HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

machina_ex_deus

1,808 karma · joined August 9, 2022

submissionscomments
machina_ex_deus··on None of us are truly living off the grid
Another climate doomer.

First of all, statistically speaking you're less likely to die off the grid after global warming because death from cold is just much much more common than all the other effects that global warming will have.

But I honestly don't buy the global warming narrative. And other physicists are starting to speak up against it, for example recent Nobel prize winner John F Clauser, known as the 'C' in CHSH inequality in quantum mechanics.

https://clintel.org/nobel-prize-winner-dr-john-f-clauser-sig...

Freeman Dyson, was also against the climate narrative. And these are two actual scientists which had profound unintuitive predictions about how the world works.

It is so important when people like this OP are speaking contagious fearful narratives that seek to propagate based on emotions, that more skeptics speak up and diffuse this infectious irrational fear that is dangerous to our society.

machina_ex_deus··on Israeli startups are moving jobs and money out of the country
There's much more nuance to it. The supreme court in Israel did not intervene in laws at all until 1995 (with a single exception of a law contradicting a requirement of 61 majority).

Then in 1995, in Bank hamizrachi verdict [0], the supreme court declared it has the authority to overturn regular laws according to basic laws, including basic laws which were legislated with 32-20 majority (out of 120 seats). The supreme court declared that the only thing required for a law to be constitutional is the string "basic law" in its name. (That this terrible idea took 30 years to blow up is an achievement).

Over the years, the supreme court had decided to intervene in things which are the open wounds of Israeli society. These include the issue of Haredim recruitment to the army (where the supreme court had cancelled many laws that seeked a resolution, from both sides of the political aisles), issues of religion and state (the last leftist coalition had fallen as a direct result of an intervention of the supreme court with Hametz laws, leading to the resignation of Idit Silman).

A bit like how the U.S. supreme court intervention into abortions has led to politization of the court, and into heavy pressure from Christians to pick "pro life" judges that eventually resulted in overturning the abortion verdict, we're seeing a similar dynamic playing out where supreme court preventing resolution of a political - religious conflict leads to politization of the court and to religious people seeking to pick judges.

My personal opinion is that the supreme court should've stayed out of this mess so that we wouldn't reach this point. I don't support politicization of the court but the court also bears a responsibility.

Politicians should resist the temptation intervene with the court, and the court should resist the temptation to intervene in politics.

And this is especially true in a country where the supreme court wasn't granted its authority from any constitution, but from its own verdicts.

[0] https://he.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D7%A4%D7%A1%D7%A7_%D7%93%D7... (you'll need Google translate)

machina_ex_deus··on Airline Passengers Will Be Forced to Pay for $5T Carbon Cleanup
"polluters". Literally the least harmful to the environment gas is getting the most attention. The only gas which actually increases planet growth and is completely benign to humans.

Minewhile, chemical factories, oil refineries, and other real polluters of real harmful chemicals laugh as the climate change narrative took off all the pressure from pollution which causes cancer and death into this insufferable virtue signaling.

machina_ex_deus··on ASML EUV lithography machine could keep Moore’s Law on track
If you think predicting a single number and doing it this badly (temperatures), 33% within the correct value, and calling it science, you're the problem.

Oh and nice cherry picking. With the given variable and its pretty small variance, I can cherry pick models too, and claim it is the rain god's judgement, or whatever.

The fact that IPCC's models currently barely even give a consistent prediction, and the variance between them is so high, shows this isn't science.

Everyone's attributing the signal in the models to CO2 or climate change, while the most reasonable explanation, is that the signal is a result of the agreed upon biases and approximations that everyone in "climate science" is copying from each other, and it is also clear that models that were developed independently give more diverging results, the Russian model even predicting cooling.

machina_ex_deus··on Young people are flocking to astrology
Your view of the six days of creation is backwards. It is a story that is meant to justify the division into weeks and the concept of Shabbat, a day off once in a week.

It is probably the most widespread social policy that had ever been spread by any religion.

You can look everywhere in the world, including the non judeo Christian parts, and see the work week with a day off implemented.

It is such an intuitive and effective policy that nearly everyone forgot where it came from - but back then, it took a lot of effort to get people on board with it.

So don't judge the merit of the story by whether it's physically how the world was created, but by how the message and the consequences it teaches the reader have changed the world.

Every time you have the weekend to look forward to, remember that without some people believing God created the world in 6 days, you would be working non stop, or without the same day as your family to stop and rest.

It's definitely debatable whether that's how the world was created (I don't think it was that way), but the merits of the message of story are also undeniable. And it is the kind of message you can only get people initially on board with using drastic beliefs.

machina_ex_deus··on Young people are flocking to astrology
Another failed prediction for the astrology here.

Not the it's going to shake your beliefs in it. That's our difference I guess. When I'm wrong it's something I strive to fix, but when you're wrong, what do you do?

So believing random wrong things is something you do because you enjoy it? I believe things because I think they might be true, and you believe things because you enjoy believing them ?

What an alien (to me) epistemology.

So what do I need to do, convince you that thinking rationally is even more fun? Try reading Harry Potter and the methods of rationality.

Or doing math.

And how is socio economic related to this?

You're ironically just proving me right.

machina_ex_deus··on Young people are flocking to astrology
My somewhat mathematical point of view is that I can accept adjoining independent but weird axioms into your axiom set, but I can't accept running around with a formal system that has already reached a logical contradiction or that doesn't even use inference from axioms as its basis.
machina_ex_deus··on Young people are flocking to astrology
The current state with aliens is that we don't know. Some give 100% prior, some give 0% prior, and I can have an intelligent discussion about it. Regardless of our discussion, in the end, we still don't know and can't know (yet?). But I can tolerate people who have strong conviction either way.

I put it as opposed to astrology where we clearly know it's wrong, and the even worse part is that we had no reason to think it was true in the first place. It's just nonsense that came out of nothing, without even an attempt to ground itself with a reasonable connection to reality.

And yes, I am condenscending. If you go around believing random stuff and "simply doesn't think it through", that is precisely my problem with you. I'd rather a person who tries thinking and reaches the wrong conclusion than someone who "doesn't think it through". Such a person who doesn't even think should be more ashamed of himself than even the person who thinks wrongly.

machina_ex_deus··on Young people are flocking to astrology
Magicians can do what looks like turning water into wine easily. Is that seriously your biggest issue with religion? If there's anything to be really skeptical about its that a person resurrected from the dead, rest of the miracles are pretty mundane in modern standards. And the way I understand their epistemology, they know it happened because people saw him both dying and living afterwards, so it boils down to whether you believe their accounts. I don't expect more evidence to that than witnesses, but then again, it's hard to believe when the only evidence is witnesses.

Either way, I don't see a huge epistemological problem with a person believing these things. They might be believing wrong things but at least they do it for reasonable reasons.

You need to distinguish between epistemology and logic. It's much more important to get your epistemology correctly than your logic. It's ok to be wrong with your reasoning, you can still have an intelligent discussion. But talking to a person without epistemology is like talking to the wall. You're playing chess and he's playing checkers.

If the other person doesn't epistemologically need cause and effect relationships to believe in something, and it doesn't matter to him, I can't have an intelligent discussion. I can't reason without cause and effect, and if it doesn't matter to the other person it's completely hopeless.

machina_ex_deus··on Young people are flocking to astrology
To me there is an a huge difference. I can accept religions, which are adding axioms that aren't falsifiable, and that are usually taught to a person when he is a child. And religions had their roles in shaping society for good.

I can accept conspiracy theories and disbelieving the known consensus.

I just can't accept a person who, in the age where we know exactly how planets move and what they are, decided to believe they have correlation with psychology.

It's the worst. It shows the person doesn't even try to connect cause and effect in a meaningful way, and in astrology this is all there is to it. No epistemology. No logic. It's one thing to believe in unfalsifiable things, and another to believe in falsifiable things that we fully understand and have no causual relationship.

machina_ex_deus··on Young people are flocking to astrology
Speaking of stereotypes, if anyone takes astrology seriously, I automatically assume they are not intelligent, irrational, and I find it impossible to take them seriously.

I consider them beyond reason so I don't even try. If a person's logic and epistemology lead to him believing in astrology, it shows a deeper problem and I don't hope to have an intelligent discussion with them any more than I expect to have an intelligent discussion with GPT2 or with a talking parrot.

I can tolerate conspiracy theories, or aliens, or whacky religions, but astrology is just so dumb. I can't see an intelligent person ever falling for it. Hell I would probably consider a flat earther with a tinfoil hat more intelligent.

machina_ex_deus··on Could an industrial civilization have predated humans on Earth?
And then you remember that there are 10^23 particles in a single gram, which is in orders of magnitude of all CPUs on earth.

We're as close in orders of magnitude to the size galaxy 10^20 as we are to the nucleus 10^-18. Or put it another way, there is the same amount of units of proton radius in 10 meters as there are 10 meters in the entire Galaxy.

Another way to look at it, is that the most plausible assumption about self- simulation is that it is maxed out at some constant efficiency, say you need a system that is 10 times bigger. Then the entire babushka of simulations are merely a geometric series, and in fact you're most likely to exist in the outermost babushka except the most efficient of all simulations.

If you assume the world is a simulation, it must be an imperfect simulation that shortcuts away several orders of magnitude compared to whatever it is meant to mimic.

machina_ex_deus··on Iranians sell kidneys on Instagram to survive economic hardship
Sadly, the alternative with this regime isn't lack of sanctions, it's (potentially nuclear) war. They have said many times they intend to destroy Israel, and I believe they intend to do as they say. We're on the brink of a regional war, that would be much worse than those suffering from economic hardship in Iran.

The sanctions aren't meant to topple the regime, they are meant to restrict the magnitude of the external damage they inflict. If there were no sanctions, Iran would have had nuclear weapons years ago, and there would probably have been a regional war with tens of thousands of casualties. I'm not sure it's even avoidable at the moment.

We're already on the brink of war if Iran decides to rush nukes right now.

I don't have any hope Iranians topple the regime, it's just robust enough to survive. The sanctions are necessary to prevent war or at least delay it. Without sanctions today, we wouldn't have prosperous Iran, we would have war ravaged middle east.

Israel could've had peace with Lebanon by now if it wasn't for Iran's cancer of hizbullah. Instead we have this. The only obstacle to peace in the middle east right now is Iran. Every terrorist organization can trace it's funding to Iran.

The only thing we can do is suffocate Iran so they can't afford to spread. That's the least violent option on the table.

machina_ex_deus··on Iranians sell kidneys on Instagram to survive economic hardship
Or they can just stop getting nuclear weapons. And spending all their money funding terror against Israel, in Yemen and in Syria. You know, the sane option that they could've done for years.

Truth is that Iran is a terrorist organization leaching of its people. They have plenty of options to fix their problem, but their priorities are holy wars and nuclear weapons. Sadly it will be incredibly difficult for the Iranian people to overthrow this regime, and many of the Iranians who could've fight back had been leaving the country for years. I can't blame them, but sadly, regimes like these usually spiral downward in this way.

machina_ex_deus··on The ad-based internet is dying, and it's getting worse in the process [video]
I would love to see a search engine which only indexes ad free websites. Would probably beat Google in many things without any algorithm. Even as blockers don't solve the problem of only getting SEO ad pages, but a search engine which doesn't show any website with ads will automatically filter all the trash.
machina_ex_deus··on GPT-4 details leaked?
Placebos are known to work. I neither overestimate nor underestimate them. I understand them for what they are: placebos. And some people actually need them.

Moreover, in social contexts, religion also "works" in many senses. A person asked me what me what can he do about depression and feeling of meaninglessness. Science would prescribe anti-depressants, medicate him and he would both have side-effects and the problem would never be cured. I suggested that if he were religious, the meaninglessness would immediately go away and he would need no medication, no external interventions.

So again, judging religion by "what can it do", it can successfully give people meanings. Which is quite non-trivial thing that science fails to do to many people. So religion can be presumed to be acting on some truths regarding what drives and gives people meanings. Religion successfully demonstrated an understanding of that, you don't need statistical analysis or peer review to see that, it's plainly obvious. That knowledge just doesn't carry on to other stuff like how celestial bodies move, and there's no reason to think it does.

I love how you're the spokesperson for "science".

Ironically, when you look at how you describe the merits of peer review, you sound quite like an instrumentalist yourself.

Also quite ironically, the new science religion keep on pushing this funny narrative that science is about "being wrong all the time" which is like the complete opposite of scientific history. All of the established science is just the successes. Look at the great physicists. There is no mistake in Newton's laws. Or in Einstein's. They are just as valid today as they have been back then, in the areas where they were demonstrated and studied.

How did we reach this apologetic science? "good scientist will be wrong all the time"? That sounds like gaslighting scientists in a failed system rather than accurate historical statement. Science advances because someone eventually succeeds. In the grand scheme of things, there are no mistakes. There are corrections, there are expanding the domain of applicability. But the mistakes are sent to the trashbin of history, and if a failed system decided to gaslight you into rationalizing failure, stop listening to it and start seeking success.

machina_ex_deus··on GPT-4 details leaked?
I'm tired of science as a religion. People treat it as some gospel, like if you check out some criterions you're suddenly "scientific" and instantly get a sense of validity and authority that you shouldn't logically get.

I judge things as "what you can do", not "what can you predict". The only demonstration of knowledge and understanding is being able to do something. Not predict. Not "scientific method" and ridiculous "peer review" (actually peer pressure), not blind trials and not rigorous statistical analysis.

In the end of the day, you either manage to do something or you don't. So much of so called science had lost all contact with reality because our judgement of success isn't successfully doing something, it is successfully jumping through "scientific" hoops. Look at string theory and social sciences. The scientific process, instead of being a tool, became the purpose. It became a stamp of validity to seek. A stamp of validity with gatekeepers in the academia, in the peer review process, in the media coverage afterwards all the way to social media censorship and "fact checkers".

What used to be the frontier of creative people became a stagnant beurocratic machine worshipped like a new religion. The side of the heretics burned at the stake became the ones crying out heresy.

Enjoy your new brand of science. I'll stick to the older brand of heretics and mad men which did whatever it was the prevailing orthodoxy told them to avoid doing and thinking, and I'll remind you that the only real reason those are remembered is because they did something useful, not because of the social traditions they adhered to or the rigorous scientific standards they followed.

machina_ex_deus··on StackRot (CVE-2023-3269): Linux kernel privilege escalation vulnerability
Rust hardly deals with memory race conditions better than C, and managed languages are not fit for kernel. This isn't the fault of C at all. These kinds of issues are unavoidable part of kernel programming in multiprocessor settings and not something you can solve with a different programming language.

This comment just can't be more wrong.

machina_ex_deus··on I shouldn’t have to accept being in deepfake porn
> You can be against this lady, but also be against deepfake porn targeting women only at the same time.

To be clear, I am against deepfake porn. But I'm even more against these kinds of people who make a career out of abusing real victims to create positions of power which they then abuse for unrelated actions that were the real reason in the first place.

Just like how you can be against child porn and yet raise some eyebrows with some of the suggested policies like Apple's scanning all internal photos.

If you're willing to let morally questionable people gather more power because of bad things, you'll be surprised to find out more bad things happening compared to if you just didn't care.

She strikes me as exactly that kind of psychopathic person, and whatever action she's suggesting I'm sure to avoid doing it. And I don't believe her for a moment.

machina_ex_deus··on Humans aren’t mentally ready for an AI-saturated ‘post-truth world’
"Everyone knows" is not an argument that shows someone is wrong. It's an argument that shows you're just judging people because they stray away from the consensus. Ironically, after you were crying about mob mentality.

A person who thinks "flat earthers are stupid" because "everyone knows", and not because of the actual reasons this is true, is not smarter. The flat earther also knows everyone knows the earth is round. You didn't display any knowledge they don't have.

How can you tell the earth is round is a pretty insightful question. The difference between us is that I understand that people coming to recognize truth from falsehood, including making mistakes and falling in the way, is more important than reaching the correct result. Which is why I'm not afraid of disinformation, because I think people need to not be afraid to think and ask questions and take a path where they don't get the correct result right away.

Mine while, you wish for people to avoid thinking and defer to authority. It's extremely relevant, it's at the core of my argument, that's what this discussion is all about.

The system failed the flat earther not because it prevented the false information from reaching them. The system failed to properly educate them to recognize truth from falsehood, and instead taught them, like your attitude, to rely on authority. The only difference between you is that their trust in authority has stopped. And their reasoning is bad because they never used them.

machina_ex_deus··on Humans aren’t mentally ready for an AI-saturated ‘post-truth world’
You don't need set theory to prove that 1+1=2. You don't need mathematical logic. A child which answers that if he puts one thing and then another thing and then counts and gets two things have proved it just fine. Those later complications are just there when you try to put it in context of other things you know. Ancient Greeks did not do set theory or mathematical logic, yet their understanding of basic addition was completely fine.

You inability to understand what is irrelevant complication, and your deferral to authority and expertise even when you are perfectly capable of understanding, is your own problem.

Here are two quote you said:

> "(There are no right questions, only right answers.)

A point that does not pertain to what I said. I said nothing about “right” questions."

> "Asking the right questions requires some perspicacity."

You also say "The thoughts were completely wrong". There are also no wrong thoughts, only wrong conclusions. A person afraid to "think" wrongly as the narrative so strongly tries to program people, is infinitely dumber than a person who doesn't constrain his thinking. That's what they want to happen. Amazing there are NPCs like you who avoid "wrongthink".

There are people who know a lot and understand nothing. Knowledge is spewing up complications from set theory. Understanding is being able to tell, by the context, that this is completely irrelevant.

You appealed to authority to even tell me that the earth is flat. You didn't say that we can observe the curvature from measuring distances, from doing an experiment with ships masts disappearing into the horizon, or any other way even ancient people figured it out. It's true because "The knowledge that the Earth is spheroidal has been known for many hundreds of years. ".

People "knew" the sun rotates around earth for thousand of years. And the truth won despite it being against the "authority". And nothing will change that understanding, even if some string theory will discover the 11th dimension or whatever, because that will be irrelevant in the same sense that set theory is irrelevant to 1+1=2. For these same reasons you don't need and shouldn't appeal to authority.

Appeal to authority is only knowledge. Zero understanding.

I said nothing about "doing the research". A person who deferred to authority and knowledge to answer a question is always inferior to a person who tried to understand and failed. A person appealing to authority is just trying to mirror someone's intelligence. A parrot who repeats a correct sentence is still dumber than a human saying a wrong sentence.

A parrot who repeats "vaccines are good" because he heard that is always the greater fool than the anti vax who says vaccines are bad.

A parrot who says 1+1=2 because set theory shows less understanding than a kid with an abacus. The parrot is saying irrelevant things while the child isn't.

machina_ex_deus··on Humans aren’t mentally ready for an AI-saturated ‘post-truth world’
There are no right questions, only right answers. A question, by definition, isn't right or wrong. That's why it's a question, not an answer.

The very first step to being an intelligent person is not being afraid to ask questions.

The second step is trying to understand it even if you might reach the wrong result.

Only if you passed those first two steps you even have the hope of answering the question correctly.

And even a child can prove that 1+1=2, and if you're such an NPC you think it's hard to prove, I honestly find flat earthers more intelligent.

Ironically, you're acting like such a bot that you're actually quite good at contradicting my point. You're begging the question (like "why are vaccines effective"). You don't look for understanding but for knowledge to remember then repeat.

I always value more the person who tried and failed than the person who never tried. I don't think a layperson can conduct academic research, but I think they can try to understand.

And I think that those who tried to understand yet reached the wrong conclusion are still much better than those who never tried.

machina_ex_deus··on Humans aren’t mentally ready for an AI-saturated ‘post-truth world’
So now it's the elderly. I've seen them fall for phone scams much more commonly, they usually don't have the technical ability to use the internet.

You're deflecting from the disinformation narrative into elderly scam. Which I agree is a problem, just a completely different one than the disinformation narrative presents.

machina_ex_deus··on Humans aren’t mentally ready for an AI-saturated ‘post-truth world’
And my general experience with anti vaxers is that they generally look into more resources and research and put much more thoughts into their decisions than a regular person. Which I generally view as a positive quality. I put much more value on the process by which a person reached his decisions than whether they were correct in one particular instance.

Whether I agree with their final conclusion is irrelevant, I can't with straight face call a person who spent his time carefully considering his decisions less intelligent than a person who didn't spend a single moment to think about it. Even if they reached the wrong conclusion.

It's actually hilarious that you call them mob mentality. Going with the herd automatically is the most mob mentality possible.

Have you tried talking to Trump supporters before you assumed they are "cult" and "mob"?

You're exactly the kind of person I directed my post at. You've been successfully fooled into thinking other people are stupid without even trying to understand them.

And for the record, I think flat earthers are more intelligent than people who never even asked themselves how do we know that the earth is spherical. They are not intelligent because they couldn't understand the answer, but they are more intelligent than a person who never even asked the question.

The people I consider more intelligent than flat earthers tried asking this question, looked for the solution and could understand basic geometry enough to understand why it is true. Anyone else isn't more intelligent, just more conformal and knowledgeable. In the case of knowing the earth is flat, it's such well known fact it's just pure conformity never asking why, and I don't value that at all. It's not an intelligent trait.

machina_ex_deus··on Humans aren’t mentally ready for an AI-saturated ‘post-truth world’
So you assume your fellow humans are stupid and will fall for this crap, and must be protected at all costs including the cost of regulation preventing speech?

By the way, how's that scammer SBF doing? I heard he managed to scam even more money than that funny YouTube ad, and I think he was advertising on mainstream media too. Even got to lobby in Congress.

This is still far from the leading mainstream narrative that "your fellow humans are stupid". By your anecdote I can learn that here we have another person who's capable of recognizing false information, therefore it isn't dangerous.

Anyone who fell for disinformation is welcome to step in and contribute an anecdote to the opposite statistics so maybe I'll be convinced people really are guillible and need protecting.

Somehow it's always other people who the speaker thinks are more stupid and will fall for something he sees as a scam.

machina_ex_deus··on Humans aren’t mentally ready for an AI-saturated ‘post-truth world’
Disinformation is the narrative constructed by crumbling authorities of mainstream media desperately trying to preserve their power.

You might think like their narrative is "think critically, and consider everything critically".

But the actual message is, your fellow humans are stupid, they fall for misinformation and fake sources. Ignore all alternative sources of information and most importantly, do not trust your friends and people you know, instead assume they are stupid and when they contradict the authority, be sure to put up a firewall and stop the propagation of dangerous thoughts.

Truth is always more powerful than lies. Don't underestimate your own reasoning capabilities, and if you do underestimate them, the most important thing to do is to train them. I'm not saying to argue against an anonymous bot, but if you meet in person, if your friends have non standard ideas, don't assume they are stupid and fell for misinformation. Not everyone on the other side is stupid, or heartless, or bad.

They are trying to inject faults into various alternative information sources just to turn around and catch them and say "see? This podcaster is a conspiracy theorist and unreliable!".

It's mainstream media which benefits the most from efficient fault and spam injection into alternative information sources, because it makes them relatively more trustworthy. And it is actually against the interests of alternative news sources to be caught in a lie because it is likely to erode their reputation.

If you're confused by the whole disinformation phenomenon, ask the simple question, who benefits.

And remember that the media's willingness to intentionally lie and deceive their readers is directly proportional to the cost to your reputation, and the likeliness of your readers to discover the truth.

machina_ex_deus··on Security analysis of the Dominion ImageCast X
The government is the "Eve" of this protocol. What happens in practice is that the government is controlled by political parties, and these have enough leverage to put their confidants into sensitive positions.

And the challenge of observability is that your adversary here, Eve, or the government, is the one providing the information. Therefore you can't rely on that information in the verification.

Human error hardly matters. And normal elections shouldn't have razor thin margins, razor thin margins are already evidence of tampering.

The irony is that instead they use the razor thin margins to justify ridiculous methods of counting.

Several people are used to counting to prevent malicious opportunities, not innocent errors. Innocent errors have zero probability of changing anything.

machina_ex_deus··on Security analysis of the Dominion ImageCast X
The structure of the election process itself, is what determines whether it is a plausible conspiracy or probably impossible.

In an election where each vote is counted by hand, it's indeed quite hard and implausible for the government to conspire to rig it.

If, however, the government presented you with a process which had very few points of failure - a single person counting tens of thousands of votes using machines, or mail ballots where all the workers never needed to see the voter, and rely on government supplied information to validate the person exists - these do not require huge conspiracy but only a select few.

It is indeed bordering on conspiracy theory, and the border is exactly on proper process.

Another way to "measure" the security of an election process, is instead of looking at votes gap, look at how many people are needed to conspire to change the results. If your answer is very few, for example, a hacker with access to voting machine, the worker which counted thousands of votes, or the voting machine manufacturer, or the dude with the mail ballots database, it is a possible conspiracy, because it is possible that very few people aren't honest.

A properly designed election process really does require an implausible conspiracy to rig.

An improperly designed election, is almost like a backdoor, and the conspiracy theory defense no longer works.

By the way, there's another side to the coin: in a properly designed election, fraud claims simply do not happen, because it would take hundreds of individual and independent claims of fraud, to be able to claim that the results should be different.

Because the most simple solution, hand counting, works, if the government fails to give you proper verification, it is already the government's fault.

This is also the explanation that should be given in any functioning democracy. You shouldn't need PR campaign or media to establish trust in elections. Well designed democratic elections, by design, the losing side as a verifier can tell they were fair by the protocol itself. The losing side can try to see how many parts of the process they don't trust, and almost always in normally decentralized election, they could discount those parts and the results would barely change.

If your government fails this verification, skips the rational explanation and instead gives you cliche media campaign, and uses an inherently bad process, that's the part where you should already stop and distrust it.

At that point, the government already broke through all the security boundaries of the election process, and it's impossible to know that they didn't exploit it.

machina_ex_deus··on Security analysis of the Dominion ImageCast X
The biggest security vulnerability of voting machines are that a single person can count thousands of votes. And that is by design.

Election security is a confusing business. It is, by design, the only thing you should not trust your government with, because your trust in the government comes from the election process.

If you trust your government with the election, that's a circular trust problem and it's abused to the maximal extent possible.

Which is why voting machines can't be secure, ever. Nothing the government does can truly convince the lay person it can trust a government provided voting machine, because in the security settings of election, the government is the adversary.

It is actually the only time you should consider the government as an adversary and malicious - because that is when you verify and force it to be good.

It matters less to win the election than to know that the government is accountable to the majority. I prefer the opposite political side to win in an accountable and trustworthy way (such as that I know their interest align with the majority of the population) than to have my side win and then answer to no one.

machina_ex_deus··on The myth of machine consciousness makes Narcissus of us all
It's not about having the artificial notion of self. It's about having a real self. Memories of who you are, what is your history, what is your place in the world, who are your friends and your relationship with them, I can keep going but it's obvious ChatGPT has none of it and has no simple way to acquire it because it is not even designed to learn anything from its own interactions except a small 3000 tokens context window.

Every human learned everything except few innate instincts from their own experiences. They didn't get it fed through some backdoor in their head specifically designed to learn. That's how I see "training" AI. None of what they learned was from an interactive experience of the world. All their knowledge came from some backdoor interface directly hacking their neurons to fit.

You know what you know because of experiences, not because your creator was hacking with your neurons. It's also much more demanding intellectually to understand the world through such a limited interface. Children understand language from orders of magnitude less data.

← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →