HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

machina_ex_deus

1,808 karma · joined August 9, 2022

submissionscomments
machina_ex_deus··on Automatic1111's GitHub account suspended for "ToS violations" [restored]
They literally got nothing to lose and they can just go "oops, we saw X in the repo and banned by mistake".

There's just no way this is a mistake. I don't believe for a second their internal review systems don't have any safeguards against banning extremely popular repositories without manual oversight, because they must have these safeguards. Other open source repos probably get spurious reports commonly.

These systems always have popularity thresholds for manual oversight because as something gets popular, it gets false reports. It's just fact of life.

Any manual oversight would easily recognize what's going on and would never ban extremely popular repo for a random transgression of its creator in other repo. Not without consulting a manager.

machina_ex_deus··on Automatic1111's GitHub account suspended for "ToS violations" [restored]
Need to call this bullshit by its name: Microsoft killing their competition. They had just released their own version of stable diffusion in bing a moment ago and now they ban the biggest competition from GitHub.

I don't believe they didn't know what they are doing. They definitely have statistics about repo usage and the guy suspending him definitely knew that it's one of the most popular repos out there.

Microsoft don't deserve the benefit of doubt here. This is a warning to anyone who competes with Microsoft in an open source project. Move elsewhere.

machina_ex_deus··on Ask HN: Concepts that clicked only years after you first encountered them?
I never hated reading, it's just that I didn't get the point of it. What are we even doing here and why?

What's the point? Math has clear purpose. I do enjoy some books. I just didn't get the point of studying them beyond reading. Why are they babbling about ? Is there any use for this information or is it just a torture in memorization? Why would I ever care about all these abstract literature terms?

Ironically they missed telling the meta story: why would anyone care about stories.

If stories are just something you read for fun, why would anyone care to teach me how to analyze them?

EDIT: To be clear, these were the questions that weren't answered back then.

Only now, years later with life experience the purpose is clear.

machina_ex_deus··on Ask HN: Concepts that clicked only years after you first encountered them?
Learning history / literature in school is important.

I was a total STEM math nerd in school. I used to frequently complain how I don't get what's the point of it, or how it's a waste of time and I'm learning nothing. I still think the emphasis of school was off, but I get the point of it now.

Stories are like code for humans. You can't tell someone what it means to be good or bad, or to give them a course in philosophy and they will become good people. But you can tell them a good story, that engages with them emotionally, and it will change their perception. And history shows that in fact, those stories being told and repeated aren't just interesting minor curiosity, but they have shaped the direction of humanity and they are driving it. A single person with a single story can change history in such a way that it would be completely different without it. And some stories about stories need to be told as a warning so that people will not fall for those kinds of stories again.

machina_ex_deus··on The internet wants to be fragmented
The simplest possible implementation of user interaction is writing a response. It's already as rich as it can be. It gives less power to bots because bots are incoherent. I feel like the internet devolved us from eloquent human speakers back into monkeys making few noises for communicating. Emoji is similar.

Speak. Write text. Formulate your position. We're humans not apes. Get feedback from speaking. The video format in some cases is the same - ape like reaction movies, no content. Assume you're interacting with someone intelligent who isn't convinced by the funny number of likes on your post, but by the content of what you say.

machina_ex_deus··on The internet wants to be fragmented
Ever heard of someone saying "fuck cars" in person? Where the conversation just stood on "fuck cars", and stopped there? When someone on the internet says "fuck cars", it's because he's expecting to get some dopamine from getting liked by similarly minded friends who also hate cars.

If his purpose was to have a discussion, to convince you, it wouldn't be "fuck cars", it would be "cars are polluting". And even if he's an arrogant asshole in real life, you could explain how cars are useful to you, and ask what he's suggesting to do. Maybe 1% are such total careless assholes you shouldn't be talking to them, but others will try to come up with an answer, and if they fail to give it, they will remember it.

machina_ex_deus··on The Fable of the Dragon-Tyrant (2005)
It's a bad analogy. Ironically, this story flips the assymetry of death on its head. It is always easier to destroy than to create something durable. It's not a coincidence that when the story flips the difficulty on its head such that the job was killing (bringing death) to a dragon, intuitions flipped too.

Every programmer knows that getting his program to crash is always an easier job than to keep it running indefinitely. Every probablistic bug eventually will happen on long enough timescales, and defeating death isn't defeating a single bug, it's defeating all of them. It isn't a single dragon but infinite bugs.

I preferred Blade runner take on it: when they tell the replicant that there was no built in destruction mechanism, they built him as best as they could, and that was simply it.

machina_ex_deus··on The internet wants to be fragmented
Speaking is meant to exchange information. You're not exchanging any information when the other side agrees with you and knows everything you're saying.

An advocacy group is ineffective if all its members have this mindset. With signaling mindset you have no chance to convince anyone of anything. I'd rather get someone thinking differently a little bit confused than lament something with people who think the same. It doesn't reinforce helplessness.

I have many anecdotes with somewhat low chance of moving opinions. Few people will admit changing their minds, but sometimes they will agree with you but still offer a weaker counterpoint of the opposing narrative.

You can't flip someone's opinion 180° on the internet, but you can get someone on the other side to acknowledge a counter point.

machina_ex_deus··on The internet wants to be fragmented
I said change theirs or yours. Not necessarily change it completely but at least learn where the difference comes from, and either move my position to account for new information or logic, or try to convince the other side.

But I do see it as a goal to get the opinions closer. I prefer listening while having a clear picture of what I'm currently thinking about it because only then you can realize where's the difference, and the difference is what you want to learn.

If the other side doesn't listen to statements, they might listen to questions. Asking what they think about X might get a better response than just stating X. Works in real world too against these types. Many times it's not because it's online, it's just narcissistic personality. Many people won't acknowledge when something moves their opinion.

machina_ex_deus··on The internet wants to be fragmented
I agree with you on mass media, in fact I think the problem already started there, and it's even worse because it's not even a conversation, it's one sided.

When I'm speaking in person it's still similar to what I'm describing. I could have political discussion in highly polarized family with different opinions and people listening, and with friends too.

It's not "used to be", unless somehow you stopped talking in the real world.

machina_ex_deus··on The internet wants to be fragmented
The biggest problem is the like button. The like button is not only a bad metric - it's the worst possible metric.

Speaking up used to be something you do to change someone's mind or yours. What's the point in speaking up if nobody does anything with what you said?

The like button reprogrammed people. They started getting positive feedback for speaking in an echo chamber, for saying and doing things their audience already agrees with. They started getting negative feedback for doing the thing language was designed for.

Normal purposeful speech makes different opinions closer, while speech under the feedback of the like button makes similar opinions even closer and different opinions further apart.

If the interaction stays the same of course fragmentation is inevitable - but that's not a good thing. This fragmentation extends to the real world and has real consequences. It will blow up. Even with Twitter being internally fragmented the polarization in society grew. Nobody wants to listen to the other side anymore, while there's always the most to be learned from listening to the other side.

The core of the problem needs to be addressed: that social media has reprogrammed people to the purpose of speech.

One of the reasons I'm even bothering with websites like HN as opposed to social media is because it still feels like there's a slight chance of making people change their minds here.

machina_ex_deus··on It's easier and faster to pirate an e-book, than it is to buy it
Just imagine what it would be like if everything worked with the same design.

You would own nothing and be happy...

machina_ex_deus··on The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter
Is that the debate? Because I think it's pretty settled the files show extensive collaboration of the FBI and Twitter on controversial topics, it shows many instances of twits censored by a request from the FBI. Am I moving the debate position or are you? Did you even read them? Many comments here accept the existing evidence as something normal. I disagree strongly.
machina_ex_deus··on The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter
Then all it will take to lose your democracy is for a dictator to proclaim his opponents a danger to democracy. Maybe using a Reichstag fire. You can't fight evil with evil, or fight undemocratic tyrants with undemocratic measures. Introducing vulnerabilities into your democratic system is a double edged sword.
machina_ex_deus··on The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter
Schrodinger's conspiracy: in superposition of being a dangerous conspiracy theory and well known fact everyone knew and nothing interesting.

Of course, the status of a Schrodinger's conspiracy is only known when the truth is revealed and the conspiracy is measured.

When the truth becomes known, it is retconned to have always been known.

machina_ex_deus··on The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter
If you don't see anything wrong with the government forcing censorship on controversial political questions, such as whether elections are safe and fair, just imagine your own reaction if after the 2016 election, Trump's FBI would be monitoring Twitter for any information about Cambridge Analytica / Russia's interference, labeling them as misinformation and censoring and banning everyone mentioning them.

If your values only apply when they fit your wanted outcome, they aren't values they are pathetic excuses.

By the way, this opens the door to all the other agencies of the world outside US to demand same kind of access. Including European. Maybe China wants it too.

And for the record, I think Elon banning Elon Jet and journalists is wrong too. But there are too many people who only care about the censorship when it hurts them, and cheer for it when it suits them.

machina_ex_deus··on Bill Gates: Our grandchildren will pay if we don’t fix climate change
My bet is that it is regular HN readers who use throw away accounts to post this.

Those are actual positions of people. They just don't want their regular accounts burned on them.

Since posting well thought out posts on these topics will get downvoted regardless, and they already use throwaway, they don't have any reason to expend effort.

So they just come out like this. They want the opposing voice to be heard but the structure here is just encouraging low effort inflammatory posts on throwaway on controversial topics instead of long posts on real account that get downvoted to oblivion anyway.

I might even get downvoted to oblivion for simply having some empathy to their position regardless of how politely I wrote this.

machina_ex_deus··on Should I step down as head of Twitter? I will abide by the results of this poll
That's maybe not how you would react. But it's a classical response - when under attack, identify enemies, and attack back.

It takes a certain kind of social intellect to understand which actions will actually psychologically affect someone for the better.

Does he consciously tie his actions directly to this? Or is it indirectly, by getting very negative emotions and associations to leftism, which are then turned into this culture war?

machina_ex_deus··on Should I step down as head of Twitter? I will abide by the results of this poll
If you go back to Musk deal, it was immediately after Babylon bee was banned for an anti trans remark about man of the year.

I'm speculating a bit, and I'm not supporting his actions, I'm trying to explain then. I think he already had disagreement with his son that came out as trans later, and I think the major reason he changed his political position is because of his child. The child also cut all ties with him.

He said "The woke mind virus must be destroyed, nothing else matters".

It's not Elon the entrepreneur, or Elon the management genius, or even Elon the troll on social media.

What's really driving him is Elon the father that views leftism and woke as a mind virus that had possessed his child.

When you reach that position as a father, there's no loyalty to old political parties, there's no choosing words carefully or looking at Twitter as a regular business.

This is a person who could not care much about ideology until ideology reached his house and destroyed it - and only at that point he actually started fighting the fight.

He treats Twitter and leftists as the enemies because in his mind they are enemies, enemies that managed to destroy his child. It might seem inconceivable that someone might change his position so radically, and surprise everyone, but that's because they don't understand the real motivation.

Anyway, I'm not supporting his actions, this is meant to empathize with him so I'll understand what's going on and where all this is coming from, and therefore, where is it going.

machina_ex_deus··on Google elegantly says goodbye to Waze
> Noam Bardin opened a can of worms in a famous post that analyzed Google's problematic attitude towards Waze and innovation in general. Google, instead of seeing Waze as a brand to be nurtured and promoted, treated it as an incubator of ideas that should be exploited. "Every idea we had was quickly adopted by Google Maps," he wrote. Nor did the company use its vast resources to attract new users to Waze: "The Android app store treated us as a third-party application. There were no pre-installations on devices and no further distribution. We had a much larger marketing budget, but we were limited in what we could do and the third parties we could work with because of corporate policy. All of Waze’s post-acquisition growth came from work we did, not from mothership support. Looking back, we could probably grow much faster and much more efficiently if we had remained independent."

Waze is better than Google maps, but it's impossible to compete with someone just copying everything. It's a shame they were allowed to buy their competitions. Google maps still doesn't have the features I'm using Waze for, like traffic cameras, road hazards warnings, police warnings etc.

I guess that's a good time for a Waze clone to come up. Probably a matter of time until it becomes another thing Google destroyed.

machina_ex_deus··on An alarming number of US homebuyers are underwater
There are always forced sellers. Foreclosures, inheritance, construction companies with thin margins. The best time to buy if you have cash on hand is from forced sellers at the peak of the panic.
machina_ex_deus··on A fake job offer gone wrong
Isn't wedding gift being cash the standard thing? Do you bring gift items to weddings? I always thought the standard of bringing cash to help them pay back for the cost of the event was standard everywhere. This is a Jewish thing?

It kind of explains why weddings in Israel are so expensive, I heard it's almost cheaper to buy flight tickets to buy wedding dress in another country.

machina_ex_deus··on Identical twins aren't that identical
They probably calculated the original chances assuming independent random variables for answers, and the truth is that those variables are dependent and highly correlated because they are twins.

Both the articles and the original out of thin air calculations are completely made up, but it's pretty conceivable that the cheating program had a mistaken assumption of variable independence, which is clearly false in this case.

machina_ex_deus··on Iran set to freeze bank accounts of women who refuse to wear a hijab
There's not much effort needed. The comparison to Canada is obvious. This is completely new tactic for dictatorships. What else do you expect to be said?

At this point you either contort in various ways to fit the narrative or you stand by a consistent set of values.

To me personally, hypocrisy is the worst ideological crime. It's always possible to construct a narrative, the harder thing to do is realizing when your values collide with your 'interest' or political side and standing by your values instead of the easy choice of picking the narrative.

If your moral values only ever happened to be on your side, you don't have values, you have excuses.

machina_ex_deus··on Hiding in plain sight? The argument for invisible aliens (2020)
There are three time periods: before there is any intelligent life, during the spread of the first intelligent life, and afterwards where it's already extremely unlikely to be independent of the first life.

If you assume life spreads very fast, the first duration being much much longer than the second, and the third duration has no room for independent life to exist, it means in most universes most observers are the first. Only if a second life somehow develops during the second time window despite the expectation time being the first time window, you'll have a chance of not being the first. The time for a critical fluctuation to arise is much much longer than the time it takes for it to dominate, so most critical fluctuations are the first.

Universe isn't infinite because we know it started with the big bang. We're likely the first in whatever scale it is likely that life can spread to faster than develop independently. So we're likely be the first anywhere we'll ever be able to reach.

machina_ex_deus··on Hiding in plain sight? The argument for invisible aliens (2020)
Looking at the rate of technological progress, my bets are that intelligent life that spreads intergalactically takes extremely small time to do so (relative to the expected time to randomly spawn life from fluctuations). So the odds of two simultaneous fluctuations competing is nearly zero. We're just the first, and it is the normal thing to expect to be the first. With sufficiently high ratio between these two durations, most observers in most universes would be the first ones. Being first isn't special, it's actually the most common.
machina_ex_deus··on The distinction between free speech as a legal right and cultural value
> All meaningful speech has consequences. Calls to violence definitely so. Is this really something that needs to be defended when spam and porn don't?

To me it's all pretty simple. The platform has its loyalty to the listener. It is up to the listener to decide whether he wants to engage with different kinds of speech, and most networks already can determine that, either by separation into forums and communities or just by general engagement metrics.

If you prevent exposure because the listener doesn't want to be exposed, that's OK.

If you prevent exposure because you don't want the listener to be exposed, that's censorship.

Censorship is suppressing information because it might be listened to, while spam filters and porn filters is suppressing information because it won't be listened to. The ethical and moral boundary is clear, and it is strictly the platform's loyalty to its consumers.

Anything else is inherently positioning the platform in an assumed moral superiority to its users, which given the recent Twitter revelations, is an incredibly bad assumption.

Moderation can be both good and bad. Good moderators are those that remove content nobody will want to see. Bad moderators remove content because people might see it.

There are plenty of calls to violence from the Ukraine side against Russia. None of those got censored. Should they?

I'm not defending the essence of the speech. It should be irrelevant. I'm defending what is a moral intent and what is an immoral intent of the platform. There's meaningful discussion and then there are constructing strawman and fabricated threats and vague ambiguous terms like hate speech.

If your method for deciding whether to censor foofoo is whether there exists a story where foofoo leads to bad outcome, and someone wants foofoo censored, they will create that story (potentially including real life actions). Therefore deciding whether to censor foofoo should be independent of the existence of those stories. They also tend to overgeneralize and use broad categories when the stories themselves are specific anecdotes.

To me the boundaries are pretty clear, and everything else is just people telling pretty meaningless stories, conflating terms, and having inconsistent standards.

Understanding where things stand morally is something you do after discussing them, not before.

machina_ex_deus··on Elon: Let Me Help You Speed Run the Content Moderation Learning Curve
They are justified only up to the point where Apple starts scanning your personal photos and then the EU joins in requiring everyone else to do that too?

There are politicians constantly testing their legislation boundaries all over CSAM. It's getting abused to make proof of concepts that companies are willing to implement something, and then they extend it to other shit every time. You can't just slap the "for CSAM" label on increasingly ridiculous things. It needs to actually make sense.

machina_ex_deus··on Elon: Let Me Help You Speed Run the Content Moderation Learning Curve
I don't think HN is the DMCA fans crowd, so what exactly triggered everyone? The hate speech?
machina_ex_deus··on Elon: Let Me Help You Speed Run the Content Moderation Learning Curve
What's the point in getting someone who already agrees to listen? You want to find those willing to listen that don't agree.

I don't want to reinforce my ego that I have people agreeing with me, I could get plenty of that if I wanted, I want those disagreeing and willing to listen to see the other side. I want to see what's actually a convincing argument that's changing opinion.

But hey, everyone's so used to the likes and points system, they forget that speaking is to covey a message, not to get internet points for your ego. If that's all free speech means to you, no wonder you give it away easily.

I happily paid those -5 internet points. If that surprised any of the downvoters, maybe they will think again what's the point of speech that does nothing. It's funny how none of them responded with actual speech, maybe because they think talking is about getting those downvotes and not about interacting with people.

← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →