HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

magduf

4,506 karma · joined April 3, 2018

submissionscomments
magduf··on Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower than it was in 1983 (2017)
>Web devs are obsessed with the fancy new frameworks that allow you to use even more JavaScript and somehow convince themselves that it's what users want.

Do they really convince themselves of this, or even care about users? Why would they care about anyone besides their employer, who only has an interest in profit, and doesn't care at all about users aside from how much profit they can extract from them?

>There is a strong aversion to simplicity.

Right, because simplicity doesn't generate profit. Simplicity is a web page that tells the user what they need to know, and no more. But that doesn't generate as much profit as having loads of JS which tracks the user so that information can be sold to marketers.

>But web devs want "new and interesting", users be damned. So we get huge kubernetes clusters

The other factor is skill development. Crafting a simple website with minimal JS doesn't look as good on your resume as working with the latest trendy tool, so having Docker and Kubernetes on your resume looks great for future job prospects, so devs have an incentive to use those things everyplace, even if it's just overly complicating the solution and making things slower.

magduf··on Almost everything on computers is perceptually slower than it was in 1983 (2017)
>But I also don't need to spend an entire weekend setting up a PC and a printer for my mom anymore either.

You still have to waste a lot of time doing this crap. Last time I set up a printer for my mom, it was a PITA: I had to download drivers, install some giant pile of crap software, go through a bunch of screens of garbage, etc. Needless to say, her computer runs Windows 10.

By contrast, when I wanted to print to that same printer with my own laptop (running Linux Mint), it was simple: there was absolutely no extra software to install, and all I had to do was go to my Settings->Printers, search for printers on the network (took a few seconds), notice that it found the (WiFi) printer, verify it was an HP and whatever model, and then it was done.

Things could be much faster and simpler than they are now. They aren't, because it's not profitable for various actors for it to be, and because most users accept this. Most users are happy to have gigabytes of malware and spyware on their systems, wasting CPU cycles reporting their behavior back to Microsoft or their printer vendor or whoever, and that's a big reason things are so much slower than in 1983.

So if I'm being "elitist" to point out that spyware is a bad thing, then I'll happily accept that moniker.

magduf··on Indian police open case against hundreds in Kashmir for using VPN
>Clever circumvention technologies such as VPN won't save you when they arrest your for using circumvention technologies.

True, but my question here is: given that VPNs are pretty much essential for the way many large corporations work (they're not going to let employees access sensitive data over the internet in the clear), how does India, a country with a large tech presence and which promotes itself as a good place for software development, handle this?

magduf··on Why designing for open source can be difficult
One thing that bites me from time to time: if I run VLC from the command line with a media file as the argument, but I screw up and don't enter a valid filename (easy to do with tab-completion, with multiple files matching and then accidentally hitting Enter before completing the name), then VLC starts up and goes bonkers. I have to switch back to my terminal window and Ctrl-C to shut it down.
magduf··on Home Office tells man, 101, his parents must confirm ID
>The MRZ is an ICAO standard so you’ll need to blame the UN for this.

>This passport was issued by a foreign government though.

From my 20 seconds of Google research, plus your comment, it looks like the MRZ is something that various governments agreed on at some point, so the government that issued it isn't completely to blame, it's all of them that stupidly thought that either 1) no one over the age of 100 would ever have a passport or 2) there would never be a 21st century (as seemed to be the assumption through much of the 20th century with things like this; everyone always assumed the first two digits of years were always "19" and that anything starting with "18" or less was ancient history, and anything with "20" or greater was science fiction and would never happen in our lifetimes).

So my first comment is still correct, I just can't blame the UK government entirely for it, but since they're one of the main members of the UN (being on the Security Council), they do earn more blame than, say, Zimbabwe.

Anyway, the app was presumably made for a government contract, and silliness like this is common with those. There's a long list of contractual requirements for things made for the government, and the vendor has to meet all those requirements, so that's what they do. The vendor only has to satisfy the demands of the customer, and some 101-year-old person is not their customer, nor is whatever agent who had to deal with the mess, the government is (specifically whomever awarded the contract).

Generally speaking, with software, it works best when the customer is also the user. Users who don't like some software will try to avoid buying it, or will find another vendor if they're mad. When the customer is someone totally different from the user, you see real problems in usability, because the customer doesn't use it and doesn't care. So software made for government contracts tends to be horrible.

magduf··on Docker for Windows won't run if Razer Synapse driver management tool is running
>Docker for Windows has had a fundamental Dns[1] bug since April of last year, I've been forced...

>Truly a second class platform.

Now maybe some Windows users will see how Linux users have felt for over 2 decades.

magduf··on Home Office tells man, 101, his parents must confirm ID
I'm wondering if this is a case of idiotic government regulations meeting contractor requirements:

The government stupidly decides to only put 2 digits on the passport. They sign a contract with a company to write OCR software for reading passports. The contractor points out "hey! There's only 2 digits here!", but the customer doesn't have an answer because that's some other department and it's already done. So the contractor just implements the software as specified, assuming that being older than 100 is impossible, because the customer couldn't come up with a solution for this problem.

magduf··on Early humans in Africa may have interbred with an extinct species: new research
Was it a small group of humanoids that came from another star system composed of 12 colonies after being pursued by a society of artificial lifeforms that was bent on their extermination?
magduf··on Giant dams enclosing North Sea could protect millions from rising waters
It's too bad because it's got to be pretty horrible. If they could just get the data for the amount of diesel/jet fuel consumed, that would tell us a lot. The US military burned a ridiculous amount of diesel fuel in Afghanistan just to try to air-condition tents in the desert.
magduf··on Boeing fired midlevel executive following embarrassing emails
Future: President -> Titanium VP -> Platinum VP -> etc.

It's funny how "titanium" is somehow such a big thing with marketing names these days, such as with car trim models. It's a pretty neat metal but it isn't particularly valuable. Steel and aluminum are pretty neat metals too, in different ways, but no one uses those in marketing this way.

magduf··on Giant dams enclosing North Sea could protect millions from rising waters
From the article: “A rise of 10 metres by the year 2500 is predicted, according to the bleakest scenarios. This dam is therefore mainly a call to do something about climate change now. If we do nothing, this extreme dam might just be the only solution.”

Building these dams will be a lot easier than getting people to stop driving SUVs and pumping CO2 into the atmosphere.

magduf··on Giant dams enclosing North Sea could protect millions from rising waters
There was a similar idea for the Mediterranean sea almost 100 years ago:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantropa

Edit: some grad student more recently (2014) proposed this as well: https://phys.org/news/2014-08-gibraltar-sea.html

magduf··on Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental problem,” NASA says
Sorry to reply twice, but I think there's more here to address.

First, the thing about cars doesn't work even for individuals, because it's not comparable. Buying an all-new spacecraft or aircraft isn't anything like buying a car. Cars are engineered and designed for a market, and manufactured in quantities of tens to hundreds of thousands or more. This is more like getting an extremely custom house built for yourself (think something like a Frank Lloyd Wright house, not a subdivision house): you have to find someone who can architect it, and someone to build it. Neither of these is easy because the house is entirely unique and not even like other houses. It's not something you can just go pay someone to do and not think much about, like you can with a car: you have to be actively involved in the design and construction process.

>If the government started bidding out smaller real hardware contracts to new companies

What companies have these abilities? Would you have a super-custom mansion designed and built by some random guy you met on a street corner? Of course not. You have to find someone who can actually do the work, and you have to be careful because a bunch of people will claim they can do it, but they really can't, so you can't accept their bids, and that means you have to do a lot of work in verifying they're capable of delivering.

Building a new spacecraft or airplane isn't trivial, and isn't something some small company can just do, like you seem to believe. How is a new company going to start up that can actually do these things? The only reason SpaceX worked out is because a billionaire started it as a hobby project, and even there, it's been at it for well over a decade now. Same goes for Blue Origin: it wouldn't exist if it weren't for some billionaire who apparently had nothing better to do with his time. Even going back to the old days, this is what happened with TWA and Hughes aviation: Howard Hughes was a billionaire who inherited his fortune and got bored with oil drilling bits. You can't just award a hardware contract to some tiny company that has no ability to deliver on the contract in a reasonable timeframe.

magduf··on Powerful Radio Signal from Deep Space
Didn't we see a movie about this? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contact_(1997_American_film)
magduf··on Powerful Radio Signal from Deep Space
Magnetars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetar
magduf··on Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental problem,” NASA says
No, but it's the inevitable result of these shenanigans.
magduf··on Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental problem,” NASA says
Don't forget, there's a LOT more than 3 competitors in the auto market. There's 4 in America now (Ford, GM, Fiat/Chrysler, Tesla), but that doesn't count all the foreign automakers, many of whom have manufacturing plants right here in the US: Honda, Toyota, BMW, VW, etc. Just looking at cars on the road, the "American" automakers don't even appear to have a majority of sales.
magduf··on N26 will be leaving the UK
I don't even have a local branch; I use Ally, which has no branches at all and is 100% online. I have no idea why anyone uses physical banks any more unless they need to deposit cash or get cashiers checks. The online banks offer far higher interest rates and low/no fees.
magduf··on Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental problem,” NASA says
The problem with this argument is that Boeing hasn't produced any innovation lately that I can see, while their much smaller competitor, SpaceX, is the one that came up with reusable rockets that can land themselves.

Things were really different back in the days of Bell Labs when those inventions were made (another example is Xerox and PARC). Companies like those invested heavily in R&D; long-term stability and profitability was more important than next-quarter returns. This just isn't the case in America any more.

magduf··on The Disneyfication of a University
This is disingenuous. Social security has multiple components, but the main one people think of is called "OASDI", and is a government-run retirement program, not a social safety net. It's paid for by individuals over their working careers through a separate tax (called FICA), and then when retired, they draw out of it, based on what they contributed. Someone who contributes nothing to SS gets nothing out of it, while someone with a high income gets a relatively large pension check. It's not helping the poor much at all. It's just a guaranteed but generally poor-return investment that's mandatory for all working adults.

There are some other components administered by the same agency, including TANF, SCHIP, and Medicare, so yes there is some safety net there, but relative to other western countries it's rather poor. If it weren't, we wouldn't have so many homeless people. America is NOT like western European nations.

magduf··on Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental problem,” NASA says
>If the government started bidding out smaller real hardware contracts to new companies, we would see a rise in new competitors and an accompanying rise in quality and roi.

Do you have any evidence that this would actually work?

Small companies generally don't have the resources to do large project. How is a small company going to build a state-of-the-art fighter jet? It's pretty much impossible. Look at other countries to see how they do it with small companies: they don't. The European nations basically have only a few large companies, the Chinese are the same, and so are the Russians.

The reasons America had a lot more aerospace companies in decades past are 1) planes were a lot simpler, 2) they were wiling to accept higher risk back then (some test planes crashing and killing the pilot was OK), and 3) the defense budget was enormous because there was a Cold War and the US's economy was gigantic thanks to being the only industrial power left standing after WWII. #3 is probably the biggest factor, and isn't going to happen again.

As for the stuff about golden parachutes, that's endemic to US companies in general, not just contractors. I don't see how it really affects competition much since everyone does it, except that it adds costs to American companies that, for instance, Chinese companies do not have, so it's probably bad in the long term for American competitiveness, but that really doesn't affect this argument for competitiveness between US government contractors (since they don't compete with foreign companies anyway). The bit about "a nice private sector job post government retirement" is pretty much the same: it's bad for American competitiveness, but doesn't affect things much internally, except that it probably makes upstart companies more competitive as far as costs go, but since acquiring contracts is very political it actually probably hurts upstarts since they're not connected the way the incumbents are.

Also, I should add they government actually does farm out smaller contracts to smaller companies. They even have a policy I think which causes them to do this more than they probably should, in an effort to help small companies. They don't farm out fighter jets to small companies, of course, but there are a bunch of processes that cause them to farm out small things to small companies.

The other thing that's important to understand is that most small companies do NOT want government contracts, if they're not already in that business. It's not like there's small companies that would be happy to bid on these things but are being prevented. In reality, government contracting is a giant pain in the ass, so the companies that do it are ones that are interested in it, and are good at it: their processes are set up to handle that kind of business model. Bidding on contracts is a pretty arduous thing and requires a lot of specialized skill and knowledge and special staff, so companies that aren't in that sector just don't bother.

magduf··on Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental problem,” NASA says
Where are you getting that crazy idea? Why wouldn't the US government trust them going forward? It doesn't matter if they don't deliver or their planes crash and kill hundreds: what's important is that they know all the right people, and they're "too big to fail". I see no indication that the government will stop preferring them.

Of course, foreign government and airlines might very well stop doing business with them, but that'll just cause the US government to prop them up even more.

magduf··on Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental problem,” NASA says
You can't have 100 aerospace companies doing big projects; the economy just isn't that large.

For very mature industries, I believe studies have found that the optimal number of competitors is usually 3 large companies. For immature industries with a lot of change and innovation, that number is generally higher, but as the industry matures, players either die off or merge. A good example of this is the American auto industry.

magduf··on Boeing Starliner's flight's flaws show “fundamental problem,” NASA says
They're a government contractor: they're not supposed to deliver a functional product right away. They're supposed to deliver a totally flawed product that's way behind schedule and that doesn't work, and then they're supposed to get more money from the government to fix it until it finally does work. That's how government contacts work.

>This seems much deeper than just not being nimble.

Yep, it goes much deeper than just Boeing.

magduf··on Microsoft begins showing an anti-Firefox ad in the Windows 10 start menu
>I guess linking to the web archive is just carefulness at this point.

It's a good idea IMO. Now that the web has been around for literally decades, I can't tell you how many times I've searched for something, found blog/forum posts to read, and then tried following links in those posts only to find they're dead, because they're so many years out-of-date.

magduf··on The Disneyfication of a University
I believe that's absolutely true, however the people whining about "emotional labor" never seem to see this, they just blame the husband.

Honestly, I'm starting to think that very few married couples are really all that compatible in the first place, and that the institution isn't a very good deal for most people involved. Considering just how many marriages end in divorce, plus how many people simple stay single these days, it seems like marriage really isn't workable. It only worked in "the old days" because women were 2nd-class citizens who rarely could get good jobs, and social pressures just forced people to get married, and stay married, even if they were miserable together.

magduf··on The Disneyfication of a University
>It must be this way because otherwise it'd be that very high earning people help the poor to a vastly greater extent than the average person does, just by turning up to work every day and paying their taxes.

This would only make sense if paying taxes actually helped the poor. In America, it doesn't really follow. There's not much of a social safety net here. For proof, all you have to do is walk around various large cities' downtowns and see all the homeless people. There's thousands of them within a very short walking distance of the White House and Capitol buildings in DC.

magduf··on The limits of high-speed rail
>the trains stop exactly in the same place on the station, so the are markers for each card & door on the platform

They do this on Japanese subways too, because many stations have gates that the train has to line up with.

This would be completely impossible in America. Anyone who's ridden the DC Metro would know this: there is absolutely no way you could get American train operators to stop the train that precisely. Trains here stop with variances of many car-lengths.

magduf··on The limits of high-speed rail
Pricy compared to what? Trains in India?

Compared to Amtrak ticket prices in America, Shinkansen is an excellent value. It doesn't seem out-of-line with German ICE train prices either.

magduf··on The Disneyfication of a University
The free snacks help with morale, and cost the company very little. Personally, I'd rather have more money so I can buy my own snacks, but I've never heard of a company offering employees an actual choice between free snacks or a raise, so in reality it really comes down to free snacks vs. no free snacks.
← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →