HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

makomk

18,698 karma · joined September 28, 2011

submissionscomments
makomk··on Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC
I've seen this argument made a few times, and it's nonsense. SVB didn't fail because they paid out 4.5% APY on their money market accounts; that's pretty safe for them because they can easily earn that much from low-risk bonds and Treasuries and as I understand it that doesn't have the duration mismatch problems that affected their normal, boring, no-or-minimal-interest demand deposit accounts. (Also, I'm pretty sure people weren't earning that kind of interest for the past few years - the interest rate increases that made it possible are really recent.) It's related to the cause of their failure, but only in the sense that the fact interest rates increased so much that it was viable to offer that kind of money market account caused outflows from other accounts - it didn't particularly matter whether it was SVB or any other bank, or even potentially corporations just buying bonds directly.
makomk··on Silicon Valley Bank Depositor Bailout Makes Mockery of ‘Too Big to Fail’
You're right that without the bank run SVB probably wouldn't have collapsed on Friday and might well have held on for a few more weeks or months. That's not really enough though; in order for pulling your money early and parking it safer not to be the sensible choice everyone would need to know that it wouldn't collapse at all, and the best anyone's been able to offer is that it might have survived. There's this weird sentiment that it's all the fault of stupid Silicon Valley startup bros for not keeping their money in a bank that was flashing warning signs, and also that keeping large amount of money in a bank that's showing signs of failure is such a bad decision that making people and companies who do it whole causes moral hazard. You really cannot have both those things at once.
makomk··on Joint statement by the Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC
It's not moving the goalposts - this is an actual, real, and extremely sneaky loss. Having bonds that will pay out say $100 in eight years time is pretty much exactly equivalent to having the reduced value of those bonds now (say $80) because if you had that reduced amount of money now you could invest it in similar bonds and receive $100 in eight years time. In fact, I think with current interest rates you could even stick it in more liquid bank accounts or short-term bills and likely still receive more interest whilst not being locked in.
makomk··on Silicon Valley Bank Depositor Bailout Makes Mockery of ‘Too Big to Fail’
This seems to miss the point by a mile. The reason this backstop is necessary is because without one, pulling your funds is the rational decision as soon as it's "not even clear" whether the bank is in good enough shape to back everyone's deposits - the sooner the better, and anyone who ignores the warning signs and waits until it's definitely clear that the bank is bankrupt is going to get screwed.
makomk··on Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend
Not nearly the same kind of losses, I don't think. The drop in value of bond-like investments is heavily affected not just by the change in interest rates but also the duration: long duration bonds drop much more heavily because the total amount of interest people now expect over their life is much higher. The interest rates on three-month Treasury bills has barely increased over the last few months (which is obviously the longest they could've been holding any for), and then taking into account the duration and the interest they're receiving they shouldn't be looking at mark-to-market losses at all really.
makomk··on SVB depositors, investors tried to pull $42B Thursday
They are, and this is a full-on solvency issue, not just a liquidity one. Think of it this way: suppose you have an investment that pays out $100 in 2031, plus a low rate of interest that due to interest rates increasing substantially in 2022 is now below what you can get from savings accounts or ultra-safe investments like Treasury bonds. That investment may have been worth $100 in 2021, but it's worth substantially less in 2023 because someone with $100 in 2023 could put it into those higher-interest investments and end up with a lot more money by 2031. However, banking regulations allow banks to not immediately recognize that drop in the value of their reserves by claiming they'd hold the investments to maturity.
makomk··on Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend
Having the entire reserve as cash wouldn't exactly help here - imagine if 30% of USDC's total reserves was in Silicon Valley Bank, rather than just 30% of their cash. (I think I've pointed out before in discussions of Tether etc that stablecoins can't safely just hold their rexerves as cash in a bank account because banks can and do fail and FDIC protection basically does nothing at this scale, but I wasn't expecting it to be demonstrated quite so spectacularly.)
makomk··on FDIC Takes over Silicon Valley Bank
Yeah, arguably duration risk is pretty much the stogiest, most old-fashioned banking kind of risk that could possibly have tripped them up. Long-term loans and short-term deposits is basically what banks traditionally do.
makomk··on Bank run on Silicon Valley Bank
This doesn't work either. Remember, the reason that the market value of the T-bills in their reserves has dropped is that the interest rate on them is lower than the current interest rate that people can get by buying them now, so the bank likely cannot afford to pay their customers a market interest rate of 1% below that. The only way for the hold-to-maturity value of their reserves to actually be realised is if customers don't withdraw their deposits and they don't have to substantially increase the interest rates they pay in order to achieve that - otherwise they're likely to run out of money, either quickly or slowly.
makomk··on Bank run on Silicon Valley Bank
Higher interest rates decrease the value of long-duration bonds even in nominal terms. Think of it this way: because the interest rate on a bond is fixed at issue, and because newer bonds now have higher interest rates, your existing bonds have to be sold for less in order for someone to buy them over a newer higher-interest bond. This means that the banks' reserves have actually shrunk in value. This is made worse by the fact that the combination of low interest rates and requirements to choose safe investments means that the only way for banks to meet their cost of operations is by picking longer-duration bonds which have higher drops in value, and that they haven't been earning enough interest to really grow their reserves either.
makomk··on Bank run on Silicon Valley Bank
Those government-mandated, ultra-safe capital reserves look like they're actually the big problem that's going to bring down banks right now. Banks have stuck a bunch of their reserves in really safe, predictable, high quality long-term bonds (particularly government issued ones). Because interest rates have gone up, those bonds are now worth substantially less than they were a year or so ago, meaning that the banks' ability to cope with people and businesses withdrawing their deposits has gone down substantially.
makomk··on $22B project to provide 8% of UK energy via undersea cable from North Africa
The UK has built a huge amount of offshore wind generation - in fact it had the most in the world until quite recently, and is currently second only to China. This just isn't a complete solution because wind is intermittent, and in particular it tends to drop off to nearly nothing during the coldest parts of winter when energy demand is at its highest. All of the solutions to this are about as speculative and questionable as this proposal.
makomk··on Zero energy ready homes are coming
That only works on short timescales, which isn't the main problem because there are so many ways of solving that (for example batteries or thermal storage for home heating).
makomk··on Zero energy ready homes are coming
It's the fundamental problem that needs solving in order to achieve what this announcement claims is the ultimate end goal of all this - a "net-zero carbon economy" for the country as a whole - and it has been the fundamental obstacle to achieving this for decades now. So long as this problem remains unsolved, no amount of supposedly zero energy homes will ever get the country as a whole to that goal because they're still reliant on selling excess energy to the remaining "non zero energy" parts of the country in the summer and buying energy back from fossil fuel plants in the winter.
makomk··on Denmark’s Welfare State Became a Surveillance Nightmare
That's not an easy fix at all. One of the forms of fraud they're worried about is people who aren't actually living in Denmark claiming benefits - generally by actually living in another country with lower cost of living and income (and potentially claiming benefits or working there without having to report that income). Universal basic income makes that easier if anything. There's also the huge difficulty of how to fund it, especially if you can't guarantee that the recipients are actually paying taxes to your government on their wages...
makomk··on Roku devices don't support IPv6 in 2023 and it's costing ISPs
The more usual reason why devices would be making an IPv4 request despite having an IPv6-supporting connection is precisely because the server doesn't support IPv6 - either the network it's on doesn't support it, or it's not configured for it, or more rarely the software on the other end doesn't have IPv6 support. The request can't just be translated into an IPv6 one because there's no way of knowing that the server even understands that, let alone what its associated IPv6 address is.
makomk··on Maybe treating housing as an investment was a mistake
We had a whole, massive global financial crisis that was essentially caused by the fact that this does not work for housing because the risks are so heavily correlated: a large chunk of society finds that they cannot afford the downpayments and defaults all at once, which causes house prices to decrease and the economy to collapse, which in turn means that more people default on their mortgages. It's a systemic risk that affects everyone and that the markets alone do not protect against, which is why regulators have cracked down on mortgage lending so strongly.
makomk··on Deutschlandticket for regional bus and rail services to be offered for €49/month
The truth is that it's not possible to to push renewable electricity generation up to arbitrary levels by just continuing to build more and more of them, especially with the mix that Germany ended up going with, because not only are they intermittent but every solar panel produces electrity at basically the same time and stops producing at basically the same time and the same with wind. This means that eventually, extra renewable generation mostly just cannabalizes the existing renewable generation by producing at the same time as them and forcing it to shut down in order not to overwhelm the grid rather than replacing non-renewable generation. This causes a rapid explosion in cost, and those costs ultimately have to be paid for by the public somehow whether that's via high energy bills or increased taxes. Germany's renewable energy mix was particularly bad in this regard because they had a lot of solar which is cheap on paper but isn't useful that far north in the winter when energy demand is at its highest.
makomk··on First in-the-wild UEFI bootkit bypassing UEFI Secure Boot
The write-up I saw suggests that revoking the Windows bootloader would cause existing install and restore images to fail to boot even with Secure Boot disabled because it checks its own signature, which would be pretty amazing if true: https://github.com/Wack0/CVE-2022-21894
makomk··on Germany refuses to agree to EU ban on new fossil fuel cars from 2035
Of course they are. If I remember rightly, the EU's NO2 emission standards for vehicles were substantially laxer than the US in order to protect the German car industry and its investment in diesel engines. This resulted in most major cities having NO2 levels in excess of that allowed by EU law, with those countries not really having any good way to come into compliance since they couldn't set their own vehicle emission standards. In the end I think a bunch of cities ended up having to ban older vehicles, screwing over anyone who couldn't afford to buy a new car and generating even more sales for the German car industry.
makomk··on AMD Instinct MI300 Data Center APU – 146B Transistors, Shipping H2’23
Those packages are only in Debian testing, and I think RDNA2 GPUs are the only consumer-level GPUs with reasonably good support in ROCm (and then probably only some of them). AMD also dragged their feet for a long time on supporting RDNA after it launched, and actually managed to break support for the only consumer GPUs that worked reasonably well with ROCm before that (the RX570 and similar) quite a while before they added support for RDNA.
makomk··on Analysis finds Australia’s inflation being driven by company profits, not wages
The general goal of all the windfall taxes I've seen proposed is precisely that the money used goes back to ordinary people so it can be spent instead of supposedly being wasted sitting around in the bank accounts of the super-rich. This does not, of course, actually help with the underlying problem that there is too much money chasing too few goods and services - it has the opposite effect by increasing the amount of money whilst disincentivizing companies from trying to expand production. In order to use tax to take out excessive money supply, that tax needs to come out of the pockets of ordinary workers and consumers who'd otherwise spend the money buying stuff, either through an increase in income tax or sales tax/VAT. Usually I think income tax would be used. This is incredibly politically unpopular and an election-loser since people see that the government is taking their money whilst they can't afford stuff and some corporations are making big profits.
makomk··on Analysis finds Australia’s inflation being driven by company profits, not wages
It really isn't, publications like the Guardian have just misled people about how the economy works and why corporations make profits in situations like this. It's basically a direct consequence of two things: people cannot buy stuff unless it's actually available to buy, and money does not disappear when it's spent. This means that when there's not enough stuff available to buy, everyone bids up prices until demand meets supply again, with the money ending up as profits at whatever parts of the supply chain are most constrained. This is a perfectly reasonable place for it to end up: those companies are actively helping make the problem less bad by existing and investing in production at the level they did, it incentivises more such investment, and - most importantly - limiting corporate profits and price increases cannot prevent people from becoming worse off in real terms because the amount they buy is still limited to what's actually being produced.
makomk··on Analysis finds Australia’s inflation being driven by company profits, not wages
Even in an ideal world where there's no fundamental difference in the cost of producing 1000 units or 5000, companies aren't going to be able to sell 5000 at the same price as they could 1000 when doing so exceeds their current capacity. Expanding that capacity means more staff and equipment, which costs money that has to be paid for somehow. It also takes time, which means that it cannot act as an immediate solution to the cost problem and also that there's substantial risk involved - by the time the extra capacity is there, the demand may not be. In order to justify taking on this risk there needs to be the expectation of substantially higher profits.

Also, commercial airlines in particular are an industry with a history of over-optimistic expansion followed by cut-throat competition on pricing and then bankrupcy, and I'm pretty sure everyone in the industry knows this by now which is why there's not a huge rush to expand massively.

makomk··on Why UK supermarkets are rationing fruit and vegetables
From what I can tell, the big reason that supermarkets in mainland Europe can work around this by ordering from different suppliers is that they're willing to pay their suppliers more and pass the cost increase on to their customers, whereas UK supermarkets aren't so willing to do this. That is, the main contributing factor seems to be precisely our supermarkets' unwillingness to engage in "price gouging" - and if they had put prices up, you can bet that would've been blamed on Brexit as well.
makomk··on AMD CEO: The Next Challenge Is Energy Efficiency
One big reason that demand is low is that the current generation of GPUs are way too expensive, with top-end GPUs about twice what they used to cost a few years ago, very poor improvements in performance-per-$, and anythign below the top end offering even more dubious value for money especially on the AMD side. Originally those high prices were a result of high demand compared to supply, but the companies seem to have gotten greedy and decided they can permanently keep prices high and just throttle back supply to keep them there.
makomk··on SDK update for Raspberry Pi Pico W unlocks Bluetooth support
There's also a fully open source Bluetooth stack for the Nordic chips (Apache nimBLE) compared to the non-commercial use only but with some vague and possibly not yet available exception for the RP2040 license of the BTstack used here. (This seems to have been enabled by the radio hardware being fully documented, which is very unusual for Bluetooth chips.)
makomk··on A Heisenbug lurking in async Python
Well, this explains that one really annoying intermittent bug that I was having in some asyncio-based code.
makomk··on BP sees biggest profit in 114 year history
The whole idea that this could all have been funded from a windfall tax pretty much came from Labour, which is how they're relevant. Also, the fact check I linked to specifically addressed the "investment loophole" - closing it's not even close to enough money. The claim that the price cap could be funded from windfall taxes really, heavily relied on Labour playing sneaky tricks with ending their proposed price cap in April and the media not calling them out on it (along with other dodgy accounting tricks, and more recently them pointing to Shell's global profits as proof the existing windfall tax isn't aggressive enough even though they only proposed to tax UK profits).
makomk··on BP sees biggest profit in 114 year history
Actually, in a way it does. The idea that the reason the government's plan required borrowing so much money was because they'd refused to impose a proper windfall tax was a lie by the opposition Labour party (that was repeated unchallenged by most of the media, including the BBC): https://www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-labour-kee... There's just not enough money there.

The actual reason that Labour's plan could be mostly funded from windfall taxes was much more cynical: it ended in April back when energy prices were expected to be even higher then, whilst the government plan extended for two years and cost substantially more as a result. It couldn't just be extended for longer either because a huge chunk of the money came from backdating windfall taxes as far as possible. This worked for Labour because the media was willing to ignore what this would actually mean for consumers - something they didn't do when the Government inevitably caved and did the same thing themselves. Of course, now that April is coming Rachel Reeves and other Labour politicians are claiming that the reason energy prices are going up is because the Tories refused to impose proper windfall taxes and of course Labour would keep the cap past then, and the BBC and others are repeating that claim unchallenged too.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →