HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mactavish88

934 karma · joined February 11, 2018

submissionscomments
mactavish88··on [dead]
From this page[1] on the site:

> Climate science should be less political, while climate policies should be more scientific. In particular, scientists should emphasize that their modeling output is not the result of magic: computer models are human-made. What comes out is fully dependent on what theoreticians and programmers have put in: hypotheses, assumptions, relationships, parameterizations, stability constraints, etc. Unfortunately, in mainstream climate science most of this input is undeclared.

> To believe the outcome of a climate model is to believe what the model makers have put in. This is precisely the problem of today’s climate discussion to which climate models are central. Climate science has degenerated into a discussion based on beliefs, not on sound self-critical science. We should free ourselves from the naïve belief in immature climate models. In future, climate research must give significantly more emphasis to empirical science.

[1]: https://clintel.org/world-climate-declaration/

mactavish88··on We're not even close to ready for the population growth we're getting
I don’t have the exact statistics on hand, but from various reports it seems as though there’s a substantial (and increasing) proportion of Canadians retiring and Canadians are having fewer children. Once retirees exit the work force, there will naturally be gaps in the labor force. Who fills those gaps? What’re the economic consequences if those gaps aren’t filled?

Canada’s Express Entry immigration system prioritizes young, healthy, skilled and/or qualified people.

To me it seems Canada needs both to be able to continue to function effectively: immigration and housing (and healthcare, access to education, municipal services, green spaces, etc.)

Healthcare in Canada is another catastrophe in the making at present.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: How do you deal with managers/customers questioning your estimates?
It’s the telling the team how to do their job I find disrespectful. If all they were asking for was more information on the estimates, it’d be a different story.

The presumption in their attitude and approach is that our team doesn’t know what they’re doing and they could do it better, even though they haven’t put in the effort to do the scoping.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: How do you deal with managers/customers questioning your estimates?
Part of the problem I pick up here is that, in general, engineers who haven't done the hard work of the actual scoping themselves tend to be wildly optimistic in their estimates.

I'm not sure if this applies to more seasoned engineer-customers though. The more experienced engineer-customers (people who've been working for 10+ years) tend to be far more understanding here.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: How do you deal with managers/customers questioning your estimates?
In previous jobs where we were negotiating with non-technical people, they'd actually negotiate at the business requirement level: "if we take out features B and C, how much would that reduce the cost?"

That to me seems like a far more reasonable negotiation strategy.

To tell someone how they should be doing their job, I find, is disrespectful.

But I agree, putting someone more emotionally capable between the team and the customer is probably the best way forward there.

mactavish88··on A Difficult Diagnosis
Neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome is pretty difficult to diagnose if you don’t clearly have an extra rib. I have it, and it comes on when my neck muscles are tight - my scalenes are unfortunately just structured such that they “scissor” my brachial plexus. I have exercises and stretches that help, and in times of excess stress a good massage goes a long way.

A friend had the vascular form and ended up with a blood clot in his arm as the first symptom, which was fortunately picked up at the ER just before it developed into a pulmonary embolism - he was lucky to be in the hospital already when the PE developed. He was on blood thinners for months and still hasn’t regained totally normal function in his arm due to reduced blood flow.

mactavish88··on Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years
They can’t build them fast enough.
mactavish88··on Tell HN: Turned 44 today and I'm lost
I’d consider your history to be rather successful, and while I wouldn’t consider myself nearly as successful I do feel like I can relate on many levels.

What got me through the depression that ensues in what I think was also a “mid-life crisis” was the perspective offered by James Hollis in his book: “The Middle Passage: From misery to meaning in midlife”.

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/47849.The_Middle_Passage

These sorts of crises come along at various points in our lives apparently, when something new starts brewing within that finds itself at odds with the outer structures in our lives. Unfortunately we don’t have very good societal structures/processes to assist people through these difficult times, but I feel that an understanding of the underlying psychological dynamics within oneself that give rise to this conflict can ease the suffering induced by these times of transition.

And it is genuine suffering. Make no mistake. Part of you needs to die and be renewed. It’s also not something to numb or shy away from, but to work through. Just as building your life “before” was a project, or series of projects, so is this task of moving through this difficult time, riddled with paradoxes and contradictions.

mactavish88··on Facebook, Instagram to allow calls for violence against Russians temporarily
Call me cynical but there’s got to be a profit motive in here.

There are far too many people (bots?) online baying for blood. I’m sure that drives clicks.

mactavish88··on Making CRDTs Byzantine Fault Tolerant [pdf]
> Further work is required to demonstrate whether the techniques presented here are indeed effective in the context of particular CRDT algorithms, to prove their correctness in the face of Byzantine nodes, and to measure the performance impact of Byzantine fault tolerance.

This paper is super interesting, but it'd be even more interesting when we see this future work is completed.

mactavish88··on Ukraine Pushes to Unplug Russia from the Internet
How do people then communicate with the Russian people to tell them the truth of what’s going on in Ukraine?
mactavish88··on Anonymous takes .ru government websites offline
I’d imagine it’d be incredibly unlikely that critical software systems in jets or tanks would be internet-connected.

From past experience with military-spec software development, it’s usually highly redundant and isolated. The operating systems are often real-time Linux-based ones (at least the ones I was exposed to).

If there’s Windows running there somewhere, it’s unlikely it’s in a critical system.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: What keeps you motivated to keep going?
At this point, pretty much a desire for survival.

Working remotely, almost perpetually stuck in COVID lockdowns/restrictions in Canada for the past 2 years, not having many friends/family and not being able to visit them (they’re all over 10,000km away) for nearly 3 years now, and a partner who’s recently been diagnosed with depression is all taking its toll.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: What are you looking for in a new job?
Something that genuinely adds value to people’s lives.

So nothing in ad-tech, cryptocurrency, marketing, or finance.

mactavish88··on The Shameful Decline of Scientific American
Within the original article, there's a reference to this paper: https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/full/10.1086/704991 (the author seems well-credentialed in the physics realm: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chanda_Prescod-Weinstein).

Does anyone have any insight as to what this paper's trying to show? Looking at the beginning of the conclusion:

> The central argument of this article is that white empiricism limits who is authorized to make claims about physics and that this is damaging to physics and alters its empirical direction.

All I can get from it is that the author's trying to point out that (1) science has emerged in dialogue between humans, and (2) we should be mindful of who exactly's participating in that dialogue as that influences the kind of science that emerges. This seems somewhat reasonable and a good justification for encouraging a diversity of perspectives.

But what new insight/perspective does the paper really contribute?

For example, earlier in the same paper we find this when talking about some of the author's perceived failings of string theory:

> Surveying what should happen next, there are at least three distinct possibilities:

> 1. Patience is required, and evidence is coming.

> 2. String theory has failed to succeed in expected ways because the community—which is almost entirely male and disproportionately white relative to other areas of physics—is too homogeneous.

> 3. The scientific method overly constrains our models to meet certain requirements that no longer serve the needs of physics theory.

> ...

> The second option is effectively unconsidered in the literature. Instead, the case for the third option has been made. This is a curious turn of events. Rather than considering whether structural and individual discrimination results in a homogeneous, epistemically limited community, physicists are willing to throw out their long-touted objectivity tool, the scientific method.

The author hints that "there are at least three distinct possibilities", and from what I understand of postmodernism, it's what's hidden in the margins of the text, i.e. what's left out of a philosophical argument, that usually unravels that original argument entirely. One glaring missing possibility is that we just haven't yet found a better theory or approach that more accurately fits observations than string theory. If that's what the author's trying to convey with option 2, it seems like a pretty unnecessarily racialized and facile way to do so to me, and still hints at an important omission that there may be a totally non-racialized explanation for why string theory hasn't lived up to expectations.

Maybe I haven't read enough postmodern literature to be able to appreciate this paper's contributions (maybe they're subtle), but from my first reading it ultimately just seems like one long complaint that black women have been excluded from physics by white men, which isn't really a novel contribution in 2020 if the theme already made its way into popular films. For someone so well-credentialed, I really would've expected a more substantial epistemological critique, or at least practical recommendations as to how to cultivate an environment that encourages a diversity of perspectives. Or, even more practically, if the author had actual evidence of bias (i.e. practices of actively excluding people of certain groups from the physics community), why not address that in the appropriate forum?

It's all very strange to me, including why a paper like this is cited in Scientific American.

mactavish88··on COVID vaccines may briefly change menstruation, but you should still get one
The way this piece is written gives me the sense that this is a benign phenomenon, yet they still don’t understand the mechanism - is that not contradictory? If they don’t know why it happens, then surely they can’t make pronouncements as to its temporariness?
mactavish88··on The Arctic Is Warming Four Times Faster Than the Rest of the World
Who said anything about being confident in our ability to adapt? I’m totally fine with the worst case possibility that we’re facing an extinction-level event here with the looming climate disasters. If that’s what nature is going to give us, what choice do I have but to accept it?
mactavish88··on The Arctic Is Warming Four Times Faster Than the Rest of the World
The difference, as always, lies in action. Talk is cheap (and even cheaper than ever in the age of social media).
mactavish88··on The Arctic Is Warming Four Times Faster Than the Rest of the World
Climate panic isn’t constructive (at best it causes anxiety and depression and energy directed in ways that aren’t constructive, at worst apathy), so I’ve made peace with the prospect of a highly turbulent future.

Some of my personal goals include finding and supporting carbon capture/sequestration efforts, and activism organizations who I believe can lobby for meaningful policy changes in a better direction. That, because I don’t have the skills/network to do something about it directly. If I did I’d be doing something about it directly.

Beyond that, I believe we all have to accept our limitations, that there’s a lot of luck/random chance/etc. in us being alive here on this planet in the first place and be grateful for that, and then do our best to be kind/generous to and have empathy for people suffering from the climate-related disasters.

mactavish88··on The Greedy Doctor Problem
Yes there’ll need to be some way of catering for the reality of untreatable conditions (a kind of force majeure).
mactavish88··on The Greedy Doctor Problem
I was about to suggest the same solution.

The same approach can be applied to any service that requires regular intervention to avoid service interruption. If you pay someone every time the service is interrupted, then they’ll be incentivized to do a bad job so it gets interrupted more frequently (e.g. contractors tasked with ensuring traffic lights or electricity supply works all year round in all weather conditions).

Pay a flat rate for continual service. Beyond a certain reasonable/acceptable level of interruption, reduce what you pay them. Eventually if they do enough poor quality work they’ll go out of business - as opposed to the current conventional approach that incentivizes them to do poor quality work.

If this applied to certain goods as well (like electronics) we’d probably be able to get rid of planned obsolescence.

mactavish88··on Tech journalism is less diverse than tech (2020)
I think study (1) is something that companies could implement internally (hopefully in a somewhat unbiased way). That'll at least help address localized bias in the hiring process.

As for (2), I'm aware of the fact that many people around the world don't have access to opportunities to do things that they'd be really good at. I'd really just like to understand the nuances there and how to practically make a difference.

Part of the problem I see is that the conversation around "diversity" (at least in popular media) is very US-centric, when the majority of the human species lives outside of the US. Different countries, states and even cities have very different sets of problems when it comes to lack of access to opportunity.

mactavish88··on Tech journalism is less diverse than tech (2020)
It seems to me as though people who make a big deal out of "lack of diversity" in any field are saying that it's because of some form of discrimination or bias in hiring. This is the primary hypothesis they're putting forward, often as fact, as opposed to the reality that it's a hypothesis until it's adequately substantiated with unbiased data collected from multiple sources.

The hypothesis may be true, but it's hard to tell objectively (e.g. I don't know many managers who would even be capable of seeing that they're biased, let alone acknowledging their biases). Accusing people of being biased without evidence isn't constructive for anyone involved either.

So we need to come at the problem a little differently, and accept the fact that we're never going to get a 100% clear-cut answer, but we can get much closer to the truth than we are right now. We also need to accept the fact that the reality will change over time, and so regular interrogation of the hypothesis is necessary.

We can look at a variety of metrics to try to tease out whether there are biases in specific companies (this list is by no means complete, these are just two studies that I can think of conducting off the top of my head):

1. Compare the candidates who actively apply for jobs to those who actually get the jobs. This comparison must not only include candidates' group affiliations (ethnicity, gender, age, etc.), but reliable measures of competency for the particular role for which they applied.

2. Find out from a larger pool of people outside of (1) whether they would have applied for a particular job but did not or could not because of particular barriers.

If you find that the data from (1) shows that there are candidates who have particular group affiliations and meet the competency criteria for the roles, and they are less preferred by a particular company than people of other group affiliations of similar or lower competency, then you can say with a reasonable degree of likelihood that whoever made the hiring decisions at those specific companies is/are probably biased. Not the company as a whole - just the people who made the hiring decisions (there won't be data on the other people in the company, so you can't make judgements of them from such a study). Do that for enough companies in different geographies and you'll get a sense of the different biases in different cities/states/countries (e.g. some places may be biased against competent women, others may be biased against competent older people).

Then, (2) should help us to find out qualitatively what factors are actively contributing to people not even applying for particular jobs in the first place. These may be structural problems in countries'/states'/cities' education systems, lack of access to food or housing, poverty, etc. (the possibilities are almost endless). This will form the basis for more study to figure out how to best address particular structural problems/impediments.

mactavish88··on Tech journalism is less diverse than tech (2020)
Focusing on such statistics usually encourages equality of outcome as opposed to equality of opportunity.

A far more helpful metric would probably be to know how many people want to be in tech (or tech journalism in this case) but can’t, along with the various factors that are preventing them from getting into their desired profession.

If you do then break down the numbers by ethnicity, gender, etc., you may be able to tease out a correlation that may hint at institutional bias, but there’s still no way to prove causation with just that data.

You would at least be clearer on the what the obstacles are that’re faced by people, perhaps marginalized people, that put them at a disadvantage when it comes to trying to get into those fields. Then you can proactively and practically start to do something about those specific obstacles.

mactavish88··on Microsoft blocks EdgeDeflector to force Windows 11 users into Edge
What would be interesting to know is what % of Windows users actually want to use Windows (as opposed to being forced to do so through corporate/organizational dictates).
mactavish88··on Microsoft blocks EdgeDeflector to force Windows 11 users into Edge
Totally. Which is why I’d pay over $300 for a dumb phone like the Mudita Pure with its FreeRTOS-based, open source OS.

Call me stupid, but I’d be far happier without Apple or Google in my life, and am willing to pay the price for that in terms of inconvenience. I’m way happier without Microsoft, that’s for sure.

mactavish88··on Microsoft blocks EdgeDeflector to force Windows 11 users into Edge
And so am I.
mactavish88··on Microsoft blocks EdgeDeflector to force Windows 11 users into Edge
The last version of Windows I used was Windows XP. I since switched to various Linux distros and macOS, now settling on a combination of Debian and Ubuntu as my daily laptop/server OS’s.

My initial reasons for my leaving the Microsoft world were because I didn’t agree with Microsoft’s ethics: it’s like being an exploitative, self-serving (as opposed to user-serving) conglomerate is wired into its company structure.

MS’s great work with VS Code got me thinking that maybe there’s some hope for them as an organization, but every time I peek back into the Microsoft world like this I’m even less inclined to ever go back.

I mean, their customers are actively developing workarounds for their shitty dark UX patterns, and their response is basically: “sorry, we insist that you adhere to our dark UX patterns”.

Fuck that. Life’s too short for that bullshit. Vote with your time, money and attention.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: HTTP request headers to facilitate better UX on web sites?
Maybe, we’ll see how we turn out in the coming decades :-)

As for the psychological ramifications (not “damage”), I was talking specifically about the loss of privacy. There seems to be something very important about privacy that facilitates a healthy individuation process (at least from a Jungian perspective). Not to mention the notion of lack of respect for healthy boundaries.

What does it do to a person when their boundaries are continually intruded upon (either against their will or without their knowledge)? In my experience, it erodes a person’s sense of identity.

What does it do to a society whose devices continually listen in on their private conversations without their consent and use those conversations to subtly infiltrate their digital lives, manipulating the content to which they’re exposed?

This is beyond, of course, the Big Brother-esque uses for which this same technology is now being employed. As inequality rises and people become unhappier, Big Brother will need to keep ever-tighter control on people. We will be manipulated, and ultimately coerced into submission in order to preserve the current social order - much of which will be achieved using repurposed ad-tech.

mactavish88··on Ask HN: HTTP request headers to facilitate better UX on web sites?
To be frank, I really don’t care. The ad-driven business model needs to die.

The ad-driven business model is making our society sick on so many levels. The incentivization it creates is totally toxic. It’s one of the biggest driving forces behind our near total loss of privacy online and offline (the psychological ramifications of which we’ll be unpacking for decades to come - if, of course, we don’t destroy ourselves first in advertising-promoting algorithmically driven social media-induced fits of rage).

There are many other ways to make money online that allow you to make the user and the customer the same person. And if you can’t find a way, maybe your site/service shouldn’t exist in the first place.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →