No, Occam's razor: this is just tribalism. He's convinced them that he is on their side reality be damned. It is too painful and hopeless to countenance the other.
684 karma · joined November 23, 2015
No, Occam's razor: this is just tribalism. He's convinced them that he is on their side reality be damned. It is too painful and hopeless to countenance the other.
"No, it isn't us, it is all the other people who are taking your American Dream away!"
When you think about it, isn't it remarkable how well this works that a rich billionaire blowhard from New York City convinces the hoi polloi that he is one of them?
Sure, the GOP in D.C. doesn't give two pennies about climate change, more parks, more air, fair treatment, or the rest, but they also are doing nothing different that will substantially help the Atlanta warehouse worker either.
https://www.vox.com/2015/8/11/9127769/parenting-advice-worth...
https://www.vox.com/2015/3/31/8320233/time-spent-with-kids
http://quillette.com/2016/01/19/heritability-and-why-parents...
1) When AI is able to mimic humans in terms of creativity, passion, emotions, etc
2) When we are able to biologically integrate compute resources into the human body
Future scenarios might be vastly different depending on which of these two technical research projects wins the race.
I am sorry to have said "go home" and will refrain in the future. Still, you have lodged what I consider factually incorrect assertions about Penrose's argument. When asked for evidence you have provided none.
Penrose's contention can be summed up without it. He basically thinks that gravity will be discovered to play a role in quantum wave function collapse. And that this role will render non-quantum Turing machines incapable of accurately modeling quantum gravity in some very serious way. Another way of saying it is that he believes when a real theory of quantum gravity is developed we'll find that non-quantum Turing machines will not be able to accurately model the physics of a black hole.
Note that this says nothing whatsoever about the human mind or microtubes or formal systems, etc. This is about his subject of expertise: gravity, mathematical physics, and quantum gravity. He's one of the world's leading experts in these fields.
And if he is right, he conjectures it will have strong implications for non-quantum Turing machines as a basis for Strong AI.
Yes, you can make a computer spit out nonsense, but this is a far cry from the computer actually behaving in an illogical way. A Turing machine's entire operation is logical. It is built with logic. It is a logical machine.
Penrose claims the human mind is not a Turing machine. That it is not logical. That it is not built with logic. That it is not a logical machine.
Pointing out that the human mind is not logical is thus restating Penrose' point and not refuting it.
Say what you will about Penrose, but can you seriously deny that he is one of the world's foremost experts on gravity?? You might not like his conclusion, but to say that he is out of his element here is ridiculous. Are you in your element when discussing gravity causing wave function collapse? Who do you think would be more in their element on this subject than Penrose??
Penrose does not argue for "something computationally more powerful than objective collapse" rather, he argues that the physical Church-Turing thesis is false due to quantum gravity. Something he is an expert on, btw.
There is just tons of reading on this if you care to scour the literature. Penrose' objective collapse theory is usually given as the prime example of the whole genre.
Please show how that paper describes a Turing machine 'programmed with PE' can't simulate a Turing machine 'programmed with ZFC'?
Perhaps we are arguing over what 'programmed with PE' or 'programmed with ZFC' means? The parent post seemed to claim that it was possible to construct a physical computer with the axioms of ZFC built-in so to speak. As opposed to one with PE built-in. Which obviously calls into question the parent post understanding of what exactly idealized Turing machines are.
Few people have made more contributions in the twentieth century to actual physics than Penrose. He is one of the world's leading experts on general relativity and his objective collapse theory is nothing more that when quantum gravity is understood that gravity will play a role in the collapse of the wavefunction.
To describe Penrose as engaging in 'quantum woo' or 'quantum magic' is grossly inappropriate. It just gives evidence that you don't understand what he is proposing. See Scott Aaronson for what an rebuttal to Penrose looks like not the ham fisted straw man takedowns from the likes of people in this comment section.
All Penrose is saying is that Turing machines can not be the basis for modeling the human mind. He is not saying that the human mind is not governed by physics. He is not saying that the universe is not governed by physics. And he is not resorting to 'quantum woo' like some here are saying.
Penrose' argument is that there is something non-algorithmic going on in the human brain and that this non-algorithmic process is governed by physical laws. He then goes on to discuss objective collapse theories for quantum mechanics and how that may be the source of non-algorithmic behavior in the human brain.
To be clear, objective collapse theories have as of yet no experimental evidence. But, crucially, they are not inconsistent with QM as some above have said. Also, the precise biological mechanism that Penrose postulates for how the brain operates with objective collapse is highly controversial ie, microtubules.
That.
There are good refutations of Penrose' argument, but I've seen none of them here. Just a bunch of bandwagon hackers assuming Penrose doesn't know what he is talking about and then putting up lazy straw man takedowns.
#2 See fundamental level. Penrose claims that what sets us apart from Turing machines is fundamental. But whatever, you've refuted whatever point you wanted to make by saying human's are not logically consistent. Your snark about Penrose not understanding is as empty as whatever point you were trying to make.
#3 Cite a paper showing that objective collapse gives these supposed algorithmic speedups or go home. NOTE: objective collapse theories are an active area of research and are not limited to Penrose by any means. Your claim that they are inconsistent with QM begs for evidence. Cite some or stop spreading nonsense.
#4 Your answer here is completely void of any context to the question: where Penrose says that microtubules are limited to humans. I take it you concede that he did not say any such thing?
You treat Penrose as an idiot missing obvious problems. I think it far more likely that you've misunderstood. Pity your lack of humility might make it impossible for you to understand what he actually argues rather than your strawmen.
No, it is not. It is far from proven that universal physical law can everywhere be simulated by a Turing machine. If you had proof of that you'd be up for a Nobel. So publish your paper or perhaps consider that Roger Penrose is not an idiot and you might not know what you are talking about.