HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lz400

1,058 karma · joined November 29, 2016

submissionscomments
lz400··on How OpenAI uses complex and circular deals to fuel its multibillion-dollar rise
Even if/when the bubble pops, I don't think NVIDIA is even close to need rescuing or being in trouble. They might end being worth 2 trillion instead of 5 but they're still selling GPUs nobody else knows how to make that power one of the most important technologies in the world. Also, all their other divisions.

The .com bubble didn't stop the internet or e-commerce, they still won, revolutioned everything, etc. etc. Just because there's a bubble it doesn't mean AI won't be successful. It will be, almost for sure. We've all used it, it's truly useful and transformative. Let's not miss the forest for the trees.

lz400··on Public Montessori programs strengthen learning outcomes at lower costs: study
Very interesting story. If I may ask, looking back, do you blame Montessori for the “lack of real world preparation” or do you think rather that it was the regular school that had a bad system and you were in a better one and should have stayed there? If you had stayed there until uni do you think you’d adapted well to higher edu?
lz400··on Public Montessori programs strengthen learning outcomes at lower costs: study
I want to offer a different data point. I took my daughter to a Montessori-adjacent school for 3 years. It's not Montessori exactly and they didn't advertise as such but they had a different European name attached to it that is downstream from Montessori. They had multi-age education, stressed in children directed learning and individual growth, they didn't have exams, etc.

I changed my daughter this year and overall I'm disappointed in that school. There were many issues but the most important ones to me where:

- No exams, only individual growth meant there's no guarantee the kid is learning at a good pace. When I worked with her at home I could easily identify many gaps and deficiencies. She's now struggling a bit in her new school because of this but I think it will resolve soon.

- Because they didn't like comparing kids to standards or among each other the feedback I received was useless. It was always "she's doing excellent, we see strong growth" but it wasn't true.

- The school rejected most parent feedback and issues raised with something "maybe this style of education is not for you". For example, I know of a few other kids that had to leave because the school didn't take action against bullying because they didn't believe in punishments, etc.

I have to say there were good things too, in particular my daughter really enjoyed it there and formed strong bonds with other kids. I think in general it was ok for elementary education but I strongly think it's not after that and I now have a perhaps unjust bias against Montessori and derivatives.

lz400··on What Americans die from vs. what the news reports on
That's not correct. It counts the total number of school shootings. Some of those shootings had no victims. The total of students shot is also provided with some more elaboration with charts here.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-12-17/us-school-shootings-2...

As you can see your number of 13 makes no sense, there were 200-300 students shot (!)

lz400··on What Americans die from vs. what the news reports on
I think there are actually more school shootings than mass shootings because mass requires ~4 victims and school doesn't. There were ~330 shootings in 2024. 70 people died. 200 wounded.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-12-17/us-school-shootings-2...

lz400··on What Americans die from vs. what the news reports on
>School shootings in 2024 dipped slightly from the year before, but the 330 school shootings recorded last year still mark the second-highest number since 1966

https://www.k12dive.com/news/school-shootings-2024-near-reco...

lz400··on What Americans die from vs. what the news reports on
You guys had a shooting last year, but school shootings in the US average to ~1 per day
lz400··on Suno Studio, a Generative AI DAW
> And listeners/consumers can tell the difference between art created with intent and soul, and a pale imitation of that.

Strong disagree there. I think that's true of a very small % of consumers nowadays. I mean, total honesty, I think that Suno is not worse than a large fraction of the commercial pop made by humans (maybe) that tops the charts regularly. It's already extremely formula based artificial music made by professional hit makers from Sweden or Korea.

The objective was never to grab discerning listeners but the mass of people. It would work even if they grab 50% but honestly I think it's going to be higher.

lz400··on Microsoft is officially sending employees back to the office
What I find repugnant (but not surprising) is that with the same earnestness and confidence they're announcing that RTOs are for the betterment of their own workforce, they were announcing the same thing about WFH just a couple of years back.
lz400··on Wikipedia survives while the rest of the internet breaks
This reminds me of donating again, thanks
lz400··on Trump to Rebrand Pentagon as Department of War
Might be my perception from my algorithm curated news / social media feeds, but to me it looks like Trump's strategy of doing so many outrageous things every day that most of them go through unnoticed or unchallenged is working. And, after a while, the Overton window definitely shifts.
lz400··on Anthropic raises $13B Series F
That’s probably what the companies spending the money think, that they’re building a huge moat. There’s an alternative view. If there’s a bubble and all these companies are spending these huge sums on something that ends up not returning that much on that investment, and the models plateau and eventually smaller, cheaper, self-runnable open source versions get 90% of the way there, what’s going to happen to that moat? And the companies that over spent so much?

This article is a good example of the bear case https://www.honest-broker.com/p/is-the-bubble-bursting

lz400··on When did AI take over Hacker News?
But that makes sense, technology makes headlines when it's exciting. Crypto I'd disagree there's been advances, it's mostly scams and pyramid schemes and it got boring and predictable in that sense so once the promise and excitement is gone, HN doesn't talk about it anymore. Self driving cars became a slow advance over many years, with people not claiming it was around the corner and about to revolutionize everything.

AI is now a field where the claims are, in essence, that we're going to build God in 2 years. Make the whole planet unemployed. Create a permanent underclass. AI researches are being hired at $100-300m comp. I mean, it's definitely a very exciting topic and polarizes opinion. If things plateau and the claims dissappear and it becomes a more boring grind over diminishing returns and price adjustments I think we'll see the same thing, less comments over it.

lz400··on Streaming services are driving viewers back to piracy
That's a bit of an edge case, powered by the absolute, lovely turbo-nerdery of a few dedicated souls. They are called 4K77 / 4K80 versions for people looking for them.
lz400··on Reflections on OpenAI
I mean, they're wrong? LLMs don't have agency, don't learn, don't do anything except react to prompts really.
lz400··on Reflections on OpenAI
Not sure about that one. I do agree with the AI bros that, _if_ we build AGI, ASI looks inevitable shortly after, at least a "soft ASI". Because something with the agency of a human but all the knowledge of the world at its fingertips, the ability to replicate itself, think at order of magnitudes faster and paralelly on many things at the same time and modify itself... really looks like it won't stay comparable to a baseline human for long.
lz400··on Reflections on OpenAI
Engineers thinking they're building god is such a good marketing strategy. I can't overstate it. It's even difficult to be rational about it. I don't actually believe it's true, I think it's pure hype and LLMs won't even approximate AGI. But this idea is sort of half-immune to criticism or skepticism: you can always respond with "but what if it's true?". The stakes are so high that the potentially infinite payoff snowballs over any probabilities. 0.00001% multiplied by infinite is an infinite EV so you have to treat it like that. Best marketing, it writes itself.
lz400··on Why Is Fertility So Low in High Income Countries? (NBER)
I think at this point the better question is: why in the past fertility was so high? and I think the reasons were mainly that people _relied_ on their children to grow up and take over the farm and take care of their parents. They were also mortally bored and children are fun. They had them for selfish reasons.

But nowadays? why would you have a child? for a middle class+ family in a developed country, having a child is a 6 figures expense over their lifetime, limits your career, holidays, etc. From a selfish point of view, it doesn't make a lot of sense.

I don't think it's the only explanation but children are, individually, optional so you can, for selfish reasons, do it or not.

lz400··on Uv and Ray: Pain-Free Python Dependencies in Clusters
the problem is that you still need to install all the low level stuff manually, conda does it automatically
lz400··on Uv and Ray: Pain-Free Python Dependencies in Clusters
Unfortunately uv is usually insufficient for certain ML deployments in Python. It's a real pain to install pytorch/CUDA with all the necessary drivers and C++ dependencies so people tend to fall back to conda.

Any modern tips / life hacks for this situation?

lz400··on "AI Will Replace All the Jobs " Is Just Tech Execs Doing Marketing
not all of them, but that's not the issue, the issue is 100 engineers + AI replacing 500 engineers
lz400··on xAI has acquired X, xAI now valued at $80B
IMHO the US is turning into an oligarchy / autocracy like Russia. Musk is one of the oligarchs. We all know what happens to oligarchs when they get too close to eclipse the top dog and go near a window.
lz400··on Oxygen atoms discovered in most distant known galaxy
I think on average trusting the experts is the right thing. And by the way LK99 is not even particularly damning, as far as we know it was science working as intended
lz400··on Oxygen discovered in most distant known galaxy
I think this is a real problem but your post is an exaggeration. There are cases of fraud in science. There is a reproducibility crisis in some areas. There are political angles and rent seeking wrt grants. But how widespread is it? You're assuming it's close to 100% without evidence. I don't claim to have the exact number but intuitively yours is extraordinary (so it would need extraordinary evidence). I think these issues affect some areas much more than others and some regions more than others. I still believe science is the best way of enquiry for the natural world.
lz400··on Zelensky leaves White House after angry meeting
I've watched it. I disagree. Zelensky calmly and reasonably asked JD Vance a question regarding his answer to the reporter. It was all fine until Vance started with the "frankly I think it's very disrespectful" line. HE decided to escalate. What Zelensky asked was reasonable and pretty in character for him. They know he's uncompromising with dealing with Putin. The _diplomatic_ position is to understand both sides and mediate, not to try to get one of the sides to bow down to their aggressor.
lz400··on AI is killing some companies, yet others are thriving – let's look at the data
That's not true for the kind of searches we're talking about here. If you are looking for "best mechanical keyboard" or "reviews of shimano bicycle gearsets", reddit will regularly be of higher quality than the median google first page.
lz400··on Failure to respond will be taken as a resignation
Unless of course it’s Trump who wants him out
lz400··on Failure to respond will be taken as a resignation
I can't believe what's happening to be honest. Any world where Musk doesn't end up in jail feels unjust at this point.
lz400··on DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data
I think all those things are obviously and trivially opposed to evidence coming daily now.
lz400··on Anyone can push updates to the doge.gov website
I really hope this is an outlier and the median smart guy like you has a bit more of a moral compass and doesn't seem to willing to sell their own country for a cool line on a CV.
← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →