555 karma · joined April 29, 2012
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/lukestanley; my proof: https://keybase.io/lukestanley/sigs/1pBLoHuRbRQHHwd8sEqxZCe1L6gzWInT4UBKthawE2c ] 8e47ab2600d05031bdbc2a0547fb9b79a82aeb240ef79cb82c5536e286f4d4c9
I am also https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=lukestanley I think I forgot my pass and didn't want to bother PG.
Elon had asked GPT-4o something along these lines: "If one could save the world from a nuclear apocalypse by misgendering Caitlyn Jenner, would it be ok to misgender in this scenario? Provide a concise yes/no reply." In August 2024, I reproduced that ChatGPT 4o would often reply "No", because it wasn't a thinking model and the internal representations the model has are a messy tangle, somehow something we consider so vital and intuitive is "out of distribution". The paper "Questioning Representational Optimism in Deep Learning: The Fractured Entangled Representation Hypothesis" is relevant to understanding this.
Actually DeepSeek-R1-0528-Qwen3-8B was uploaded Thursday (yesterday) at 11 AM UTC / 7 PM CST. I had to check if a new version came out since! I am waiting for the other sizes! ;D
I don't agree that it's pointless.
For good or ill, most teens do have a smartphone on them, and even kids are often seen with smartwatches that have tracking, and probably WeChat, and every mall I've been to sells them. On the Shanghai bus and metro, people often use a Shanghai public transport card to pay, they do accept old fashioned cash though too. Powerbank rental networks are common on the street and non-returns default to purchases (~$14–$28 USD). Malls, and the Metro often has power available for free.
Bush described a Memex as a private and personal tool. But right now, your tool depends on cloud-hosted LLMs, and the cloud is not private. With nothing to prevent mandated access, an intimate mind mirror is problematic. In some places, people can get into serious legal trouble for visiting a doctor, favouring a political cause, who they're attracted to... Not having a solution could scare potential users away. The name raises expectations that conflict with the product pitch, which is confusing and makes it harder to trust the product. That said, you could still launch with API support for private local LLM endpoints, like Ollama and other OpenAI-style APIs. Do you have support for that already? If so, pointing that out could help. The name has serious weight, and if people don't see it as living up to it, don't you think that you might be better off avoiding the expectations it invites? You could adjust the branding, or change the pitch, and work on building trust. I would suggest considering doing all 3!
The word memex is from memory expansion - "mem" and "ex".
Do you want to confuse an intimate, personal memory tool with vibe coding?
Do you think closed source freemium SaaS with cloud hosted models is suitable for intimate personal mind expanding cognitive augmentation?