go.

ludston··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
Yes? Take any natural or real number. If it has no decimal point add one. Then append any digit. Repeat as necessary.
ludston··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
> So in what sense is either one longer?

Neither. That's my point. Literally any definition of something infinite can always be reduced to a procedure that recursively transforms or observes some prior state. To say that one of these functions can produce more distinct states than another is pointless, because the procedure that produces the most states will always be the one that you ran the most times.

There is nothing observably infinite, since it would take infinite time to observe that any given thing was infinite. The only possible proof of infinity would be a machine that runs infinitely quickly. e.g. https://qntm.org/responsibility

ludston··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
A potentially infinite universe is also potentially finite? I.E. There is not sufficient evidence to determine that it is infinite since we are only able to make observations of a finite distance?
ludston··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
So what you're trying to say is that he has infinite apples?
ludston··on Georg Cantor and His Heritage
Nah, infinities don't exist. There are just recursive procedures that emit ever-increasing numbers of digits with no bounds checking.

The diagonal proof is just arguing that two nested while(true) loops will run for longer than one. (And then we define this as "bigger" just to confuse undergraduates)

ludston··on The Montreal problem: Why programming languages need a style czar
It's another example of bikeshedding.
ludston··on Piano on Paper
What? Why would they? Digital piano sounds still can't reproduce the richness of dynamics and texture of an acoustic piano. Practising on a digital keyboard and then performing on a real piano is jarring enough, let alone using an instrument with zero haptic feedback. This is pure gimmick.
ludston··on Three virtues of a great programmer
Wisdom is to know yourself. Hubris is the belief that your accomplishments and skills are greater than they are. Are these not mutually exclusive?
ludston··on Show HN: Pokemon prototype game made with JavaScript and p5.js
Copyright/trademark infringement though.
ludston··on Show HN: I'm open-sourcing my game engine
I mean it only takes an afternoon if you're just making it for yourself.
ludston··on Nvidia sued for stealing trade secrets: blunder showed rival company's code
It's quite a different from the analogy you suggest, as copilot is controlled by a single organisation and we know the address.
ludston··on GIMP 3.0 has a release schedule
Exactly. It's no skin off your nose. Which is why I don't understand the drive of commenters who try to take skin off the nose of the maintainers by bashing their free product.
ludston··on GIMP 3.0 has a release schedule
Usually when there is a post on HN about some open source project with a GUI there is a deluge of comments complaining about it for one reason or another. Even though it's free. I don't understand why.

Gimp is a wonderful piece of free software that I use often, and I greatly appreciate the work and time the maintainers are putting into it.

ludston··on 'Energy independent' Uruguay runs on 100% renewables for four straight months
It's pretty concerning that there are users on this platform operating like this given what it could imply.
ludston··on 'Energy independent' Uruguay runs on 100% renewables for four straight months
Why are there two replies to you with the same content but two user names?
ludston··on A Philosophy of Software Design
> And that part can be "design."

It's those design choices that are subject to all of the dilemmas that necessitate schools of thought such as those in "A Philosophy of Software Design". The mathematics hasn't been invented yet to determined the most efficient way to lay out complex software. And it won't be until long after our jobs are all replaced by fuzzy AI. Until then, software development is a performance art subject to many different schools of thought or philosophies of design, and you're fooling yourself if you think that you can escape from them.

At the end of the day, there is no mathematical formula to choose which color the border of a selected text-input should be: Only conventions, design philosophies, tastes and opinions.

The book you've linked (although I haven't read it all yet), provides a design philosophy for approaching a subset of the problems that computer programmers face. But: It doesn't have any writing on the hardest problems that programmers face in regards to IO and managing persistent state in a concurrent-access environment.

ludston··on A Philosophy of Software Design
I think I do understand your argument: In your view a formal theory has a level of rigour and evidence that exceeds that of a "best practice" such as SOLID. And I agree with that, but the point is that writing code based on formal theories is still just another software development philosophy with its own set of fuzzy trade offs. For example:

Given ten different calculuses with completely different syntaxes and modes of expression, (for example lamba calculus, combinatory calculus, a Turing machine, a type inference calculus, euclidean geometry, ultrafinitism), each and every one of these ought to be able to express a formal theory that is equivalent. When you are writing software based upon some theory, which calculus will you use to express it? A giant tree of lambdas? A state machine? Pure functions? Mathematically they are all proven to be equivalent so you must make a practical decision based on which one that you believe is best for the job. How will you make that decision? Most likely you will follow some set of personal heuristics that in your experience have shown one form of expression is easier for you than others. And thus you are adopting some philosophy of software even if you try tell yourself that you aren't.

ludston··on A Philosophy of Software Design
Ad hominem and an argument from authority in one breath. Or to summarize: Irrelevant.
ludston··on A Philosophy of Software Design
Formal theories are not independent of belief at all! They are based upon axioms, which are the beliefs that must be true in order for the formal theory to be useful.
ludston··on A Philosophy of Software Design
Yes probably. The only real difference between an opinion and a philosophy are the number of people that believe it.
ludston··on A Philosophy of Software Design
Mathematics and science can both be viewed as very fleshed out and practical branches philosophy, so they certainly aren't mutually exclusive.
ludston··on A Philosophy of Software Design
But don't forget that there are two reasons why something will not be obvious: It may not be obvious because the meaning is obfuscated, or it may not be obvious because it relies on the reader understanding certain ideas, concepts or technologies.
ludston··on Transactions Are Not Locks (2022)
The problem is that the industry standard of banking is eventually consistent. Whilst having atomic transactions is necessary, it's not sufficient: Using banks as a teaching metaphor for RDBMS systems is like using animals as a teaching metaphor for polymorphism. From a naive point of view it works, but it does more harm than good because students walk away thinking that they have a solution to a problem that isn't actually sufficient for it.
ludston··on The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology (2021)
From a purely profit focused standpoint, these jobs should very rarely exist. And yet, due to other incentives they do. E.g. because the owner might like being greeted on their way to work.
ludston··on The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology (2021)
Traditionally they'd be called "elevator operator" or "doorman" or some equally mundane/superfluous job.
ludston··on The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology (2021)
Whilst business owners have a financial incentive not to employ people, there are competing incentives. For example, non-owners are incentivised to have more people reporting to them because it increases their status and status is usually correlated with salary. In fact, when you are rich enough that money doesn't mean anything any more, you may as well have a bunch of people employed to do nothing but make you feel important and powerful.
ludston··on Transactions Are Not Locks (2022)
It's a deceptive example because banks are distributed systems (in that they interoperate with other banks/financial systems, and often have distributed internal database systems across multiple products too). Regular db transactions are insufficient for ensuring consistency across a distributed system, primarily because one of the systems may fail to commit their transaction after the other has succeeded. Even if there is only a single database, protecting data against concurrency issues is still non-trivial even with transactions.
ludston··on Bandcamp's Entire Union Bargaining Team Was Laid Off
Of course? The most famously talented people their lives teaching, mentoring and otherwise trying to lift up those around them. Could any person be an effective leader if they didn't enjoy the challenge of working with people with different values and motivations to themselves? I've certainly never seen one.
← PreviousPage 6 of 14Next →