HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

martinclayton

366 karma · joined March 27, 2017

Consulting Technologist. UCL alumnus, UK-based.

Former astronomer and ex-Starlink (no, not that one).

Co-author of https://foximax.com/ word game.

submissionscomments
martinclayton··on America is getting an AI gold rush instead of a factory boom
https://archive.is/TY950
martinclayton··on Study of 1M-year-old skull points to earlier origins of modern humans
I have to admit I thought it might be "like that" before I read the article. But I don't think Chris Stringer would be a co-author on the paper if there was an issue of bias.

While this work is impressive, it is just one skull and, as the article points out, seems statistically anomalous, and therefore interesting.

martinclayton··on 60 years after Gemini, newly processed images reveal details
Fabulous, obviously.

I found the headline image confusing - thought it was a Sontaran (Dr. Who baddie) in there! Aldrin's face and the earth reflection are quite confusing to the eye.

martinclayton··on Prime Number Grid
Hours of fun (stimulation?) to be had...

Try these shapes: 100x113, then 100x114, then 100x115, the "patterns" swing from slant down, to vertical, to slant up.

I'd love this (even more) with some animation and colo(u)r options.

martinclayton··on Wick Effect
The Leeds case sounds a bit disturbing: they used real human fat and "simulated" clothing for an experiment. Seems odd that it was easy to find real human fat, but they had to resort to simulating clothing. I guess in 1963 fast fashion wasn't a thing.
martinclayton··on Matt Trout has died
I use Catalyst quite a lot - have been working on a new thing this morning.

Thanks, Matt, the ripples will go on for a good while.

martinclayton··on Astronomers discover 3I/ATLAS – Third interstellar object to visit Solar System
In a thread elsewhere I saw "Interstellar Objects in the Solar System: 1. Isotropic Kinematics from the Gaia Early Data Release 3" (https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.03289) mentioned.

In there, one estimate of the number of these objects is

   Nisc <~ 7.2 × 10−5 AU−3
Which (my, probably wrong, calc) implies roughly one inside the orbital volume at the radius of Saturn's orbit at any time.
martinclayton··on First American pope elected and will be known as Pope Leo XIV
What happens if Charlie Stross meets the Pope?
martinclayton··on 2024 YR4 and other dangerous asteroids
Information-rich but is sadly very click-baity.

The head/title of the page is: "Asteroid to Hit Earth 2025 | Most Dangerous Asteroid 2025".

Heading is "Next Asteroid Predicted to Hit Earth: All About 2024 YR4 and Other Dangerous Asteroids". Then big picture of bad things happening: "Are We Doomed?"

Body text kicks off with: "Every now and then, the media produces dozens of scary headlines about rocks from space headed toward our planet." ...like this one, you mean?

There's a section headed "Famous asteroids predicted to hit Earth". Why use this misleading style? The body text below this heading can be summarised as: "there are no famous asteroids predicted to hit Earth".

At least it says "At this time, there is no evidence that any of these asteroids will collide with Earth". Sounds like "so you're saying there is a chance!"

martinclayton··on Nothing-up-my-sleeve number
When a magician does this, you know it's likely a distraction, and somewhere else there is trickery going on.

As a cryptography layman this would make me more suspicious...

martinclayton··on COBOL has been “dead” for so long, my grandpa wrote about it
I think this must be it, or at least this is one story that fits.

Seems a shame that people report Objective-C experience as Swift experience to such a great extent. These surveys are not resumes...

Perhaps it just "proves" that all data in these charts is questionable.

martinclayton··on COBOL has been “dead” for so long, my grandpa wrote about it
In case anyone is interested...

The SO Developer Surveys give some info on the job market for COBOL as it appears on the average salary versus years-of-experience graphs, which I like as there's as many stories or reasons as you can think of to explain them.

In 2023 there were 222 respondents who averaged 19 years of experience, and an average salary of $75,500. In 2024 the exact number of respondents is not shown, but likely similar based on the color code of the point, but the average experience had dropped to 17 years.

Elsewhere in the graph my favourite open question is: how come the over 2000 respondents mentioning Swift average over 11 years experience in a language that's only been public for 10 years?

2024 https://survey.stackoverflow.co/2024/work#salary-comp-total-...

2023 https://survey.stackoverflow.co/2023/?utm_source=so-owned&ut...

martinclayton··on The quest to build a telescope on the moon
There was an interesting Fraser Cain YT vid a couple of weeks back:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wcR6gs0Up6k

Interview with Gerard van Belle, director or the Lowell Observatory.

The topic was space/lunar optical interferometers. It's easier to do this on the Moon than in space, as there's no formation flying. He's got a "menu" of projects from a few/small unit telescopes right up to lunar manufacturing like this.

martinclayton··on Disney+ terms prevent allergy death lawsuit, Disney says
Given that the customer ticked an agree to terms box for the park tickets that likely will be enough for the company to keep the case out of court, why would they feel the need to go with the "stretch" to the streaming agreement terms too?

Could there be some difference in the terms, where the streaming terms have some advantage over the park ticket terms for the company, perhaps?

martinclayton··on Go is my hammer, and everything is a nail
My experience is different to that.

I'd say people and businesses that best understand and balance risks against potential rewards are the most successful. I know a couple of skydiving accountants...

Use of innovative tech in finance is one way for companies to gain an "edge" which can make them a lot of money. I wouldn't characterise people working in those particular areas as more risk averse.

OTOH finance businesses (esp. those that manage other peoples money) are regulated and can't put new tech into Production without careful change control. But this evolves over time, and controls were looser in the past.

There's a steady creep of regulation and control into tech used in finance outside and around IT: so called EUC (End-User Computing). This can be a source of "wrong tool for the job" syndrome. I've seen some hellish SQL written by non-IT people, but it got the job done. It's also an area where source code control, testing, and release processes are inevitably more human and error-prone.

There is a culture clash internal to large finance between "move fast and break things!" and "nothing can change, ever - too risky!" This leads to a mixture of the very old and very new, and inevitably, more complexity. Achieving homogeneity once the heterogeneous is out of the bottle is very hard - attempts to do so often (always?) lead to a variation on the xkcd "Standards" situation https://xkcd.com/927/

martinclayton··on Mitochondrial Eve
Y-chromosomal Adam, aka Y-MRCA, must be due a spoof Village People number ...
martinclayton··on Potential ozone depletion from satellite demise during atmospheric reentry
It's in section 3.3.

- Natural Al estimated at 141.1 metric tons / year not varying.

- Human-made: 2016: 5.36 tons, 2022: 41.7 tons, "future" could be 912 tons, i.e. more than 6x natural.

I think the last figure is based on many planned large satellite constellations being deployed.

martinclayton··on Fossil fuels could have been left in the dust 25 years ago
An aside: Tim Harford presents one of the very best programmes on BBC Radio 4: More or Less [1].

Each programme investigates the reality behind statistics used in the media and by politicians. It's quite UK-centric, of course, but simply one of the most informative shows there is.

[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b006qshd

martinclayton··on CamelCase vs underscores: Scientific showdown (2011)
Title should mention that the article is from 2011.
martinclayton··on Scrabble and the Nature of Expertise (2015)
I was going to write a "Previously on Hacker News" comment, but no one commented the one time this was posted before ...
martinclayton··on The Great Flattening
I'd forgotten about the Aggregation Theory piece.

"By extension, this means that the most important factor determining success is the user experience: the best distributors/aggregators/market-makers win by providing the best experience, which earns them the most consumers/users, which attracts the most suppliers, which enhances the user experience in a virtuous cycle."

Sadly, the reality of the virtuous circle though is: enshittification.

"...from music to video to books to art; the extent to which being “special” meant being scarce is the extent to which the existence of “special” meant a constriction of opportunity"

I don't get this. Rarity or inaccessibility has been used as marketing tool, sure. But great music and books were not scarce for a long time pre-internet. Feels like a "never mind the quality, feel the width" view of culture.

"LLMs are breaking down all written text ever into massive models that don’t even bother with pages: they simply give you the answer."

When will people stop saying that? The give an answer, yes, but is it the answer: caveat emptor.

martinclayton··on Please don't share our links on Mastodon
Previews only use the HMTL head - to get OG metadata - and usually an image.

Never thought about this before. One of my sites is (a single-page application) 45k HTML and 40k image. Hence about 50% of what is served for previews is wasted.

It would be nice if there was a way to recognise an "only html head needed" type of request. Don't think there is?

martinclayton··on Ask HN: PhD or continue my consulting work
(Roughly) where in the world are you?
martinclayton··on The DDoS attack of academic bullshit
I think I agree; my take:

The point that the leading group in a field could and indeed did know each other to some extent is somewhat conflated in the piece with that particular group, who represent a very particular set of one-off extreme high achievers.

Self evidently "most physicists" are not going to measure up against a group including 17 Nobel Prize winners.

PhDs serve a different purpose now in society, but are still of value.

martinclayton··on The DDoS attack of academic bullshit
I don't disagree with the article - enjoyed it. The 5th Solvay is somewhat of an outlier: majority of the folks in the famous photo were Nobel laureates or laureates to be, which must be some sort of record.

Unfortunately, everything is held back by the en(bull)shitification cycle we're in, not just academe. This seems to be an area where LLMs will make a big difference: what we think now is a flood will turn out to be the receding tide before the tsunami.

martinclayton··on Are you fitting the Gaussian curve or is it fitting you?
Is a "right imbalance", which seems to be the central idea expressed here, somehow being illustrated by a counter example: the content of the article itself?
martinclayton··on The Making of a PowerPoint Slide
https://archive.is/jAhtf
martinclayton··on Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)
Richard Littler's poster for the "real" Festival of Brexit Britain:

https://www.dezeen.com/2018/10/03/richard-littler-satirical-...

martinclayton··on Empty Frames and Other Oddities from the Unsolved Gardner Museum Heist
https://archive.is/WWhat
martinclayton··on Don Knuth letter about libraries increasingly unable to afford prices (2003) [pdf]
And the outcome was ... ACM Transactions on Algorithms (TALG)[1][2]

    [1] https://home.cs.colorado.edu/~hal/s.pdf
    [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACM_Transactions_on_Algorithms
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →