575 karma · joined January 31, 2010
Feel free to reach out: mallyvai at offerletter.io
software engineer. python, java, ruby. infrastructure, distributed systems, full-stack.
also see http://www.quora.com/Vaibhav-Mallya
-Vaibhav
What's your background? are you still looking?
tl;dr they are no good at saying what you should earn.
Also, there is definitely a ton of salary and negotiation "advice" out there. But many of the people we work with, already tried reading it or talking to friends, etc. There is an enormous amount of stress and pressure at the last-mile, and a few essays in no way compare to someone with institutionalized knowledge actively working with you over Skype, coffee, or on the phone.
One of the first ideas I had in the space was a better Glassdoor of sorts. I discarded it quickly. http://offerletter.io is, fundamentally, very different.
1) Multiple levels of taxation
2) Startups will be wary of having random third parties on their cap table
There's probably other stuff too. But I don't think it's impossible, just very hard. There are other ethical concerns from this side as well - hollywood talent agents don't always have the best persona. It's part of why we're avoiding the "Agent" moniker at http://offerletter.io and branding ourselves as Advisors instead.
This is a long ways off, of course - there's a lot of work to be done even in at the narrow step of the funnel we're targeting right now.
Here's where you and I diverge:
1) Yes, engineers and other in-demand workers have ready access to jobs. I remember when I was looking for a good engineering job out of Amazon, I was basically spammed nonstop by virtually every party on the planet.
2) But the opportunity cost for poor job selection is enormously high. The difference between choosing between a good startup on good terms, and a less-good startup on less-good terms, can literally mean the difference between retiring 20 years early having your work used by millions of people, and just puddling around for a few years with, say, the occasional PyCon lightning talk for visibility.
At http://offerletter.io , we are doing precisely this - we are getting paid by engineers, designers and PMs for value added - in this case, during the negotiation process. Our team of Advisors guides candidates on the "last-mile" of offer selection and negotiation in exchange for a cut of the increase.
It makes too much sense - there's massive information asymmetry during the process, companies are full of shit, and many people outside of "the club" - however you choose to define it - just don't know what they're worth, or how to get it. While we can't justify charging the $10k-$30k that recruiters make, the incentives are still incredibly strong for us to do what we do.
And of course there's the ethical and human component, which is very strong - I tried more traditional recruiting for a while and just raw selling of companies is so tiring. I like helping people first - all of the Advisors do.
We have a lot of advisors right now - there's a culture in the Valley of proactively wanting to help and connect with good people who need guidance. So even my friends who are busy founders, PMs, and leaders in their own right, are more than willing to make time to serve as Advisors. (It also helps that they get compensated well for it - and compensated proportional to the value they deliver :-).
The more interesting question is how we get the word out more aggressively to get more individuals on-board. If you have any ideas about that, let me know - mallyvai@offerletter.io.
Drop me a line - mallyvai at offerletter.io - I guide a lot of other engineers on job-related stuff (i founded offerletter.io ) - we may be able to help here (and we're absolutely discreet about this stuff :-)
-V
OfferLetter is adding real value to people's lives and careers. We have a lot of great data on market rates, career trajectories, and company cultures. And because of our tip-as-percent-increase structure, the incentives are totally aligned.
Shoot me a mail if you have any questions, or I'll be hanging around the comments here! mallyvai AT offerletter.io
Caching is hard. Consistency is hard. Peer to peer is hard. I hope the author is addressing these in a sane, verifiable way. I'm really curious to see the demo apps that come out of this.
I like it! There are two things I would still like though. One would be page rendering in the browser. We often have to iterate several times on a paper adjusting figures, text, padding, etc. to get everything to fit within the page limit. I could write the paper in this and then export it to tex, but that defeats the purpose. The second thing is support of popular LaTeX packages. It looks like I can upload arbitrary tex documents, but that's going to get messy if I have to upload the same packages for every paper I'm writing.
We use github for our papers right now. Less than ideal. "