HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mactavish88

934 karma · joined February 11, 2018

submissionscomments
mactavish88··on A World Split Apart (1978)
Sounds to me a lot like Nietzsche’s prediction of the impact of the “death of God”.

Solzhenitsyn primarily focuses in this speech, it seems to me, on there being a growing lack of subordination to a higher spiritual purpose in the West, similar to that in the East, both having predictable consequences in terms of the collapse and eventual destruction of those societies. (Materialism and “anthropocentricity” take over and life loses its meaning.)

The superficial shape of the collapse in the East (under Communism) is different to that of the West, but according to him both suffer from the same underlying disease.

mactavish88··on The surprising cause of fasting's regenerative powers
Were you supplementing with electrolytes while fasting? Don’t have any studies at hand right now, but fasting apparently causes you to quickly lose fluid and electrolytes.

I recently started doing 5:2 fasting and noticed on the day after fasting that I tend to get bouts of pretty bad orthostatic hypotension. Supplementing with a zero-calorie electrolyte on fasting days and the day after helped mitigate this.

mactavish88··on The surprising cause of fasting's regenerative powers
For those potentially concerned about cancer risk from breaking fasts, from the article itself:

> Researchers should always be concerned about anything that could cause cancer, but Valter Longo, a biogerontologist at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles, says that mice with the tweaked genes were “almost doomed to get cancer”, and that the slight rise in risk found in this study might not be applicable more broadly. For example, he points to a study he published in 2015 that found a 45% reduction in abnormal cell and tissue growth in mice that fasted compared with animals that did not.

The mice that developed precancerous growths were genetically modified to be prone to such cancerous development.

mactavish88··on Alacritty – A fast, cross-platform, OpenGL terminal emulator
Been using Alacritty daily for over a year now on Ubuntu for paid and unpaid (hobby) work and it’s exactly what I need: something that doesn’t get in my way, and it renders nicely. Performance on a ThinkPad with Nvidia graphics card is great.

I primarily use it alongside tmux and NeoVim.

mactavish88··on CBC cancels New Year's Eve broadcast special due to 'financial pressures'
I wonder whether any of that cash has actually made its way to the CBC. Promises of future revenue are often hard to turn into salaries today.
mactavish88··on CBC cancels New Year's Eve broadcast special due to 'financial pressures'
Has anyone quantified the financial impact on Canadian news outlets of Google and Meta’s blocking of news content due to Bill C-18?

https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/google-canada-online-news-1...

mactavish88··on Unprecedented Cryptosporidium Outbreak in UK
> The outbreak has splattered into almost every region of all four UK nations.

> …

> Though we don't know what's behind the UK's startling gush of cases…

What a choice of wording!

mactavish88··on The glass at McCormick Place in Chicago is a lethal obstacle for birds
We find that, while this deters birds, it seems to attract bees. They fly and land on many individual dots before eventually flying away.

Has anyone else experienced this?

mactavish88··on Nomnoml
As someone who has been working on open source software for 5 years now, GitHub issues are my primary source of truth for what users want and how to go about prioritizing features.

If people can’t be bothered to log an issue or thumbs-up/comment on an existing one, it can’t be such an important thing to them.

mactavish88··on Nomnoml
Very cool!

It blows my mind though how the moment that someone offers free stuff, the first comments are people asking for more free stuff.

If I wasn't paid to work full time on open source software, I'd think very carefully about whether to do any open source work nowadays.

mactavish88··on What are dreams for?
My understanding of Jung’s hypothesis about this was that every facet of the dream (the scene, the characters, etc.) is you - your psyche. In other words, your subconscious is effectively using those images as puppets to act out a play of sorts that reveals or releases some kind of tension.
mactavish88··on What are dreams for?
Odd that there’s no mention at all in the article of Carl Jung’s perspective on dreams - being one of Freud’s more prominent students and having spent an inordinate amount of his life analyzing his own and others’ dreams.

EDIT: The reason I bring this up is that it seems as though the prevailing reductionist perspective on dreaming is that it’s “random noise” created by the brain. This article effectively says the same thing, but says that the noise is created by arbitrary muscle twitches during sleep while the brain “learns the body”.

Jung and his students spent a huge amount of their time looking for patterns in that “random noise”.

It’s entirely possible that there are layers to the purpose of dreams. Yes, they could help the brain “learn the body” better. But why those specific dream characters and not others? Why those specific scenes and not others? How do those scenes and characters relate to what’s going on in a person’s life right now?

It seems unlikely that evolution would produce very wasteful complex processes - it seems far more likely to me that they also serve a use in a certain type of psychological (and therefore ultimately physical) energy dissipation or tension resolution - an idea that seems to come up through Jung’s insights.

Jung and his students then analyzed out common themes in the symbols in people’s dreams and discovered themes that were common across cultures, implying connections to common biological and sociological patterns (e.g. the fact that each of us grows older facing different kinds of challenges along the way).

mactavish88··on The Psychotherapy Myth
Agreed. My understanding from someone I consider to be a very good clinical psychologist is that the only time you may need some psychotherapeutic intervention is when you are genuinely stuck with a problem you can’t figure out yourself _and_ it’s significantly hampering your quality of life in some way you consider meaningful.

And then, you only need help until you’re unstuck.

Teach a man to fish, and all that…

mactavish88··on Maker's schedule, Manager's schedule (2009)
Doesn't seem like this dynamic's changed much since 2009 when the article was originally published.

Taking the maker's schedule into consideration in small companies seems relatively easy - especially when the CEO's coding alongside you. But I'd be interested to know if there are any medium- to large-sized companies who actively think about this and deal with this problem successfully as opposed to just always giving in to the manager's schedule.

mactavish88··on Office vacancies in San Francisco jump to a record 33%
How hard would it be to transform all this commercial real estate into residential real estate?
mactavish88··on Ask HN: How to transition into Biotech?
Where’s a good place to find job listings, and where, geographically, is all the interesting biotech work currently happening?

I’ve tried the standard places where I’d search for non-biotech jobs (and there are craploads of those types of jobs listed), but barely any biotech jobs come up e.g. on LinkedIn. Maybe because I’m in Canada?

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
Did you perhaps read the primary text of this submission?

It seems like everyone commenting here is totally missing the point of why I submitted this question in the first place and is so fixated on the content of the links I originally submitted that they just can’t see the actual questions I’m asking.

I’m tired of engaging with people who refuse to engage with the actual questions I asked.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
As per my comment on your other thread:

> Here you go, my first page of hits on mobile: https://imgur.com/a/zSL5fVX

> Only when I got to my laptop now did the set of links differ: https://imgur.com/a/EuUt7U5

> Clearly not the same set of results for the same search.

Re: this site's guidelines, I find your comment here a little disingenuous and far too generous towards HN's "guidelines". The mere fact that such content as this exists suggests that HN's guidelines are quite opaque: https://github.com/minimaxir/hacker-news-undocumented

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
Here you go, my first page of hits on mobile: https://imgur.com/a/zSL5fVX

Only when I got to my laptop now did the set of links differ: https://imgur.com/a/EuUt7U5

Clearly not the same set of results for the same search.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
But also, if there was at least a reason tagged along with the flagging, that could be helpful to submitters, don’t you think? Making people guess as to the reason for flagging seems like poor UX to me, and increases the overall hostility of the site to users.

Also, those links I posted are of far less importance to me than my actual concern in terms of how HN and other sites shape my perception of the world based on their UX design. That is the reason I posed this question. Not to complain about my posts getting flagged.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
I get none of those links on the first page. It took several pages of search results before I started seeing any of the links you’ve shared here.
mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
Maybe just move on with your life and don’t engage with the content if you’re not interested?
mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
I get literally nothing from the news search in DuckDuckGo when I search for “clintel”

It still seems you assume I have a particular agenda here beyond wanting to have a conversation on the topic.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
Who said you had to do the work?

If this was a topic that was somehow discussed previously, should there not be some kind of mechanism to indicate this in the flagging process? (Ideally automated)

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
Don’t you think it’s at least be insightful for whoever’s submitting content to understand why it was flagged?

If it’s content a submitter’s come across for the first time, and they don’t see it discussed here on HN, so they post it, and it immediately gets suppressed without any explanation, how does that help the submitter? (e.g. if it’s been autoflagged, it’d be helpful to see a reason for that, and perhaps a link to past discussion the submitter might have missed).

It just concerns me that this mechanism could be prematurely filtering out many valuable conversations that I’d like to be aware of.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
So this is exactly the perspective I’m looking for from HN.

If my post (which clearly wasn’t for or against the linked material) was not immediately flagged and killed then it would’ve been possible to actually solicit this kind of perspective.

But if my post is immediately killed then I never get to see this kind of insight.

Hence my question about whether there’s a better model than simply flagging content, as HN currently works.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
This is not the default mode of browsing facilitated by HN, so the system inherently lends itself to killing contrarian perspectives long before there can be any meaningful discussion about them.

To me, there’s nothing more powerful than someone posting a contrarian perspective and there being a highly upvoted, well-reasoned/cited response as to why the contrarian perspective isn’t valid. This I would prefer over having those contrarian perspectives suppressed, and I never get to see or engage with them.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
I think this is the key problem. It seems you assume I have a particular position on climate change, as opposed to my actual intention of making people aware of this declaration. Those are very different positions.

Also, my second submission was a link to a specific page on the site where I copied/pasted the title verbatim, and it was flagged immediately.

This leads me to believe that my post wasn’t flagged because of an inaccurate title, but because someone really didn’t want (and didn’t want others) to see the post.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: Is there a better model than flagging?
How does that help if the post’s not alive for long enough for more than a handful of people to see it?
mactavish88··on [dead]
From the site:

> Climate science should be less political, while climate policies should be more scientific. In particular, scientists should emphasize that their modeling output is not the result of magic: computer models are human-made. What comes out is fully dependent on what theoreticians and programmers have put in: hypotheses, assumptions, relationships, parameterizations, stability constraints, etc. Unfortunately, in mainstream climate science most of this input is undeclared.

> To believe the outcome of a climate model is to believe what the model makers have put in. This is precisely the problem of today’s climate discussion to which climate models are central. Climate science has degenerated into a discussion based on beliefs, not on sound self-critical science. We should free ourselves from the naïve belief in immature climate models. In future, climate research must give significantly more emphasis to empirical science.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →