HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

maldeh

519 karma · joined September 6, 2013

submissionscomments
maldeh··on Soylent CEO Could Face Criminal Charges for LA Hilltop 'Experiment'
On whether I am myself mistaken about the ecological impact of clothing, eating out, etc. I agree - it is hard to compare efficiencies in a complex environment, or to quantify the net environmental impact of any one action, so my assumptions may well be just as flawed, if not more so - even if I am not personally convinced by the validity of Rhinehart's choices, who am I to judge?
maldeh··on Soylent CEO Could Face Criminal Charges for LA Hilltop 'Experiment'
He did go and call it an experiment in sustainable living, implying the intent was for it to be a dwelling. I don't think it's unreasonable for some permit requisites to apply to it, like being a rust hazard or a danger to neighbors during an earthquake.
maldeh··on Soylent CEO Could Face Criminal Charges for LA Hilltop 'Experiment'
Strange, that wasn't my take from Rhinehart's blog post. His lifestyle is certainly... alternative. But I think his choices appear to be driven more by dispassionate energy calculations than douchebag judgmentality.

Which isn't to say that I am convinced by half of his "life hacks" as being more energy-efficient - I'm uncertain if he has accounted for a lot of externalities of the stuff he advocates (like costs of trashing / recycling used clothing? Food wastage from frequent restaurant usage? Uber over Tesla?) But what's interesting to me is that even if we assume the worst case, the energy profile of his lifestyle does not appear to be too far off from that of the typical consumer.

In a sense, he's attempting an extreme form of dog-fooding of the ethos of his company - Soylent undergoes constant iteration and refining of its core ingredients to further its objective of being eco-friendly and healthy - some choices don't work out because they are sourced from the same places as the fast food industry, or may trigger hitherto unknown reactions within one's gut microbiome... but that's not a good reason to swear off experimentation altogether (albeit with reasonable safety regulations). And on occasion, his method may lead him to stumble across an objectively good idea.

At any rate, I'd rather cut a man some slack to dream and experiment on new ideas, than dismiss him off-hand as a delusional silicon valley kid.

maldeh··on How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the San Andreas?
It essentially comes down to whether you assume that the probability of an earthquake every subsequent year is independent of the result in previous years. The notion of tectonic pressure build-up suggests that that assumption isn't true.

The author has a reasonable idea in applying survival analysis to estimate the probability without making any assumptions about the underlying model.

maldeh··on The Cloned-Consciousness-as-Continuous-Consciousness Fallacy
Your comment made me recall this classic comic: http://existentialcomics.com/comic/1

I personally try to resolve this quandary in my head by defining my consciousness not as a single state at an instant in time, but rather a pattern over a time continuity - just as mass and matter occupies a continuum of space instead of a single point.

maldeh··on Scammers Game Amazon A-Z Policy By Replacing iPhones With Clay
Not quite escrow, but there's 'Fulfillment By Amazon', which takes care of distribution and shipping for you (albeit for additional fulfillment fees), and can be safer for both the buyer and seller since goods pass through inventory checks at a warehouse. (Disclaimer: work with Fulfillment By Amazon)
maldeh··on A Grain of Salt
we'll fix your car for you

*for free. The customer can always choose to pay the standard repair cost and not sign any Goodwill waiver.

maldeh··on Escaping the Local Minimum: Where AI Has Been and Where It Needs to Go
The field isn't going to get trapped in a local minimum with neural nets because the field is too big now. When AI was 20 people each at Stanford, MIT, and CMU, that could happen. With 50,000 people taking machine learning courses, there are enough people for some to focus on optimizing existing technologies without taking away from new ideas.

Riffing off the OP's argument of AI as gradient descent, one could say the 50,000 new people aren't necessarily doing purely random-restart hillclimbing so much as sequential monte carlo, sampling around a distribution laid out by the main pillars of the ML community. That is to say, it should only be robust against weak local minima. Hopefully we should be self-aware enough to know when we're trapped in a strong one, and await a true random-restart.

maldeh··on More answers to your questions about Apple and the environment
Personally, I think that answer is more useful or actionable than attempting to answer in absolute terms. How much lead does "trace amounts" actually amount to? Is it realistic to expect manufacturing processes to be completely lead free to arbitrary significant figures?

This response quotes a documented standard that they are in compliance with, so it instead becomes a matter of evaluating whether the standard is sufficiently safe or not.

maldeh··on Simple anomaly detection for metrics with a weekly pattern
The criticisms leveled against control charts in the wiki again elucidate a common problem with the state of statistics today. If experts, who have thought long and hard about the philosophical implications of likelihood versus significance, cannot reach any consensus, then how do we teach experimenters or engineers to correctly apply practical statistical tests or draw the right kind of inferences?
maldeh··on The “Other Side” Is Not Dumb
This reaction feels to me to be exactly what the article (and even the old debate club maxim) is hoping to have us consider.

On most of the pressing social issues of our time, I can at least identify a considered point from the other side - [a]theism, pro-[life|choice], gun-control, liberalism/conservatism, you name it. I often disagree heavily with the other side, but that doesn't invalidate their particular perspective. It always comes down to some axioms each side assumes that are inviolate, in tandem with a personal utility function judging certain outcomes more important or more just than others.

Take pro-life/choice for instance; here I am personally very strongly on the pro-choice side, but I can't deny that the other side at least has these points which they evaluate differently from me: - at what point do we consider an embryo alive and sentient? We reduce lifeforms to black and white like this all the time, yet we know there to be a wide range of grey in between - considering it is valid for people to consider a fetus as alive and sentient, where do we draw the line on saying it is okay to terminate its life? - even as we accept that it is okay to abort a fetus and a future potential life, does it not come down to a value judgment whether a woman's right to her own body, and her right not be held in thrall to rapists, supercedes that of a potential human life?

Acknowledging an argument on its merits does not automatically put it on the same level playing field or "elevate" it to be equal to the other side. Some arguments can have holes picked through them and can be successfully dismantled if not substantiated fully against all attacks. But this can only happen when both sides play by the rules to evaluate each other objectively, without weaseling out and dismissing the other side with reductionism. Granted, you have no control of the other, and can't compel them to play by your rules, but you will still be able to come to your own truths if you can internally argue on their behalf, and be more satisfied your reasoning for it.

maldeh··on Permission to Fail
> What she is really saying is that she has permission to fail the customers who trusted her.

No she really isn't.

> She is unilaterally demanding the right to betray that trust in order to have both the benefits of success, and also the easy lifestyle of someone who is just a worker bee.

This is baseless. She is giving herself permission to not be wracked with guilt, beat herself up about it endlessly, and put herself through self-imposed torture if she fails. It makes sense not to snowball over and compound your failures by piling on. Nobody is advocating screwing customers over by default.

> This idea that everyone deserves an easy lifestyle, regardless of their position, is one that needs to die.

Kind of extreme?

> Marissa Mayer and her ultra short maternity leaves gets it. This lady does not.

...

maldeh··on Permission to Fail
I feel like you are getting distracted by the sound bite. This post is not about telling employees that it's okay for them to do mediocre work - it's about having a healthy perspective about their jobs and not getting emotionally entangled with failures. Rationally, this should always lead to better outcomes, aggregated over a large number of employees and personality types. Working on one of these double-down-rally type companies myself, I can say that all you would have to show for it after sufficient time is burnout and mental exhaustion. You seldom feel like you are doing your best work when you're in crunch mode all the time.

As to expecting companies to keep private thoughts to themselves, and maintaining a different public front - are you really better off paying money to a company where the staff could riot and quit at the wrong time, as opposed to one where they ask you to manage expectations more realistically?

But this does inform why leadership and PR so rarely attempt to reach out to the public with honesty and frankness. Without critical reading, a lot of people simply "take it the wrong way", and the wrong kind of misapprehension can do significant damage to their public image.

maldeh··on Facebook’s “Save Free Basics in India” Campaign Provokes Controversy
Not to mention that Facebook's partner in all this is Reliance Telecom, who do not have a good track record on censorship. You need an RCom subscription in order to have access.

Does anybody happen to know how easy or hard it is for a site to be whitelisted under Free Basics? Or if Reliance has any negotiating power on that front?

maldeh··on Show HN: Wise – Mechanical Turk-like service with a Stripe-like API
Interesting idea. Sounds like you may hit scaling issues rapidly if this gains modest popularity though, since you're tied directly to a worker pool. I see there's about 300k HITs active on MTurk at any time, so even the startup pack at 1000 requests/mo would be a significant fraction of all MTurk activity.

Would you be expanding to other crowdsourcing providers as you grow?

Edit: Wasn't paying enough attention to the math. I guess without data like HITs resolved / second, it'd be hard to estimate just how many requests could be feasibly absorbed by the workforce. The rate limits look sane enough.

maldeh··on What if mega-rich people could buy places on clinical trials?
Alright, that's fair. I'm not too familiar with the design of these trials, so I concede that my worrying about sample-poisoning is likely misplaced.

Still, and I realise I'm coming dangerously close to sounding like a tinfoil spouting "money corrupts" as I type this, I would still be wary about how introducing massive amounts of private donations of this sort might impact the process of bringing drugs to the market. For the moment, this sounds great as trials could now have a source of funding where there currently is none... but it seems to me that this would further exacerbate the problem with the pharma industry focusing on cash-cow meds. Things could get such that it would be more profitable to target an exotic ailment with wealthy backers than to target an affliction disproportionately affecting the plebes.

Not that I'm saying that we must not explore alternatives to the current policy of denying experimental drugs to terminal patients. I'm simply cautioning that we have limited resources and researchers, so we ought to be careful how policy changes influences their priorities over the years.

maldeh··on What if mega-rich people could buy places on clinical trials?
I'm not entirely comfortable with allowing this by policy. I could see this affecting the interpretability of results from such trials in the long run.

If there's a rising proportion of mega-rich people in any given study, this could introduce significant sampling biases. Ethnicity, diet, lifestyle, gender - it all factors in and will have to be controlled for appropriately.

Another concern is that this could introduce incentives into the eco-system that detract from the primary goal that is to obtain a drug that would be effective for as many people as possible (setting aside drugs with specificity as a goal for a moment).

Imagine there's a drug A that happens to show very promising results on caucasians but not so much for africans, and a drug B that has more general effectiveness (hackneyed I know, but please bear with me). While a more impartial set of trials might have wound up selecting drug B (albeit after some passage of time), it's now possible drug A could get fast-tracked to market by virtue of being awash with funding from affluent volunteers while drug B never generates enough monetary interest to make it.

maldeh··on Bash 'shellshock' bug is wormable
Keep in mind that /bin/sh is bash on OS X. So if you have any scripts with the #!/bin/sh preamble you'll have to replace the default sh too.
maldeh··on Sculpting text with regex, grep, sed, awk, emacs and vim (2012)
One shouldn't discount the free concurrency offered by the unix pipelining paradigm. There are several data-mining usecases where you'd wind up writing much more performant scripts exchanging I/O between processes, with less brainpower than it takes to write a bunch of for-loops in python.
maldeh··on Mozilla under fire: Inside the 9-day reign of fallen CEO Brendan Eich
What would you consider a viable alternative to "majority-is-right" morality? I've always personally taken a moral action to mean the one that a majority of people, over and by whom the action is to be judged, consider to be the right one. If there is an absolute set of morals, what principles would they have to be evaluated by?

(Not to say that your argument about democratic morality doesn't have its merits, I'm just curious about your take on it)

maldeh··on Ada Initiative No Longer Partnering with GitHub
Surely one doesn't need to be pressured by third parties to make a judgment call on this situation? You must concede that there is some polarization in the debate over Github's reaction, with positive nods about the company's work environment and promptness, and some consternation over the legal posturing.

Again, Ada is simply saying they cannot continue association with Github. The statement you quoted explicitly states that there were several variables to consider, including their own image as a protector of women's rights (their charter is not to end ALL prejudice, it's specifically aimed at prejudice against women).

maldeh··on Ada Initiative No Longer Partnering with GitHub
The post only deals with ending association, and doesn't make any direct accusation against Github. As a feminist organization devoted to protecting women in the workplace from similar (but not necessarily identical) circumstances, it's only prudent to distance themselves at this point of time regardless of whether Github's actions were truly gender-biased.
maldeh··on Computer Science from the Bottom Up
Or automata theory and turing machines, for that matter.
maldeh··on Why Yahoo’s Not Going To Steal The Search Default For iPhone Away From Google
Keep in mind that Yahoo Japan is not wholly owned by Yahoo! Inc. Similar to its shares in Alibaba, The global company holds a minority stake in Yahoo JP (about ~35%, which puts it in second place on ownership [0]).

[0] http://ir.yahoo.co.jp/en/holder/status.html

maldeh··on Krueger Statement on Use of Airbnb for Floating Brothels
this only bears a very superficial resemblance to the slippery slope argument. We're not leaping from a dubious, frowned upon activity to an extreme hypothetical.

All of the aforementioned activities are (a) unambiguously illegal, and (b) within the same class of illegality, in that they are all based off social norms of morality and thrive on the same drives of moral ambiguity.

maldeh··on Obama Lets N.S.A. Exploit Some Internet Flaws, Officials Say
Call it paucity of imagination on my part, but I was wondering if somebody could make explicit some legitimate examples of situations involving a "clear national security need"? It's not like they're just making a legal exception for a "Blockbuster" scenario, where terrorists are about to nuke a city and a lone hacker saves the day by breaking SSH, right?

Is this supposed to apply to instances where the flaw affects the competition more than civilians -- say, a security flaw that somehow disproportionately affects Iran, China and Russia over the US? (there are obvious reasons why the government cannot explicitly acknowledge this, but I'm wondering if this is a direct implication)

maldeh··on The great 1980s Dungeons and Dragons panic
Moral objections don't just come from biblical incompatibility. Back in high-school (not-US), I once had an uncomfortable questioning from our principal because a kid's parent complained after seeing us playing with unfamiliar dice. They equated the probability-driven game mechanics to gambling, or at least believed that it led to a slippery slope.

Then again I later majored in statistics, so maybe they had a point ^_^

maldeh··on Facebook privacy settings are about to change again
It might not be a big deal, but I found this particularly infuriating:

> The graphic comes along with an icon of a little dinosaur. Asked whether Facebook was implying that privacy was an artifact of the past, ...

It was just a cute, irreverent dinosaur icon! Must the press always come up with misleading angles for everything?

maldeh··on Facebook acquires Oculus VR
Fair point. It definitely looks like an emotional purchase in a tough market. They're already getting creamed for it in the stock market [1]

The way things look, this is largely a win for Oculus for finding a big backer, and a risky gamble for facebook.

I think it's good that FB's putting some faith in a great team and product all the same

-- [1] http://www.marketwatch.com/story/facebook-shares-drop-more-t...

maldeh··on Oculus Joins Facebook
I see the absence of overlap as a good thing. It means it's highly unlikely that Facebook threw down $2 billion for some gimmicky social integration that a tiny sliver of their userbase could harness.

The Oculus team is cutting-edge hardware along a completely different vertical, orthogonal to facebook's core. Despite their size they have the talent and expertise to create that entire market by themselves, provided adequate funding. Facebook does not have to interfere at all, beyond writing the cheques. Over three years, Facebook could have itself a new gaming product to compete with Sony and XBox... in five, it might have an innovative consumer device to take on Apple. The conglomerate model typically has better odds of long-term survival - what happens when people grow tired of social in its current form (primarily content curation)? Then facebook's flagship product would be obsolete.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →