HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lwouis

428 karma · joined October 14, 2019

submissionscomments
lwouis··on You can have geothermal power everywhere if you drill deep enough
Independence is a pipe-dream. You always depend on others and physical resources. If you install a solar panel to "become independent from centralized energy systems", you're moving from a dependence to established energy networks to another type of dependence. You now depend on people making, delivering, maintaining panels for you. As well as the batteries to store the energy.

No-one can make or repair this take themselves. You just moved the dependence from one system to another. The current system is also battle-tested and mutualized. Outage see lots of people on deck to fix things. If your solar installation panel breaks it's your individual problem and it will quickly reveal just how dependent you actually are.

The only way to be independent of other humans would be to live a lifestyle which requires only rudimentary knowledge, and the muscles of your body. Probably only hunter-gatherer. Anything beyond that means you rely on knowledge, skills, and muscles of other, and dependent on them for your life.

Maybe you knew all this, but it may still be useful for other readers to realize since these days we hear a lot of prophets telling us how we should increase our independence by installing solar panels or wind turbines. And people don't think twice about where these come from, and who will maintain them.

lwouis··on Weak vs. Strong Memory Models (2012)
I must say as a non expert on the topic, i don't understand the downvotes. I wish people who downvoted would take a moment and explain what they disliked
lwouis··on NFT marketplace shuts, citing 'rampant' fakes, plagiarism problem
Every week, I read some new grotesque story about NFC. Every time I'm reminded of the movie Idiocracy.

We have 2 billion people in poverty. Climate change threatens our sedentary civilizations. We still have no clue what's going on in the universe and how to make sense of it.

And yet somehow enough of us participate in this circus that it make the news, and I have to witness pathetic drama stories about screenshot-ing monkey drawings, people spending 250M dollars to encode a book onto a chain, NFT marketplaces centralizing into traditional model while operating on a technology that literally and non-ironically requires "gas fees" for simple transactions because of how inept the tech is.

Gas fees. In the same world that holds COP events every year to try and get us to not self-extinct from our own waste products.

What a sad show this is.

lwouis··on The Polygons of Éric's Chahi Another World
I think a lot is transferable. It depends on what your daily job is. Retro-gaming and emulation is low-level. So if your job is low-level like systems, OS, embedded, etc, then it's transferable experience/knowledge.
lwouis··on Switching from macOS to Pop_OS
I made a FOSS alt-tab drop-in for macOS: https://alt-tab-macos.netlify.app/

I also list alternatives on that page. That may inspire you

lwouis··on macOS Setup after 15 Years of Linux
Lots of links/tips on windows management on macOS in this thread. For people interested, you can check out my FLOSS app which brings Windows alt-tab to macOS: https://alt-tab-macos.netlify.app/

I investigated this space for years so check out the list of alternatives on the page linked above as well.

Also note that i'm looking for someone to take over the project: https://github.com/lwouis/alt-tab-macos/issues/1179

lwouis··on Running IntelliJ Idea with JDK 17 for Better Render Performance with Metal
You clearly don't know what IntelliJ offers. I've been paying a high price for their tools for years now, and will not stop. My colleagues are often on VSCode so i've forced myself to use it and learn it so i could help them when they struggle, especially junior people.

The difference is night and day. VSCode is a light code editor. IntelliJ is a rich IDE.

The database tool in IntelliJ is better than all other specialized DB software i've tried last year when i did a market study to try and find a good DB tool. That tool is hardly even advertised and is like 1 button out of 100 buttons in the IDE. The diff tool is another example of top of the industry software rivaling stuff like Beyond Compare.

Bottomline is you seem to not have dug into it before sharing your judgment of it with people who have

lwouis··on Ask HN: What is humanity building towards?
> civilization is becoming better (over time) by every single measurable metric.

CO2 concentration in the atmosphere is increasing. Fossil fuel, metals, and other one-off resources being depleted at exponential rate. Biodiversity is collapsing -5 exponential rate.

We are on our way to a grim future by all measurable metric i can think of. The metrics you have in mind are great for the here-and-now, but a blink in the longer timeframe of our species.

lwouis··on Kintsugi – Art of Repair
For example, angular, react, vue, etc. You can follow these tools as their popularity comes and go, but at the end of the day they exist on top of HTML/CSS/JS. So while these 3 basic blocks are there to stay forever, the tools on top are a game of musical chairs.

I'm not saying that they are bad. I've been using them at works for years. I'm saying that some people chose to focus on "old" tech and produce web pages and webapps without much tools. The advantage of this approach is that your environment is stable so you can actually learn and master the tools. You can even find crazy tricks and "abuse" some of the features as you become really good at those.

It can be liberating to stop changing tools every year, but instead learn the intricacies of the basic tools that will never change.

lwouis··on Kintsugi – Art of Repair
> They were replaced with [FOTM mills] as soon as better alternatives became available (probably during the industrial revolution?).

This is not true. The definition of "better" doesn't exist as it's subjective. Windmills of all types exist today, and co-existed back then. Some people like certain trade-offs, and other people like other trade-offs. Saying for example that a metal tool is better than a wood tool is simply wrong. Some people to this day use very old technology, very much on purpose, because they deem it superior. People still marvel at stone buildings even though modern buildings use cement. There are different types or cement actually and all have pros and cons. Like Roman cement may last longer at the cost of needing more time/money whereas modern cement can be mass produced.

You can find analogies in software where old C tools are to this day cherished by many. Another example is people collecting retro hardware, or recreating old software like SerenityOS.

Some "improvements" may not be seem as such by some users, the same way an old master cheese maker does not see an industrial steel milk mixer as an improvement for what they are trying to do, as well the lifestyle they are trying to promote.

lwouis··on Why don't you accept donations?
> You can’t pay rent with smiles.

You do. Make an effort to think of the many cases in life where people do things for each other without money. Parents will host you for free, shelters do it, woofing or being au-pair, etc.

Open-source can be run like a business, but it can just as well be run like a shelter, or language-enthusiasts club, and any other form of human social organization.

In the same way, people do ride-sharing for a fee, yet you can also put your thumb in the air and people will gladly share their ride for free.

Humanity has many facets to it

lwouis··on Bulgaria's new eGov minister is a software engineer
Of course it's valid to want your website to serve users of IE6 or iPad1. You may not care for such users but not everyone is like you, living in your country, caring about the things you care about.

There are many valid use cases for HTTP, and more broadly, keeping old devices and experiences working as time passes

My country (France) has many buildings and bridges from 500 years ago for instance. I hope these get preserved as there is a lot to learn from them, lots of beauty in them, and they may be more and more relevant in the future.

Not everything should disappear the instant there an alternative. Things co-existing is great.

lwouis··on Kintsugi – Art of Repair
The spirit of this, caring for objects that have helped people for a long time so they can be used for years to come, is something I try to develop in regards to software.

I try to point out to people who use words like "legacy" as an insult that the system having reached that status and still being maintained is a sign that it has served a lot in the past and probably can if maintained with care. I think the "my dream would be to rewrite it from scratch using [FOTM language]" is a bad mindset.

I think we should be curious about old software like we are about many physical old objects. You wouldn't visit a windmill and call it a terrible relic of the past; you would marvel at how ingenuous people had been with so little back then).

By cherishing and caring for what we have been handed over, we have a great opportunity to maintain and improve it, and hand it over to the next generation/team.

I live in Japan where the care for other people work is everywhere, and i can witness how it then motivate people to do their best, and cultivate a culture of respect and care.

lwouis··on Bulgaria's new eGov minister is a software engineer
HTTPS is not a strict improvement over HTTP. Indeed it adds SSL requirements to the client, increases resources needed to access/serve the content, requires to acquire and maintain a certificate, etc.

It's a common practice to offer HTTPS, but you shouldn't think of it as dogma. It's perfectly reasonable to provide both so that people using old terminals (an iPad v1, or an old game console for example) can access the content without technical issues. Or if you want a very low-resources device to access it.

It's all trade-offs and use-cases. One is not a superset of the other.

It's like saying every door should have a lock. No, not every door is improved by adding a lock. Many use-cases are actually not possible with a lock.

Different situations have different tradeoffs, and different people value different things.

lwouis··on Why don't you accept donations?
Money as the end-all-be-all is pretty new. I notice it a lot in American culture in particular.

People have dedicated their life to all sorts of endeavors in the past, and still do of course. Big religions are a prime source of people doing large amounts of work for no money.

It's quite odd to me to think that any activity i engage in should be to accumulate these tokens. Something i do stuff for the process itself. Sometimes to get a smile from people. Sometimes to see more beauty around me. Etc

lwouis··on The unexpected return of JavaScript for automation
macOS APIs have poor documentation overall, but JXA is on another level. It's not even like Carbon APIs which are still necessary to use today, but which documentation was removed from Apple's website. At least here, you can find an archive somewhere. No, JXA was simply never documented.

You basically have the AppleScript docs, which themselves are under-documented, and you have to guess what JXA APIs exist based off it. My recommendation is to use Safari and play with the debugger at runtime. That way you can test and see which APIs are available by trial and error. You can also hack around and display JS objects internal variables/prototypes to get an idea of what things may be available.

I've had to dig deep into this for my FOSS app recently, and I'll like to share these 2 gems of very-hard-to-find information:

- How AppleEvents (AppleScript or JXA triggered events) permission works (https://www.felix-schwarz.org/blog/2018/08/new-apple-event-a...)

- (Bitter) testimony from someone involved at JXA's inception (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21803874)

Hopefully this message saves someone hours of research~

lwouis··on Apple isn’t patching all the security holes in older versions of macOS
I find fewer and fewer new features motivating an upgrade. These days it's integration or fluff like tracking the time you spend on each app. I'm on Catalina and have no incentive to upgrade, but have many incentives not to (e.g. breaking compatibility)
lwouis··on Don’t do interviews, do discussions
I don't think there is anything you can do to prevent rich kids from having an easy life.

They are not numerous though, but definition. So the concern shouldn't be too large as well. In France where i'm from, and also here in Japan, i see the education system as mostly working. People get educated and the people more designed for more study can pursue while other go working before them. This seems to work enough to me. I wouldn't know how to improve it without regressing more on other fronts, for instance

lwouis··on [dead]
The demo link sent me to a straight-up scam website...
lwouis··on It’s mostly a demand shock, not a supply shock, and it’s everywhere
Personally, I don't want any more growth. Infinite growth is not sustainable. Developed countries are way past what's necessary for a good life.

I'd like to advocate for a slow controlled de-growth so we can reach climate agreement goals, and sustain humankind for a few more centuries, in decent living conditions.

lwouis··on Don’t do interviews, do discussions
I read a lot of anti-diplomas ideology, especially from US culture. Over the years I've realized that the multi-years selection people go through in academia is a decent and most importantly long process to select people.

A lot of the conversation is on interviews these days, on the idea that anyone can be a genius programmer after a bootcamp. While I don't deny it's possible, I think traditional selection based on the school people went to, and building a relationship between companies and school is a good thing.

Trying to holistically evaluate a worker in a few hours is not nice. It's very intense for candidates to have such opportunities to unlock in such a short time. People prepare for interviews intensely, and can live rejections as a deep traumas as a result. Having this process happen over years in academia seems healthier, and more accurate.

Companies would benefit from having their HR spend time studying curriculums of some schools, and build relationships. That guarantees a steady flow of qualified workers.

I see this where I live here in Japan, and I'm quite found of the work culture / society it produces.

lwouis··on Never update anything
Oh that's where i read that. Thanks!

I believe the point i made still stands though

lwouis··on Never update anything
I really appreciate people like you reminding most everyone that new != better. I live in Japan which people usually mock for still using fax machines, or keeping "the old ways" in many aspect of society.

There are important positive things that people don't realize are lost as we "modernize" society.

For example, these days the TV spies on my usage and sends that data back to the maker company; they will then sell it to advertisers. Every update is aggressively pushed to me, and after i accept it, i notice more ads (rebranded "you may enjoy" or "now trending") on the home screen.

Another example would be how awesome paper is. It displays information without requiring an energy source. It can be folded and unfolded. May not impress you until your phone battery dies on a trip or at the airport/stadium where you need to present your e-ticket

lwouis··on Never update anything
"Breaking" is undefinable. I remember reading about some user complaining that a small bugfix broke their work setup because it fixed a bug that used to make the CPU go 100% when the spacebar was held. The user would hold it with a weight and get the CPU to make heat that way. The small fix broke his experience.

There are many other examples of this. Breaking compatibility by fixing bugs people rely on for instance.

Any change can break something for a user downstream. It's a very subjective evaluation for the producer to imagine potential impact to their consumers. It's easier if the relationship is rich and exclusive. In open-source where people do it on their free time and have thousands of consumers with widely different interests, it's pretty much impossible to label the release in a way that's conveying the right message to every user.

Semver, the way i see it, is just a way for the producer to subjectively label the amplitude of changes. The consumer should then ideally be familiar with the producer and get a sense of how they work and what they perceive as big. Still at the end of the day it's a very subjective judgment call system that doesn't offer real guarantees to consumers. If your software needs to be stable, don't upgrade, or spend time to review the changes in the dependencies. The version numbers are no guaranty.

lwouis··on Seeding oceans with volcanic ash could be new tool to tackle climate change
Societies of the past had to deal with this. We still deal with this in wealthy societies actually. When the US west coast is hot and dry, authorities ration water usage.

I can imagine governements doing a more serious job and limiting more things for the common good (aka we don't kill ourselves by destroying our environment)

lwouis··on Seeding oceans with volcanic ash could be new tool to tackle climate change
You're looking at bacterias on a petri dish. They are exponentially taking over the dish and soon will collapse under their own activity.

That's us. An advantage we have over the bacterias is that we can discuss together how we will face the limits of our box.

Saying "not slowing down and consuming everything in the dish is not serious" confuses me. It's the only serious thing here. Everything else is noise before we collapse.

Exponential scale is scary. Bacterias doubling every cycle means 1 cycle before the bottle is full, it's half full. You're looking around and there is still plenty of room. Next cycle it's 100% and you're gasping for air.

Humans don't double every cycle but you only need 7% growth to double in 10 years.

So when you hear that we use X% more steel or coal every year, keep in mind it's a doubling cycle every few years.

Reducing consumption (per capita and/or population size) is the only serious discussion to not hit the walls and gasp for air

lwouis··on Seeding oceans with volcanic ash could be new tool to tackle climate change
We moved from having a few new clothes a year to having new clothes as often as we want. We have also exponentially grown our population.

An Earth with let's say 2 billion people at 2 set of clothes a year has considerably less environment impact that an Earth with 8 billion people averaging let's say 10 set of clothes a year.

The scale of deforestation to produce coton, and the boom of the plastic fiber industry are sizable phenomenons with huge visible consequences. Whole industries exist now in Bangladesh and Vietnam for instance that didn't exist 20 years ago. Factories, supply chains, large yearly resources consumption, etc.

These changes are visible anywhere from the shops of wealthy nation cities, to Google Earth timeline where you see entire forests disappear every year now (rate is exponentially accelerating)

lwouis··on Seeding oceans with volcanic ash could be new tool to tackle climate change
Any time we increase efficiency, we also increase consumption. 5G increases efficiency, it's true. Now people consume more. It's enables new usages which people will jump on.

This happens in History every time we improve efficiency. Cars now consume a fraction of what early cars did, yet we use these efficiency gains to stuff them with gadgets, and make them bigger, and overall they still consume more than they used now in absolute terms.

In other words the engine inside your modern car is more fuel efficient than the first Ford, but we now make SUV that consume way more to produce and operate, can't be repaired/services easily, and people own multiple of them per household.

This "rebound effect" can be seen everywhere

lwouis··on Seeding oceans with volcanic ash could be new tool to tackle climate change
5G is a new park of machines for the network operators. It's also a new park of machines for the consumers.

It's huge because we are so numerous.

Imagine you renew a boat fleet. Imagine the impact on the nearby forest. Going from no boats to having a fleet may be worth the damage. Going from a very good fleet to a slightly more advanced fleet may not be worth it.

Network infra and smartphones are the same. They require us to mine all their components and use energy to transform them.

4G seems to provide enough value to me. I don't like the tradeoff we get of "i can download 4K in the elevator now" (seems unnecessary to me) vs "we unleashed megatones of CO2, mined out large cobalt mines that will never form again in milleniaz to come, etc (seems critical to me)

lwouis··on Seeding oceans with volcanic ash could be new tool to tackle climate change
My proposition is that we have to deal with our scale if we don't want to be the bacterias that took over the petri dish and died because they made their environment toxic for themselves.

We have never had to care so far because we were not numerous. Now human activity is similar to geological forces like rain/volcanoes/etc and i think we should plan how we can exist on a stable cycle.

Mindless growth leads to us breaking our environment through our scale. Scale is exponential so after thousands of years we have a small window of 100 years where we grew so high in impact that we may break it all. It's a first for us, and i hope we can see further than the mold in the petri dish and make a concerted plan on how to live in a stable cycle without growing.

I'm advocating for planning a sustainable future. It's the first time in History we have to deal with this. People assume the future is like the past, and other incorrect things. They also live in cities, removed from physical realities. They only understand the collapse of species through some stats in a newspaper they forget the next day, and the energy/resources supply chains are unknown to them until there is a blackout and they lose internet for a few hours.

The future seems bleak in many ways for physical reasons. I don't think pretending we are not reaching planetary limits will help. I think it will make the fall harder. I would rather we concert and plan together what level of quality of life we want, and how we can stabilize our population, so we can cycle generations of human in a sustainable way.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →