HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

marinmania

386 karma · joined June 5, 2024

submissionscomments
marinmania··on T-Mobile, AT&T oppose unlocking rule, claim locked phones are good for users
Even if that's true it's still a less accurate headline.

The rule is about unlocking, not deals.

The carriers say this is bad for consumers.

Both those can be true and the current headline captures that.

marinmania··on T-Mobile, AT&T oppose unlocking rule, claim locked phones are good for users
I don't think that is a more accurate headline.

The potential regulation is about the government making phones unlock automatically after two months of purchase. The regulation isn't about banning discounts or sales.

marinmania··on FTC announces "click-to-cancel" rule making it easier to cancel subscriptions
I was wondering this too.

LA Fitness wanted me to mail something to their headquarters, which was intentionally onerous. I filed a complaint with BBB and cc'd LA Fitness on them, and they ended up cancelling it for me.

Still, I did originally sign up for the gym in person, so I wonder if they'd be allowed to force the person to come back in person to cancel. This still seems like too much work, especially for when people move.

marinmania··on Do U.S. ports need more automation?
It's like asking if we should install a manned toll booth that raises exactly enough money to pay the toll booth workers. Or if everyone should pay higher taxes to raise the social security benefits of a randomly selected group of people.

That's not an alignment issue, because it's not clear if raising prices on everyone to support a few thousands workers is pro-worker or pre-human. You could just as easily argue (and I do) that lowering prices and freeing up man hours is pro-worker and pro-human.

marinmania··on Do U.S. ports need more automation?
It's not an alignment problem, it's a distribution problem. Automated ports would acutely hurt a very small group of people and help all other people a small amount.
marinmania··on The US finally takes aim at truck bloat
I think the nanny state charge is appropriate when people engage in dangerous behavior (like riding a motorcycle without a helmet) where almost all the risk of the potential harm is taken on by the user.

With large cars its the opposite. The people who drive large cars take on no risk, while everyone else is subjected to their negative externalities.

marinmania··on U.S. Added 818,000 Fewer Jobs Than Reported Earlier
It's the third featured story for me now. The top story is one that criticizes Harris for her economic policies.

I can't find the web version for the day the original report came out, but in print the initial jobs report was on B1.

https://www.nytimes.com/issue/todayspaper/2024/03/09/todays-...

I'm not even sure if your conspiracy is that the government is cooking the books - or that newspapers are covering for Democrats.

marinmania··on U.S. Added 818,000 Fewer Jobs Than Reported Earlier
People report this though. It's literally on the front page of the NYTimes right now (with the article this is linked to)
marinmania··on U.S. Added 818,000 Fewer Jobs Than Reported Earlier
What would be the point of releasing good numbers a year before the election and then forcing yourself to release worse numbers just a couple months before the election?
marinmania··on A road safety plan that will lead to cars communicating with each other
I don't completely disagree with you, but the main factor is really speed. Golf carts top out at 15mph and at that speed pedestrians don't die when they are hit by trucks either.

https://mobikefed.org/2020/10/research-risk-death-pedestrian...

marinmania··on Cancer rates are rising in young people
https://www.epicresearch.org/articles/colorectal-cancer-scre...

This shows that the colon cancer screening rate has quadrupled for ages 45-49 since 2020. It says official guidelines were changed in 2021.

I am not going to pretend to be an expert, but I also imagine there could be significant difference in how sensitive these screenings have been over the decades.

marinmania··on Cancer rates are rising in young people
I would wager this is more a function of better/earlier detection than anything.

In general deaths from cancer are down considerably. I'm having trouble finding exact stats I want, but believe this is the case for young people as well.

Cases of cancer that result in fatality have been and will always be counted pretty close to 100%, since they will eventually seek medical help.

Cases of cancer that are less serious are more likely to be diagnosed when medical care is good.

The survival rate of cancer is over 50%.

https://marypatcampbell.substack.com/p/cancer-death-rates-by...

marinmania··on Atlanta Police Monitoring of 'Cop City' Opponents' Political Activity
https://www.brennancenter.org/sites/default/files/2024-05/Ex...

These are what the article is referring to when it talked about police monitoring the signature collection protests.

As far as I can tell they generate a report like this for every single protest in the city and send to police so they know what's going and how many people they expect to be a different public place.

marinmania··on Atlanta Police Monitoring of 'Cop City' Opponents' Political Activity
Political action is able to happen every couple years in Atlanta at the voting booth. Voting is the safeguard. The majority of people in Atlanta consistently vote for people who want to build a police training center.

Just because you think your side is just, it does not give you the right to overrule the will of voters.

Constitutional rights cannot be trampled on, but otherwise it's counterproductive to give extra care to the losing side of a political fight simply because they trespass and start fires.

marinmania··on Atlanta Police Monitoring of 'Cop City' Opponents' Political Activity
I feel like the issue here is not necessarily that the surveillance happened, but it has the appearance of impropriety. I think a possible solution is to have a national law enforcement agency that can step in when local agencies run into issues that involve investigating their own.

The number of protests involved here that turned violent is rather large. It would be silly to insist that local police not monitor public channels where protestors are organizing. We don't even get from this report if this was necessarily more work compared to a counterfactual where sit-ins or violent protests were against local schools or other government agencies.

I get where people are skeptical, but that's why an outside agency could potentially be useful in doing the same exact work (if not more) while making it more clear there is no impropriety.

>On March 6, 2023, it was reported that 23 people who had thrown large rocks, bricks, Molotov cocktails, and fireworks at police, as well having set buildings and equipment on fire, had been charged with domestic terrorism. Only two of them were from Atlanta. One was from France, and one was from Canada.

>On January 18, 2023, Georgia State Troopers and other agencies launched another raid. During the raid a trooper was shot in the leg, and a protester, Manuel Terán, known also as "Tortuguita", was shot and killed by police.[24] Police stated that Terán fired on them without warning.[25] Multiple groups, including other protestors, two independent journalists who had previously interviewed Terán, and Terán's family, have questioned whether Terán fired first, pointing to the lack of body camera footage of the shooting and calling for an independent investigation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_Cop_City

marinmania··on Robot dentist performs first human procedure
And the lowest hanging fruit doesn't even necessarily have to do with AI or robotic tech.

In the US you need a prescription within the last year to buy contact lenses. European countries do not require this. Not only does this mean contacts are more expensive and come from fewer suppliers, but demand for appointments with eye doctors would never go down, even though a test of vision could easily be done now by an automated machine where you choose a series of A/B options.

marinmania··on Suspicious data pattern in recent Venezuelan election
Venezuela released the vote totals

https://www.albatcp.org/en/2024/07/29/cne-announced-nicolas-...

Their vote totals happen to align (almost perfectly) with round percentages

Fwiw most governments don't even report percentages. They just report totals and the percentages are added (by sites like CNN) for clarity

https://results.elections.ny.gov/document/468?page=1

marinmania··on Big tech wants to make AI cost nothing
For what it's worth energy and electricity consumption are not the same. Fuel (for autos, planes, heating oil, etc.) would be included in energy consumption but not electrical.

I'm having trouble finding reliable data quickly, but looks like 35% of energy consumption in the world is electrical.

It's still an increasing fraction as you say, but it seems like a doubling or quadrupling of energy used for AI would probably have much less of an impact than the share of the population using ice-cars changing a few percentage points.

marinmania··on End Mandatory Single Family Zoning by Overturning Euclid vs. Ambler
I don't think that's a fair reading.

I can't think of any instance where the endangered species act would allow housing in some area near wildlife, but only if it didn't have a dividing wall between living spaces.

Same with the EPA.

Zoning is almost entirely set at the local level.

marinmania··on How Olympics officials try to catch “motor doping”
There was a controversy in curling a few years ago where some curling teams were using new brooms by a new company that had significantly better tech. It was so good it made it unnecessary to have two sweepers. The resolution was to ban it and only allow brooms from certain manufacturers.

It seems reasonable that these sports could narrow down the list of approved equipment down to a few approved suppliers every year.

https://www.cbc.ca/listen/cbc-podcasts/1427-broomgate-a-curl...

marinmania··on FBI raids Atlanta corporate landlord in probe of rental market price fixing
The supply and demand of housing would be very different if a YIMBY policy agenda was in place.

Right now, it may be possible a rental company could own a large amount of apartments without fear of new units being added.

If YIMBY policies were in place, new apartments could be added within a year or two and in the long-term this would mean housing prices are met by supply and demand. The landlords only have power when supply is artificially capped.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2