HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

malkarouri

67 karma · joined July 12, 2010

submissionscomments
malkarouri··on Markdown: The Spec - it's coming and it's full of personalities
Totally agree. Jeff is almost acting like a common bully here. I am surprised people are coming to the opposite conclusion.
malkarouri··on Git 1.8.0
I would have gone for

"git cherry-pick" acquired the "--allow-empty-message" option

or

"git cherry-pick" now has the "--allow-empty-message" option

myself. I think the subject is fine with the emphasis where it belongs. The verb is weird, though.

malkarouri··on Stop building dumb stuff
Does Afghanistan qualify as a has gotten out of poverty country?
malkarouri··on Matlab, R, and Julia: Languages for data analysis
.. which are supported by all the environments in question
malkarouri··on My Python Code for the Netflix Prize
Specific to NumPy. Boolean indexing.

http://www.scipy.org/Cookbook/Indexing#head-86055279f6592d36...

malkarouri··on Google Sues Apple, Seeks To Block iPhone, iPad & Mac Imports To U.S.
The lawsuits about prior art should be enough to lock down the judicial system on its own.
malkarouri··on Google Sues Apple, Seeks To Block iPhone, iPad & Mac Imports To U.S.
(In a Bizarro World, it's Siemens bringing back Symbian)

OMG

malkarouri··on PowerShell vs. Unix shells
One problem with PowerShell is that it uses too much resources for a shell. I believe it to be superior in some ways to Unix shells, but I was never able to get (psychologically) past the 15 second or more startup time needed on my machine (Windows 7 netbook). Given that languages like Python have less starting times, I am likely to use the command prompt and/or scripting language every time.

I guess server people would not encounter this problem.

malkarouri··on Trello is now half million strong
True. On the other hand, it creates some level of trust since any programmer can now implement a Trello alternative for you to port your data to. So making the data available removes a lot of the lock-in. Of course, if the data can be exported in a format immediately usable by an application you already know such as some form of calendar this would be better. But I don't know of an application that overlaps sufficiently with Trello to capture the whole experience.
malkarouri··on What Twitter could have been
Is that still valid? I mean, after GPRS, MMS and various technologies in this area it might not be as bad as originally implemented.
malkarouri··on What I learnt pretending to be a programmer
Interesting that you effectively use an engineer's definition of "solved" rather than that of a theoretician.

Message passing is effectively the assembly language of distributed computing: very low level. Mapreduce and the various NoSQL databases are effectively the next level up, but we still have some time to be able to have a proper theory for designing and implementing effective scalable distributed systems.

In short, we have many bits and pieces that can be brought together with a bit of luck to be able to attain the scale that we are currently seem to be happy with. So I can accept that the engineering definition of solved is there. But from a computer science point of view, we certainly are far from having a satisfactory theory. So we definitely do not have the answers.

malkarouri··on What I learnt pretending to be a programmer
> true computer scientists already have the answers.

And the answer is .. 42?

No, really. When did the distributed computing issues become "solved" in computer science?

malkarouri··on Ivo – a reimagined Unix terminal system
> There is also not much stopping you from using PHP, Python, Ruby, or anything else with a REPL as your daily shell, but bash is the most popular and works quite well for this problem domain.

This is relevant: http://stackoverflow.com/q/3637668/336455 In short, there are some objective reasons, not just popularity.

malkarouri··on Python For The Web
A good language, as a good anything, is a reasonable language. Giving extremes as arguments against sensible middle positions is the way of madness, paralysis, or extremism..
malkarouri··on What's better about Ruby than Python? - comp.lang.python
As somebody who used Python a lot and being unable to learn Ruby, I have to say that I don't feel they can be merged.

I have been successful at learning a variety of languages. Ruby was difficult for me because it is so similar to Python and yet so different. You have almost the same syntax getting very different results. So if you come from Python you get the exact opposite experience to the principle of least surprise. On the other hand, if you move from OCaml or Erlang there are no surprises because the syntax is different enough that there are no pre-expectations.

Also, metaprogramming in Python and Ruby are quite distinct. The way Python went about it using metaclasses and decorators is very different to the monkeypatching you get in Ruby, so I don't expect the AST results to be that similar for idiomatic code in both languages.

malkarouri··on A Snowball's Chance In Hell : IronRuby
Any argument that builds on protecting the cash cows for Microsoft is not helpful, either to Microsoft or to the community.

For big companies to survive long term, the main thing is to have the flexibility to do that. The most relevant example here is IBM, which almost didn't survive the 80s until they emphasized more system integration.

As humanity progresses, demands will change. Microsoft has enough power, both in terms of number of employees and in cash, to pursue more than one option. Hence, many of the innovation coming from Microsoft Research can be very useful in the future. Moreover, one of the main advantages for Microsoft in the 80s and 90s was that they are friendly to developers. Of course there will eventually be a tie-in. You start using IronRuby, then you find ready .Net solutions to your programming, then you commit to using their database, and maybe visualisation via Excel, and you find yourself and your customers tied to the Windows/Office platform. Just like many companies are tied to IE6 despite what Microsoft wants and despite common sense.

Give developers no incentives at all, and they wander around. At some point, the clear division in tools makes people either commit to Microsoft or to everything else, and when Windows come short (and it will, nothing is forever) people will move in droves. But give them a semblance of cross compatibility, and they will stick to Windows/Office while convincing themselves that there is always a way out. In reality, they will be locked by the economics of rewriting all the use of .Net technologies.

Bad for the community, because splitting the community into Microsoft and others camps will lessen competition in both sides. Cross pollination will C# and Ruby will not exist when there is no shared community. And no improvements will be needed in either camp because of new features in the other.

malkarouri··on World War II was totally unrealistic
There is nothing special about Africans that will make them "properly[sic?] be so long after we are gone". The same tendency for long wars is everywhere. The history of Europe in the 19th century and earlier was almost a series of continuous wars. The main difference is that the cost of war is now too high for advanced countries. Even WWI wasn't enough. People recognize it and made the League of Nations, which still wasn't enough so the lesson had to be repeated with bigger losses.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2