HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

martian

2,476 karma · joined October 11, 2007

Untitled
submissionscomments
martian··on Want To Be A Startup CEO? Better Learn How To Code.
I'd add: help establish some basic decision-making structure (e.g., despotic vs democratic) and simple accountability measures.
martian··on Google’s Trojan Horse (or Why Location Based Services are not a Business)
My impression of the article is that the author was saying it's difficult to get into business selling only what or who is nearby, since both of those are close to becoming (if they're not already) commodities. The trick with location-based services is to provide novel interaction or functionality or customization on top of these commodities. Quoting the OP: "As a LBS start-up, you need to think about adding distinctive value for users; differentiating on location is an oxymoron."

There are plenty of companies who will be hugely successful in the LBS space. Maybe Google, maybe Loopt, maybe Brightkite or Yahoo or CloudMade... If you think you can be the next company to track where everyone and everything is (massive infrastructure requirements!) -- this article is suggesting you are probably on the wrong track.

(side note: Yahoo's FireEagle is also something to watch in this space, as are the recently launched developer products from CloudMade.)

martian··on Images of flies on a urinal = 80% less 'spillage' on the airport bathroom floor
Yeah, this is a great book. Evidently it is also on Obama's reading list.

The book talks about a few different ways to "nudge" people into the "best" behavior. One of the key points is that a default choice (for ANY consumer choice, whether health care, options on a car, or how to invest a 401k) is far and away the option most likely chosen. So the book's authors argue that it is the responsibility of politicians to help people make the right "default" choice.

One great example is a particularly nasty curve on a road -- Lake Shore Drive -- in Chicago. It's a major thoroughfare along Lake Michigan, and cars were always going too fast when they came up to a sharp curve in the road. After trying all sorts of "slow down" and "sharp curve" signs, city planners opted to paint lines on the road perpendicular to the flow of traffic. The lines were set at regular intervals, but near the curve the lines were painted closer together. This gave drivers the impression that they were going too fast, and caused them to subconsciously slow down. This dramatically improved the traffic flow on this particular stretch of Lake Shore Drive and reduced accidents and fatalities.

I won't comment on whether or not I agree with of all this book's theories, but it is well worth a read, and certainly shines some light on more subtle aspects of human decision making.

martian··on Ask HN: Which accounts (twitter, gmail, etc) should I secure?
I would suspect that you would want to pay attention to where your users are. If you're a Web 2.0 social network site, then Twitter is probably essential since most of your users would likely be using Twitter as well. Same things goes for Delicious. If you're in the US, then look into getting a presence on Facebook or MySpace (MySpace especially if you're working with music). If you're somewhere overseas, then Orkut may be worth a look. If you're a design firm, it probably wouldn't hurt to have a Flickr account.

The answer to this question seems to depend on where your users hang out. If they hang out on the web, then be on the web. If they hang out at trade shows, then go to trade shows.

(Sam_in_nyc, I read your profile so know that not all of this applies directly to your situation, but maybe it's useful for thinking about the more general case...?)

martian··on Ask HN: How do you produce product demo videos?
Aside from all the technology, it's crucial to get a solid, professional voice-over that tells a clear story about your product. My personal experience has been that even the best video production can be quickly tarnished by a voice-over that is casual, meandering, or inconsistent. For our demo video, we first sketched out what points we wanted to make in the video, wrote a draft script, then recorded nearly an hour of screen footage. My colleague then spent a couple of days locked in a room with iMovie and a microphone. We ended up with a five minute video that I think really captured what we were trying to do with our product. We used ffmpeg for conversion to mp4+h264 (and a fallback to flv), and the very respectable JW flash video player. I think Snapz Pro X was used for video capture.
martian··on Ask HN: What to do with a spare computer?
Electric Sheep makes an amazing screen-saver -- could be a great piece of wall art? Other benefits would be that you'd be contributing to a massive art project and it'd make a great conversation piece: "what's that?", "oh, that's just Harrison Ford dreaming..."
martian··on Why You Should Try Django
You shouldn't be compiling your own packages. Then you have to pay close attention to bug fixes, new versions, etc.

Instead, sudo apt-get install python-mysqldb

See: http://diveintomark.org/archives/2007/11/11/installing-mysql...

[edit: I know you are talking about shared hosting plans, which are a different beast, but the general rule that you shouldn't compile your own stuff is still valid.]

martian··on Ask HN: E-mail providers and mail servers
One option would be to buy cheap shared hosting plans (I've seen as low as $6/mo) and use them only for email. Not always perfect, and things like SSL might be messier, but cheap and easy and these days you'll get as much if not more storage as Google Apps. One drawback to a shared plan is that you might be on the same IP as some spammer and you might get blacklisted. SPF records are easy to set up and can really help with that.

I used to manage an email server and it was not very pleasant for someone who just wanted to hack. :-) If you do end up running your own mail server(s) you'll want to be sure you have good spam/virus filtering or users will start complaining. I had really good luck installing Postini a couple years ago -- reduced spam by nearly 100%.

martian··on How designers work (Ph.D. Dissertation)
Beyond the critique of the amateur, he's also tackling larger trends of thinking about design methodology. The trend is from formal to informal, from abstract to concrete. From ideas without context to ideas that receive immediate feedback from their environment...

Gedenryd quotes: "The writings of design theorists imply that the traditional method of design-by-drawing is too simple for the growing complexity of the man-made world. This belief is widely held and may not require any further justification. (Jones 1970, p. 27)"

But recently we've seen a resurgence of such "simple" methods like sketching, storyboarding, model-building, etc. Here's where we see the Renaissance of Sketching.

Basically it seems to me the trend is that a bunch of theoreticians in the mid-20th century thought that abstract thought and logic could (by themselves) produce perfect designs. But in fact recent research and writing about design are suggesting that the world's best designs come about because they were designed using processes like sketching that have a direct, real-world, tangible feedback. My favorite passage is maybe "Quist's demonstration of sketching" in ch 4, which directly addresses this dichotomy of formal/abstract vs informal/specific design processes.

I think many people have realized that overly formal methods do not produce designs that are all that beautiful or engaging. Most people hate cube-farms. Most programmers can't stand the waterfall model. Most consumers hate corporate bloat-ware. Maybe it's always better to use paper prototypes, sketches, extreme programming, and so on.

In some ways this whole debate was foreshadowed by Spock's musings in Star Trek I: it is an embrace of what is most human.

martian··on Christopher Alexander: An Introduction for Object-Oriented Designers
Yeah, I'd always considered Alexander more of an academic than a practitioner, but it's interesting to look at what he and his colleagues actually produce. His buildings don't look amazing, but perhaps they work really well for their intended audience?

http://www.katarxis3.com/Gallery/community/community.htm

http://www.patternlanguage.com/pbrochure/purplebrochurehead....

Ha, this is my first time to the Pattern Language website... It's clear that while Alexander may understand patterns in architecture, he has very little understanding of patterns in web design.

martian··on Why is the default answer always a web app?
Agreed. There are many things still not possible on the web.

Office/productivity apps? I'd say Google Docs is a far cry from the performance of MS Office or OpenOffice.

Likewise, 3d performance on the web is miserable at best. You might get a bit of help from Papervision or Java's 3d engine, but it's not suitable for large, interactive, 3d applications.

How about copying and pasting from one web app to another? :-)

I love web apps, don't get me wrong, but I'm agreeing that there are many times when they just won't work.

martian··on A Modest Proposal
Jonathan Swift: http://www.gutenberg.org/files/1080/1080.txt
martian··on Ask YC: What is the best area in SF Bay Area for startup hackers?
You can definitely find a place cheaper than $500/wk in SF. I live in the city, and pay way less than that.
martian··on Column versus row stores
Sometimes column stores are really the way to go. For massive RDF storage, they offer orders of magnitude improvement in query speeds when compared to the best row-store DBs.

The C-Store project at MIT is cool. Here's a good summary: http://patricklogan.blogspot.com/2007/12/column-oriented-rdf...

martian··on Ask YC: Feedback on PolishMyWriting.com
Also, the use of "said" allows for subtlety of dialog that would be lost with more trite words such as "exclaimed" or "retorted".

Joyce takes it to an extreme: only a dash separates dialog from narration.

martian··on Deschooling Society
During my last year of high school, I remember asking the college guidance counselors if there were other alternatives to going to college.

They told me my only other choice was to join the military.

Clearly something needs to change.

martian··on Review my Startup's Front Page
I'm stoked on your concept and loving the logo.

Vertical spacing overall should be a tidied and made consistent. Maybe push the second line of your logo up onto the first line to compress the header?

Also I'd suggest you put some more constraints on the design. Pick three colors max. Also maybe limit font choice. You have at least four fonts (two in the logo, and two more in the text of the page), shifting between serif and sans-serif with all sorts of colors and weights and sizes that all add up to looking like clutter. Similarly link colors seem to be very different (the light green on a light blue background looks a lot different than the light green on the dark blue bg).

Font sizes in the three boxes at the bottom are too small. Also, headers on those boxes should be clickable (since there are little arrows on those headers).

You could try looking at one of the many CSS frameworks (I personally enjoy Blueprint) to add some cross-platform consistency to line-heights and font sizes.

Regarding content: It seems there are two places on the page to learn what ScribbleWiki does. Once in the light blue box and once in the space right below it. Maybe put all this text into one place?

Hope my comments don't come off as too negative -- just trying to provide some constructive criticism.

martian··on Netflix prize competitor: With the best algorithms, metadata becomes worthless
This reminds me of some of the spam filtering algorithms I've read about.

You'd think that categorizing spam based on keywords (or sender IP, etc) would be useful, but machine learning algorithms can pick up more subtle nuances of language patterns and act more effectively.

http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1216017&jmp=cit...

martian··on Want to live a long life? Run
Agreed, I started bicycling regularly about two years ago, and it has vastly improved my overall health, focus, and drive. Getting sick in the winter used to be the regular course of things -- I'd be knocked out for about a week or so with a cold or flu -- but the regular exercise and exposure to fresh air has kept me healthy in spite of everything. My productivity is higher, and my ideas more focused. I can only imagine the health benefits that would carry through into old age.

There is certainly no silver bullet to living into a healthy old-age, but it seems clear that running, biking, swimming, or any other exercise could only help you. Combined with good diet, social activity, intellectual hobbies, and who knows -- Ray Kurzweil's predictions may come true.

While biking the other day I came across this old dude (probably 70 years old) who was also on a bicycle up in the hills north of San Francisco. He was flying down this major hill, pedaling like mad, and the wackiest grin was on his face. When I'm old, I want to be that dude.

martian··on CSS Frameworks
I agree that the original post lacks in critique.

On the other hand, he does provide a great place to start from when considering CSS frameworks. By laying them all out on the table, we should be able to have a conversation around them to flesh out their relative pros and cons.

In an attempt to start a constructive conversation, I'll outline my brief experience with Blueprint.

Pros for Blueprint:

  - 24 columns to layout the page. E.g., you could have one 12-unit column, and 2 six-unit columns.
  - Basic text formatting, nice line-height handling.
  - Some decorators like borders between columns.
  - When you need tables, they look good.
Cons for Blueprint:

  - Fixed 24-column layout can be limiting in some situations.
  - The occasional floated item breaks layouts.
  - Fixed height on headers is problematic for text with line breaks. (can be overridden, I think, with height:auto)
I have less experience with other frameworks.
martian··on CSS Frameworks
What frameworks do other YC folks use?

I've been running with Blueprint for a while now and it's working great. The simple 24-column system makes a lot of sense for layouts, but I'm not tied to it necessarily.

martian··on Python for Lisp Programmers
My experience with C# suggests it is extremely tied into the Windows world, and for some tasks -- like building a plugin for Internet Explorer -- you may be best of with one of the MS languages (VB or C# being the most prominent).

For more general-purpose desktop development, Qt is pretty good. It's mostly a rich set of GUI libraries on top of C++, but is packed with features like integrated WebKit browser, OpenGL, SQL, networking libs, etc.

And if you develop with Qt, you get Mac and Linux versions for free.

martian··on We Want A Dead Simple Web Tablet. Help Us Build It.
Arrington reminds me a lot of the character of Anton Ego in Ratatouille. A vicious critic. This speech (by Ego) in particular comes to mind:

[POTENTIAL SPOILER WARNING]

"In many ways, the work of a critic is easy. We risk very little, yet enjoy a position over those who offer up their work and their selves to our judgment. We thrive on negative criticism, which is fun to write and to read. But the bitter truth we critics must face, is that in the grand scheme of things, the average piece of junk is probably more meaningful than our criticism designating it so. But there are times when a critic truly risks something, and that is in the discovery and defense of the new. The world is often unkind to new talents, new creations. The new needs friends."

martian··on Your Design Is Good Enough
Couldn't agree more. Over-architecting should be the 8th deadly sin (at least for start-ups).
martian··on How long will it take for Google to index this?
In the spirit of Douglas Hofstadter... nice recursion.
martian··on Ask YC: What do you use for outbound email sending?
+1 SPF. It helps a lot with the major email providers, and it's super easy to configure.
martian··on SocialHistory.js: See Which Sites Your Users Visit
This is cool.

Last summer I had an inkling of an idea that used basically the same strategy. My idea (never implemented) was to set the background images on visited anchors to a dynamic image url that could be used to track pageviews from other sites, to perhaps determine what links from your site your visitors found most interesting, even if they didn't click to them from your site.

There are plenty of terrible use cases for something like this, but also plenty of benign and probably useful cases as well. If you were a search engine, for example, you could determine if a user has been to sites that show up in the search results, even if they don't click on the links from your site.

The full write-up of my strategy is here: http://tinyurl.com/6fnjod

martian··on Live From All Things Digital: Gates and Ballmer Preview Windows 7
I hope web browsers for Windows 7 will support multi-touch. The richness of desktop apps is so often quickly lost on the web, and it would be fantastic if we could be building multi-touch web apps right out of the gate.
martian··on Ask YC: How do I find a new programmer?
Aside from news.yc... If you're in a metro area, Craigslist is usually a good bet as well. As a programmer, I've had reasonably good luck finding interesting jobs through Craigslist -- much better IMO than dice.com or Monster or other major sites.

Other job boards with intelligent readers that you might consider are at 37signals and Joel on Software.

martian··on New Laptop
When I purchased my Thinkpad T60 (nearly 18 months ago now -- how time flies!), the Lenovo sales staff was unable to help me find a notebook with Linux preinstalled. Maybe this has changed recently, but you're better off just buying the base Windows version and putting your favorite Linux distro on top of it.

http://www.thinkwiki.org is the best resource I'm aware of for Linux + Thinkpad installation tips.

← PreviousPage 8 of 9Next →