HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

manyoso

684 karma · joined November 23, 2015

submissionscomments
manyoso··on The Lucas-Penrose Argument about Gödel's Theorem (2012)
Then I am sorry to say you have no idea what you are talking about. Penrose nowhere claims the human mind is not bound by physical laws.

Cite one place where he says anything like this or go home.

manyoso··on The Lucas-Penrose Argument about Gödel's Theorem (2012)
So your claim is that the Human mind is a physical machine and that computers are also physical machines and thus both are bound to physical laws... and this negates Penrose how?

Do you think Penrose disagrees that the Human mind is bound by physical laws??

manyoso··on The Lucas-Penrose Argument about Gödel's Theorem (2012)
Lots of folks missing the forest for the trees. Objecting to Penrose' argument on the grounds that it assumes Humans are logically consistent when that is no the case misses the point.

The claim is that you can not adequately model the Human mind with a Turing machine. Pointing out that Human's are not logical only strengthens this claim and does not refute it. Further, the claim at this non-Turing machine-like ability of Humans is valuable and allows us insight that Turing machine is fundamentally incapable of.

manyoso··on The Lucas-Penrose Argument about Gödel's Theorem (2012)
#1 Please show how to program a Turing machine to use "axioms stronger than PA"

#2 Please show how to program a Turing machine so that it is not logically consistent at a fundamental level?

#3 Are you questioning the viability of objective collapse theories in general? To date we have no experimental evidence of said theories, but I don't think anyone has suggested they are inconsistent with QM. Are you? If so, please show how...

#4 Show where Penrose has said humans are only species to make use of microtubules and your claims regarding Penrose' theory of objective collapse and having staggering new computational speedups are ... without any evidence. Please provide some.

The tenor of your comment suggests you find Penrose to be an idiot and missing obvious problems. Consider that perhaps you are the one misunderstanding what he is proposing and that he is not, in fact, an idiot.

manyoso··on The Lucas-Penrose Argument about Gödel's Theorem (2012)
Here is the quote from Gödel supposedly supporting this:

"So the following disjunctive conclusion is inevitable: Either mathematics is incompletable in this sense, that its evident axioms can never be comprised in a finite rule, that is to say, the human mind (even within the realm of pure mathematics) infinitely surpasses the powers of any finite machine, or else there exist absolutely unsolvable diophantine problems of the type specified" . . . (Gödel 1995: 310).

manyoso··on The Lucas-Penrose Argument about Gödel's Theorem (2012)
Most interesting part was suggestion that Gödel himself agreed with Penrose argument against Strong AI. I think this will be highly contentious.
manyoso··on The largest Git repo
I would pay money to see a video camera of Linus' face reading this article. I think we'd probably get impossible new shades of the color red heretofore unknown to humanity.
manyoso··on The largest Git repo
I am very certain that Linus would read this article and curse the jaw dropping stupidity of the whole endeavor. They've basically taken a tool he wrote to do real distributed source control that can scale and turned it into a central server.

Git was never meant to be used this way and I know he'd be horrified+amused in the extreme.

manyoso··on Judge orders Uber not to use technology taken from Waymo
"It seems that the scope of possible harm has been reduced..."

The Judge specifically says in the ruling that a much stronger injunction can come at any point right up to the start of trial if Google is able to find additional evidence in the new discovery he is ordering. My read of the ruling is that the Judge expects that Google is likely to find just such evidence in the discovery he is newly ordering.

manyoso··on Judge orders Uber not to use technology taken from Waymo
I think the Judge is very clearly signaling that if any pilfered files were used by Uber that he is intent on getting to the bottom of it. And that all the claims of privilege that Uber has been claiming so far in the expedited discovery is about to go bye bye.

The head of research on LIDAR at Uber had 14,000 files from Google that were pilfered before he left and he did this for purely for shits and giggles and not in any way to use these files for anything in his future job? The Judge says in the order it is preposterous to think this. Still, it is up to Google to prove misuse and he is intent on giving them the discovery they need to do so if they can.

manyoso··on Judge orders Uber not to use technology taken from Waymo
In the expedited discovery done so far Uber has claimed privilege for huge amounts of requested documents. If you read the order, the Judge is signaling that this isn't going to be allowed to continue. One of the reasons he turned down the adverse inference is basically that he expects discovery going forward to favor Waymo and the adverse inference question is not necessary to decide now.

The ruling in general gives the definite impression that the Judge is very interested in seeing the evidence one way or another whether stolen tech was used by Uber and claims of privilege and 5th amendment will be greatly hindered going forward.

manyoso··on Judge orders Uber not to use technology taken from Waymo
It isn't just the order to return the documents. Uber is compelled by June 23rd for a complete and chronological record of everyone at Uber or on behalf of Uber who discussed LIDAR with Anthony and what they talked about. They have to question all of these people about knowledge about those 14,000 files and contents.

Under oath. How many employees do you think that is? How many people?

If Anthony discussed these 14,000 files with anyone - which is not a stretch to think that he has - then they have to admit it under oath or deny it under oath. You think others are going to want to perjure themselves for Uber?

manyoso··on Judge orders Uber not to use technology taken from Waymo
Contrary, it says that Uber either knew or should have known that he took those 14,000 files and that undoubtedly those files were used by Uber to develop LIDAR. It says that Waymo has shown evidence of trade secret misuse enough to grant provisional relief.

It is not a knock out blow against Uber, but look at the relief granted with regard to more discover. Uber has to do a complete accounting of everyone who talked to Lewandowsky about LIDAR and the contents and dates of those conversations. They have to get every employee under oath saying whether they used any info or knew of any info in those 14,000 files.

In short, Uber didn't get knocked out by this order, but it certainly sets them up for getting knocked out as the Judge clearly is interested in getting to the bottom of this.

If evidence exists that Uber knew of or used information in those 14,000 files ... the Judge and Waymo are determined to find it. I think that is bad for Uber know matter how you look at it.

manyoso··on Judge orders Uber not to use technology taken from Waymo
I think Waymo laywers are very happy with the expedited discovery ruling and the order that Uber must make every effort to compel the return of the 14,000 files.

This might not have been the bombshell ruling against Uber that they were hoping for, but it sets up that bombshell ruling if they can actually find the evidence with this new discovery.

manyoso··on Judge orders Uber not to use technology taken from Waymo
Look at the new discovery that the Judge is allowing Waymo. In effect, Waymo gets to look at all internal LIDAR development at Uber to see if they can find their trade secrets.
manyoso··on Ted Seides Concedes Bet with Warren Buffett
Yeah, its not like he gets paid to make smart bets or anything... oh wait!
manyoso··on What if we made video conferencing work?
Last few months I have used Zoom, RingCentral, Skype for Business, Google Hangouts, and Gotomeeting.

Zoom was best followed by gotomeeting.

manyoso··on What if we made video conferencing work?
This is a great rant, but what are the best solutions to this today? Has someone, somewhere solved this or at least well on their way to a solution?
manyoso··on Building a QNX 7 Desktop
A better way to go is port ubuntu-Linux subsystem to QNX 7 like Microsoft did for windows 10. Should be much easier too since QNX is posix compliant.

And then QNX Screen <-> wayland integration and you'd have a full fledged desktop full stop.

manyoso··on Google plans to reach a Quantum Computing milestone before the year is out
We are so far from talking about this that your question is nearly meaningless. Quantum computing has not even been demonstrated yet. This "quantum supremacy" is for a highly contrived algorithm and set up that has very little if any real world use cases.

A generalized quantum computer able to run standard computing algorithms is very far in the future and so much basic research in computing science has to happen before it can be talked about meaningfully.

manyoso··on Google plans to reach a Quantum Computing milestone before the year is out
No, this is the real thing they are trying to achieve.
manyoso··on Uber finds one allegedly stolen Waymo file on an employee’s personal device
Sounds like he is. The guy still runs the part of Uber's company that is under question here. They could fire him, but they have not. They want their cake - not being penalized for his adverse inference - while eating it too - letting him run the part of the company that is in question. And they have not denied that he took the files in question. With no one disputing it Google's claim stands and that alone, with or without adverse inference, might be enough for the prelim injunction.
manyoso··on Is Consciousness an Illusion?
How is that an innovation?!

Materialists have been asserting since forever that consciousness arises from the brain and that the brain evolved according to Darwin's laws. What is new in Dennett's viewpoint?

manyoso··on Is Consciousness an Illusion?
It is a critique of the criticism of the review. If the review is wrong and Dennett's point is really just the standard materialistic worldview plus the trivial observation that consciousness evolved according to Darwin's laws, then it is really trifling.
manyoso··on Is Consciousness an Illusion?
Ok, so where does Dennett's view lead that is in anyway more interesting?!
manyoso··on Is Consciousness an Illusion?
That's just a wordy way of saying that we evolved according to Darwin and our consciousness was selected. Not terribly original or deep. Yawn.
manyoso··on Is Consciousness an Illusion?
Dennett denies his own first person evidence of his own consciousness so that he can sustain his belief that all that exists is the materialistic world view. Motivated reasoning in the extreme and completely violating Occam's Razor which is quite ironic.
manyoso··on Android May Adopt Swift Programming Language
The original article seems to be this: http://thenextweb.com/dd/2016/04/07/google-facebook-uber-swi...

And the only source in that one is "Sources say" so a big grain of salt is probably warranted.

manyoso··on Thinscript: language that compiles to both WebAssembly and JavaScript
Just go with pure reference counting. It'll be faster and easier.
manyoso··on Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income
What you argue has been tried in the early have of the 20th century in the United States where workplace safety laws and minimum wages were ruled unconstitutional based on the theory of free contracting parties. It failed MISERABLY and by miserably I mean it left working people in ... literally ... misery.

BTW, my 'smug one liner' I learned in school was uttered by President Abraham Lincoln who is widely regarded as our nations greatest President.

← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →