HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

magice

236 karma · joined March 5, 2009

submissionscomments
magice··on I studied engineering, not English. I still can't find a job
Yet-another-whining-about-college-education. Frankly, this is the most appropriate place to scream, "get a job, man."

I never understanding these complains about how bad college education is. We talking about America here, the land of individualism, of self-interest, of self-discovery. It seems like everyone expects 5-year-old kids to pace their studies. Yet, funnily, if it's college, the professors have to decide what the students need for "real world." What gives? So elementary pupils know what they need to learn, but college students (aka 18+) do not?

On a closely related note: half of all technology workers have no formal education, the article said. Wait, if those workers can learn by themselves, can't our precious, innocent, poorly taught college students get off their behinds and study those, too? Rather than whining about how their professors are not familiar with, you know, "real-world" experience, why not focus on what they are familiar with? Can you go out to a real world and expect those to know the greatest and latest algorithms and languages and formal definitions, their pros and cons and applications? Or how, says, Windows applications and AJAX applications are similar and different. Or a thousands of those long-term researches that businesses just can't afford to do. No. That's why we need professors and researchers.

Geez. Get a job, will ya?

magice··on Programming is not math
I think the fundamental problem is this: programming is not computer science. Think physics vs mechanics, or biology vs medicine, or theory vs practice. Nobody will expect a physicist to fix their cars, or a biologist to cure their sickness. Nobody studies physics to work as a mechanics.

On the other hand, computer science, being young as it is, is still confused with with its instruments (computer) and application skill (programming). This causes all the confusion. It was once pointed out to me that math major undergrads generally perform better than most computer science undergrad in many PhD programs. When you think about it, academia for computer science involves things like type theory, computational calculus, proof of correctness, etc. Much of these has little to do with actual programming!

So, programming is not math. Computer science, on the other hand, is strongly related to math (same way that physics relates to math; remember, physicists more or less defined calculus).

magice··on Let’s Keep the Internet Dumb
You know what I love about these kinds of posts and articles? It's their awesome logics: private entities (who, naturally, seek to maximize their profits) are damaging net neutrality (to make profit); therefore, we should limit the government (FCC). My natural reaction whenever I see FCC being bashed over net neutrality is, "either there is some weird causal fuckup somewhere, or logics stops working; either way, WTF?"
magice··on Adults are Obsolete Children
sigh

I once read that Americans over-estimate children and under-estimate age (and expertise in general). This shows so well.

Can children enjoy food? Music? Play music properly? Pursuit passions? Spending days glued to a book? Of course, make it a series of books. Obviously, I just listed the obvious activities. Can children feel the full depth of betrayal? Full happiness of unexpected return? Full hopelessness in face of impossible? Full excitement when attaining things once thought impossible?

Children are stupid, shallow, short-sighted, undeveloped. They know nothing save the most primitive urges. They do nothing save screaming for help. They are, in short, very young humans who need growth. They are neither angels nor saints, but CHILDREN.

Wake up, please, from your disrespect and overly-spoiling of children.

magice··on Programming Is Not for Everybody
Interestingly enough, discreet mathematics is also math. Surprisingly enough, every single programmer uses that thing everyday.

So math is useless.

magice··on We Should Expect To Pay For Small Open Source Projects
Here is my wish: a system that collect money from me (a few bucks a month, says), and spread that money to different projects according to how much I use/like them. That would be awesome.
magice··on The Coming Anti-Tech Counterculture
Here is the interesting thing about the US (I almost typed America, but we all know America also includes places like Canada and Mexico and Chile, etc.): everyone believes that s/he is in an counter-culture. By that I meant every single person seems to hold to a belief that s/he belongs to a special clique, or holds on to unique ideology.

Reading the article, the things should jump out to you: 1. all of the points are no secret! 2. All of those points are the mainstream. Frankly. Facebook was cool, I don't know, 5, 6 years ago? The crusade against Facebook started 2 years ago already, and the anti industrial food started at least a decade ago. All of these believes are now, surprised!, mainstream. 3. all of the listed end notes are common sense that every single fucking person will agree to.

So, what's so "coming" about those things? what's so "counter"-culture about those things?

Ah, the US-ian mind. What a wonderfully ignorant thing.

magice··on Stop teaching calculating; Start teaching math
This is sad. Really sad. My personal opinion is that Americans just dislike academic matters so much that they are incapable of forming a coherent solution for their children's schooling.

Let me tell you some personal anecdotes. I moved to Minnesota during my High school senior year from Vietnam. It sucked: I couldn't hold on to conversations, and people couldn't understand my pronunciation; so I was bored and very lonely. You know what I do during my lunch time? Trying to re-prove Fermat's Last Theorem. Is there any "real world" application of that? Well, there may be, but I don't care. It was fun.

You know how people listen to (and rock to) puke music on buses? I rode bus a lot during my college years, and spent that time wreaking my brain to work on various NP complete problems (my favorite is the man-woman-dog matching :D). Do I know it is beyond my capacity? Yes. Do I care about any real world problem of it? No. Why did I do it then? It's fun. It killed time. I still do this from time to time during meetings at work.

When you think about it, most of math, or most of the academia for that matter, is not readily applicable. True, people use calculus to build Hoover Dam, but the effect of that information on whether or not a student likes math is equivalent of a political speech to a person political orientation: either you already like it (math/Obama) and cheer for it, or you already hate it (math/Obama) and boo/ignore it. These things, by itself, can't change a person's opinion regarding the big picture.

You know why I like doing math in my free time? Because I have done a whole load of it. Vietnamese High School graduates are required to learn around sophomore math level in American college (and I fully expect most other East Asian systems to be the same). This explains neatly why Asian students are "smart." They freaking know the things already. Furthermore, the learning of math there involved an absurd amount of drill (compared to American high schools). Oh, calculators are banned until high school, and graphing calculators are banned. Period.

Now, should that not make me abhor math? I mean, slaving myself so much time over such stupid and abstract matter must bore me to death, right? Actually, the opposite happened. It's like taste bud. You rebuild your taste bud every so often, so if you have been eating a whole load of broccoli lately, you will start to like broccoli. Yeah, after the first few days, you can't even digest to crap. However, after a few months, you can't digest without broccoli. Humans are adaptable. Do a lot of math, and you will like it.

This also speaks of the problem with calculators and computers. The problem is no so much that they dump down math. The problem is that they alienate the students from math. When you do math, all of it, the result is made of your sweat. It may be wrong, but it's yours. It may be stupid and winded and long and whatnots, but it's yours. It's personal. I remember once, during 5th grade (yes, elementary school), there was this problem that I just could not solve, and we were kicked out of class for lunch break. Walking out, I cling to the teacher and cried out of frustration. The same frustration that keeps me up at nights when some stupid bugs could not be fixed. Must be the same frustration that all artisans experience at challenges. It's the indication of the bond that I have with my work, MY math, and it necessitates the toil, the slaving, the mind-numbing work of calculation.

I hope you see my point: there is no elevator to interest in math. Math lovers must have toiled and slaved over stupid calculation over and over, until a point that they could actually produce the trace of math working, just like the zone in programming or any other art. That trace, that focus, that absorption builds the love for math.

Of course, this means that the students must fist cross the initial barrier of math, just like the first few days of broccoli eating. In Asian cultures, academia is a point of pride. Parents take enormous pride in their children's academia success. Schools take enormous pride in their students' academia achievements. Think about football in American high schools. It's something similar. Study well, perform well in competition, and a student will enjoy numerous privileges and honors that is just unattainable through any other mean. The whole culture rates academia above any other activities, and use that as the measure for potential success. Playing sport well will earn praise, but it is understood to be temporary, fast passing. Studying well, and people will talk about how you will got to such and such colleges, and will become such and such person in the future. It's just different.

Back to problem of American math schooling. Here is my prescription: just make the damn students do it. Require them to work on math. Forget about the whole, um, personality and uniqueness and whatnots. You know where these things are from? The toil of work (for students, that's studying) builds personality, values, and one's importance and uniqueness. You know where self esteem is from? It's from holding a piece of paper on which a problem has been solved and solution has been neatly presented; it's from the overcoming of frustration and challenges that the problem presents. Artisans take pride and esteem in their works. Students take pride and esteem in their tests and homework (except when you tell them that the football players will get the praise, the money, and the sex, and only these 3 things matter). Stop worrying about overworking them. Actually, overwork them to the ground. Leave them no energy and time to experiment with drugs and sex and alcohol.

It takes challenges and toil to make a person. Stop taking these things away from the youngsters!

magice··on Ask HN: why do people seem to hate ; that much?
The thing is, if the semicolon is optional, you can't write more complex expression. For example, if you want to sum a bunch of numbers, you can't have the plus signs at the beginning of the lines anymore.
magice··on Poll: What's Your Most Disliked Programming Language?
I chose Python not because of the language itself (in fact, it is not that different from a bunch of languages that I love), but because it is a preacher under the cloak of a language.

I mean, yes, by default, I do a lot of things that Python requires. However, that does NOT mean I need a stupid computer program to rub into my face what I am supposed and not supposed to do. Oh, and for an incomplete, not fully ideal language (look at it stupidity in lambda form, fake private fields in classes), it's a sorry excuse for a preacher who attempts to "right" already right programmers.

Programming is about self expression, about creativity, and about practicality. It's not about preaching, high ideal, and hypocrisy. Reading Python's mailing list always makes me want to puke and stab someone.

Lastly, Python's popularity constantly reminds me of the sad state of, you know, freedom of speech, expression, and thinking. Oh, did you realize that the only thing Python is better than other languages is its library? Yeah, the language itself sucks, restricts people, cumbersome, and fails to implement all features (again, lambda and private). Yet, it's popular. Sad.

magice··on Harmony, by design.
The current state of "design":

1. If it is Apple, it is perfect

2. If it successfully emulates Apple, it is awesome

3. If it tries to emulate Apple, it is good

4. If it is different from Apple, it is bad, devil, unintuitive, terrible, be-damned, should-be-destroyed-and-cursed-by-the-whole-internet

5. If it challenges/threatens Apple's position, or the reviewer's position (which is as described above), it is harmful to humanity, innovation, the economy, and everything; the imperative object of the government/media/users is to destroy such thing.

Just love it.

magice··on Reasons to install Sublime Text 2
<another emacs partisan> Look at emacs. Now look at Sublime Text. Now back to emacs. Time to admit it: Sublime Text makes you look like a wimpy stupid wench who cannot stop talking about some stupid unprofessional tool that tries to spoon-feed little crybabies who concern more about, um um, look than actually getting things done. Let's face it, if you want to prove your manliness, be my guest and pull down your pants. Otherwise, I have more useful stuff to worry about than the stupid sexism. </another emacs partisan>
magice··on The price of a messy codebase: No LaTeX on the iPad
This article is a proof of the stupidity, ignorance, and general jerkiness of an Apple user. It's like, the world must resolve around some standards set by Apple because it fails to deliver a system that actually works. Oh, and never mind that the stupid guy never understands the reason why the code base is set up as it is.

All in all, here is my opinion: who ever upvote this should feel ashame of yourself for wasting everyone's real-estate on this stupid rant.

magice··on Why teenagers are rebellious and why its good.
I strongly believe (even observed) that the whole "teenage rebellion" is more or less a modern American phenomenon. At least in my experience of teenage Vietnamese (a few years ago, at least), as well as reading of various literature regarding this age group, the teenagers are not THAT bad. True, they are immature, but at least they obey the authority imposed upon them (aka families, schools, etc.). Rebellions do exist, and even at slightly higher rate than other age group, but they are still exceptions, not norms as how American parents and adults describe their children/younger siblings.

I think the whole ordeal is, more or less, the result of various views on how humans (children especially) should be educated:

* The whole hyper-freedom-worshiping culture (even one's freedom will result in destruction of the society and one's future) removes any restriction on behaviors of teenagers, and prevent any effective discipline/self-control training for a young child

* The uniquely-me-esteem-inflation movement destroys any incentive to obey (or even pay attention to) advices/authority of adults, who are clearly wiser and more mature. After all, if everyone is completely unique, why listen?

* The no-child-left-behind-but-no-pressure (in conjunction with the inflation above) ideology results in an education system that is so easy and low-pressure that teenagers have way too much time and energy left in their hands. Oh, and if you fail, that's fine, you are unique either way, it's just you ain't fit to the current system (and we will lower the expectation so you will pass).

All in all, American teenagers receive insufficient training (in discipline/self-control), have absolutely no incentive to listen to anyone, are under no pressure and challenging expectation, but possess obscene amount of free time.

And you blame THEM for screwing up.

magice··on How US Debt to GDP ratio has changed since Obama took over
Agreed. Plus, he had upto 2 expensive wars to fight, and now a hostile House of Representatives who clearly do not understand anything about economics.
magice··on The Lisp Curse
Lisp HAS way too many CPAN's
magice··on The Lisp Curse
I think this essay is bull. As someone points out, it is yet another I-am-so-good-that-no-one-wants-me things that LISP people love to throw out. Maybe THIS attitude ("Lisp is Olympia and I, the proud user, is Zeus") is why.

Let's be frank, there are many many excellent languages that do not even attract enough people to have a "community." Icon always comes to mind as example: brilliant language, excellent libraries, but the only believers are myself and a professor. Other than that, Haskell, SML, OCaml have never attracted a significant number of users. They all are brilliant, right? BASH may have more serious products than those great things.

Let's face it, the true Lisp curse has not been discovered, and Lispers' attitude has helped it hide even better. I have my theories; you have yours. And mine are always more correct than yours. It's Lisp land, man. You can't argue against that.

magice··on Things Economists Agree On
Last time I checked, economics was still considered "scientific." That means we should not be operating on consensus basis, but proof. What is the scientific model of these things that economists agree on? Have them be checked against history? Have them predicted future accurately? Have we been able explained whatever deviation they have with reality?

Until such model exists, consensus means nothing but politics. Maybe, just maybe, we should start considering demote economics status to "pseudo-science." Last time I check, fortune tellers also agree on shit, you know.

magice··on [dead]
Well, truth to be told, Obama is NOT an engineer, is he?

He is a policy maker, so he should concentrate on policies so long as: 1. his policies generally agree with the popular consent and the constitution (the US is a democratic republic, last time I check) 2. his policies are flexible enough for engineers to work around in corner cases.

Otherwise, why the complain?

magice··on This is Why I'll Never be an Adult
Personally, I think people who think so ing pessimistic like you are THE degraders of the society. BTW, can you please stop the whole uninformed stream of junks about how glorious "the past" is? In the real past, people starved to death in "rich" countries (aka Western Europe, China, et al). In the real past, the number of literate people (at least in Western world) is abysmal. In the real past, there were no air conditioners, no heaters, no computers.

Oh, yes, in the past, people were in much better shape. They worked to death, you know.

magice··on How Microsoft Research banished the BSOD
Haha, so Microsoft decides against banishing the BSOD? So far as I know, it seems that most stuffs started at Microsoft Research end there. Therefore: good job, researcher, now I will come back to my trusted fedora. I mean, Fedora.
magice··on Apple iPad. Are you underwhelmed?
Actually, I ain't. Apple does an excellent job, as always: Everyone is overflowing with emotions by now.

"What emotions" is, obviously, a different story.

magice··on Ask YC: Any suggestion/ideas for a college project
It highly depends on how much you are willing to do. I mean, the possibilities are endless. Some come to my mind are:

* compiler/interpreter of some languages (for simplicity, usually Scheme or something easy) to Javascript, with good interface to Javascript code. Optimize the produced code. Bonus: full reflection (aka incremental compiling) support. Another bonus: mixed solution, with javascript for new users, and plug-in for accelerated speed.

* Telnet/SSH/VNC in Browser. I have seen some solutions, but all of them are primitive, especially with respect to the screen size

* Games, as always. Bonus: 3D.

* Geolocation-based stuffs. These are really hot these days, eh?

See, just one minute, and all kinds of thing flash through one's mind. Of course, you have only 3 months, which makes any of these extremely challenging.

magice··on GPL is being used as a vehicle for corruption in the Philippines.
I don't understand. Are you saying that Philippines is abusing GPL, or that GPL is the cause of of corruption there?

I am willing to admit that GPL is not perfect (it is very US-oriented, to say the least), but to throw out this kind of non-sense against GPL is just unfair.

magice··on What will Chrome OS watch you do?
The thing that I am most irritated with is the discrimination between Google and Microsoft. Hey, why no one ever talks about how Bing (or Live Search, or whatever) may record your behavior? Heck, Microsoft EULA states explicitly that Microsoft reserves the right to peek at its customers, and it does not even give you the code to confirm that it does/does not. Why does no one demand privacy and whatnots from Redmond? Because they are too scary? Because they produce the best software, which crashes into my face at least once a month?

sign If you are so scared, grab the source (which Google promises to open), check for any potential privacy problem, remove these problems, recompile, and off you go.

magice··on Software Engineering ≠ Computer Science
I believe that the difference between Software Engineering and Computer Science is not in human activity (mind you, Computer Scientists are affected by that discipline: how about reading papers and such? Reading and understanding heavy math is never an easy thing).

The differences are in scope and expectation of audience.

Usually, a paper of Computer Science deals with a limited and well-defined problem, while even the simplest program from Software Engineering must work on an infinite set of requirements, from security to ease of use. Plus, many of a program's requirements are in perpetual war with each other. Therefore, Software Engineering is slippery: sometimes, such and such requirements dominant, some other times, those other requirements are important.

Secondly, Computer Scientists demand a certain level of intelligence, effort, and knowledge from their audience (aka readers of their papers). Software Engineers have no such luxury: Just look at how they are screamed at just because a button is put at the wrong position. Plus, many computer users have come to expect that they are stupid and have absolute right to remain as stupid and ignorant as possible. Remember, computer programs are complex. Hiding away the complexity of the program, having an attractive interface, while still being correct, secure, and efficient must be satisfied at the exact same time. That's extremely difficult (if not impossible).

magice··on Ask HN: Are macros still an enormous edge in the power of a language?
Have you ever use the combination of LISP + Perl? Okay, maybe not. The idea is to use Perl's ideology (aka copy everything) with LISP technology (macro, since perl does not provide that).

A has X? Well, implement that. It takes 2 days, but it will save you months later. B has Y? implement that. Now you have BOTH X and Y. A users will wish for Y, B users will wish for X. You? Both. Sorry, I meant "Lisper? Both".

magice··on Ask HN: Are macros still an enormous edge in the power of a language?
The issue of macro is that it is, by itself, not a power. It's like how knife by itself is not food. However, knife can make you food. That's the main point.

Imagine this Christmas, Perl 6 is out with some killing features. Now, your language (Python? Haskell? ML? Whatever) does not have these features. What would you do?

You have 2 choices, basically: a. forget about that features, write a long blog in which you prove how your language can do just the same thing, albeit "a little" less elegant b. Switch to perl. This is not always possible, btw, since you may sacrifice some OTHER features that your language has.

How about a LISPer? Well, simple, let's implement these features. Keep in mind: All languages are Turing equivalent, meaning they can do roughly the same thing. There are two differences: 1. some do some task more elegantly (aka easier to maintain) than others. 2. Some have better support (eg. corporates, community, etc.) than others

Thus, you CAN always write the exact same features in LISP. Now, the definition of the macros WILL be messy. However, as a good practice, you spend 2 days debug that holy mess, and jam it into a file you banish somewhere with a dot precede the directory. Next time, you can use the features, pretending that you are using Perl 6!

This is my strategy. My Scheme code always has for-loop (purely functional, too), foreach-like, OO-like features. Of course, Scheme (remember, it's not even CL) does not provide these, but I can either implement them or find the implement somewhere. I have once even try to implement Icon-like mechanism with Macro + Continuation (okay, the Scheme implementation that time was a bit fuzzy, so I failed. But, with pure Scheme, it SHOULD be possible). That's the main power: you can copy others' ideas extremely fast! Without throwing away your old code, too. Hurray to Macro!

magice··on Poll: Does your startup use pirated software?
Come on, you can use only one application for you computer. Its name is Emacs :D (yes, Emacs can use to show images and play music. I would guess porting something like Gecko into would be possible. In that case, why bother a separate browser?)
← PreviousPage 2 of 2