HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

m0zg

1,604 karma · joined December 18, 2018

submissionscomments
m0zg··on The Brain-Circuit Of Even the Simplest Networks of Neurons Defy Understanding
Not just "plausible". I'm talking about near exact, not just "plausible" simulation of the signals they will consume and produce, in time domain, at an arbitrary time resolution. There's no "package" for that.
m0zg··on The Brain-Circuit Of Even the Simplest Networks of Neurons Defy Understanding
Note that compared to real neurons this is very, very crude, and it does not replicate their functionality in full. The key thing to understand is that a real neuron is not a constant thing, it is subject to its environment, meaning that if it receives a lot of spikes, for example, it may become temporarily depleted, and that very depletion will play a role in how the bigger system works. It also does not have "time steps" - it processes the signal continuously. In general, as in any biological system, everything depends on everything else, often in circuitous, ambiguous, non-obvious ways, which makes things extremely difficult to model and/or understand.

What this means from the research perspective: it's like that joke with a drunk searching for car keys under a streetlamp because it's easier to search there. People make progress where they can until someone unusual comes along and installs a new "streetlamp" elsewhere. 100% of research and engineering (and life in general) works this way, not just neuroscience. It's just that at the moment the street lamps in this field are few, dim, and very far between.

m0zg··on The Brain-Circuit Of Even the Simplest Networks of Neurons Defy Understanding
The reason why we don't have such a book is simply because nobody has the slightest clue as to how things work at the macro level. We got as far as figuring out a few dozen cells at a time, but beyond that it's really anyone's guess. We don't even know what the _questions_ should be in this field, let alone the answers. I suspect it's also strongly discouraging to newcomers because things just start looking very obviously intractable very early on, modeling of large numbers of neurons sufficiently well is mathematically near impossible, readout is mostly destructive to the specimen (and in ghastly ways - the specimen has to be alive and awake for it to even be possible), and completely impossible in humans, though Neuralink might provide a much needed boost there. Speaking of Neuralink, I think this un-developedness of the field is why Musk is pursuing it. This is, in many ways, the _real_ last frontier - understanding ourselves. There won't really be much to understand beyond that, since it is but a small step between full understanding and the ability to replicate, and possible eclipse what we have.
m0zg··on LLVM relicensing update and call for help
I don't see why he would necessarily be against relicensing, frankly. His rejection of racial discrimination (which LLVM indirectly supported in that case) has nothing to do with licensing of the code.
m0zg··on LLVM relicensing update and call for help
> That made it impossible for some companies to contribute.

It did all right regardless. Why bother with coddling the companies? As someone who wants software patents to die in a fire, I think coddling of this kind is counterproductive in the long run. I do buy the rest of their arguments though.

m0zg··on What it's like to ride 900 km in a day
More like bread and bread-like things. Sugar has to pass through your liver first, so it's not instantly available. Nuts, which are often recommended, are also energy dense, but harder to fully digest, unless you chew them really freakin' well, which nobody does.
m0zg··on The Brain-Circuit Of Even the Simplest Networks of Neurons Defy Understanding
> is it always necessary to model our systems "exactly" on the natural physiology

To replicate their effects? Probably not. "Probably" because it could very well be that evolution came up with something that anything more straightforward simply can't replicate, or maybe can replicate but not economically.

But to understand what already exists, I think yes, you do need to be able to model it. Otherwise the speed with which you acquire your understanding becomes glacial because all of your means of acquiring new knowledge are slow, low in scale, and destructive.

m0zg··on What it's like to ride 900 km in a day
> and contemplated the mistake I had made

Reminds me of my own "contemplation" on the way back out of the Grand Canyon. Getting down there is hard. Getting back up is way harder. And the only "food" I took with me was a six pack of beer, so somewhere halfway back up my body ran out of glycogen and I couldn't even maintain my body temperature. Thought I was gonna die, and realistically I could have died, actually. I was there alone, and had I sat down to "rest" that could have been it. Moral of the story: if you're going to attempt something physically demanding like this, at a minimum have plenty of energy dense food, water, and a thermal blanket with you. That's how I pack for longer hikes nowadays.

m0zg··on The Brain-Circuit Of Even the Simplest Networks of Neurons Defy Understanding
I took a computational neuroscience course many years ago and discovered just how primitive our understanding of neural circuitry is. Case in point: at the time (don't know how it is now) it was not possible to precisely model more than a handful of neurons in time domain. This is done with differential equations, but the systems get extremely complicated very quickly and you can't realistically expect to solve them and get something predictive out. One cell is quite easy. 2 is already getting harder and 3 and beyond are crazy because everything is affected by everything. From that I concluded that we simply don't have the right math to express this. If there have been any developments on the math side since then I'd be interested in hearing about it.

This is likely why ANNs effectively model neurons in frequency domain (where magnitude of the signal is proportional to the strength of the spike train). But they don't do the same thing, and the mechanism the real neurons use to learn patterns is completely different - it relies (in part) on timing of signal arrival, and the processes are continuous, there aren't any "forward" or "backward steps". Nor are there any gradients. And there are other timing effects that have to do with chemistry, on top of all that.

m0zg··on After 20 Years of Failure, Kill the TSA
Speaking of, can someone explain why the TSA security theater does not include body temperature measurement (or any other screening for COVID symptoms) nowadays? The whole airport situation is weird: mask enforcement in the environment where people can plausibly socially distance (airport terminal) is hardcore, yet when they are stuffed into a plane like sardines for hours without any distancing they can take the masks off to drink or eat. Or even sneeze, as the case may be. And _nobody_ screens for even the most obvious symptoms of infection. You can sneeze and cough your way straight to the plane flying a domestic flight, and infect everyone inside if you wanted to. They should run a "red team" to show that.
m0zg··on Will World Government Rot?
Yeah, how about we don't go there in the first place? Of all the obviously bad ideas, the "world government" strikes me as a particularly bad one.
m0zg··on Why Are Topre Keyboards So Expensive?
> work ethics and attention to detail

This, by the way, is immediately apparent if you are traveling in Japan. You get the impression that the Japanese don't goof off at work. This is especially noticeable with folks who work outside: road work, construction, janitors, etc. Quick, to the point, and you won't see anyone leaning on their shovels like in the US. My already high regard for the Japanese has improved even more after a couple of weeks there.

m0zg··on Zstandard RFC 8878
I'like to point out though that "zstd" is itself an abbreviation, and "zstandard" would be quite onerous.
m0zg··on Ask HN: I feel so shallow and dumb when I see what other smart people are doing
> I realized how mediocre and untalented I was

Read Peter Thiel's "Zero to One" and rejoice then. One of the key ideas in the book is that to be successful you have to avoid competition, and build a monopoly on something to the extent you're able. The monopoly will be temporary, but you must have it to avoid race to the bottom which just makes everyone poor and depressed. The monopoly can be a technology, or a brand, or, in the case of a person a set of skills and a track record. In fact it could also be all of the above, but you _must_ have it in order to really succeed.

It is very unlikely that you're talented at nothing. It is very likely that you're fairly talented at 2-3 different things in fact, you might just not know what they are. So if you find those things and get good at them, you'll very likely to be one of the few people in the world who are good at those 3 things at the same time. And unless those three things are "watching Youtube", "shitposting on Twitter" and "scrolling Instagram", this skill stack could be very valuable, and someone would look at you much like you look at others and wonder how it is they themselves are so worthless next to your greatness.

For me the reason of the past 30 years or so, even the smartest people are not uniformly good at everything, and you can easily be better than them at a myriad of things outside their field of expertise. And that's why teams work better than individuals, no matter how talented that individual is.

> Now, I’m an unimportant technical writer composing documents for developers and users.

See, you're good at something others aren't good at. Most engineers can't write docs normal humans can read. Add a few things to the mix, change jobs 2-3 times to establish an upward trajectory, and you'll be unstoppable.

> My talents are shallow and honestly quite useless

Well, deepen them and make them useful then? You must differentiate to succeed, either through the quality of your skills, or through your skill stack, or preferably both at the same time.

> I blame it on the lack of time

Based on what you wrote, I blame your lack of time on excessive use of social media and the internet in general. You know it's true. Give it up, and you'll be able to focus again, have better relationships, better sleep, more confidence, deeper thoughts, more skills.

And for the love of god don't tell other people you're "bipolar schizoaffective". I'm sure it's a real problem for you but others don't want anything in common with that. Paraphrasing a vulgar Russian proverb: "Why would I want a Dick without a dick if there are plenty of Dicks with dicks?" ("Нахуя мне без хуя, когда с хуем до хуя?"). Don't ruin your chances out of the gate if your disease is manageable. And also don't use your disease as an excuse to not succeed. Plenty of people overcame much greater adversities than you'll ever experience.

Above all, if I could leave you with one thought: nobody will respect you until you learn to respect yourself. Do not self-deprecate. Do not use false modesty. If you're good at at least anything (such as technical writing), put it front and center and develop more skills in your skill stack.

m0zg··on Zstandard RFC 8878
I'm not the one who came up with the extension. It just sort of organically happened I guess. I'd prefer "zstd" myself, but, frankly, "zst" is fine as well.
m0zg··on Zstandard RFC 8878
Zstd is an amazing bit of work and all I ever use for data compression nowadays (or LZ4 when speed is even more critical). Several times the compression/decompression speed of gzip, approximately the same compression ratio with default settings.

It's also supported by tar in recent Linux distros, if zstd is installed, so "tar acf blah.tar.zst *" works fine, and "tar xf blah.tar.zst" works automatically as well. Give it a try, folks, and retire gzip shortly afterwards.

m0zg··on IBM unveils 127-qubit quantum processor
But you aren't "spending time" with that person. You're spending time with that person's poorly rendered avatar. You can't even hear them properly. You can't see them at all. You can't touch them or read a lot of the nonverbal cues. And for the privilege of not being in their presence, you also need to pay several hundred (if not thousands, this being Apple) dollars, and both sides need to use Apple products. I very strongly suspect that all but the most ardent Apple fans will pass on this generous offer.
m0zg··on SerenityOS demo at Handmade Seattle 2021 [video]
The CPU emulator looked like Valgrind judging by the output. So you'd have to stretch the definition of "original code" to the max for it to hold up.
m0zg··on SerenityOS demo at Handmade Seattle 2021 [video]
Which itself is a carbon copy of BeOS, as far as UX is concerned.
m0zg··on Power Fx: open-source now available
My wife is a goddess of "Excel abuse". She (a financial analyst) unearths and uses the kinds of features in Excel I didn't know existed. But she can't code and isn't interested in learning how to do so. It's a different mindset entirely. I think MS is blindsided by having so many programmers around that 99% of the people out there aren't anything like engineers in terms of their mindset, let alone programmers. To those folks all this "accessing of properties" might as well be some inscrutable alien language.
m0zg··on Power Fx: open-source now available
Who's the user for this? It looks too "dumb" for a "real" programmer, and way too "smart" for everyone else. There's no way a real user will be able to navigate that "formula bar".

Source: have observed dozens of regular users through one-way mirror _while at MS_ ~18 years ago. The product later became Dynamics. Users would struggle to find the extremely prominent "OK" button sometimes, or press whichever button was highlighted by default even when they didn't mean to. Anything more complicated than that, it' completely hopeless.

Their own user testing probably shows the same thing, and that's probably why it's open source.

m0zg··on Stacked changes: how FB and Google engineers stay unblocked and ship faster
I also switched my dev team to it once it grew sufficiently large (at a now acquired startup). The primary thing it enables is actually having a structured conversation about your changes, and having several _revisions_ of your changes through which the reviewer can navigate, much like Gerrit or its progenitor - Critique. Once you experience that, there's simply no going back to anything else.

The UX makes me want to gouge my eyes out with a dirty spoon, but it's still worth it, in spite of the UX. I'm baffled why MS/GitHub can't just go ahead and rip it off at this point, to replace its own utterly atrocious PR review workflow.

m0zg··on Ivermectin: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Yeah, I knew a guy who got his legs destroyed by it. Given how well the polio vaccine is tolerated, and how grim the prognosis is without it, I don't think there'd be any issues with vaccine adoption. Measles one could argue either way - the disease is far less severe in most people.
m0zg··on Ivermectin: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
> has caused a lot of people to forego their vaccinations

Citation needed. I think people forego vaccinations due primarily to how hard they are being pushed, and due to almost 2 years of pretty much nonstop incoherence (or even outright lies sometimes) from the health authorities and the press worldwide.

Case in point: we're still being told by talking heads that "vaccines can stop covid" whereas the reality is nothing can stop it - it's endemic. And that was clear to any sane person back in February of 2020.

m0zg··on Ivermectin: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Sure, but my point is "consensus" doesn't necessarily mean "truth", even though the vast majority of people use the terms interchangeably. "Everyone but one person is wrong" is a situation we've seen numerous times before in the history of science. And when the matters of social acceptability, prestige, politics, and just plain ability to make a living enter into the consideration, very, very few people would even be willing to challenge the status quo. I wouldn't. I have mouths to feed.

I'm fully resigned to the fact that we won't know for sure if Ivermectin helps with any of this shit for at least another decade until tensions subside. Could be that millions of people died while they didn't have to. Could be that it's total horseshit. There's no way to know, and "consensus" means next to nothing in these circumstances.

m0zg··on Ivermectin: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Most scientists/doctors believed at one point that ulcers were caused by "stress". My father lost half his stomach to an ulcer surgery. Nowadays ulcers are cured with antibiotics in the span of a week. Don't put much stock in what crowds "believe" to be true, _especially_ when _not_ believing it means they can't work in their field.
m0zg··on IBM unveils 127-qubit quantum processor
That's the point. As long as I'm lucid I should have full bodily autonomy, including the decision to shuffle off this mortal coil. In fact I already have control over this decision.

> and there are forces in society

So? You're going to tell me I can't go anytime I want to? That's not the case even now. It's just that now I'd have to procure the nitrogen myself (which isn't difficult), and my relatives would have to deal with the body. I'm merely suggesting a service that resolves this purely logistical complication, and excludes the possibility of not quite dying but living the rest of one's life as a vegetable.

Think of what we have now: people spend years, sometimes decades suffering from chronic diseases, or just plain not having anything or anyone to live for. And it'll get worse as medicine "improves", and lifespans "improve" with it. Is it humane to withhold the option to end it all from them? I don't think it is. I will grant you that there are likely tens of millions of such people on the planet right now. I will also grant that this is not an uncontroversial thing to suggest. But the alternative we have now doesn't seem any more humane or dignified to me.

If this still doesn't sit right with people, we could age and condition-restrict it, or require a long waiting period for when this is not related to acute incurable disease.

> as with the death penalty

Which is also inhumane, IMO. It's much worse to spend the rest of one's days in confinement instead of 30 seconds until barbiturates kick in. That's what the sadists who are against the death penalty are counting on.

m0zg··on IBM unveils 127-qubit quantum processor
And there will be approximately zero non-gimmick software for them until at least 2032, if it ever materializes at all.
m0zg··on IBM unveils 127-qubit quantum processor
Half of these are on their way into "valley of disillusionment" before they become generally useful, though perhaps not as grandiose as originally promised.

And longevity research is not even a real need - we already live too long as it is, from the evolutionary and economic standpoint. I'd much rather someone came up with a way to cheaply and painlessly end one's life once quality of life begins to deteriorate due to chronic disease and such. Some kind of company (and legislative framework) where you pay, say $1K and they put you into a nitrogen chamber and then cremate and flush the ashes down the toilet afterwards. Or perhaps use them as fertilizer. I'd use the service myself at some point in distant future.

m0zg··on Facebook employees are now more willing to leave, tech recruiters say
Age happens to be the only way to obtain life experience, unfortunately, although the reverse is not true - a lot of people never actually learn of the deeper issues in their lives in that meta-cognitive way. Some just keep doing things more or less the same way they had done them when they were 20. That is a recipe for much regret on one's deathbed. One thing that helps profoundly to understand one's life in a deeper context is raising kids. You see exactly what you were at any given age, and you see the shortcomings (and sometimes advantages) of behaving that way. So you learn much more effectively. It's not the same if it's someone else that you can't observe 100% of the time, without a "facade".
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →